flopping and scoring higher vs. not flopping and scoring lower

would you rather have a game that scores higher than another game but flops or that game that scored lower and have it not flop?

i don't really know how to say this without sounding like a fanboy but i guess my point is that it's great that cows have a game that didn't flop but it's still not up to par with games coming out on the 360.... at least on gs anyway.

It comes down to an AA exclusive or an AA flop.

For sake of System Wars, I would have to go with the AA exclusive. SW will remember Mass Effect as a flop, not as an AA game. Of course in real life, I'd take the better game.

i would go by the game i think is better .

and yeah, ME flopped big time

Mass Effect flopped, get over it dude.steelers89

yea, i'll be losing sleep over this review for a week. :|