No matter how much you hate Nintendo, face it, OOT pwns GTA IV in every possible way, considering of course the time which they were released.
But still, A Link To The Past is the best Zelda game ever.
This topic is locked from further discussion.
No matter how much you hate Nintendo, face it, OOT pwns GTA IV in every possible way, considering of course the time which they were released.
But still, A Link To The Past is the best Zelda game ever.
sneslover
Amen.
[QUOTE="meischris39"]I still think it is atrocious how Final Fantasy VII isn't even in the top 10 but as long as Zelda is top the world is still righteous.
Also do you not think its about time, they removed duplicate multiple platform game instances. Such as The Orange Box that is listed twice and GTA IV listed twice i mean come on, just put the highest rated platform on their for god sakes.
Video_Game_King
Hey, the graphics haven't aged as well as Ocarina of Time. At least OoT has facial expressions. And less polygon jaginess. And a non-reliance on FMV cutscenes.
Not to mention it was actually fully 3-D.[QUOTE="Video_Game_King"][QUOTE="meischris39"]I still think it is atrocious how Final Fantasy VII isn't even in the top 10 but as long as Zelda is top the world is still righteous.
Also do you not think its about time, they removed duplicate multiple platform game instances. Such as The Orange Box that is listed twice and GTA IV listed twice i mean come on, just put the highest rated platform on their for god sakes.
Zaeryn
Hey, the graphics haven't aged as well as Ocarina of Time. At least OoT has facial expressions. And less polygon jaginess. And a non-reliance on FMV cutscenes.
Not to mention it was actually fully 3-D. and also back then stories in video games werre overlooked and not taken seriously, yet the simple story to oot its still very deep.[QUOTE="TheUtmost"]as of SMG, i havent played it,, i guess, but it looks boring like hell, but it hsa gotten very good reviews so i dont know, perhaps a good game but not my genre!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jeimseu
You should try it. Its really fun!
Whats "your genre"? *guesses*
anything where you can see peoples limbs blow off. jumping on tutrtles aint violent enough for him.[QUOTE="fishfake"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"][QUOTE="Shy_Guy_Red"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"][QUOTE="majadamus"]Why does this surprise you gamers, even fanboys? The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is a godsend among the gaming community. So, just accept its greatness and get on with your lives. TheUtmost
gta iv is more popular and killes oot when it had 30 reviews, it's a cheaty game face it
You do know that GTAIV is not the only game where that is true. This has happened numerous times and they've all ended the same way. Accept it.
if OoT would have 70-80 it would have ended up 95, or so, face it!1111111
every game what it deservse
if gta4 is better than zelda we would see it in the later reviews, if not you are wrong , face it
Zelda, 30 reviews - 97 %.
GTA IV, 30 reviews - 100 %.
Zelda got owned, face it.
Dude, that totally depends on which 30 reviews you choose to count. If we picked 30 of GTAIV's worst reviews, it would be alot lower.
[QUOTE="Eponique"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"]and at the moment, GTA IV is #2, SMG is #3, check your facts, TheUtmost
GTA IV PS3 has less reviews.
:lol:
that didnt stop the, what, 4 million people buy it, right? better than smg's 5 million sales since november lol
Say whaaaat? SMG is closer to 7 million than 5 million :?
[QUOTE="readingfc_1"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"][QUOTE="readingfc_1"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"]LoZ OoT doesnt deserve to be #1 with its 30 reviews cheaty game when GTA IV was at 30, it HAD 100 % reviews and COMPLETELY killed LoZ OoT
as of SMG, i havent played it,, i guess, but it looks boring like hell, but it hsa gotten very good reviews so i dont know, perhaps a good game but not my genre!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
TheUtmost
Thats because there wern't as many publications around back when OoT was released. Do you think it should be judged differently for this reason?
Half-Life, released '98, 63 reviews.
But at the time i assume more people had pc's and there were more PC publications. Gaming wasn't as big and wouldn't have had as many publications. You can give me facts all you want but Half life is a bad example because people will still be reviewing it today as its still pretty easy to get hold of. Zelda OoT isn't as the original version for N64 isn't pressed anymore.
whatever, zelda ain't that good, and not many people played "the best ever", as stated by some, i mean it has sold like 7 million in 10 years LOL LOL GTA has sold 9 million in one month! ohh, zelda got so owned!!!
How do you explain how Galaxy beat GTA??? I like GTA, but just want to know?
IMHO,
Zelda: OoT was a much more revolutionary game. It defined a genre and practically reinvented video games. The game was epic, even by today's standards.
GTA IV is a great game with an amazing amount of detail. It sticks to the exact same formula, though. I'd say GTA III was a better game because it redefined the formula so much.
Honestly though, I had more fun replaying Zelda: OoT then I'm having playing through GTA IV. Zelda: OoT is a game I could replay every couple of years. I'll probably never play GTA IV again after I beat the SP.
[QUOTE="TheUtmost"][QUOTE="Eponique"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"]and at the moment, GTA IV is #2, SMG is #3, check your facts, ---OkeyDokey---
GTA IV PS3 has less reviews.
:lol:
that didnt stop the, what, 4 million people buy it, right? better than smg's 5 million sales since november lol
Say whaaaat? SMG is closer to 7 million than 5 million :?
dream on, 5 - 6, i think its like 5.4 or 5.5
[QUOTE="TheUtmost"][QUOTE="readingfc_1"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"][QUOTE="readingfc_1"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"]LoZ OoT doesnt deserve to be #1 with its 30 reviews cheaty game when GTA IV was at 30, it HAD 100 % reviews and COMPLETELY killed LoZ OoT
as of SMG, i havent played it,, i guess, but it looks boring like hell, but it hsa gotten very good reviews so i dont know, perhaps a good game but not my genre!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
skingus
Thats because there wern't as many publications around back when OoT was released. Do you think it should be judged differently for this reason?
Half-Life, released '98, 63 reviews.
But at the time i assume more people had pc's and there were more PC publications. Gaming wasn't as big and wouldn't have had as many publications. You can give me facts all you want but Half life is a bad example because people will still be reviewing it today as its still pretty easy to get hold of. Zelda OoT isn't as the original version for N64 isn't pressed anymore.
whatever, zelda ain't that good, and not many people played "the best ever", as stated by some, i mean it has sold like 7 million in 10 years LOL LOL GTA has sold 9 million in one month! ohh, zelda got so owned!!!
How do you explain how Galaxy beat GTA??? I like GTA, but just want to know?
i have already said my thoughts on SMG, read further back. How do you explain GTA scored 10 on IGN and GameSPot, the most popular gaming websites, and SMG didnt? :(
[QUOTE="Shy_Guy_Red"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"][QUOTE="majadamus"]Why does this surprise you gamers, even fanboys? The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is a godsend among the gaming community. So, just accept its greatness and get on with your lives. TheUtmost
gta iv is more popular and killes oot when it had 30 reviews, it's a cheaty game face it
You do know that GTAIV is not the only game where that is true. This has happened numerous times and they've all ended the same way. Accept it.
if OoT would have 70-80 it would have ended up 95, or so, face it!1111111
Havent you noticed that in practically every top 100 list, zelda OOT is always at least in the top 10, and more often than not number 1. It has been ranked first more than any other game currently released. And no GTA4 wasnt on 100 at 30 reviews. It had received more than 10 90+ scores making its score around 97%
No game can ever conquer Ocarina of Time, and definitely not GTA IV. It's not even the best in the series.ash10692
as people have said, it wouldnt have been #1 if it had more reviews, think about it
No game can ever conquer Ocarina of Time, and definitely not GTA IV. It's not even the best in the series.ash10692
OoT's first 30 reviews - 98 % ()
GTA IV's first 30 reviews - 100 % ()
D E T H R O N E D
OoT's sales (10 years) - 7-8 million.
GTA IV's sales (1 month) - 9 million.
OWNED!
[QUOTE="ash10692"]No game can ever conquer Ocarina of Time, and definitely not GTA IV. It's not even the best in the series.Hype_Status
as people have said, it wouldnt have been #1 if it had more reviews, think about it
If it had more reviews from 1998, its score would've been closer to a 100%.
Notice how almost half the reviewers that reviewed it after 2000 gave it less than a 10. While all except one who reviewed it in 1998 gave it a 10.
[QUOTE="ash10692"]No game can ever conquer Ocarina of Time, and definitely not GTA IV. It's not even the best in the series.TheUtmost
OoT's first 30 reviews - 98 % ()
GTA IV's first 30 reviews - 100 % ()
D E T H R O N E D
OoT's sales (10 years) - 7-8 million.
GTA IV's sales (1 month) - 9 million.
OWNED!
Damage control. Even SMG was higher than OoT at 30 reviews. GTA was NOT 100% at 30 reviews, so just stop saying that. It was 97.8% IIRC.
[QUOTE="TheUtmost"][QUOTE="Shy_Guy_Red"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"][QUOTE="majadamus"]Why does this surprise you gamers, even fanboys? The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is a godsend among the gaming community. So, just accept its greatness and get on with your lives. samusarmada
gta iv is more popular and killes oot when it had 30 reviews, it's a cheaty game face it
You do know that GTAIV is not the only game where that is true. This has happened numerous times and they've all ended the same way. Accept it.
if OoT would have 70-80 it would have ended up 95, or so, face it!1111111
Havent you noticed that in practically every top 100 list, zelda OOT is always at least in the top 10, and more often than not number 1. It has been ranked first more than any other game currently released. And no GTA4 wasnt on 100 at 30 reviews. It had received more than 10 90+ scores making its score around 97%
HAHAHAHAH, GTA first 30 REVIEWS RACKED up at 100 % if we ()
Alright, lemme break this down.
Look at IGNs 100 best games evel. Number 16 is Castlevania:Symphony of the Night. That game got a 9 from them. But it's higher up than Halo, which got a much better score.
Scores in games, fundamentally, are flawed. In that way, Gamerankings is crap.
And besides, what if there were reviews for the NES and SNES? That would be the entire top 10, so OoT isn't necessarily the best game ever. Get over it.
[QUOTE="ash10692"]No game can ever conquer Ocarina of Time, and definitely not GTA IV. It's not even the best in the series.TheUtmost
OoT's first 30 reviews - 98 % ()
GTA IV's first 30 reviews - 100 % ()
D E T H R O N E D
OoT's sales (10 years) - 7-8 million.
GTA IV's sales (1 month) - 9 million.
OWNED!
If any GTA has a chance of 'DETHRONING' Ocarina, it is the almighty GTA III[QUOTE="majadamus"]Why does this surprise you gamers, even fanboys? The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is a godsend among the gaming community. So, just accept its greatness and get on with your lives. TheUtmost
gta iv is more popular and killes oot when it had 30 reviews, it's a cheaty game face it
cheaty game??? ha. go read the review it's like "this is undeniably perfect" all over it. also zelda franchise has been going on for far far far longer than pathetic "n00b" GTA4.
[QUOTE="TheUtmost"][QUOTE="majadamus"]Why does this surprise you gamers, even fanboys? The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is a godsend among the gaming community. So, just accept its greatness and get on with your lives. crunchUK
gta iv is more popular and killes oot when it had 30 reviews, it's a cheaty game face it
cheaty game??? ha. go read the review it's like "this is undeniably perfect" all over it. also zelda franchise has been going on for far far far longer than pathetic "n00b" GTA4.
hahahaha who's the noob? i mean, OoT DIDNT sell 9 million copies month 1 lol
OoT's first review - 100%[QUOTE="Eponique"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"]GTA IV's first review - 100%. TheUtmost
i meant gta IV's 30 first reviews compare to OoT's
GTAIV's first 30 reviews
GamingExcellence 5/2/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
Jolt UK 5/2/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
Kikizo 5/1/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
Totally360 5/1/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
PGNx Media 5/1/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
Official Xbox Magazine UK 5/1/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
NZGamer 4/30/2008 9.9 out of 10 99.0%
Boomtown 4/30/2008 9 out of 10 90.0%
Kombo 4/29/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
AtomicGamer 4/29/2008 97 out of 100 97.0%
MS Xbox World 4/29/2008 9.5 out of 10 95.0%
Gameplanet 4/29/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
Chea!t Code Central 4/29/2008 4.9 out of 5 98.0%
GameAlmighty 4/29/2008 9.8 out of 10 98.0%
UGO 4/28/2008 A+ 100.0%
ActionTrip 4/28/2008 9.7 out of 10 97.0%
GameSpot 4/28/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
G4 - X-Play 4/28/2008 5 out of 5 100.0%
VideoGamer 4/28/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
Xbox World 360 Magazine UK 4/28/2008 98 out of 100 98.0%
TotalVideoGames 4/27/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
GamePro 4/27/2008 5 out of 5 100.0%
Computer & Video Games UK 4/27/2008 9.5 out of 10 95.0%
GameSpy 4/27/2008 5 out of 5 100.0%
Eurogamer 4/27/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
TeamXbox 4/27/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
1UP 4/27/2008 A+ 100.0%
Gametrailers 4/27/2008 9.8 out of 10 98.0%
GameDaily 4/27/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
IGN 4/25/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
[QUOTE="crunchUK"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"][QUOTE="majadamus"]Why does this surprise you gamers, even fanboys? The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is a godsend among the gaming community. So, just accept its greatness and get on with your lives. TheUtmost
gta iv is more popular and killes oot when it had 30 reviews, it's a cheaty game face it
cheaty game??? ha. go read the review it's like "this is undeniably perfect" all over it. also zelda franchise has been going on for far far far longer than pathetic "n00b" GTA4.
hahahaha who's the noob? i mean, OoT DIDNT sell 9 million copies month 1 lol
]YEAH this proves that GTA4 is superior the same way china is superior because they have more population. and that isn't even a good analogy. how about rats being more than eagles? also lat time i looked GTA4 was one 2 systems while OoT was on 1 not doing well-at-all system. rofl
Alright, lemme break this down.
Look at IGNs 100 best games evel. Number 16 is Castlevania:Symphony of the Night. That game got a 9 from them. But it's higher up than Halo, which got a much better score.
Scores in games, fundamentally, are flawed. In that way, Gamerankings is crap.
And besides, what if there were reviews for the NES and SNES? That would be the entire top 10, so OoT isn't necessarily the best game ever. Get over it.
Arkthemaniac
Amen
Oot was a good game but no where near my top 30 games of all time (maybe in the top 50), theres been other games out there that have revolutionized the gaming industry more and better than Oot.
HAHAHAHAH, GTA first 30 REVIEWS RACKED up at 100 % if we () TheUtmost
And if we took the worst 30, it would have been off the top 10 :lol: GTA has lost, cry me 10 rivers the size of the Amazon. IT HAS LOST.
Score | LoZ: OoT | GTA IV PS3 | GTA IV 360
-------------------------------------------
AAAA | 54.84 % | 52.63 % | 54.29 %
AAA | 45.16 % | 43.86 % | 41.43 %
AA | 0.00 % | 3.51 % | 4.29 %
GTA has lost, it even got 3 AA scores :lol: OoT also has a higher AAAA and AAA precentage than both GTAs. TCLHBO.
[QUOTE="TheUtmost"]HAHAHAHAH, GTA first 30 REVIEWS RACKED up at 100 % if we () Eponique
And if we took the worst 30, it would have been off the top 10 :lol: GTA has lost, cry me 10 rivers the size of the Amazon. IT HAS LOST.
Score | LoZ: OoT | GTA IV PS3 | GTA IV 360
-------------------------------------------
AAAA | 54.84 % | 52.63 % | 54.29 %
AAA | 45.16 % | 43.86 % | 41.43 %
AA | 0.00 % | 3.51 % | 4.29 %
GTA has lost, it even got 3 AA scores :lol: OoT also has a higher AAAA and AAA precentage than both GTAs. TCLHBO.
Owned. Well done with the maths.
I'll add some LOGIC to it:
How big was OoT's marketing campaign? = Small (almost nonexistential)
How big was GTA IV's marketing campaign? = Videogames history BIGGEST.
How much was OoT hyped? = Not much, just the old fans of the franchise
How much was GTA IV? = Extremely, so much it is incredible.
How dubious are OoT reviews?= Not much, as far I know.
How dubious are GTA IV reviews? = COULDN'T BE MORE DUBIOUS. Proof?:
Zelda is wack, and I could care less what a website says. 98% of game journalists are Nintendo fanboys.DisPimpin
Then why did the other 2 not give ocarina under 90%?
Why does this surprise you gamers, even fanboys? The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is a godsend among the gaming community. So, just accept its greatness and get on with your lives. majadamus
I completely agree. What Oot did for the gaming community was far more significant than what GTA IV did.
[QUOTE="Eponique"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"]HAHAHAHAH, GTA first 30 REVIEWS RACKED up at 100 % if we () TheUtmost
And if we took the worst 30, it would have been off the top 10 :lol: GTA has lost, cry me 10 rivers the size of the Amazon. IT HAS LOST.
Score | LoZ: OoT | GTA IV PS3 | GTA IV 360
-------------------------------------------
AAAA | 54.84 % | 52.63 % | 54.29 %
AAA | 45.16 % | 43.86 % | 41.43 %
AA | 0.00 % | 3.51 % | 4.29 %
GTA has lost, it even got 3 AA scores :lol: OoT also has a higher AAAA and AAA precentage than both GTAs. TCLHBO.
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time - 30 reviews - 98 % (the first ones).
Grand Theft Auto IV - 30 reviews - 100 % (the first ones).
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time - sales - 7-8 million (10 years - HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA)
Grand Theft Auto IV - sales - 9 million (ONE MONTH)
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
You have lost!
GTAIV's first 30 reviews
GamingExcellence 5/2/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
Jolt UK 5/2/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
Kikizo 5/1/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
Totally360 5/1/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
PGNx Media 5/1/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
Official Xbox Magazine UK 5/1/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
NZGamer 4/30/2008 9.9 out of 10 99.0%
Boomtown 4/30/2008 9 out of 10 90.0%
Kombo 4/29/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
AtomicGamer 4/29/2008 97 out of 100 97.0%
MS Xbox World 4/29/2008 9.5 out of 10 95.0%
Gameplanet 4/29/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
Chea!t Code Central 4/29/2008 4.9 out of 5 98.0%
GameAlmighty 4/29/2008 9.8 out of 10 98.0%
UGO 4/28/2008 A+ 100.0%
ActionTrip 4/28/2008 9.7 out of 10 97.0%
GameSpot 4/28/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
G4 - X-Play 4/28/2008 5 out of 5 100.0%
VideoGamer 4/28/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
Xbox World 360 Magazine UK 4/28/2008 98 out of 100 98.0%
TotalVideoGames 4/27/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
GamePro 4/27/2008 5 out of 5 100.0%
Computer & Video Games UK 4/27/2008 9.5 out of 10 95.0%
GameSpy 4/27/2008 5 out of 5 100.0%
Eurogamer 4/27/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
TeamXbox 4/27/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
1UP 4/27/2008 A+ 100.0%
Gametrailers 4/27/2008 9.8 out of 10 98.0%
GameDaily 4/27/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
IGN 4/25/2008 10 out of 10 100.0%
[QUOTE="Eponique"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"]HAHAHAHAH, GTA first 30 REVIEWS RACKED up at 100 % if we () TheUtmost
And if we took the worst 30, it would have been off the top 10 :lol: GTA has lost, cry me 10 rivers the size of the Amazon. IT HAS LOST.
Score | LoZ: OoT | GTA IV PS3 | GTA IV 360
-------------------------------------------
AAAA | 54.84 % | 52.63 % | 54.29 %
AAA | 45.16 % | 43.86 % | 41.43 %
AA | 0.00 % | 3.51 % | 4.29 %
GTA has lost, it even got 3 AA scores :lol: OoT also has a higher AAAA and AAA precentage than both GTAs. TCLHBO.
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time - 30 reviews - 98 % (the first ones).
Grand Theft Auto IV - 30 reviews - 100 % (the first ones).
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time - sales - 7-8 million (10 years - HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA)
Grand Theft Auto IV - sales - 9 million (ONE MONTH)
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
You have lost!
No pal, you have. Sorry. Better luck next time.
[QUOTE="Eponique"][QUOTE="TheUtmost"]HAHAHAHAH, GTA first 30 REVIEWS RACKED up at 100 % if we () TheUtmost
And if we took the worst 30, it would have been off the top 10 :lol: GTA has lost, cry me 10 rivers the size of the Amazon. IT HAS LOST.
Score | LoZ: OoT | GTA IV PS3 | GTA IV 360
-------------------------------------------
AAAA | 54.84 % | 52.63 % | 54.29 %
AAA | 45.16 % | 43.86 % | 41.43 %
AA | 0.00 % | 3.51 % | 4.29 %
GTA has lost, it even got 3 AA scores :lol: OoT also has a higher AAAA and AAA precentage than both GTAs. TCLHBO.
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time - 30 reviews - 98 % (the first ones).
Grand Theft Auto IV - 30 reviews - 100 % (the first ones).
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time - sales - 7-8 million (10 years - HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA)
Grand Theft Auto IV - sales - 9 million (ONE MONTH)
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
You have lost!
Does that also include online sales, and the free preorder disc that came with the WindWaker? And, OoT is an exclusive whereas GTA IV is a multiplatform. Consider those factors, No single system game is going to outsell a multiplatform game at this level.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment