Consolespot am confirmed

[QUOTE="XturnalS"]

[QUOTE="Hanass"]

But you played the console version, so you don't really have an accurate idea of what the game really is. The PC version is very different.

SaltyMeatballs

content and gameplay wise? probably not.

Graphics and UI (which may alter the gameplay a bit) But other than that I don't see that huge of a difference between the console and PC versions. Its a .5 difference not a 5 point difference.

How so? I'd honestly like to know because for me its: pause queue up some attacks, unpause, fighting happens, do some real time button presses for spells/attacks, pause if I'm getting overwhelmed, queue up potions/healing spells, unpause, and finish fight.

Rinse repeat. Is it drastically different from that?

[QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

[QUOTE="HAZE-Unit"]

Well Dragon Age should have been in the As, the game is very old school and doesn't do anything new to the genre, add to that the awful graphics, bugs and framerate issues in both 360 and PS3 consoles, clunky gameplay mechanics and you get an overrated trash.

Skittles_McGee

and a somewhat challenging Action RPG Does DO something new to the genre?

This is exactly what I wanted to say.

It is an opinion. Get used to seeing people having different opinions. Not everyone has some agenda towards one console or another. Most people don't care.

[QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

[QUOTE="HAZE-Unit"]

Well Dragon Age should have been in the As, the game is very old school and doesn't do anything new to the genre, add to that the awful graphics, bugs and framerate issues in both 360 and PS3 consoles, clunky gameplay mechanics and you get an overrated trash.

Skittles_McGee

and a somewhat challenging Action RPG Does DO something new to the genre?

like reading messages that state "be wary of fall ahead" in front of pits that most intelligent people would've already guessed meant death obviously if you drop down?...i'm sure bioware is real sorry they didnt implement that "unique" innovation into DA.

[QUOTE="Skittles_McGee"][QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

and a somewhat challenging Action RPG Does DO something new to the genre?

Kandlegoat

like reading messages that state "be wary of fall ahead" in front of pits that most intelligent people would've already guessed meant death obviously if you drop down?...i'm sure bioware is real sorry they didnt implement that "unique" innovation into DA.

[QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

[QUOTE="Skittles_McGee"] Demon's Souls? Yes actually, it does. Nearly all of the Demon's Souls online features are new to the genre, hence part of the reason it won the award for Best Original Game Mechanic. It innovates in some ways.Skittles_McGee

like reading messages that state "be wary of fall ahead" in front of pits that most intelligent people would've already guessed meant death obviously if you drop down?...i'm sure bioware is real sorry they didnt implement that "unique" innovation into DA.

PvP has been around forever....You don't play many RPGs,do you?

[QUOTE="Skittles_McGee"][QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

like reading messages that state "be wary of fall ahead" in front of pits that most intelligent people would've already guessed meant death obviously if you drop down?...i'm sure bioware is real sorry they didnt implement that "unique" innovation into DA.

Kandlegoat

PvP has been around forever....You don't play many RPGs,do you?

[QUOTE="Revolution316"]

[QUOTE="HoolaHoopMan"]That is what's puzzling to me as well. I've played and beaten both, and I can say that DAO is easily better than Demon's Soul's. But just remember that this is the same site that said MGS4 had better graphics than Crysis: Warhead.mirriorman

[QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

[QUOTE="Skittles_McGee"] Call it what you want, but it is something new. There's also the way different players interact such as Black Phantoms, as an easy example. You can downplay it all night. It brought something new.Skittles_McGee

PvP has been around forever....You don't play many RPGs,do you?

Haven't played either, so no comment from me...

What I really dont understand didnt all the people claiming that Demon Souls didnt deserved the award But believe 90% of the havent even touched the Game I dont thing they have even seen soneone playing it Soo The **** can you say that this game deserved it and this one not When you even havent touched one of the games?

[QUOTE="mirriorman"]

[QUOTE="Revolution316"]gametrailers also gave rpg of the year to DS. so its not only GS. theres no way a turnbased boring sleeping pill of an rpg can beat a action rpg.

Revolution316

The score is given by an individual reviewer, while the editorial board decides on the overall best game.iggyb387

Much like Metacritic and GameRankings where the industry decides the overall best game.

What I really dont understand didnt all the people claiming that Demon Souls didnt deserved the award But believe 90% of the havent even touched the Game I dont thing they have even seen soneone playing it Soo The **** can you say that this game deserved it and this one not When you even havent touched one of the games?

Haito_81

[QUOTE="Salt_The_Fries"]Since when 9.5 < 9.0

How could Gamespot so impetuously put Demon's Souls ahead of Dragon's Age: Origins?

PC is not a platform? :(

Disgrace...XturnalS

1. Scores don't mean squat in determining which game wins which award. 8.4 GOTY to Everquest is proof enough.

2. Group opinion > individual opinion

3. DS is just as deserving of the award as DAO and this isn't the first place DS has won RPGOTY.

Much like how Metacritic + GameRankings > gamespot

[QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

[QUOTE="Skittles_McGee"] Call it what you want, but it is something new. There's also the way different players interact such as Black Phantoms, as an easy example. You can downplay it all night. It brought something new.Skittles_McGee

PvP has been around forever....You don't play many RPGs,do you?

[QUOTE="XturnalS"][QUOTE="Salt_The_Fries"]Since when 9.5 < 9.0

How could Gamespot so impetuously put Demon's Souls ahead of Dragon's Age: Origins?

PC is not a platform? :(

Disgrace...Hexagon_777

1. Scores don't mean squat in determining which game wins which award. 8.4 GOTY to Everquest is proof enough.

2. Group opinion > individual opinion

3. DS is just as deserving of the award as DAO and this isn't the first place DS has won RPGOTY.

Much like how Metacritic + GameRankings > gamespot

Better than Demon's Souls? With the combat system of DAO?

Nope, I'll take Gamespot's opinion thanks.

Better than Demon's Souls? With the combat system of DAO?

Nope, I'll take Gamespot's opinion thanks.

Theguy56

Ps3 has higher standards :P

[QUOTE="Theguy56"]

Better than Demon's Souls? With the combat system of DAO?

Nope, I'll take Gamespot's opinion thanks.

AAllxxjjnn