Galaxy 2 being the highest rated game ever is ridiculous

The game is a rehash. Sure its a good rehash but still its a rehash.

And so it starts....

Nintendo payed the critics obviously, I mean, it's not even in HD.tagyhag

i agree totally, I dont get WII in general, or the block graphics kiddie graphics, or that this game gets a 10. I mean obviously the casual rules the world!!!

I don't think it should be the highest rated game, but for different reasons than the ones you provided.

And so it starts....

Shirokishi_

I got some popcorn. Want me to make some?

[QUOTE="tagyhag"]Nintendo payed the critics obviously, I mean, it's not even in HD.Sollet

Why is a nintendo fan trying to start something?

[QUOTE="Sollet"][QUOTE="tagyhag"]Nintendo payed the critics obviously, I mean, it's not even in HD.tagyhag

well based on your logic, we will go with SMG 1 then :)

Is that a "Baa Baa Baa" I hear coming?

[QUOTE="Sollet"][QUOTE="tagyhag"]Nintendo payed the critics obviously, I mean, it's not even in HD.tagyhag

And what the hell no blood!?

[QUOTE="Sollet"][QUOTE="tagyhag"]Nintendo payed the critics obviously, I mean, it's not even in HD.tagyhag

Somebody post a haters pic, but not the eagle one, I grew tired of that one.FIipMode

EDIT: Beaten by the guy below me.

well based on your logic, we will go with SMG 1 then :)

Half-Way

Somebody post a haters pic, but not the eagle one, I grew tired of that one.FIipMode

Here's one that kinda goes with the theme of the thread.

This about sums the OP up.

sequel =/= rehash

[QUOTE="tagyhag"][QUOTE="Sollet"] No MP too!siLVURcross

[QUOTE="Shirokishi_"]

And so it starts....

yokofox33

I got some popcorn. Want me to make some?

Reggies got me covered.

[QUOTE="yokofox33"]

[QUOTE="Shirokishi_"]

And so it starts....

Shirokishi_

I got some popcorn. Want me to make some?

[QUOTE="Half-Way"]

well based on your logic, we will go with SMG 1 then :)

farnham

so about 90% of all games on the top 100 list on gamerankins dont count...

Hurr! Nintendo only makes rehashes, why do sheep always play those stupid kiddy, rehashed games? I'll go black to playing my super diverse games now.

*Goes back to playing...

Halo

Gears of War

Call of Duty

Killzone

Crysis

Team Fortress

Half-Life

Stalker*

[QUOTE="Ragnarok1051"]

[QUOTE="FIipMode"]Somebody post a haters pic, but not the eagle one, I grew tired of that one.CAPSROGUE

Here's one that kinda goes with the theme of the thread.

Damn it, I had the fat guy first. Then I found that one and decided to edit fast. Damn it.

This thread is a bit fishy, considering the TC's posting history shows that he is a big Nintendo fan. Either he made a complete 180 since yesterday or he is simply trying to get a reaction. I'm not sure which is the case.

Well thats your opinion apparently, but it would seem almost every reviewer disagree's with you as do the paying customers. If you have played SMG2, which I would hope you have given this marvelous contribution you have provided system wars, I wouldn't use the term rehash.

Both of you guys posted the same pic but I only have one brownie, you guys will have to fight to the death for it.

Why is a nintendo fan trying to start something?

Ragnarok1051

It's likely that he's doing this because it gets people angry, and no matter what it can't be wrong, it is a fact that it is the best, based on scores of course.

Somebody post a haters pic, but not the eagle one, I grew tired of that one.FIipMode

Hmm. I went wrong somewhere...

TC is a Nintendo fan for those that don't know. These threads are how he gets his kicks.

[QUOTE="CAPSROGUE"]

[QUOTE="Ragnarok1051"]

Here's one that kinda goes with the theme of the thread.Ragnarok1051

Damn it, I had the fat guy first. Then I found that one and decided to edit fast. Damn it.

I think that's the first time I've got beaten by someone that posted later. Well actually earlier ... but you know what I mean.

This thread is a bit fishy, considering the TC is a big sheep. Either he made a complete 180 since yesterday or he is just trying to get a reaction.

Sky-

then it was obviously a "look look, SMG2 is the higest rated game ever!" thread :P

[QUOTE="Shirokishi_"]

[QUOTE="yokofox33"]

I got some popcorn. Want me to make some?

Ragnarok1051

Yeah, that was good. I want some Reggie popcorn!

And so it starts....

Shirokishi_

I think it deserves to be up there. The game is amazing and is blowing me away. (just got it 2 days ago) The game is so polished and so much character

[QUOTE="Sollet"][QUOTE="tagyhag"]Nintendo payed the critics obviously, I mean, it's not even in HD.tagyhag

And blood? I want gore when I curbstomp those mushroom men.

Warning flamebait thread.

[QUOTE="tagyhag"]Nintendo payed the critics obviously, I mean, it's not even in HD.Sollet

[QUOTE="farnham"][QUOTE="Half-Way"]

well based on your logic, we will go with SMG 1 then :)

Half-Way

so about 90% of all games on the top 100 list on gamerankins dont count...

And here I thought the TC was a Ninty supporter. Go figure. Rehash means the same game altered slightly, graphically or gameplay-wise. Sunshine is drastically different that 64. Galaxy is very different than Sunshine. SMG2 has a lot of refinement and changes compared to SMG1. Rehash it is not. It's a true sequel. Not the same thing.

And no DLC on day 1 is fail aswell, because paying for something that should be in the game in the first place is next-gen. Especially if it's already on the disc.

This thread is a bit fishy, considering the TC's posting history shows that he is a big Nintendo fan. Either he made a complete 180 since yesterday or he is simply trying to get a reaction. I'm not sure which is the case.

Sky-

And here I thought the TC was a Ninty supporter. Go figure. Rehash means the same game altered slightly, graphically or gameplay-wise. Sunshine is drastically different that 64. Galaxy is very different than Sunshine. SMG2 has a lot of refinement and changes compared to SMG1. Rehash it is not. It's a true sequel. Not the same thing.

jimkabrhel

[QUOTE="Ragnarok1051"]

Why is a nintendo fan trying to start something?

maverick_41

It's likely that he's doing this because it gets people angry, and no matter what it can't be wrong, it is a fact that it is the best, based on scores of course.