Gears Of War vs Uncharted - Sales and Critical Acclaim

@Krelian-co said:

@tushar172787 said:

@Krelian-co said:

@tushar172787 said:

@Douevenlift_bro said:

@tushar172787 said:

@Douevenlift_bro said:

@tushar172787 said:

@quadknight said:

@cinematicgalore said:

@quadknight said:

Dat butthurt rebuttal thread. Weren't you already owned in your previous thread?

Gears wins, facts are there. You blind?

You're still butthurt lol.

quadknight in tears... hahaha!

Look at that fake laughter at the end of your post. Gears 4 had an abysmal showing at E3, the trailer was pitch black, the scripted scenes somehow managed to be boring and the gameplay looked clunky. Meanwhile UC4 demo was some of the most amazing gaming sequence ever.

Aim lower lems.. compete with Knack or something.

uhh.. we're talking about gears 1-3 here? lel, keep moving your goalposts...

Uncharted 2 >>> Gears series.

What were you saying ? Oh you'd rather not talk about that Gears 4 showing? Don't blame ya.

goalpost moved the second time, we are talking about gears 1-3 and uncharted 1-3 here, i can say "gears 1 >>>>>>>>>>>>> than the uncharted series...

since when 94 > 96? you fail at math.

when did i fail at math when you missed uncharted golden abyss metascore?

there is quite the backtracking on your post

a. you say gears 1-3 and uncharted 1-3 (which by itself is bullshit because judgement was released togethe with the rest for xbox 360), then proceed to mention golden abyss (which is a psp game and not related with naughty dogs.

b. you say gears 1 >>>> uncharted series, i don't think you know what > means, how can a 94 be > to 96? u2 has 96, that alone destroys your "argument"

1. you included judgement in your "calculation" of scores, see above.

2. did i say gears 1>uncharted 2? i didn't. i was just giving an example to the other guy who was saying uncharted 2>>>gears series.

@Krelian-co: that being said, i can never give my personal opinion on the game because i only played UC2, i was just sifting through the forums and laughing at the troll that quadknight is and then the other fool comes along and says "(insert PS trailer here)game is much better than (insert xbox trailer) game lol" when i never mentioned a single time than either uncharted is better or gears is better. and then, to dignify your cow status, you start supporting both and saying uncharted is loads better than gears when i never said the opposite, shows your insecurity while supporting the trolls.

@Krelian-co:

@tushar172787 said:

@Douevenlift_bro said:

@tushar172787 said:

@quadknight said:

@cinematicgalore said:

@quadknight said:

Dat butthurt rebuttal thread. Weren't you already owned in your previous thread?

Gears wins, facts are there. You blind?

You're still butthurt lol.

quadknight in tears... hahaha!

Look at that fake laughter at the end of your post. Gears 4 had an abysmal showing at E3, the trailer was pitch black, the scripted scenes somehow managed to be boring and the gameplay looked clunky. Meanwhile UC4 demo was some of the most amazing gaming sequence ever.

Aim lower lems.. compete with Knack or something.

uhh.. we're talking about gears 1-3 here? lel, keep moving your goalposts...

see? butthurt cow starts his rant when i never mentioned gears was better, and when quadknight didn't give an opinion.

@Douevenlift_bro said:

@tushar172787 said:

@quadknight said:

@cinematicgalore said:

@quadknight said:

Dat butthurt rebuttal thread. Weren't you already owned in your previous thread?

Gears wins, facts are there. You blind?

You're still butthurt lol.

quadknight in tears... hahaha!

Look at that fake laughter at the end of your post. Gears 4 had an abysmal showing at E3, the trailer was pitch black, the scripted scenes somehow managed to be boring and the gameplay looked clunky. Meanwhile UC4 demo was some of the most amazing gaming sequence seen in recent time.

I genuinely tried to like the gears 4 demo showing...but i couldnt see shit and what I saw looked tired mostly.

then the smartass edits his post to look more "mature", seriously you cows are pathetic.

@Douevenlift_bro said:

Uncharted wins all day, everyday. Gears hasnt been at the forefront of its genre since 2006. Is it a bad game? no. Can it compete with Uncharted?

Yes it can compete with uncharted obviously, it's sold more than the uncharted franchise znd the overall scores are virtually identical.so how is it not competing with it?

You live in cloud cuckoo land, yet again what you post does not fall in line with reality.

And gears was at the forefront of it;s Genre until Vanquish released, Uncharted cannot even compete as a TPS Because it's TPS mechanics don't even/ come close to Gears.

@delta3074 said:

@Douevenlift_bro said:

Uncharted wins all day, everyday. Gears hasnt been at the forefront of its genre since 2006. Is it a bad game? no. Can it compete with Uncharted?

Yes it can compete with uncharted obviously, it's sold more than the uncharted franchise znd the overall scores are virtually identical.so how is it not competing with it?

You live in cloud cuckoo land, yet again what you post does not fall in line with reality.

And gears was at the forefront of it;s Genre until Vanquish released, Uncharted cannot even compete as a TPS Because it's TPS mechanics don't even/ come close to Gears.

the fool has no maturity, lets just leave it at that..

@tushar172787 said:

@quadknight said:

@cinematicgalore said:

@quadknight said:

Dat butthurt rebuttal thread. Weren't you already owned in your previous thread?

Gears wins, facts are there. You blind?

You're still butthurt lol.

quadknight in tears... hahaha!

LOL, looks like I touched a nerve. LMAO @ the way you're rushing in to defend your fellow lemming. I'm sure you're the OP's alt lol.

/thread.

OP is crying himself to sleep now.

UC2 was the only great game out of the UC series so far. Gears 1, 2, and 3 were all great.

UC4 may turn out to be great, but UC has a history of hype, followed by mediocrity.

@quadknight said:

@tushar172787 said:

@quadknight said:

@cinematicgalore said:

@quadknight said:

Dat butthurt rebuttal thread. Weren't you already owned in your previous thread?

Gears wins, facts are there. You blind?

You're still butthurt lol.

quadknight in tears... hahaha!

LOL, looks like I touched a nerve. LMAO @ the way you're rushing in to defend your fellow lemming. I'm sure you're the OP's alt lol.

@Krelian-co said:

Gears 1 = 94

Gears 2 = 93

Gears 3 = 91

Gears Judgement = 79

Average = 89.25

to

Uncharted 1 = 88

Uncharted 2 = 96

Uncharted 3 = 92

Average = 92

GLAD WE COULD CLEAR THAT UNCHARTED IS THE BETTER FRANCHISE AND HAS THE BEST GAME OF BOTH.

Keep trying to use fake scores, vita games and card games, it clearly doesn't show desperation.

/thread.

OP is crying himself to sleep now.

lol, when 2 cows are defending you with all their might, it's hard not to say you're an alt.. and you're supporting the cow who excluded golden abyss.. keep deflecting!

If you cite Metacritic, they will retort with sales data. If you cite sales figures, they will counter with Metacritic. You can't win, and everyone loses.

@delta3074 said:

@Douevenlift_bro said:

Uncharted wins all day, everyday. Gears hasnt been at the forefront of its genre since 2006. Is it a bad game? no. Can it compete with Uncharted?

Yes it can compete with uncharted obviously, it's sold more than the uncharted franchise znd the overall scores are virtually identical.so how is it not competing with it?

You live in cloud cuckoo land, yet again what you post does not fall in line with reality.

And gears was at the forefront of it;s Genre until Vanquish released, Uncharted cannot even compete as a TPS Because it's TPS mechanics don't even/ come close to Gears.

No it hasn't sold more and scores aren't "virtually" identical lol. It cant compete with it because Gears is dated, their last outing was a flop and studios have changed hands. You know its not the Gears it was in 2006 ;) All lems know this..

Vanquish...now thats a fun game. Gears looks clunky and dated compared to either of the two. Deal with it

Uncharted 2 alone won more GOTY awards than all 4 Gears of war games combined. FACT!

THAT is more than enough pwnage. Gears will never get that much praise.

One thing's for sure though, Gears was the first truly "next gen" looking game last gen, as much as I hate using that term. Resistance was "meh" in comparison.

Wait... so you're putting GA, an handheld game in the same pedestal as Judgement? A full fleged home console game? gtf outta here

Why dont you count this aswell while you're at it?

If you dont count GA score then Uncharted is the most critically acclaimed series - FACT

@Douevenlift_bro said:

@delta3074 said:

@Douevenlift_bro said:

Uncharted wins all day, everyday. Gears hasnt been at the forefront of its genre since 2006. Is it a bad game? no. Can it compete with Uncharted?

Yes it can compete with uncharted obviously, it's sold more than the uncharted franchise znd the overall scores are virtually identical.so how is it not competing with it?

You live in cloud cuckoo land, yet again what you post does not fall in line with reality.

And gears was at the forefront of it;s Genre until Vanquish released, Uncharted cannot even compete as a TPS Because it's TPS mechanics don't even/ come close to Gears.

No it hasn't sold more and scores aren't "virtually" identical lol. It cant compete with it because Gears is dated, their last outing was a flop and studios have changed hands. You know its not the Gears it was in 2006 ;) All lems know this..

Vanquish...now thats a fun game. Gears looks clunky and dated compared to either of the two. Deal with it

Yes it has sold more and the rest of your post is just the opinions of a biased SONY fanboy

'All lems know this..'

Really, are you psychic?

'Gears is dated'

Just your opinion

'Gears looks clunky and dated compared to either of the two'

thats just your opinion

'their last outing was a flop'

It didn't flop here on GS

Scores are not virtually identical?

Gears=94

Gears 2=93

Gears 3=91

Gears judgement=79

total=357

Gears has 3 AAA and 1 A title

UC 1=88

UC2=96

UC 3=94

UC GA=80

total=358

uncharted has 2 AAA and 2 AA title

Gears loses in critical acclaim and sales when you place it next to Uncharted. It also doesn't help that the last Gears game was a flop and the studio behind the console Gears games has moved on. OP is a delusional butthurt lem.

@MonsieurX said:

@cinematicgalore said:

@MonsieurX said:

@cinematicgalore said:

@MonsieurX said:

@cinematicgalore said:

Metascore is much more reliable than gamerankings. Gears wins.

Source?

Where's your sources? I provided links and calculations in my post. Am I just suppose to take your word for it? Liar

Gears wins.

What an idiot.

http://www.gamerankings.com/vita/620273-uncharted-golden-abyss/index.html 80.66

http://www.gamerankings.com/ps3/955125-uncharted-2-among-thieves/index.html 96.43

http://www.gamerankings.com/ps3/615426-uncharted-3-drakes-deception/index.html 91.78

http://www.gamerankings.com/ps3/932984-uncharted-drakes-fortune/index.html 89.67

(80.66 + 96.43 + 91.78 + 89.67)/4 = 89.635

http://www.gamerankings.com/xbox360/928234-gears-of-war/index.html 93.97

http://www.gamerankings.com/xbox360/938611-gears-of-war-2/index.html 93.32

http://www.gamerankings.com/xbox360/991468-gears-of-war-3/index.html 91.49

http://www.gamerankings.com/xbox360/672902-gears-of-war-judgment/index.html 77.38

(93.97 + 93.32 + 91.49 + 77.38) = 89.04

89.635 > 89.04 so UC>GeOW

It'd be even lower if we counted the PC release of the first Gears,which is sitting at 87.07 http://www.gamerankings.com/pc/942000-gears-of-war/index.html

Metacritic >>>>>>>> GameWankings

Gears Sales >>>>>>>> Uncharted Sales

Gears wins.

Care to enlighten us on that part?

Looks like OP fled this thread

The score difference seems kind of petty. However, I think it would be fair to only count the main series (1-3) for each and not include the spinoffs (GA and Judgment).

@delta3074 said:

@Douevenlift_bro said:

@delta3074 said:

@Douevenlift_bro said:

Uncharted wins all day, everyday. Gears hasnt been at the forefront of its genre since 2006. Is it a bad game? no. Can it compete with Uncharted?

Yes it can compete with uncharted obviously, it's sold more than the uncharted franchise znd the overall scores are virtually identical.so how is it not competing with it?

You live in cloud cuckoo land, yet again what you post does not fall in line with reality.

And gears was at the forefront of it;s Genre until Vanquish released, Uncharted cannot even compete as a TPS Because it's TPS mechanics don't even/ come close to Gears.

No it hasn't sold more and scores aren't "virtually" identical lol. It cant compete with it because Gears is dated, their last outing was a flop and studios have changed hands. You know its not the Gears it was in 2006 ;) All lems know this..

Vanquish...now thats a fun game. Gears looks clunky and dated compared to either of the two. Deal with it

Yes it has sold more and the rest of your post is just the opinions of a biased SONY fanboy

'All lems know this..'

Really, are you psychic?

'Gears is dated'

Just your opinion

'Gears looks clunky and dated compared to either of the two'

thats just your opinion

'their last outing was a flop'

It didn't flop here on GS

Scores are not virtually identical?

Gears=94

Gears 2=93

Gears 3=91

Gears judgement=79

total=357

Gears has 3 AAA and 1 A title

UC 1=88

UC2=96

UC 3=94

UC GA=80

total=358

uncharted has 2 AAA and 2 AA title

dat hurt, dem tears ^ lol

Its okay buddy, Gears had its time and the one aint looking so great. Deal with it.