GamePro Review: UT3 (360) = 3.25/5 -- UT3 (PS3) = 4.25/5

someone's going to hop in and say the PC version is superior.

then someone else is going to hop in and say that UT2004 is superior.

Who cares? UT3 stinks, but PC is the only way to go for superiority.

Who cares? UT3 stinks, but PC is the only way to go for superiority.

BioShockOwnz

someone's going to hop in and say the PC version is superior.

then someone else is going to hop in and say that UT2004 is superior.

bulletsword

[QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

Who cares? UT3 stinks, but PC is the only way to go for superiority.

EVOLV3

Errr, wrong.

[QUOTE="bulletsword"]

someone's going to hop in and say the PC version is superior.

then someone else is going to hop in and say that UT2004 is superior.

Vaasman

Agreed.

GamePro Review :lol:
Jamiemydearx3

It has the "gears of bore'' look.haha

and yeah the game is almost impossible to control good without m/kb, just a tiny touch will make you move because its so sensitive.

PS3 version FTW.

[QUOTE="Jamiemydearx3"]GamePro Review :lol:
EVOLV3

IGN :lol:

Eurogamer :lol:

[QUOTE="EVOLV3"][QUOTE="Jamiemydearx3"]GamePro Review :lol:
Jamiemydearx3

IGN :lol:

Eurogamer :lol:

someone's going to hop in and say the PC version is superior.

then someone else is going to hop in and say that UT2004 is superior.

bulletsword

I own it on PC and it sucks regardless... when you have more servers than players... there's something wrong :|yoshi_64

^This poster speaks the truth.

funny, i remember that practically every sony fanboy here have been saying that only gamespot count. hypocricy much?facebooker

[QUOTE="Jamiemydearx3"]

[QUOTE="EVOLV3"][QUOTE="Jamiemydearx3"]GamePro Review :lol:
EVOLV3

IGN :lol:

Eurogamer :lol:

"funny, i remember that practically every sony fanboy here have been saying that only gamespot count. hypocricy much?"

WINNER!

[QUOTE="EVOLV3"][QUOTE="Jamiemydearx3"]

[QUOTE="EVOLV3"][QUOTE="Jamiemydearx3"]GamePro Review :lol:
Jamiemydearx3

IGN :lol:

Eurogamer :lol:

"funny, i remember that practically every sony fanboy here have been saying that only gamespot count. hypocricy much?"

[QUOTE="Jamiemydearx3"]GamePro Review :lol:
EVOLV3

I trust IGN but I dont trust eurogamer. But like I said before this game isnt worth buying. Who knows though, it might sell well on the 360 just for the fact that people will buy any game to get more achievement points.

funny, i remember that practically every sony fanboy here have been saying that only gamespot count. hypocricy much?facebooker

First, it was about bashing Ninja Gaiden 2 using outside reviews. Then MGS4 got a 10/10 and only Gamespot mattered. Now when it's used against 360 again with UT3, the switch occurs yet again. Would that be a triple 'flip flop'?

[QUOTE="facebooker"]funny, i remember that practically every sony fanboy here have been saying that only gamespot count. hypocricy much?BioShockOwnz

First, it was about bashing Ninja Gaiden 2 using outside reviews. Then MGS4 got a 10/10 and only Gamespot mattered. Now when it's used against 360 again with UT3, the switch occurs yet again. Would that be a triple 'flip flop'?

lmao. fanboys, lol

same as the ign reviews, 2 different reviewers for each versions. lol tc you need to do some more research before starting to claim ownagefacebooker

so if we ever want to compare scores, they all have to be played and scored by the exact same person?

[QUOTE="facebooker"]same as the ign reviews, 2 different reviewers for each versions. lol tc you need to do some more research before starting to claim ownagebulletsword

so if we ever want to compare scores, they all have to be played and scored by the exact same person?

i would suspect that 2 different persons might have different opinions on a particular game, dont u agree?

intresting fail for epic on this one i guess :/ oh wellz i'm sure they can recover somehow...ehehe

Oh yeah, yep win for ps3 i guess.

[QUOTE="facebooker"]funny, i remember that practically every sony fanboy here have been saying that only gamespot count. hypocricy much?EVOLV3

[QUOTE="bulletsword"]

[QUOTE="facebooker"]same as the ign reviews, 2 different reviewers for each versions. lol tc you need to do some more research before starting to claim ownagefacebooker

so if we ever want to compare scores, they all have to be played and scored by the exact same person?

i would suspect that 2 different persons might have different opinions on a particular game, dont u agree?

Of course, but now you're getting a bit nitpicky. It's from the same site and as far as System Wars go, the site is what matters.

Now normally I'd just laugh at you for using GamePro as your basis of argument (considering how much of a joke they've become) but since you've also included the much more respectable IGN and Eurogamer, your argument gets a pass for credibility.

Now here's where I start to take it apart.

Let's use The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion for the 360 and PS3. Of which, the PS3 received a "superior" port nearly a year after its release on the Xbox 360.

According to Gamerankings, the Xbox 360 version is holding firm at a 93.8% rating based on 105 reviews while the PS3 version has a 93.1% rating based on 56 reviews.

GameSpot scores for each

Xbox 360: 9.6

Playstation 3: 9.5

Oh Em Gee. This must mean the Xbox 360 version is superior right? :o

Let's move on to Fight Night Round 3 which was released nearly a year later with many improvements, including a new mode, on the PS3. Well, according to GameRankings, the game is ranked at 85.2% on the Xbox 360 and 82.3% on the PS3.

GameSpot Scores for each

Xbox 360: 8.3

Playstation 3: 8.2

I guess the Xbox 360 version is better here too right?

Bottom line is, only once in a blue moon does a port of a game that has already been released several months prior actually score higher than its earlier counterparts on other systems. This does not mean the Xbox 360 version of UT3 is substantially worse than the Playstation 3 version, despite having additional content.

UT2004 is superior.

bulletsword

[QUOTE="facebooker"][QUOTE="bulletsword"]

[QUOTE="facebooker"]same as the ign reviews, 2 different reviewers for each versions. lol tc you need to do some more research before starting to claim ownagebulletsword

so if we ever want to compare scores, they all have to be played and scored by the exact same person?

i would suspect that 2 different persons might have different opinions on a particular game, dont u agree?

Of course, but now you're getting a bit nitpicky. It's from the same site and as far as System Wars go, the site is what matters.

same sites but different reviewers might as well be different sites. and i thought sony fans here have been saying that only gs counts?

Does anyone really give a damn about this game, on any platform?

Does anyone really give a damn about this game, on any platform?

jethrovegas

Of coarse, this guy does!

Mark rein ftw.

PS: He is actually a really cool guy.

[QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

Who cares? UT3 stinks, but PC is the only way to go for superiority.

EVOLV3

Dreams-Visions is the guy with the BMW logo right? If so then yes lmao

[QUOTE="EVOLV3"][QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

Who cares? UT3 stinks, but PC is the only way to go for superiority.

I_Helios_I

Dreams-Visions is the guy with the BMW logo right? If so then yes lmao

Wait, what?

someone's going to hop in and say the PC version is superior.

then someone else is going to hop in and say that UT2004 is superior.

bulletsword

Game's not that great on pc. Yea, UT2004 is better, so's UT99.

[QUOTE="I_Helios_I"][QUOTE="EVOLV3"][QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

Who cares? UT3 stinks, but PC is the only way to go for superiority.

BioShockOwnz

Dreams-Visions is the guy with the BMW logo right? If so then yes lmao

Wait, what?

Dreams made a topic on how nobody plays UT ONLINE....and given how strong shooters are online with the 360...finding/playing a game using live will "most likely" be better......nothing more...

The game wasn't much anyway.

Stick to UT04 people.

As for the 360 version, well its a gamepad did people really think they are great for FPS games?