Assign a Grade to Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo (EA + Ubisoft too)

• Sony: A+
• Microsoft: C-
• Nintendo: F

Microsoft - C :Halo looks cool, I really liked the flashy kills from Splinter Cell but it's a multiplay yeah? The rest was rather mediocre and that Nike commercial has to be the absolutely worst moment in E3 EVER. Nike talking about how they support stars and what not. Really, if there is anything worse at E3 than companies talking about statistics, it's having a non-gaming company at E3 talking about statistics and such. South Park was hilarious as well but no thanks to Microsoft.

Sony: C maybe : I couldn't watch it so I don't know, but I checked the games and it felt lacking. Last of Us seems great (even though I dislike the post apocalyptic theme) but it seems there was pretty much no grand reveals???

Nintendo Unknown: Did not watch except two moments: Nintendolands which seem to be, a bunch of mini games for Wii U? Way to demonstrate the beast within the Wii U; mini games not utilizing their newly gained power! And I also wasn't too impressed with Zombie U, it seemd a lot of the action was happening on that controller and I am not liking it. I mean, hey, it's not a handheld game. There's a reason I'm having this big*** TV in front of me and here's a hint; it's not because I like watching a smaller monitor in front of it.

Sony- B-

Microsoft- C+

EA- B

Ubisoft- B+

Nintendo- F-

Did we evern need another thread on this topic? Anyway, I give redundant threads an F for not following the sticky.

Did we evern need another thread on this topic? Anyway, I give redundant threads an F for not following the sticky.

thom_maytees

Microsoft: B Sony: B Nintendo: B- All three had high points and low points, I'm particularly disappointed by the lack of a price and release date for the Wii U though.

Did we evern need another thread on this topic? Anyway, I give redundant threads an F for not following the sticky.

thom_maytees

Microsoft - F

Sony - C

Nintendo - D

EA - C

Ubisoft - B+

• Sony - C+
• Nintendo - D
• MS - F

[QUOTE="Silverbond"]No way MS and Sony are a full letter grade apart.kuu2

To Sony Fan it is. This is only because they are fans of Sony and not the actual industry.

If Microsoft is a D and Sony is a C, that is a full letter grade, and not exactly a lie. Sony's was rather standard and lacking in the Vita department, but decent and with some good games and new IP's. Microsoft's was just a trainwreck or Kinect love, Usher dancing and sequels.

MS- D (only Halo 4 really peaked my interest)

EA- D+ (DS3 looked cool but nothing else really interested me)

Ubisoft- C (watchdog was cool and so was dat AC3)

Sony- C- (The only thing I liked was Assassin Creed and The Last of Us. Everything else was pretty boring.)

Ninty- C (Pikmin 3 looked awesome. Paper Mario and Luigi Mansion also looked cool. Everything else was just eh though)

MS- C+

Sony - B-

Nintendo - C-

Nobody blew the doors off at E3 and you would think with Nintendo launching a new console they'd come out and unload all chambers but their conference was very uneventful. They should have started with NintendoLand and ended with Pikmin 3. But in general, all the shows were very sub-par.

[QUOTE="kuu2"]

[QUOTE="Silverbond"]No way MS and Sony are a full letter grade apart.SPYDER0416

To Sony Fan it is. This is only because they are fans of Sony and not the actual industry.

If Microsoft is a D and Sony is a C, that is a full letter grade, and not exactly a lie. Sony's was rather standard and lacking in the Vita department, but decent and with some good games and new IP's. Microsoft's was just a trainwreck or Kinect love, Usher dancing and sequels.

Microsoft - F +

Sony - C

Nintendo - C -

EA - D

Ubisoft - B

I'm hard to please what can I say...

[QUOTE="ForzaGearsFace"]

[QUOTE="Wasdie"]

Microsoft - F

Sony - C

Nintendo - D

Ubi - A

EA - D

parkurtommo

how could you give MS an F when it showed off HALO4 and it looked awesome, that shouldnt fail it.

Who did a good live performance....

Anyway

MS - C

Sony - B

Ubi - A

Konami - B

EA - C+

Nintendo - D

Microsoft -F

Nintendo -D

Ubisoft B+

Sony B

That new splinter cell game just looked so bad, like seriously.

Microsoft - C

EA - D

Ubisoft - B

Sony - C

Nintendo - F

Microsoft - C

EA - D

Ubisoft - B

Sony - C

Nintendo - F

KingFrizzy

sony B+ was a good show byt felt a little flat at times

Nintendo c+ To much family games but they are selling it to wii users as well as hardcore but i wanted more third party

Microsoft D- they got decent thrid party games and not much else other then halo

sony B+ was a good show byt felt a little flat at times

Nintendo c+ To much family games but they are selling it to wii users as well as hardcore but i wanted more third party

Microsoft D- they got decent thrid party games and not much else other then halo

dontshackzmii

[QUOTE="dontshackzmii"]

sony B+ was a good show byt felt a little flat at times

Nintendo c+ To much family games but they are selling it to wii users as well as hardcore but i wanted more third party

Microsoft D- they got decent thrid party games and not much else other then halo

JohnnyCageMK

Microsoft F-: Don't own a 360 so I don't really care about Microsofts conference.

Nintendo D-: Not good it lacked the spark of previous years plus the WiiU still hasn't won me over looks like

Sony: A+:Alot of good stuff:Nathan Drake Playstation All Stars Reveal,first gameplay of the Last of Us,GOW looked great and to top it off the newly announced Beyond has me very excited and proud to be a PS3 owner.

Ubisoft C+: Rayman and Assassins Creed 3 not bad.

EA D-:Not even Dead Space 3 could save them.

Microsoft:D- (Focused too much on garbage like Nike shoes)

Nintendo:B-(Focused a bit too much on NintendoLand even though the idea behind it looked interesting, but the conference was pretty good and had a couple of great moments).

Sony:Haven't watched yet

Ubisoft:From what I watched it was a lot better then ninty's conference

sw translation for company grades.

system i don't like F.

system balls deep in my throat A+!!!

MS: D+

Sony: C

Ninty: C

Ubisoft: A+

EA: D

Microsoft: F-

Sony: D

Nintendo: F-

Ubisoft: C+

EA: D-

Microsoft only had Halo 4

Sony had no Vita games, but atleast it seemed like they were trying with The Last of Us and the new GOW. Don't forget DRAWBOOK.

Nintendo: There is only one word: Nintendoland. Not many details about the WiiU and no good games.

Ubisoft: only Watch Dogs was good.

EA: everything was Uncharted or COD

MS - F

Sony -D

Nintendo -D

EA - U

Ubisoft - A*

Microsoft: D

Sony: C

Nintendo C

Ubisoft: A-

EA: D

I give them all an F. E3 as a whole was FAIL.

Sony: D+

MS: D

Nintendo: D-

EA: Didn't watch

Ubisoft: A-

Only watched Nintendo's, didn't bother with the others. Was a C- at best, there was no new news whatsoever other than ZombiU and NintendoLand, which both didn't interest me at all.

MS: C- (Halo 4 and Forza Horizon looked awesome but no Xbox3)

Sony: C- (The Last of Us and GoW looked awesome but no PS4)

Nintendo: C (nothing very interesting but at least they had new hardware)

Ubisoft: B+ (Watch Dogs looked incredible but im not hyped for AC3)

EA: C+ (not bad, just more of the same)

MS-C

Sony-B+

Nintendo-B

EA-D

Ubisoft-C+

MS: D (Microsoft didn't show anything to convince me to purchase a new 360 only thing that was interesting was Halo 4 but that isn't enough)

Sony: C (They showed some good things but they didn't show much on Vita and they took too much time with Wonderbook)

Ninty: C (They had a lot of games and they were good. I wish they showed Project P-100 instead of Nintendo Land)

Ubisoft: A (They had some great games shown)

EA: Couldn't vote I missed 20 minutes in the middle of it.

microsoft C+

sony C+

nintendo C

Microsoft: C - Halo 4, Gears Of War Judgement, Forza Horizon, easily the best console for multi-media

Sony: C - The Last Of Us, God Of War Ascension, Beyond

Nintendo: C+ - Project P-100, New Mario Bros 2, GTA Legos, ZombiU (don't forget Nintendo has more to show tomorrow!)

Ubisoft: B+ - Splinter Cell, Assasins Creed, Rayman, ZombieU etc

EA: C+ - Crysis III, Stars War 1313, Dead Space III, etc

MS: D

EA: C

Ubi: A-

Sony: B

Nintendo: C