AAe Wii vs 360 (360 gets blown out of the water!!!)

[QUOTE="ogvampire"]

YAY!! Sheeps are back!!! BTW, check which console has QUALITY AAe's and AAAe's? ;)93soccer

huh?

'AAe' and 'AAAe' ratings are the perception of quality by the reviewer

so saying 'QualityAAe and AAAe' makes no sense

he means "quality" as in "games i would play" ;)

making all games on the wii trash, because he wouldnt tuch them, they are low quality AAA's

SW is so sad.

Quotation marks, because Glitchspot is glitching;

Half-Way; ''that would be like removing the panda from your sig. a ninja is awesome, but not as awesome as a panda''

Removing the panda would be illogical, counting multiplats is logical. So no, it's not the same.

these threads never go well even if they are true people just dont like giving the wii credit i guess lol

Mario1331

[QUOTE="gaming25"]This argument is so dumb. The 360 has tons more AAs that cannot be played on the Wii which is the point of the exclusive debate in the first place.double_a73

Saying this mean Wiiware, VC, and Gamecube games count as well, soo will someone look these up?

Arguing with numbers so high is such a silly thing to do. I guess if you are a true System Warrior, then you would care.

Ultimately, if any console had an exclusive list of 10 games rated A or higher, and an overall library of 20 games rated A or higher, then something is wrong.

When you get to these kind of numbers, any console makes a sound purchase, and the only winner is the gamer. Overall library / exclusives, round and round and round we go. I get to play everything that I want to. Wee!

And yet, I prefer my 360 over my Wii. Funny how that works.SpruceCaboose

I have only 2 Wii games and 45+ 360 ones

So, i guess Wii library is not as good for me

Isn't this thread similar to the king of console exclusives thread? Except this one seems to be failing? All I see in this thread is "Wii has better exclusives" followed by "360 has a better overall library" then it goes round and round and round :?Kenny789

He was spouting some garbage about the Wii having 30+ more AAE then the PS3 had. Then I told him that the Wii only had 22AAE to begin with so him saying that it had 30 MORE AAE then anyconsole was a blatant lie. The Wii has 10 more AAE then the PS3 but the PS3 has 3 more AAAE. Some people would say this balances out, I personally take the AAAE over the AAE any day and some people make pretend games and balatantly lie about the difference in the number of games...Like the TC did in that thread.

Just for reference on the difference between a AA game and a AAA game. lets look at Uncharted 1(8.0) and Uncharted 2(9.5). Uncharted 1 was great, fantastic graphics, great VA, characters, you name it, it was all great. Then there's Uncharted 2 They took EVERYTHING from 1 and made it better and added more of it. The game was longer and had A whole online co-op and competitive multiplayer added. The difference between AAe and AAAE is quite staggering when you stop and think about how much extra content, polish, etc goes into a game to get that extra A. This is why I would take 3 AAAE over 10 AAE any day.

This is a wii vs 360 thread, so that means both libraries are fair game in this topic, and in that I mean "complete" libraries. Why must you have all these special qualifiers and exceptions so that you can pit the wii's library against just a fraction of the 360's? Now with 360 vs ps3, the exclusives are the coin of the realm since both consoles handle multi-plat games equally for the most part with exceptions here and there. But with wii vs 360, it should be the complete game libraries between the two systems since there aren't many games that both share. Its pretty obvious why you don't want to pit the wii's library against the 360's library. So if we're going to have to endure all of these wii vs 360 threads, at least have the courage to pit both libraries against each other, "straight up" as Teddy KGB from Rounders would say.

Damn! the only good 360 games on that list is Fable 2, Viva Pinata, PGR 4, and Shadow Complex. The only bad Wii games on that list is Super Monkey Ball and EA Active. Wii owns the 360 big time!!! Wii tha best MAN!!!

Sonicplys

[QUOTE="Half-Way"]

[QUOTE="ogvampire"]

huh?

'AAe' and 'AAAe' ratings are the perception of quality by the reviewer

so saying 'QualityAAe and AAAe' makes no sense

93soccer

he means "quality" as in "games i would play" ;)

making all games on the wii trash, because he wouldnt tuch them, they are low quality AAA's

its obvious youre not getting it

since they are both considered to be of similar quality, what you are asking is simply based on opinion....

[QUOTE="gaming25"]This argument is so dumb. The 360 has tons more AAs that cannot be played on the Wii which is the point of the exclusive debate in the first place.double_a73

Saying this mean Wiiware, VC, and Gamecube games count as well, soo will someone look these up?

This is a wii vs 360 thread, so that means both libraries are fair game in this topic, and in that I mean "complete" libraries.

FastEddie2121

It's pretty obvious he's talking about exclusives.

[QUOTE="FastEddie2121"]

This is a wii vs 360 thread, so that means both libraries are fair game in this topic, and in that I mean "complete" libraries.

It's pretty obvious he's talking about exclusives.

[QUOTE="Silverbond"]

[QUOTE="FastEddie2121"]

This is a wii vs 360 thread, so that means both libraries are fair game in this topic, and in that I mean "complete" libraries.

gaming25

It's pretty obvious he's talking about exclusives.

Sure, but that's what most of SW's arguments are. PS3 vs 360 exclusives. But for whatever reason, when the Wii gets involved the argument changes to include "overall library".

360

Saints Row
Banjo Kazooi Nuts & Bolts
Dead or Alive 4
Fable 2
Viva Pinata
Viva Pinata Trouble in Paradise
Project Gotham Racing 3
Project Gotham Racing 4
Kameo Elements of Power
Shadow Complex

Wii

Monster Hunter Tri
Zack & Wiki
Tatsunoko vs Capcom
Metroid Prime 3 Corruption
Trauma Team
Trauma Center Second Opinion
Trauma Center New Blood
No More Heroes Desporate Struggle
Dead Space Extraction
Sin & Punishment Star Successor
Super Paper Mario
New Super Mario Bros
Punch Out!!!
The House of the Dead Overkill
Excitebots Trick Racing
A Boy and his Blob
Wii Sports Resort
Endless Oean Blue World
Little Kings Story
Boom Blox Bash Party
Blast Works Build Trade Destroy
Super Monkey Ball Banana Blitz
EA Sports Active

Fried_Shrimp

omg is that robo gaisha in your display?

[QUOTE="gaming25"][QUOTE="Silverbond"]

It's pretty obvious he's talking about exclusives.

Sure, but that's what most of SW's arguments are. PS3 vs 360 exclusives. But for whatever reason, when the Wii gets involved the argument changes to include "overall library".

1) Check the AAAs

2) If a Wii game was reviewed at the same standards of quality as a 360 game, the reviews would be much lower. So I'm just saying, Wii games are only good for Wii games.

3) You listed EA Sports Active

ColdP1zza

Well that is actually partially true games that get AA would not get AA on the 360. The entire market is different games like Trauma Center and EA Sports Active would most likely not get AA on the 360 even if they were the exact same game ported to the 360. When reviewing Wii games people look for different things than when reviewing 360 games.

[QUOTE="Silverbond"]

[QUOTE="gaming25"] sure, but its a pretty .......... argument to have.gaming25

Sure, but that's what most of SW's arguments are. PS3 vs 360 exclusives. But for whatever reason, when the Wii gets involved the argument changes to include "overall library".

That doesn't make them exclusive.

[QUOTE="gaming25"][QUOTE="Silverbond"]

Sure, but that's what most of SW's arguments are. PS3 vs 360 exclusives. But for whatever reason, when the Wii gets involved the argument changes to include "overall library".

Silverbond

That doesn't make them exclusive.

[QUOTE="Silverbond"]

[QUOTE="gaming25"] Because nearly all Multiplat games for the PS3/360 arent for the Wii.eveileb-ekam

That doesn't make them exclusive.

but thats not what happens in ps3 vs 360 debates... they usually only focuse on exclusives, which of course removes any 360/pc games from the comparison

[QUOTE="eveileb-ekam"][QUOTE="Silverbond"]

That doesn't make them exclusive.

ogvampire

but thats not what happens in ps3 vs 360 debates... they usually only focuse on exclusives, which of course removes any 360/pc games from the comparison

Right off the top of my head, I know you're missing Culdcept Saga and Scene It: Box Office Smash from your 360 list.

And personally, I'd take the 360's AAe's over the Wii's. Hell, I'd take Culdcept Saga over the entire Wii AAe list.

[QUOTE="ogvampire"]

[QUOTE="eveileb-ekam"] To be honest, when making a purchasing decision, and you want to buy either a Wii or one of the HD consoles, you are going to look at the overall libraries for each, and then make your decision based on what amount of software you like. Its not flip flopping an argument, its using common sense. On system wars, exclusives matter for the silly metagame. In the real world, its what you can and cant play on the console that matters, and the Wii cannot play the vast majority of multiplatform software. Luckily, it makes up for this in other areas.eveileb-ekam

but thats not what happens in ps3 vs 360 debates... they usually only focuse on exclusives, which of course removes any 360/pc games from the comparison

if youre looking for an HD console, or any console for that matter, you look at what GAMES it has... not just exclusives

more than a few pc/360 games are of high quality... do you seriously not think of them when considering between a ps3 and 360?

Am i the only one who looks at the Wii games TC listed and thought, I wouldn't play any of those even if they where given to me for free?

[QUOTE="eveileb-ekam"][QUOTE="ogvampire"]

but thats not what happens in ps3 vs 360 debates... they usually only focuse on exclusives, which of course removes any 360/pc games from the comparison

ogvampire

if youre looking for an HD console, or any console for that matter, you look at what GAMES it has... not just exclusives

more than a few pc/360 games are of high quality... do you seriously not think of them when considering between a ps3 and 360?

Am i the only one who looks at the Wii games TC listed and thought, I wouldn't play any of those even if they where given to me for free?

mattisgod01

That list is better then the 360's AAAE list IMO (look what you have done to me SW! I'm reduced to pointing out whats an opinion and whats a statement! :cry: )

[QUOTE="mattisgod01"]

Am i the only one who looks at the Wii games TC listed and thought, I wouldn't play any of those even if they where given to me for free?

toast_burner

Super Monkey Ball Banana Blitz...I have no idea what it is but it sounds just...just aweful.

[QUOTE="toast_burner"][QUOTE="mattisgod01"]

Am i the only one who looks at the Wii games TC listed and thought, I wouldn't play any of those even if they where given to me for free?

mattisgod01

Super Monkey Ball Banana Blitz...I have no idea what it is but it sounds just...just aweful.

[QUOTE="toast_burner"][QUOTE="mattisgod01"]

Am i the only one who looks at the Wii games TC listed and thought, I wouldn't play any of those even if they where given to me for free?

mattisgod01

Super Monkey Ball Banana Blitz...I have no idea what it is but it sounds just...just aweful.

[QUOTE="ogvampire"]

[QUOTE="eveileb-ekam"] That is an anomoly used for SW ownage rights, and is stupid, I agree. In the real world, if your looking for just an HD console, then it is exclusives that define the system, and ultimately inform your purchase.eveileb-ekam

if youre looking for an HD console, or any console for that matter, you look at what GAMES it has... not just exclusives

more than a few pc/360 games are of high quality... do you seriously not think of them when considering between a ps3 and 360?

exactly... so in the case of the HD Consoles, a pc/360 game is not on the ps3, so it might as well be considered an exclusive

well, saying 'exclusive' kinda confuses things... so lets just say the pc/360 games get put into consideration

also, im not picking an argument. this is a discussion, not an argument... just trying to get something straight here

[QUOTE="mattisgod01"]

[QUOTE="toast_burner"] Yes you are. That list is better then the 360's AAAE listNintendo_Ownes7

Super Monkey Ball Banana Blitz...I have no idea what it is but it sounds just...just aweful.

I might play No More Heroes and Monster Hunter if i was given them for free but i wouldn't buy them. I still have 12 360 games on my list i'd buy before those.

[QUOTE="gaming25"]This argument is so dumb. The 360 has tons more AAs that cannot be played on the Wii which is the point of the exclusive debate in the first place.double_a73

Saying this mean Wiiware, VC, and Gamecube games count as well, soo will someone look these up?

It really doesn't. These are not wii games. People did not buy a new gen console just to play games they've played before a long time ago.

[QUOTE="double_a73"]

[QUOTE="gaming25"]This argument is so dumb. The 360 has tons more AAs that cannot be played on the Wii which is the point of the exclusive debate in the first place.Chemical_Viking

Saying this mean Wiiware, VC, and Gamecube games count as well, soo will someone look these up?

It really doesn't. These are not wii games. People did not buy a new gen console just to play games they've played before a long time ago.

i didnt know wii ware was old games...

[QUOTE="Chemical_Viking"]

[QUOTE="double_a73"]

Saying this mean Wiiware, VC, and Gamecube games count as well, soo will someone look these up?

Mario1331

It really doesn't. These are not wii games. People did not buy a new gen console just to play games they've played before a long time ago.

i didnt know wii ware was old games...

But the others are are they not? I mean its not difficult. Look at the entire library of made for wii games and the entire library of 360 games and even without the obvious discrepancies between reviews (they're obviously on a different scale, some of the wii games if released on other consoles wouldn't even get noticed let alone 8/10) the 360 is far superior.

You don't get to include 15 year old mega drive games to bolster your library.

Meanwhile, in the real world the 360 has a lot more AA games than the Wii.

Ugh, this is gonna be a long few weeks on System Wars since SMG2 got a 10