Gamespy GOTY is...

I think that's unbelievable.

I love how Uncharted got on and Halo 3 rightfully didn't.

CoD4 over SMG though? Lame.

I think that's unbelievable.

I love how Uncharted got on and Halo 3 rightfully didn't.

CoD4 over SMG though? Lame.

Udsen

its more like BS halo 3 deserved to be on there more then uncharted

How in the world could they not put WiC or Crysis in there??

[QUOTE="Udsen"]

I think that's unbelievable.

I love how Uncharted got on and Halo 3 rightfully didn't.

CoD4 over SMG though? Lame.

MasterC5

its more like BS halo 3 deserved to be on there more then uncharted

Uncharted was fantastic.

Halo sucks in general, so I'm glad publications are using their minds, not their bank accounts (Minus GS of course).

[QUOTE="MasterC5"][QUOTE="Udsen"]

I think that's unbelievable.

I love how Uncharted got on and Halo 3 rightfully didn't.

CoD4 over SMG though? Lame.

Udsen

its more like BS halo 3 deserved to be on there more then uncharted

Uncharted was fantastic.

Halo sucks in general, so I'm glad publications are using their minds, not their bank accounts (Minus GS of course).

Halo may be overrated but its still a pretty fine game so your whole comment is very fanboyish, Uncharted was good but it wasnt great still it reminds you of when tombraiderused ton be fun like it.

[QUOTE="Udsen"][QUOTE="MasterC5"][QUOTE="Udsen"]

I think that's unbelievable.

I love how Uncharted got on and Halo 3 rightfully didn't.

CoD4 over SMG though? Lame.

MasterC5

its more like BS halo 3 deserved to be on there more then uncharted

Uncharted was fantastic.

Halo sucks in general, so I'm glad publications are using their minds, not their bank accounts (Minus GS of course).

Halo may be overrated but its still a pretty fine game so your whole comment is very fanboyish, Uncharted was good but it wasnt great still it reminds you of when tombraiderused ton be fun like it.

:lol: @ You trying to tell me how I feel when I play games.

Wait, you called Gears original in your review. I think I'll stick to my own opinions, thanks.

cod4 looks more overated to me than halo 3 nownaval

I prefer halo over call of duty, but neither should be game of the year. I know halo is over rated, but is there any game more over rated than COD right now? Jesus, the game is good, but it is just not all that. COD is my pick for one of the most over rated games ever...I just dont get it. There is no way that halo and COD are better than mass effect and bioshock.

great list if you ask me... Phantom Hourglass should be higher up that list though,

But good list. Couldn't help but notice that Crysis and Halo3 are not on that list. i might put them in there myself in stead of WoW and CaLCiV.. but that's personal taste, i don't play those games.

Gaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaalllllaaaaaxyyyyyyyyy....

Tis the greatest game of all time..

Overall GOTY

1. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

2. The Orange Box

3. Bioshock

4. Super Mario Galaxy

5. Rock Band

6. GalCiv II: Dark Avatar

7. WoW: The Burning Crusade

8. Mass Effect

9. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

10. TLoZ: Phanthom Hourglass

Console GOTY

1. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

3. Super Mario Galaxy

4. The Orange Box

5. Rock Band

6. Mass Effect

7. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

8. Halo 3

9. Warhawk

Does this mean that the PC version of OB is so great that it moves it up 2 places to number 2 from 4th place on the Consoles?

Overall GOTY

1. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

2. The Orange Box

3. Bioshock

4. Super Mario Galaxy

5. Rock Band

6. GalCiv II: Dark Avatar

7. WoW: The Burning Crusade

8. Mass Effect

9. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

10. TLoZ: Phanthom Hourglass

Console GOTY

1. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare

2. Bioshock

3. Super Mario Galaxy

4. The Orange Box

5. Rock Band

6. Mass Effect

7. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune

8. Halo 3

9. Warhawk

10. Skate

Does this mean that the PC version of OB is so great that it moves it up 2 places to number 2 from 4th place on the Consoles?

Philmon

Interesting observation, lol