http://reviews.cnet.com/2722-9020_7-743.html?tag=rb_content;carouselMain
Discuss.
CNET Prize Fight: 360S vs. PS3 slim...PS3 wins by .04!
This topic is locked from further discussion.
It's a tie.
According to the link, overall result was winner = PS3.It's a tie.
adv_tr00per
[QUOTE="KevinButlerVP"]didn't the PS3 win by 2.3tempest91
I didn't calculate it, but I think it's an average, not a total. Maybe I'm wrong though.
yeah I was just looking at the last round by accident, not the entire thing
[QUOTE="tempest91"]
Online services 5 to 3.3, I think that argument is settled.
FIipMode
What argument? That XBL is superior to PSN? Who argued PSN was a better online service? People just don't want to pay for online.
It was a joke, and a response to the playstation plus thread from yesterday.
[QUOTE="tempest91"]
Online services 5 to 3.3, I think that argument is settled.
FIipMode
What argument? That XBL is superior to PSN? Who argued PSN was a better online service? People just don't want to pay for online.
Exactly even if it is a better experience. Now if you only game online for the most part I could see the reason why you would just get a 360. Personally I loved how they felt that exclusive games were better on the PS3 also even though PSN ones were lacking compared to XBLA.
[QUOTE="FIipMode"]
[QUOTE="tempest91"]
Online services 5 to 3.3, I think that argument is settled.
tempest91
What argument? That XBL is superior to PSN? Who argued PSN was a better online service? People just don't want to pay for online.
It was a joke, and a response to the playstation plus thread from yesterday.
Well at least put a ":P" or something :P.
Nothing but facts and good information but PS3 weakness can still be still be fixed if the big patch rumor is true.
XBL>>>PSN but noone wants to pay for online on top of monthly fee for online.
If Microsoft had online in XBL silver most people wouldnt even bother with XBl gold tbh.
[QUOTE="tempest91"]
[QUOTE="FIipMode"]
What argument? That XBL is superior to PSN? Who argued PSN was a better online service? People just don't want to pay for online.
FIipMode
It was a joke, and a response to the playstation plus thread from yesterday.
Well at least put a ":P" or something :P.
Sorry, i always forget that sarcasm only works in person...:oops:
What's the big patch rumour? I haven't been here much recently so I must have missed it.Nothing but facts and good information but PS3 weakness can still be still be fixed if the big patch rumor is true.
XBL>>>PSN but noone wants to pay for online on top of monthly fee for online.
If Microsoft had online in XBL silver most people wouldnt even bother with XBl gold tbh.
Keiji993
Winning only by 0.4? blasphemy.
Cnet should've called this particular prize fight "Consolation Round", or "Second Place Battle" or something along those lines...
[QUOTE="FIipMode"]
[QUOTE="tempest91"]
Online services 5 to 3.3, I think that argument is settled.
3rdbass
What argument? That XBL is superior to PSN? Who argued PSN was a better online service? People just don't want to pay for online.
Exactly even if it is a better experience. Now if you only game online for the most part I could see the reason why you would just get a 360. Personally I loved how they felt that exclusive games were better on the PS3 also even though PSN ones were lacking compared to XBLA.
Your talking about the online exclusives like Braid and Flower right? Or are you talking about exclusives meaning all games?
[QUOTE="tempest91"]
It was a joke, and a response to the playstation plus thread from yesterday.
Zophar87
So Playstation won a poll from a Playstation thread? That's not biased at all...
I just thought it was funny that there were several people defending plus's value to the death, and all 3 of these guys dismiss it and Home as a feeble attempt to strike back at XBL.
funny how poeple said Bluray would fail and everyone will switch to downloadable MediaMunashait hasn't failed yet. that being said (and believe me, i really like my PS3 for bluray), its mighty convenient to just download an hd movie via the many means of traffic available. especially nice if you don't want to wait for netflix in the mail.
[QUOTE="3rdbass"]
[QUOTE="FIipMode"]
What argument? That XBL is superior to PSN? Who argued PSN was a better online service? People just don't want to pay for online.
Blazerdt47
Exactly even if it is a better experience. Now if you only game online for the most part I could see the reason why you would just get a 360. Personally I loved how they felt that exclusive games were better on the PS3 also even though PSN ones were lacking compared to XBLA.
Your talking about the online exclusives like Braid and Flower right? Or are you talking about exclusives meaning all games?
They were talking about disc based exclusives being better on the PS3 now but this being outweighed by XBLA DD ones being better than PSN DD.
funny how poeple said Bluray would fail and everyone will switch to downloadable MediaMunasha
Bluray won't fail. In the time it would take me to download one bluray movie, I would drive.. no, walk slowly, to a store and buy the disc and walk slowly back home and watch it couple times. I can see the downloadable media as a future, but it isn't close future yet. Maybe 10 years from now on or so.
[QUOTE="KevinButlerVP"]good for the PS3, another winclone01why do you care? do you have stock in sony? huh? since when was this thread about sales or money, this is about a scoring
[QUOTE="clone01"][QUOTE="KevinButlerVP"]good for the PS3, another winKevinButlerVPwhy do you care? do you have stock in sony? huh? since when was this thread about sales or money, this is about a scoring scoring what? how did you win? because your hunk of plastic beat another hunk of plastic on CNET? and, sorry, if you believe sony, ms, or ninty care about much more than sales, i'd have to say you're mistaken.
[QUOTE="Munasha"]funny how poeple said Bluray would fail and everyone will switch to downloadable MediaIcarian
Bluray won't fail. In the time it would take me to download one bluray movie, I would drive.. no, walk slowly, to a store and buy the disc and walk slowly back home and watch it couple times. I can see the downloadable media as a future, but it isn't close future yet. Maybe 10 years from now on or so.
Bluray can still fail, as DVD is still very popular, I think it will take a few years before we are sure bluray didnt fail. Netflix coming to canada and UK, could put a dent in bluray and dvd sales.....if they are HD quality. in North American DD will not be meanstream in like forever, but the west of the world it would be no problem
this review this review wtf is up with this comparison
round 5 graphics
jeff games look the same
scott Technically, the PS3 can knock the socks off the Xbox 360, but we've rarely seen any games other than first-party titles that really take a step forward.
the only person i can only agree withnon bias on this article is brian
[QUOTE="KevinButlerVP"][QUOTE="clone01"] why do you care? do you have stock in sony?clone01huh? since when was this thread about sales or money, this is about a scoring scoring what? how did you win? because your hunk of plastic beat another hunk of plastic on CNET? and, sorry, if you believe sony, ms, or ninty care about much more than sales, i'd have to say you're mistaken. So it went from asking if he holds stock to Sony only cares about sales? :lol: I like how you are so consistent. A win is a win, if you don't care about it doesn't mean nobody else does.
[QUOTE="clone01"][QUOTE="KevinButlerVP"] huh? since when was this thread about sales or money, this is about a scoringmystervjscoring what? how did you win? because your hunk of plastic beat another hunk of plastic on CNET? and, sorry, if you believe sony, ms, or ninty care about much more than sales, i'd have to say you're mistaken. So it went from asking if he holds stock to Sony only cares about sales? :lol: I like how you are so consistent. how did he win? i'm just asking. what did he gain? kudos on a cnet battle? possible sales? how is that inconsistent? A win is a win, if you don't care about it doesn't mean nobody else does.
[QUOTE="KevinButlerVP"]good for the PS3, another winclone01why do you care? do you have stock in sony?
Chill out man, this is SYSTEM WARS. That's why he cares :|
t3h Trey :D!...again!
As far as graphics comparison part goes, isnt having slightly better multiplats, the stuff that makes up most of our gaming these days, a really big plus for the syestem? To the extent where it could be a deciding factor?
As far as graphics comparison part goes, isnt having slightly better multiplats, the stuff that makes up most of our gaming these days, a really big plus for the syestem? To the extent where it could be a deciding factor?
XboximusPrime
argue with with this: both ign and cnet gave the win to the ps3. argue with that.
:)
As far as graphics comparison part goes, isnt having slightly better multiplats, the stuff that makes up most of our gaming these days, a really big plus for the syestem? To the extent where it could be a deciding factor?
XboximusPrime
not really.
there's definitely a differentiation between the two, but to the average gamer it won't be blatantly obvious to where their immediate thought is: "wow...butchered port much?"
[QUOTE="XboximusPrime"]
As far as graphics comparison part goes, isnt having slightly better multiplats, the stuff that makes up most of our gaming these days, a really big plus for the syestem? To the extent where it could be a deciding factor?
crimsonsabre
argue with with this: both ign and cnet gave the win to the ps3. argue with that.
:)
untill gamespot comes out with the oppisite comparision what t hen lol.[QUOTE="XboximusPrime"]
As far as graphics comparison part goes, isnt having slightly better multiplats, the stuff that makes up most of our gaming these days, a really big plus for the syestem? To the extent where it could be a deciding factor?
HelloMoto56
not really.
there's definitely a differentiation between the two, but to the average gamer it won't be blatantly obvious to where their immediate thought is: "wow...butchered port much?"
Not a butchered port, but atleast not one with the same graphical quality. And why wouldnt you want the best looking and running one? dosent make sense to me. Its like Ignoring that XBOX 1 recieved the better multiplat if you have the choice to play it on that. And why wouldnt you want that better version?
Also, this isnt anoticeable difference? http://www.lensoftruth.com/?p=21110what about this? http://www.lensoftruth.com/?p=16135Or this: http://www.lensoftruth.com/?p=19855
If I got the PS3 versions of these if I could have gotten the 360 version, id feel mighty stupid. and thats what im talking about. That feeling of knowing you arent stupid for buying it on one syestem because chances are itll be worse is great and when you do get the version you know thats probaly worse, you feel like crap. And if you have the choice, theres really no reason to get the worse version, which will probaly be most of them on PS3. Its like, I have to lie to myself or overlook stuff just to think its just as good.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment