This topic is locked from further discussion.
I find it hilarious that people mentioning halo 3 in there list cant really explain why :roll:Gh0st_Of_0nyxI agree, it got AAA here, AAA on metacritic and gamerankings, sold millions and is still in the top 10 most played games on Xbox Live, and that's a flop, give me a break.
WTF twlight princess was an amazing game I'm a big fan but even I will say it does'nt deserve anything over a 9kemar7856
That's how I felt when I played the game, too. When it came out it was already a year old, and the extra dungeons that Nintendo threw in were kind of a drag IMO. They delayed it for a year even though it was done, just so they could put it on Wii. I mean, WTF? If Nintendo had released it when they were supposed to, I probably would have loved it, but as it was Nintendo released a somewhat uneven feeling experience that already felt old by the time it came out. It was a good game, but in terms of Zelda's legacy it didn't really do much to stand out at all.
As a gamer, Oblivion had a way bigger impact on me. Nintendo should have just released Zelda TP when it was finished as a Gamecube exclusive, and then developed a new game for Wii's flagship title. If TP had been a shorter, more tightly knit experience that was released when I was still excited for it, I think I would have enjoyed it a lot more.
[QUOTE="Juggernaut140"]Daikatana beast667How did this not end the thread? Theres really nothing that comes close to Daikatana in terms of hype-failure. I guess this really is fanboy wars, not system wars :? Well, I doubt many gamers who started gaming last or this gen know that game.
To those saying Bioshock failed, how is it a flop? The game was AAA here and has a ratio of 95 on GR and was well recieved by many ppl.
MGS2
Final Fantasy 8
Shenmue 1
Silent Hill 2
Street Fighter 3 (the original)
Devil May Cry 2
Guyper
ummm....mgs2? sorry MGS2?
hell no, that game blew every1s mind once it released so dont start b$-ing!
@TC
ur pretty much right, halo 3 was not a failure though :|
No way. TP was officially hyped AAA, not AAAA and it barely missed the consensus. Games like Lair, Haze, and Too Human were hyped even more and fell through the floor while the games you listed mostly had good or even great scores.Bigboi500
I know hating on Halo 3 is the done-cool-thing around here; but how can you possibly argue that it was a hype failure? It got AAA reviews, sold by the shed-load and is the most played game on live. :| The hating on halo is so generic these days it often doesn't even make sense. Ninja-HippoCouldn't have said it better myself.
Keep on jumping on that Halo-hate bandwagon guys.
[QUOTE="Bigboi500"]No way. TP was officially hyped AAA, not AAAA and it barely missed the consensus. Games like Lair, Haze, and Too Human were hyped even more and fell through the floor while the games you listed mostly had good or even great scores.foxhound_fox
[QUOTE="Guyper"]MGS2
Final Fantasy 8
Shenmue 1
Silent Hill 2
Street Fighter 3 (the original)
Devil May Cry 2
Generalmojo
ummm....mgs2? sorry MGS2?
hell no, that game blew every1s mind once it released so dont start b$-ing!
@TC
ur pretty much right, halo 3 was not a failure though :|
I've heard that MGS2 was a huge disappointment from MGS fans around here. But this was a while back...[QUOTE="Bigboi500"]No way. TP was officially hyped AAA, not AAAA and it barely missed the consensus. Games like Lair, Haze, and Too Human were hyped even more and fell through the floor while the games you listed mostly had good or even great scores.foxhound_fox
If I recall correctly you were one of the biggest hypers of Bioshock and MP 3 back then. :P
[QUOTE="Generalmojo"][QUOTE="Guyper"]MGS2
Final Fantasy 8
Shenmue 1
Silent Hill 2
Street Fighter 3 (the original)
Devil May Cry 2
Juggernaut140
ummm....mgs2? sorry MGS2?
hell no, that game blew every1s mind once it released so dont start b$-ing!
@TC
ur pretty much right, halo 3 was not a failure though :|
I've heard that MGS2 was a huge disappointment from MGS fans around here. But this was a while back...Thats becuase u have to play as a character who looks like a girl, and NOT as Snake, but every1 got used to the story and layout and loved it all the way through
PSP, it didn't fail. Because to stand up to Nintendo in the Handheld market has been seen as fail many times, they managed to stand, but not move their feet. It failed at is goal which was be the last trump card to Nintendo in the handheld market and was supposed to take the handheld market from Nintendo. ULTRA Hype Falure.
But how can anyone consider PS3 a flop? PS3 was just buildup off of the extraordinary PS2 and PS1 sales. Who wouldn't hype it? I love my PS3
Apparently, PS3 is the exceptional flop but PSP is the biggest flop period. At least the PSP has decent sales and sold a million in December... and even beats the Wii in Japan. Oh yes but, a 720k in Dec. and sub-10k sales in Japan is exceptional :roll:PSP, it didn't fail. Because to stand up to Nintendo in the Handheld market has been seen as fail many times, they managed to stand, but not move their feet. It failed at is goal which was be the last trump card to Nintendo in the handheld market and was supposed to take the handheld market from Nintendo. ULTRA Hype Falure.
But how can anyone consider PS3 a flop? PS3 was just buildup off of the extraordinary PS2 and PS1 sales. Who wouldn't hype it? I love my PS3
DazedDarkness
PSP is nowhere near as big as a flop as the PS3.
WTF twlight princess was an amazing game I'm a big fan but even I will say it does'nt deserve anything over a 9kemar7856I take you weren't around the time Zelda TP flopped? Many hyped it to be the next Zelda: OoT. AAAAAAA on lock! the dissapointment was huge. But I agree, Zelda TP is a damn fine game regardless.
[QUOTE="DazedDarkness"]Apparently, PS3 is the exceptional flop but PSP is the biggest flop period. At least the PSP has decent sales and sold a million in December... and even beats the Wii in Japan. Oh yes but, a 720k in Dec. and sub-10k sales in Japan is exceptional :roll:PSP, it didn't fail. Because to stand up to Nintendo in the Handheld market has been seen as fail many times, they managed to stand, but not move their feet. It failed at is goal which was be the last trump card to Nintendo in the handheld market and was supposed to take the handheld market from Nintendo. ULTRA Hype Falure.
But how can anyone consider PS3 a flop? PS3 was just buildup off of the extraordinary PS2 and PS1 sales. Who wouldn't hype it? I love my PS3
Vanadium2k8
PSP is nowhere near as big as a flop as the PS3.
This is hype flop, not sales flop, that thing was hyped as much as that South Park made it out to be. And I even Said that it wasn't a sales flop I said it flopped at what it was supposed to be, and that was to stomp Nintendo in the handheld market, once and for all. I own one... And it does suck games wise. Lets just say that sales still don't mean anything. That thing was hyped to be the biggest piece of tech in years.[QUOTE="kemar7856"]WTF twlight princess was an amazing game I'm a big fan but even I will say it does'nt deserve anything over a 9killerfistI take you weren't around the time Zelda TP flopped? Many hyped it to be the next Zelda: OoT. AAAAAAA on lock! the dissapointment was huge. But I agree, Zelda TP is a damn fine game regardless. In its defense, I'll say that TP's flop was kinda limited to GS and SW. Look GR, highest rated game of 2006 (yup, better rated than Oblivion or the first Gears). Lair's flop was absolute. :P
[QUOTE="killerfist"][QUOTE="kemar7856"]WTF twlight princess was an amazing game I'm a big fan but even I will say it does'nt deserve anything over a 9IronBassI take you weren't around the time Zelda TP flopped? Many hyped it to be the next Zelda: OoT. AAAAAAA on lock! the dissapointment was huge. But I agree, Zelda TP is a damn fine game regardless. In its defense, I'll say that TP's flop was kinda limited to GS and SW. Look GR, highest rated game of 2006 (yup, better rated than Oblivion or the first Gears). Lair's flop was absolute. :P meh, fair enough. I thought that was the point of this thread.
If we go by gamerankings and metacritic, in which it has an 81%, then yes, PDZ is a flop. If we got by Gamespot, it's not a flop, it was hyped AAA and got AAA(9.0).Lionheart08
- Lair
- Too Human
- Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
- Perfect Dark Zero
- Killzone
- GTA4 (Based off the mixed reaction from the fanbase :P)
- Spore
BioShock, Twilight Princess and Killzone. All three were going to usher in the second coming of Christ and were "guaranteed" AAAA ratings. They fell so short, even knowing they didn't meet their intended goals and hype was disappointing.foxhound_foxSometimes I think I'm the only person alive who thinks that Bioshock lived up to the hype. :(
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment