[QUOTE="ironcreed"] Let me summarize here....do you really think that the PS3 should have surpassed the 360 straight from it's launch, when the 360 had a YEAR HEADSTART? That my friend, is where your logic is UNFAIRLY AND BLATANTLY SLANTED and very flawed. It is like giving someone in a Porsche a 100 mile headstart over someone in a Ferrari, and then expecting the Ferrari to catch up, and surpass the Porsche straight away, lol. That dog just does not hunt, my friend....sorry. But it gives you some convienient, albeit RIDICULOUS ammo in order to try and demean the PS3 for having a lackluster launch.
I never flat out stated that the PS3 was going to completely out perform the 360, although I believe that it will with many games, and vice versa, the 360 will have some dominant titles as well. Hell, it already does. But I also believe that the PS3 is a superior console hardware wise, and will eventually prove this, given LONGER THAN SIX MONTHS of course. Even top developers, such as Factor 5, and Team Ninja have said so themselves.
How is my stating that "the PS3 is starting to live up to the hype" fundamentally flawed? Just because YOU do not think so? That is just your opinion, as was my original statement just my opinion. Although based on what people within the industry are saying about some of the upcoming titles for the PS3, and based on vidoes, screens, ect....I think I am pretty well justified in saying that the PS3 is indeed starting to deliver on some of it's promises. Namely, GOOD GAMES. Just because YOU personally think that it is just "more of the same" from Sony, it does not mean that these games will under deliver or that they will not be received well by the gaming world.
Why all of the Pessimism? No, you never directly "bashed" the PS3, but you sure do have a negative stance on it, while completely ignoring any, and all of the good news that the PS3 does have that I have brought up. You instead just take it all in and translate it into yet more negative for you to use, by claiming that, "it is just more of the same from Sony". So, tell me, how is that slanted logic not "fundamentally flawed"?
Regardless, man....go ahead and dwell in the past, and condemn the PS3 launch of 6 MONTHS AGO all you want, ok? Go ahead and downplay all of the great looking games that are coming out for the PS3, as if it is nothing but more "Sony lies", lol. No matter what else is said here, it will clearly only lead to further disagreement. So, why don't we just agree to disagree here, rather than continue to get entangled into what boils down to nothing but a mere difference of opinions?
karicha9
Catching up to total sales? Of course not. Surpassing the 360 in monthly sales? Yes.But again, since E3, TGS, Leipzig, there have been plenty of PS3 games hyped to death that didn't deliver. How can you possibly state that this is any different, and now, all of a sudden, once again, use the statement, "PS3 is starting to live up to the hype"?
The fundamental flaw is that original Sony hype encompassed the launch window. You admit yourself it didn't meet expectations, then still ensure that the PS3 is starting to live up to the hype, but how can it live up to the original hype if it didn't meet that hype at launch?
You can say the PS3 is looking for a turn around, potentially poised to push some promising titles, whatever, but you cannot state that the PS3 is starting to live up to the hype.
Furthermore, you are still completely confused about my statements, thinking I'm bashing the PS3, when I'm merely countering the statement, "PS3 is starting to live up to the hype". With what you have stated, you have clearly not shown that the PS3 is living up to the hype, since you STILL can't get past the fact that such hype encompassed the launch. Instead, you rely on trying to smear my words as some sort of tactic to declare my hate for Sony.
You've polarized this discussion to make it seem like opinion. Clearly, it is only on your half.
Yes, I indeed did say that the PS3 had a lackluster launch, as it clearly did. But that in no way means that it eventually cannot or will not live up to being the great console that we all had envisioned it would be, if given the TIME.....a concept you seem to have trouble understanding in regards to this topic. The 360 had a rough start, and DID NOT LIVE UP TO THE HYPE, but given the time, it proved it's worth. The PS3 should be afforded the same courtesy. Yet it is YOU who are polarizing the PS3 by trying to limit it's potential NOW based solely on the fact that it did not live up to it's launch 6 months ago, lol.
Indeed, you are the one who is polarizing here by your placing your own self styled constraints on the PS3, by claiming that somehow it cannot live up to it's hype just because it failed to live up to it's initial launch hype. You further polarize the PS3 by trying to use it's limited launch to overshadow it's future potential....which of course is pointless because what is done is done, and just because it as of yet has NOT lived up to it's hype, it certainly does not mean that it will not.
As for my statements that are in regards to the PS3 "starting to live up to it's hype". I even said that it WAS JUST MY OPINION, therefore, it is NOT fundamentally flawed. There indeed has been good news concerning some very intriguing looking titles that are right around the corner for the PS3, and I for one think that it is a good sign, and worthy of getting hyped for. Besides, what one considers "living up to the hype" is within the eye of the beholder anyway. What is quality for me, may be garbage for you, and vice versa, my friend. One man's cure is another man's poison.
So please, spare me the "fundamentally flawed" accusations, when all you are offering is a sour, opinionated, and POLARIZED forecast based off of the PS3's sour launch only. Your pessimistic, and rather bleak outlook in regards to the PS3 is a mere opinion, just as much as my statements were as well, so if my statements are fundamentally flawed, I guess yours are just as much as mine.
AGAIN, to each his/her own, man. This is nothing but a clash of opinons, therefore they break like glass, as everyone has one. This is drawing out into a perpetual entaglement of two opinons, of which we are BOTH entitled to. End of story.
Log in to comment