BIggest flop this year?

The title says it all, after Zelda Skyward Sword enter the nominations for Biggest Flop this year

I wanna ask questions: What's the biggest flop this year?

First, it was Infamous 2 that scored 7.5 here, although when I played it I feel it should've been 9.0, then GS made another mistake:

Zelda scored 7.5....really....biggest flop ever....

I seriusly can not believe GS review anymore, if there's anybody out here who think that Zelda SS is really a 7.5 game then....

Anybody not picking Zelda, is either trolling or has seriously never been on GameSpot before and just picked a random game.

This thread.

I'd say Zelda. Very surprising score, but I am not up in arms over it because I have never played a Zelda game before.

Zelda, but it doesn't surprise me because there shouldn't have been much hype over this game.

Zelda and Uncharted 3 is not a flop

zelda quite easily...as its meant to be like nintendos biggest franchise (behind mario?)

5 years of anticipation

7.5campzor

Duke Nukem forever beats that easily

15 years of anticipation

3.0

i wanna say zelda but the title goes to duke nukem and why is uncharted 3 up there, you really hate sony don't you?

Guess people will never get over zelda flopping lol....

Zelda:SS is the biggest flop of all time, not just of this year.

Zelda SS is the biggest flop of this gen

How are any of these games flops? Just because gamespot provided poor reviews doesnt mean the game is bad. Zelda average on gamespot 94%. All the other are in 80% or 90% so yep just some terrible reviewers.

Zelda definitely. Wonder why Uncharted 3 is up there though since 9.0 is AAA.exiledsnake

Zelda SS is the biggest flop of this gen

DroidPhysX

hmm or second biggest flop this gen to DNF, both pretty close though

A 9 out of 10 is considered a flop? What the f*** is wrong with this board?

How are any of these games flops? Just because gamespot provided poor reviews doesnt mean the game is bad. Zelda average on gamespot 94%. All the other are in 80% or 90% so yep just some terrible reviewers.

arsenal262

[QUOTE="campzor"]zelda quite easily...as its meant to be like nintendos biggest franchise (behind mario?)

5 years of anticipation

7.5R4gn4r0k

Duke Nukem forever beats that easily

15 years of anticipation

3.0

I was going to say Zelda, but DNF is far more of a FLOP!

In Gamespot? Zelda, without a spot of a doubt.

How about none of those?? The Nintendo haters seem to be having a field day btw, lol...superclocked

Zelda SS doesn't win GOTY but winning this contest is on Lock !! :P

Zelda and Uncharted 3 is not a flop

EPaul

Zelda SS doesn't win GOTY but winning this contest is on Lock !! :P

SecretPolice

How are any of these games flops? Just because gamespot provided poor reviews doesnt mean the game is bad. Zelda average on gamespot 94%. All the other are in 80% or 90% so yep just some terrible reviewers.

arsenal262

EDIT: and "Zelda average on gamespot 94%" does not make it better since it is still a hype avaage.

[QUOTE="SecretPolice"]

Zelda SS doesn't win GOTY but winning this contest is on Lock !! :P

fernandmondego_

How about none of those?? The Nintendo haters seem to be having a field day btw, lol...superclocked

From this list I'll say it's Zelda, but in all honesty nothing beats Duke Nukem Forever in terms of floppage.

Also, why is UC3 on here? It met its hype.

Duke Nukem forever, I mean sure Zelda got a very suprising score (I would have probably guessed at 8.0) however Duke Nukem Forever had many years of production, loads of money thrown in and produced a 3.0 and also flopped on many different websites as well.

Flop of the year and perhaps the past Decade is Duke Nukem Forever

From this list I'll say it's Zelda, but in all honesty nothing beats Duke Nukem Forever in terms of floppage.

Also, why is UC3 on here? It met its hype.

SpiritOfFire117

[QUOTE="arsenal262"]

How are any of these games flops? Just because gamespot provided poor reviews doesnt mean the game is bad. Zelda average on gamespot 94%. All the other are in 80% or 90% so yep just some terrible reviewers.

digimonkey12

Sorry, I know I sound like an idiot but what is SW.

Battlefield 3. It was hyped to be the superior game to MW3, and ended up getting lower scores overall. Zelda, on the other hand, has so far only flopped on Gamespot, and we should have learned a long time ago not to take Gamespot's reviews too seriously.

[QUOTE="SpiritOfFire117"]

From this list I'll say it's Zelda, but in all honesty nothing beats Duke Nukem Forever in terms of floppage.

Also, why is UC3 on here? It met its hype.

ihsanqueen

Zelda has been getting high scores and I'm sure it will sell a lot as well. Duke Nukem forever was hated by pretty much everyone.

[QUOTE="SpiritOfFire117"]

From this list I'll say it's Zelda, but in all honesty nothing beats Duke Nukem Forever in terms of floppage.

Also, why is UC3 on here? It met its hype.

ihsanqueen

It is not considered a flop it's Hype was AAA and it got AAA

On Gamespot? Zelda SS definitely.

[QUOTE="SpiritOfFire117"]

From this list I'll say it's Zelda, but in all honesty nothing beats Duke Nukem Forever in terms of floppage.

Also, why is UC3 on here? It met its hype.

ihsanqueen

Last I recalled it was hyped at AAA. 9.0 counts as AAA. Just because you were expecting a 9.5 or even a 10 doesn't neccessarily mean it's a flop, or at least a significant one.

How about none of those?? The Nintendo haters seem to be having a field day btw, lol...superclocked