I personally think it deserved the AAAA score, and the 98 on metacritic
This topic is locked from further discussion.
I actually got the game on the Xbox 360 like 2 months ago. It took me a while to get used to the controls but it was enjoyable. However all I did was use the weapon cheat and blow **** up. :P
I'll have to play it some more later.
Edit- So I can't really say if it deserve any of its praise. Gotta play more of the game. :P
It definitely deserved it. I feel too many people compare it to San Andreas, but in all honesty SA wasn't all that fun. The world was large and full of things to do, but none of those things were very fun, and it all felt incredibly artificial. GTA IV has fun gameplay and manages to be an open living world, when open world games like Saints Row and Fallout have to have less fun shooting mechanics or driving to accomodate the large world I'd say GTA IV having mechanics almost as good as the ones found in linear straight up driving or shooting games gives it a major edge.
The only thing I like more about GTAIV than the other Grand Theft's is the driving physics. Randoggysame..
Not at all. Its not even 5 worthy.
ChubbyGuy40
lmao I think that is a bit harsh :P. I think maybe around an 8.0 - 8.5ish...idk though.
explain your reasoning[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"]
Not at all. Its not even 5 worthy.
Snyper-007
Characters were bad, story was boring and bad, graphics were terrible. The GTA formula died out after Vice City and its not longer any good or interesting.
explain your reasoning[QUOTE="Snyper-007"]
[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"]
Not at all. Its not even 5 worthy.
ChubbyGuy40
Characters were bad, story was boring and bad, graphics were terrible. The GTA formula died out after Vice City and its not longer any good or interesting.
Brucie was a great character imoexplain your reasoning[QUOTE="Snyper-007"]
[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"]
Not at all. Its not even 5 worthy.
ChubbyGuy40
Characters were bad, story was boring and bad, graphics were terrible. The GTA formula died out after Vice City and its not longer any good or interesting.
Still quite interesting to me. If there is one game that will force me to get a console, it will be GTA. I get so giddy when I hear GTA being talked about.[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"][QUOTE="Snyper-007"] explain your reasoning
millerlight89
Characters were bad, story was boring and bad, graphics were terrible. The GTA formula died out after Vice City and its not longer any good or interesting.
Still quite interesting to me. If there is one game that will force me to get a console, it will be GTA. I get so giddy when I hear GTA being talked about. Same[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"]
[QUOTE="Snyper-007"] explain your reasoning
Snyper-007
Characters were bad, story was boring and bad, graphics were terrible. The GTA formula died out after Vice City and its not longer any good or interesting.
Brucie was a great character imoI see your opinion but I have to disagree... he was lame. In fact I don't think there's any GTAIV character that I can say "he's cool".
It was a great game. 9.0 imo. I didn't enjoy it as much as the past 3D GTA games, but looking back on it, I couldn't put it down until I beat it. I really can't say that about most games.
[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"][QUOTE="Snyper-007"] explain your reasoning
millerlight89
Characters were bad, story was boring and bad, graphics were terrible. The GTA formula died out after Vice City and its not longer any good or interesting.
Still quite interesting to me. If there is one game that will force me to get a console, it will be GTA. I get so giddy when I hear GTA being talked about.Fair enough. I'm just not interested in them anymore.
I get really giddy when Nintendo-anything is talked about. I don't play it nearly as often but I loves me some nintendo.
Most overrated game this generation. Game felt like work about half way through. KC_Hokiewhat he said,how he said it,why he said it,when he said it
No, the game had some of the worst gameplay I've seen from a highly rated title. Everything was so sluggish and sloppy. The only good gameplay was found while driving.
RDR had much better controls and gameplay, and all they did was tweak what was already there.
Yes I think it does. Probably put around 60 hours into the game across my playthroughs and playing multiplayer. It's so much fun getting your friend together, going to get helicopters and flying around. I probably spent 5 hours at least going to the top of the tallest building and jumping off :P I doubt I'll ever trade it in. It's just awesome.
Most overrated game this generation. Game felt like work about half way through. KC_Hokie
Couldn't have said it better myself.
I can understand if people like the game, but best in the series? Seriously? I just... I... Is this even real anymore? lolMrSelf-DestructWhat baffles me is people take SA or VC over this game.
What baffles me is people take SA or VC over this game.[QUOTE="MrSelf-Destruct"]I can understand if people like the game, but best in the series? Seriously? I just... I... Is this even real anymore? lolLto_thaG
What baffles me is people take SA or VC over this game.[QUOTE="Lto_thaG"]
[QUOTE="MrSelf-Destruct"]I can understand if people like the game, but best in the series? Seriously? I just... I... Is this even real anymore? lolMrSelf-Destruct
It's weird to me. Weird doesn't make it wrong. It just makes it really freaking weird. :P GTAIV felt more like a job than a game. At least with Vice City I had fun. But hey, to each his own, right? True. Vice City is still my number 2 favorite. You DO have a soul! :oops: *hugs* :P jk[QUOTE="MrSelf-Destruct"]
[QUOTE="Lto_thaG"] What baffles me is people take SA or VC over this game.
I just...I...Is this even real anymore?
The game is the highest rated GTA game.It's not weird if people find it the best game in the series.Lto_thaG
True. Vice City is still my number 2 favorite. You DO have a soul! :oops: *hugs* :P jk I'm a huge GTA fan,so I have a lot of love for the games :P[QUOTE="Lto_thaG"]
[QUOTE="MrSelf-Destruct"] It's weird to me. Weird doesn't make it wrong. It just makes it really freaking weird. :P GTAIV felt more like a job than a game. At least with Vice City I had fun. But hey, to each his own, right?
MrSelf-Destruct
No ****ing way. It was worse than GTA SA and Vice City and had many problems that the reviewers completely looked over due to insane hype.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment