GT5 or Forza 3: If you had to choose..

Metacritic -

GT1 - 96

GT2 - 93

GT3 - 95

GT4 - 89

Average - 93

Forza 1 - 90

Forza 2 - 92

Average - 91

GT IS more critically acclaimed.

[QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"][QUOTE="xscrapzx"] Dude this is like saying that Braid has done more for platforming games then Mario and Sonic have. Please just stop.xscrapzx

If I had to choose, I'd choose after they were both released.pyromaniac223

Metacritic -

GT1 - 96

GT2 - 93

GT3 - 95

GT4 - 89

Average - 93

Forza 1 - 90

Forza 2 - 92

Average - 91

GT IS more critically acclaimed.

Nonstop-Madness

[QUOTE="xscrapzx"][QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"] We're talking racing games here. You have a good argument there, but I fail to see it with racing games. Why would I want to play GT3 over Forza 2? :?-RocBoys9489-

gt5, because it looks like a next-gen game in motion

on the other hand forza3 imo looks like a ps2/wii game in high-def

Metacritic -

GT1 - 96

GT2 - 93

GT3 - 95

GT4 - 89

Average - 93

Forza 1 - 90

Forza 2 - 92

Average - 91

GT IS more critically acclaimed.

Metacritic -

GT1 - 96

GT2 - 93

GT3 - 95

GT4 - 89

Average - 93

Forza 1 - 90

Forza 2 - 92

Average - 91

GT IS more critically acclaimed.

[QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"][QUOTE="xscrapzx"] The argument is not about what you would rather play. The argument of which one was more critically acclaimed and you have to give that to GT because it is more known, it has been around a lot longer and it was the first to really pull off the racing simulation. Forza came out after and no doubt is a great game and could (*could is the special word there) eventually surpass GT as far racing simulation games go in the future. As of right now if you are saying which is more crictically acclaimed and more popular GT has the edge.Nonstop-Madness

I find funny how in these forums, launch 360 games are useless and old and ppl are using GT1, 2 and 3 to compete with Forza2 scores!

Heres GameRankings scores too...

Gran Turismo - 94.71
Gran Turismo 2 - 92.52
Gran Turismo 3 - 94.29
Gran Turismo 4 - 89.19

Forza Motorsport - 92.77
Forza Motorsport 2 - 89.61

GT has a higher average rating on GameRankings.

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"][QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"] Of course GT is more popular, but with the release of Forza 3 VERY soon and the fact that GT4 came out I don't even know how many years ago, I think GT is losing much of its popularity this gen, thanks in part to the time GT5 has taken to release, and the lower PS3 install base. Forza 3 could outsell GT5, a slight chance I think. Polyphony needs to step up their game and actually compete with Turn 10, they've been getting ****ed this gen.xscrapzx

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

Metacritic -

GT1 - 96

GT2 - 93

GT3 - 95

GT4 - 89

Average - 93

Forza 1 - 90

Forza 2 - 92

Average - 91

GT IS more critically acclaimed.

-RocBoys9489-

[QUOTE="ZoomZoom2490"][QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"] If you consider how late Forza entered (right after GT4, which sucked imo), it's more critically acclaimed.-RocBoys9489-

I find funny how in these forums, launch 360 games are useless and old and ppl are using GT1, 2 and 3 to compete with Forza2 scores!

PAL360

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

I find funny how in these forums, launch 360 games are useless and old and ppl are using GT1, 2 and 3 to compete with Forza2 scores!

-RocBoys9489-

I find funny how in these forums, launch 360 games are useless and old and ppl are using GT1, 2 and 3 to compete with Forza2 scores!

PAL360

[QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"][QUOTE="ZoomZoom2490"] excuses are always easy to find.ZoomZoom2490

i think people are going too far with forza3, i have a 4 year old gpu in my closet somewhere right now that can display racing games in much higher res, textures, etc.

this is why your games flop all the time, stop hyping someting that has been done looooong time ago.

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"][QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"] Of course GT is more popular, but with the release of Forza 3 VERY soon and the fact that GT4 came out I don't even know how many years ago, I think GT is losing much of its popularity this gen, thanks in part to the time GT5 has taken to release, and the lower PS3 install base. Forza 3 could outsell GT5, a slight chance I think. Polyphony needs to step up their game and actually compete with Turn 10, they've been getting ****ed this gen.xscrapzx

i think people are going too far with forza3, i have a 4 year old gpu in my closet somewhere right now that can display racing games in much higher res, textures, etc.

this is why your games flop all the time, stop hyping someting that has been done looooong time ago.

ZoomZoom2490

[QUOTE="xscrapzx"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"] GT has not lost any popularity. GT5P sold nearly 4 million and it isnt even a full game. Forza 3 has no chance of outselling GT5 worldwide. . Nonstop-Madness

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

I find funny how in these forums, launch 360 games are useless and old and ppl are using GT1, 2 and 3 to compete with Forza2 scores!

-RocBoys9489-

No problem. You should know you will go nowhere if you try to make a pro 360 point here :?

says the guy who just said "on the other hand forza3 imo looks like a ps2/wii game in high-def"-RocBoys9489-

[QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"][QUOTE="PAL360"]

I find funny how in these forums, launch 360 games are useless and old and ppl are using GT1, 2 and 3 to compete with Forza2 scores!

ZoomZoom2490

So you're agreeing that GT3 would not hold the same score today?

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

I find funny how in these forums, launch 360 games are useless and old and ppl are using GT1, 2 and 3 to compete with Forza2 scores!

Odrec

can somone plzwatch this video and tell what is so special about this racing game that ms is hyping so much?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tV0WyKglNck&feature=fvw

i really cant figure it out, it looks like any avarage racing game, even the strongest area of the game which are the graphics dont really have nothing special either.

forza 3 for me

forza 2 had a great community and i loved making cars on that..so much fun

there is just alot more for me to do in forza

[QUOTE="Odrec"][QUOTE="PAL360"]

I find funny how in these forums, launch 360 games are useless and old and ppl are using GT1, 2 and 3 to compete with Forza2 scores!

nervmeister

can somone plzwatch this video and tell what is so special about this racing game that ms is hyping so much?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tV0WyKglNck&feature=fvw

i really cant figure it out, it looks like any avarage racing game, even the strongest area of the game which are the graphics dont really have nothing special either.

ZoomZoom2490

Well, graphics are great and like everyone who played the other Forza games for sure know, gameplay is awesome

the only racing game that actually makes you say wow, is gt5p, and gt5 is going to be even better.

look at the difference betwen fm3 video i posted to this video of Gt5p:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=83svHF1lK5U&feature=related

gt5p almost looks like real life in motion, so while you people drool over still pictures with 20000000000000000 billion textures on screen ill be playing someting that looks and plays real in motion.

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"][QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"] Cool? That's too bad for you I guess. You Sony fans always say bout how Europe is "Sony land"-RocBoys9489-

[QUOTE="Odrec"][QUOTE="PAL360"]

I find funny how in these forums, launch 360 games are useless and old and ppl are using GT1, 2 and 3 to compete with Forza2 scores!

nervmeister

Sure, when discussing GT vs Forza, this applies. But when its a Killzone vs Halo debate, the fact that all Halo games outscored Killzone 2, both as a whole and each individually, suddenly the scores of those "older" Halo games don't count. Older Halo games can be subjected to "score deflation" of time, but GT3 is a 9.3 foreveeeeeeeeeeeer :roll::roll:

[QUOTE="-RocBoys9489-"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"] Its to bad a AAA franchise (Forza) cant outsell a "AA" franchise (GT). The US has a larger userbase than Europe anyways. ZoomZoom2490

Played every GT up to and including GT5P, and recently purchased Forza 2. Without a doubt I'll take GT5, the only way Forza will reach the same plateauas GT is if MS drops Turn10 & hires a talented studio. The only thing FM2 has over GT4 for PS2 is it's un-realistic damage and the dress-up ripped right off from NFS.

[QUOTE="nervmeister"]

[QUOTE="Odrec"] When people ask what series is more acclaimed you have to look at the game's lifetime not only from *insert random date here* on.AdobeArtist

Sure, when discussing GT vs Forza, this applies. But when its a Killzone vs Halo debate, the fact that all Halo games outscored Killzone 2, both as a whole and each individually, suddenly the scores of those "older" Halo games don't count.