Do you think mgs 4 and gears of war 2 can get 10

Cmon people none of these games has a chance at 10 ESPECIALLY Starcraft II ... its just another RTS thats pushing nothing new but the good old Blizzard Gameplay balance, in which case has never rewarded them a 10.

GTA4 ... to succeed on that level, such an open game, is impressive, Gears of Bore 2 , MGS4 , Starcraft II are just normal in thier genre.

Cmon people none of these games has a chance at 10 ESPECIALLY Starcraft II ... its just another RTS thats pushing nothing new but the good old Blizzard Gameplay balance, in which case has never rewarded them a 10.

GTA4 ... to succeed on that level, such an open game, is impressive, Gears of Bore 2 , MGS4 , Starcraft II are just normal in thier genre.

Meu2k7

gears 2 will be a good fps amongst the many fps probably a 9 or 9.5

Starcraft probably will get a 10 and spore if it is up to the expectations of its creator

GTA4 didn't deserve but it should have gotten real close. Im sure if we had the old rating system it would have gotten a 9.8 or something.

Gears-No.

MGS4-Potential but no.

gears 2 will be a good fps amongst the many fps probably a 9 or 9.5

Starcraft probably will get a 10 and spore if it is up to the expectations of its creator

adamosmaki

Gears is not a FPS.

Gears: Doubtful... 9.0

MGS4: Maybe if its multiplayer reviews well... 9.5

I say MGS4 gets a better chance in getting a 10 in other sites, while here in GS t will get 9.5

Gears of War 2 it will get a 9.5.

Metal Gear Solid will no doubt get perfect scores on other sites, but probably not on Gamespot. It'll probably get a 9.0 here, 9.5 at the highest and 8.5 at the lowest.

Gears will most likey get a 9.5

Metal Gear Solid will no doubt get perfect scores on other sites, but probably not on Gamespot. It'll probably get a 9.0 here, 9.5 at the highest and 8.5 at the lowest.

Gears will most likey get a 9.5

Lionheart08

I'm hyping MGS4 9.5 to be honest and I hope it gets that score.

The guns: The final game will feature over 70 weapons, from lethal assault rifles to silent tranquilizer guns, and you can outfit many of them with scopes, recoil grips, laser sights, flashlights, and more. Collecting enemy weapons will unlock new guns and "Drebin Points" for further customization. There are 70+ guns in all.

The sound: MGS4 has some of the crispest, clearest sound effects we've ever heard -- the booming gunshots will make your hair stand on end! The Hollywood soundtrack is also predictably fantastic, and Snake's raspy voice sounds more desiccated than ever. GamePro editor Sid Shuman went so far as to say that MGS4 has "the best sound I've ever heard in a game."

The story: MGS4 is the darkest Metal Gear game by far: Snake is in terrible physical shape, and the world seems to rest on the brink of self-inflicted annihilation. Though the mood is dark, it's not depressing: you'll find plenty of characters to care about in this war-torn world.

There you have it!

Gears of War I highly doubt it unless they do some leap and boundries that they didn't do in the first one. Its going to be tough considering they were 4 points short of getting 10 the first time around, so its going to have to be a killer game in order to get a score such as a ten.

IMO I just don't know what MGS4 is going to get, I think its either going to get a great score or a good score. I think it is in the same position as Gears is, both of them are going to have to step it up tramendously in order to get a score like that.

I don't think either will get a 10 on Gamespot , because R* paid them to give GTA4 a 10 and GS doesn't want to lose all credibility (not that they have any) by giving more games a 10. The last game that got a 10 was like Tony Hawk 3 I think.

Anyways, I could care less for Gamespot reviews. They aren't really that good (too short) and are very contradicting and they get paid on top of that to score games a certain way.

ryuisill81

Not MGS4. The online component will be bashed to pieces.TMontana1004

No...

No to all three . The question is, how much do the games advance the video gaming experience . GTA4 is, although the next GTA, a completely new experience that really raises the bars on many fronts . It is also a game that ANYONE can enjoy .

MGS4 : If you didn't like previous MSG : you won't like MGS4 either . It also is much more of a sequel than GTA and you should have played previous instalments to enjoy it more . Does anyone remember MGS2 on the pS2 ? It received very high scores on some sites and rediculously low scores on other . MGS is a game that you either love or hate .

GOW2 : Depends how much it differs from part 1 but I fear more of the same , which ain't bad of course, but no 10 either .

Starcraft 2 : RTS has a problem of being an old genre that hasn't seen many improvements lately . If SC2 doesn't bring some fresh winds in the genre , I don't think it will get a 10 , because to many it will just be "another RTS game" .

Now I feel a response of "no game can get a 10 because there are always people who don't like the genre" . But I think it mostly depends on how much it advances the bar . A 10 in the past for Zelda Ocarina of Time was because it really surpassed ANYTHING achieved before . Soul Calibur (Dreamcast) was a perfect port without flaws, not one !!

Many other games deserve a 10 but didn't get it . Examples are Half Life 2 and World of Warcraft .

[QUOTE="Meu2k7"]

Cmon people none of these games has a chance at 10 ESPECIALLY Starcraft II ... its just another RTS thats pushing nothing new but the good old Blizzard Gameplay balance, in which case has never rewarded them a 10.

GTA4 ... to succeed on that level, such an open game, is impressive, Gears of Bore 2 , MGS4 , Starcraft II are just normal in thier genre.

mo0ksi

PC Games cant get 10, because they dont run on windows 95 and backwards :lol: , I think weve all come to realize that by now.

That and complicated games down, check GTA4, alot easier than previous isntallments, that bumped the score up.

[QUOTE="adamosmaki"]

gears 2 will be a good fps amongst the many fps probably a 9 or 9.5

Starcraft probably will get a 10 and spore if it is up to the expectations of its creator

Star650

Gears is not a FPS.

okay third person shooter. Still not something new

You guys are a shame to gaming world. If **** GTA got a 10 than so can MGS with better story and better gameplay don't forget the best graphics that will be available on the market so far. Noobs get the f out.Zelgadiss

Neither game has the ebst graphics of this gen.

Hell DX10 Assassins Creed puts GTA4 and MGS4 to shame.

MGS SERIES SUCKSliberty71441

Die!

Just because one game can get a 10, doesnt mean all game that you think will be good, will get a 10. We have barely seen anything from MGS and nothing from GEoW 2.Cooldude224

I can see MGS4 getting a 9.5-10 average(gamespot is unpredictable)
I can see GeOW2 getting a 9.0-9.5 average. There isn't a lot of room for improvement, although it will be better I could see GeOW2 suffering the same treatment as Vegas 2, just not as harsh.

[QUOTE="Bloodseeker23"]

Sorry he doesn't know what he talking about.

[QUOTE="liberty71441"]MGS SERIES SUCKSliberty71441

nice opinion. 95% of everyone disagrees though so you are the minority. sorry you dont know what good gaming is.

They have the potential, but I doubt they will. Both will be AAA, but a 10 is hard to achieve. Out of those two I think MGS4 has the best chance. Whatever they score I could care less, they are both going to be great games.Big_Boss465

Agreed.