Critics are Diggin the PS Move (move reviews thread) *Updated Oct 15*

Move is clearly the best and wii doesnt stand a chance in graphics/physics making it look very poor compared.Also, 3D in HD with motion control brings it to a whole new level.killzowned24

The Move is only slightly better than Wii M+. It picks up motion a bit better. The pointer is not superior to Wii m+ though. It's a bit more laggy.

Most Wii owners don't care about graphics. Gameplay + Fun > Graphics. And a lot of Wii ames have great gameplay.

The Move is what the Wii motes wish they were and Kinect sucks because it can only do 2p games and can't do shooters not having controllers.

The Move 10/10

Wii Motion 8.5/10

Kinect 7/10

This is how I see it owning 2 Wiis and 3 PS3s and watching vids and reading up about Kinect.

clruff

first off, how can you rate the kinect when it hasn't even been released yet?

secondly, LMFAO @ owning 2 wiis and 3 ps3s....

I'm addicted to Table Tennis on SC and boy I got a work out with it as far as my shoulder. LOL. Isn't it suppose to be tennis elbow. lOL. SC is a lot more accurate and fun then Wii Sports. I can see where Wii sports might appeal to smaller kids due to Mii characters. Now I will say from the demo that TW11 was a pain to use since it seemed that Move wasn't the main control the game was made for. I need to try out HR and see how that works.

[QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="Half-Way"]

as opposite to the move now, right , riiiight? :roll:

-

let me just sum up most move threads, hypocrisy

Half-Way

well i must be missing something because the wii has more good games that use motion controls well then the move, so the only reason to buy it now is some sorta "hope" that it will get those types of titles later...

Then my question would be, why didnt those people buy the wii before when it was in the same position? It was better for games then both eyetoy and sixaxis, so people should have had the same "hope" for good titles as they have now with the move.

it all seems very hypocritical

Because it say "sony" now.

I love motion controls. I play my wii way more than my PS3 and I can't stnd to play any game with dual analog anymore. So I picked up Move on launch day and love it.

I'm not a cow who called motion controls a gimmick simply because it was on a nintendo system.

can we confirm whether or not kinect is going to work with computers?Renzokucant

[QUOTE="Renzokucant"]can we confirm whether or not kinect is going to work with computers?lbjkurono23

Can the 17 people that voted Kinect back up why?
Honestly anyone who knows a little about something can look at the specs and see its a dead horse at start.
And for those who don't know a little about something can go and check the countless epic fails on youtube, or the acting they try to sell, yeah, that star wars demo ^_^

Right....

WhenCicadasCry

This is like lemmings making fun of YLOD when they have RROD :(

Can the 17 people that voted Kinect back up why?
Honestly anyone who knows a little about something can look at the specs and see its a dead horse at start.
And for those who don't know a little about something can go and check the countless epic fails on youtube, or the acting they try to sell, yeah, that star wars demo ^_^

[QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

Right....

Kane04

This is like lemmings making fun of YLOD when they have RROD :(

id like to say that the person playing the fight in this gif is a girl.... so can we really expect anything different than that outcome?

[QUOTE="Kane04"]

Can the 17 people that voted Kinect back up why?
Honestly anyone who knows a little about something can look at the specs and see its a dead horse at start.
And for those who don't know a little about something can go and check the countless epic fails on youtube, or the acting they try to sell, yeah, that star wars demo ^_^

[QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

Right....

Renzokucant

This is like lemmings making fun of YLOD when they have RROD :(

id like to say that the person playing the fight in this gif is a girl.... so can we really expect anything different than that outcome?

[QUOTE="Kane04"]

Can the 17 people that voted Kinect back up why?
Honestly anyone who knows a little about something can look at the specs and see its a dead horse at start.
And for those who don't know a little about something can go and check the countless epic fails on youtube, or the acting they try to sell, yeah, that star wars demo ^_^

[QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

Right....

Renzokucant

This is like lemmings making fun of YLOD when they have RROD :(

id like to say that the person playing the fight in this gif is a girl.... so can we really expect anything different than that outcome?

yeah because girls dont have enough brain capacity to play games?

sexism wooohooo :P ?

Yeah looks like the critics like the tech, I hear it's slightly better than the Wii and it gets thrown out of calibration much less and improvements are always good, now it need to software to back it up.FIipMode

[QUOTE="Renzokucant"]

[QUOTE="Kane04"]

This is like lemmings making fun of YLOD when they have RROD :(

noodlevixen

id like to say that the person playing the fight in this gif is a girl.... so can we really expect anything different than that outcome?

id like to say that the person playing the fight in this gif is a girl.... so can we really expect anything different than that outcome?Renzokucant

id like to say that the person playing the fight in this gif is a girl.... so can we really expect anything different than that outcome?Renzokucant

[QUOTE="Kane04"][QUOTE="Half-Way"] yeah because girls dont have enough brain capacity to play games? sexism wooohooo :P ?Renzokucant

[QUOTE="Kane04"][QUOTE="Half-Way"] yeah because girls dont have enough brain capacity to play games? sexism wooohooo :P ?Renzokucant

Even this particular girl wasn't any worse than most guys I have seen playing this game. Flailing, sissy punches that look like tossing someone his keys, hitting with the glowing ball like it's a knife stabbing game or they try to break their wrists on the guys head so they won't have to go to work the next day. At least she seemed to be hitting with the fist instead of her thumbs.

If they can get the game to work right, it would be next in a line of games doing exactly what I was wanting from the Wii and didn't get. Table Tennis and Gladiator Duel are two, a decent 1:1 fighting game would be tree. I just got a feeling the punches will always be harder in the game than what you actually do, so average joe (aka. "me") won't drop on his couch gasping after half a fight.

Finally went and tried it at a Sony store.

The tech seems solid and very precise.

It was an odd sensation though - having played Wii Sports Tennis a bit - I found it difficult adjusting to actually having to perform actions correctly in Sports Champions table tennis. I kept instinctively just flicking my wrist instead of doing proper swings, was especially bad with backhanding. :/

Can the 17 people that voted Kinect back up why?
Honestly anyone who knows a little about something can look at the specs and see its a dead horse at start.
And for those who don't know a little about something can go and check the countless epic fails on youtube, or the acting they try to sell, yeah, that star wars demo ^_^

[QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

Right....

Kane04

This is like lemmings making fun of YLOD when they have RROD :(

I'm a hermit, and I never said Kinect doesn't suck either, but this thread is about THE PS MOVE. Sheesh.

I'm addicted to Table Tennis on SC and boy I got a work out with it as far as my shoulder. LOL. Isn't it suppose to be tennis elbow. lOL. SC is a lot more accurate and fun then Wii Sports. I can see where Wii sports might appeal to smaller kids due to Mii characters. Now I will say from the demo that TW11 was a pain to use since it seemed that Move wasn't the main control the game was made for. I need to try out HR and see how that works.

3rdbass

[QUOTE="Shirokishi_"]

Wow, to think a year ago the smallest motion control praise got you laughed out of a thread.

gamefan67

[QUOTE="gamefan67"][QUOTE="Shirokishi_"]

Wow, to think a year ago the smallest motion control praise got you laughed out of a thread.

KHAndAnime

Even if the Wiimote had been as accurate as move is now, you would still have gotten laughed at.

lol at the results of which is the better tech...... So much so that you have to preorder kinect or you wont get it day 1....

Good for Sony.

Motion controls are just one more reason to consider buying a console for me, so I hope we see some good dev support.

lol at the results of which is the better tech...... So much so that you have to preorder kinect or you wont get it day 1....

ProjectNatalFan

[QUOTE="ProjectNatalFan"]

lol at the results of which is the better tech...... So much so that you have to preorder kinect or you wont get it day 1....

kuraimen

no specs do eyetoy not....

[QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="Half-Way"]

as opposite to the move now, right , riiiight? :roll:

-

let me just sum up most move threads, hypocrisy

Half-Way

well i must be missing something because the wii has more good games that use motion controls well then the move, so the only reason to buy it now is some sorta "hope" that it will get those types of titles later...

Then my question would be, why didnt those people buy the wii before when it was in the same position? It was better for games then both eyetoy and sixaxis, so people should have had the same "hope" for good titles as they have now with the move.

it all seems very hypocritical

[QUOTE="ProjectNatalFan"]

lol at the results of which is the better tech...... So much so that you have to preorder kinect or you wont get it day 1....

kuraimen

The gun controller looks kinda cool for FPS.Deathtransit

[QUOTE="Half-Way"]

[QUOTE="locopatho"] Nope, the Move;s games that use it well are what people are excited about.locopatho

well i must be missing something because the wii has more good games that use motion controls well then the move, so the only reason to buy it now is some sorta "hope" that it will get those types of titles later...

Then my question would be, why didnt those people buy the wii before when it was in the same position? It was better for games then both eyetoy and sixaxis, so people should have had the same "hope" for good titles as they have now with the move.

it all seems very hypocritical

well i guess there are some people who would prefer RE5 over RE4 with motion controls... maybe someone liked the lower rated game better.. who knows.

The only reason i can see to buy it, is the hope for good ONLINE FPS. But thats probably just for people who like fps, i cant see anyone else preferring worse versions of games in HD then the wii already has.

[QUOTE="kuraimen"][QUOTE="ProjectNatalFan"]

lol at the results of which is the better tech...... So much so that you have to preorder kinect or you wont get it day 1....

Renzokucant

It's not really their fault, that's what they do.

OP: "Alot of people are comparing the Wii and PS Move and rightfully so, they are pretty much the same, with movie obviously being better. At this point though its really going to come down to who has the better games, and in all honesty I think the PS3 is capable of much more, so i'm expecint alot, hope no dissapiontment lies ahead." Illogical fallacies ahoy! Using the good ol Bandwagon approach, mixed with some nice false dillemma mixed in. Injecting his personal opinion, stating contradictions. This is pretty stupid frankly. If both are comparing them and "they are pretty much the same" you can't claim "movie" to be better. "Movie" isn't "obviously better" unless you show me proof and you don't claim they are "pretty much the same." You also said the games matter but Wii has more games with motion controls than the PS3's Move, not to mention higher quality titles like SMG, SH: SM, Sin and Punishment, Mario Kart, NMH, and oh hell you can find more on GS since this site reviews games. /end rant

[QUOTE="Pug-Nasty"]

Move is the better tech. It's basically a more accurate Wiimote with a much better button layout, plus kinect in one package.

themyth01

Finally went and tried it at a Sony store.

The tech seems solid and very precise.

It was an odd sensation though - having played Wii Sports Tennis a bit - I found it difficult adjusting to actually having to perform actions correctly in Sports Champions table tennis. I kept instinctively just flicking my wrist instead of doing proper swings, was especially bad with backhanding. :/

shinrabanshou

[QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="Half-Way"]

well i must be missing something because the wii has more good games that use motion controls well then the move, so the only reason to buy it now is some sorta "hope" that it will get those types of titles later...

Then my question would be, why didnt those people buy the wii before when it was in the same position? It was better for games then both eyetoy and sixaxis, so people should have had the same "hope" for good titles as they have now with the move.

it all seems very hypocritical

Half-Way

well i guess there are some people who would prefer RE5 over RE4 with motion controls... maybe someone liked the lower rated game better.. who knows.

The only reason i can see to buy it, is the hope for good ONLINE FPS. But thats probably just for people who like fps, i cant see anyone else preferring worse versions of games in HD then the wii already has.

[QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]

Finally went and tried it at a Sony store.

The tech seems solid and very precise.

It was an odd sensation though - having played Wii Sports Tennis a bit - I found it difficult adjusting to actually having to perform actions correctly in Sports Champions table tennis. I kept instinctively just flicking my wrist instead of doing proper swings, was especially bad with backhanding. :/

Lable1985

[QUOTE="kuraimen"][QUOTE="ProjectNatalFan"]

lol at the results of which is the better tech...... So much so that you have to preorder kinect or you wont get it day 1....

ProjectNatalFan

no specs do eyetoy not....

[QUOTE="Half-Way"]

[QUOTE="locopatho"] It's very simple. It's the games people are after, maybe people weren't thrilled about playing a PS2 port of Resi or a crazy game like Warioware with motion controls, but they are certainly thrilled about playing Resi 5 and MAG and Heavy Rain and other actual top cIass blockbuster titles with motion controls.Renzokucant

well i guess there are some people who would prefer RE5 over RE4 with motion controls... maybe someone liked the lower rated game better.. who knows.

The only reason i can see to buy it, is the hope for good ONLINE FPS. But thats probably just for people who like fps, i cant see anyone else preferring worse versions of games in HD then the wii already has.

[QUOTE="Renzokucant"][QUOTE="Half-Way"]

well i guess there are some people who would prefer RE5 over RE4 with motion controls... maybe someone liked the lower rated game better.. who knows.

The only reason i can see to buy it, is the hope for good ONLINE FPS. But thats probably just for people who like fps, i cant see anyone else preferring worse versions of games in HD then the wii already has.

KHAndAnime

really... wierd, i wonder if they will ever review it here.. like a retro review

Still looking for a Demo Kiosk somewhere.

[QUOTE="KHAndAnime"][QUOTE="gamefan67"] People can change:PWii4Fun

Even if the Wiimote had been as accurate as move is now, you would still have gotten laughed at.

Yep. Wiimote could had been perfect 1:1 and it would still be a gimmick because it didn't say "sony" on it.

[QUOTE="Wii4Fun"]

[QUOTE="KHAndAnime"] The tech got better is all.goblaa

Even if the Wiimote had been as accurate as move is now, you would still have gotten laughed at.

Yep. Wiimote could had been perfect 1:1 and it would still be a gimmick because it didn't say "sony" on it.