AAAA king!!!

I feel bad for GTA IV since it isn't an exclusive so people won't vote for it here, yet I've had the most fun with it out of all these games. For is time, OoT was better and MGS4 was a great end to the story and a great gameplay update, but GTA IV is still a fantastic game that I've spent hours upon hours in.

Standards improve over time, so we can count out OOT and CC.

And out of the other three, SMG2 is the clear winner. I don't think I have to convince you that GTA didn't deserve a 10, and MGS4 has many aspects that the majority of gamers simply don't like. It's fine if you're already a fan, but the fact is that most folks don't want to sit through hour long cutscenes in a game that doesn't even have a good plot.Not to mention the gameplay is extremely clunky and imbalanced.

Any platformer fan can appreciate the brilliance of SMG2, but not nearly all TPS/Stealth fans like MGS.

chrono cross hands down for me

Half-life 2 (Kevin-V would have given it a 10 if he had been the reviewer)ferret-gamer

The games that are actually better are not going to be voted on because the people at sw have really only been playing for 1 gen, 2 if your lucky lol.

I'd say The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time, with SMG2 a close 2nd. Both MGS IV and GTA IV did not deserve a 10 score. Not sure what Gamespot reviewers were smoking when they rating those games. I think all the hype may have pushed them to that score.

[QUOTE="ferret-gamer"]Half-life 2 (Kevin-V would have given it a 10 if he had been the reviewer)SaltyMeatballs

Legend of Zelda had more of an influence and in pact than any of those games.

I would say OoT followed closely by MGS4. The rest I have not opinion/love for.

I enjoyed Ocarina of Time more than any of these games. But I never played Chrono Cross. So OoT gets my vote.

Metal Gear Solid 4 is the best game this gen.

Oot was ONE of thebest game in that generation.
There were many great games that were on par but most have not played.. Half Life + modsfor instance.

Metal Gear Solid 4 is the best game this gen.

g0ddyX

:lol: MGS4 isn't even the best game on the PS3. Even GTA 4 is superior.

[QUOTE="g0ddyX"]

Metal Gear Solid 4 is the best game this gen.

argetlam00

:lol: MGS4 isn't even the best game on the PS3. Even GTA 4 is superior.

Ugh, I can't believe that's a real opinion. You must be faking. I understand that some people actually enjoyed the train wreck that was GTA 4, and there wasn't a lot of competition for it at the time it came out, but MGS4 has better gameplay, graphics, story, more content (yes, more content than a GTA game).

But, if that is your opinion, I respect that.

The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time

[QUOTE="argetlam00"]

[QUOTE="g0ddyX"]

Metal Gear Solid 4 is the best game this gen.

Pug-Nasty

:lol: MGS4 isn't even the best game on the PS3. Even GTA 4 is superior.

Ugh, I can't believe that's a real opinion. You must be faking. I understand that some people actually enjoyed the train wreck that was GTA 4, and there wasn't a lot of competition for it at the time it came out, but MGS4 has better gameplay, graphics, story, more content (yes, more content than a GTA game).

But, if that is your opinion, I respect that.

I prefer GTA4 over MGS4, MGS4 is the only MGS game I never got into for whatever reason, im still trying to work out why I was so underwhelmed by it 1 and 3 were great though

Chrono Cross or OOT

GTA4 and SMG2 should of been 9's, MGS4 should of been 8-8.5

Half-life 2 (Kevin-V would have given it a 10 if he had been the reviewer)ferret-gamer

MGS4 @ 33%

Ridiculous.

Anyway for me it's OoT.