Demon's Souls best RPG this gen?

No it's Mass Effect.

No it's Mass Effect.

BigDaddyPOLO

It'll be the best ARPG until Diablo III, that's for sure. :P

longtonguecat

He's talking about this gen though.....:?:(:cry:

[QUOTE="MrFanboy"][QUOTE="mythrol"]Having put about 100 hours into DS's, I can tell you it's a great game however NOT the best RPG. I'm of the opinion that DA:O and ME2 are both easily better. And those are just recently released games. AdrianWerner

WTF? That makes no sense.

No, just no.

Mass Effect2, The Witcher, Lost Odyssey and Dragon Age are all better RPGS imo. Demon Souls is a great game but I dont consider it a rpg really, great game though regardles of its category.

I haven't played Demon Soulds yet so I can't judge.On the other hand sofar I've enjoyed Witcher, Mass Effect 1,2, Dragon Age Origins, FallOut 3 and Persona 3 FES and Persona 4.

Maybe the best TEH GRAFIX console RPG but suggesting it being anymore is IMO a failure statement.

Burning-Sludge

So far DS is the best, alot of good ones on the way.

I want to play Demon's Souls so bad just because of the hype, but I'm getting tired of fantasy themes. I'll import it for sure soon though.

So far for me:

ME2 > Fallout 3 > Mass Effect > Lost Odyssey > Tales of Vesperia > Oblivion > Dragon Age > Fable 2

I couldn't really get into the Witcher, only got past the castle/keep area. Didn't run too well on my PC either, so I'll give it another go when I upgrade my PC. And I've only played the 360 version of Dragon Age. Also I haven't played too much of it, so I'm sure it will go up in the list when I finish a few other games & give it a go again. I also have Eternal Sonata unopened, but I bought that for $20 AU, & it got rated fairly well so I'll save it for a rainy day/week after I've finished all my other games, I have no expectations for it because I know almost nothing about it, but it was so cheap & got good scores, so it could be great.

I think RPGs need to take a break from fantasy & try different themes, like Sci-Fi. Mass Effect & KotoR have proven just how awesome they are. Or Steampunk! The last great Steampunk game I can remember was Arcanum. Imagine a Bioware or Bethesda game with a Steampunk setting!? *drool*