Halo 3 versus Metroid Prime 3 Gamespot Score sig bet

Across platform comparisons aren't accurate. What scores a 9 on the Wii won't necessarilly score a 9 on the Xbox 360, different expectations and standards for very disimilar systems.

WIth that being said, I say Halo 3 will score higher. And if they tie, it will still be better seeing as Xbox 360 games are held to higher standards than Wii games.

Donkey_Puncher

That's a pretty weak argument. Halo 3 is on a more graphically focused console so obviouslythe graphics will be held to higer standards, but MP3 is on a controls focused console so the controls will be held to a higher standard. and the standards for gameplay always stay the same

If MP3 scores the same, it is just as good. If it scores more it is better. That's how things work on System Wars.

1. with the new scoring system they both tie at 9.0 or 9.5

2. umm sure..

I cant see MP3 scoring higher then Halo 3. I watched the videos for MP3 andI was anything but impressed. How can it compete with the almost limitless replayability of Halo 3's multiplayer and online co-op?xXHackettXx

1. Which will score higher on Gamespot?
2. What would you like the other side to put in their signature if they are wrong?

I think that Metroid Prime 3 will score higher, and if Halo 3 scores lower I want Lemmings to admit ownage by putting in their signatures "I hyped Halo 3, but it turned out to be casual trash." :P

Now it's your turn. Remember to include both things in your reply.:)

Lilac_Benjie

[QUOTE="Donkey_Puncher"]

Across platform comparisons aren't accurate. What scores a 9 on the Wii won't necessarilly score a 9 on the Xbox 360, different expectations and standards for very disimilar systems.

WIth that being said, I say Halo 3 will score higher. And if they tie, it will still be better seeing as Xbox 360 games are held to higher standards than Wii games.

bulletmath

That's a pretty weak argument. Halo 3 is on a more graphically focused console so obviouslythe graphics will be held to higer standards, but MP3 is on a controls focused console so the controls will be held to a higher standard. and the standards for gameplay always stay the same

If MP3 scores the same, it is just as good. If it scores more it is better. That's how things work on System Wars.

It's not as simple as that. It's not just graphics that distinguish Xbox360 games from Wii games (many but not all games). You look at a game like Forza 2, for example, and think about what a Wii can muster for a racer. Put an unchanged Forza 2 on the Wii and I can guarantee you that it will score higher than 9.2.

[QUOTE="Michael85"]

This is dumb. Halo 3 should outscore MP3 because both are polished experiences, but Halo offers a more long-term value because of Live.

Halo 3 should outscore Prime, no questions asked.

HarlockJC

If you think like that then no Single person game should ever out score Multi player game.

Um...no? Yeah, that's a good enough comeback for that statement, "no".

You want us to say Halo is casual trash (if it loses)? Even though it could score 9.0 compared to MP3's 9.5 or something? Not exactly the definition of trash..

it's gamespot so my money's on halobulletmath

yea same here, im not a fan of either and i really dont like halo but itll get a higher rating so if i go in on this bet id say halo 9 and mp3 8.5 or lower

[QUOTE="linkhero1"]What if they tie?Lilac_Benjie

Cows loose.

pretty much .

if Mp3 win , cows will act : haha , halo3 is the sux0r !1!1!!!

if Halo 3 win , cows will act : Haha , MP3 is the Sux0r !1!1!!

if it's a tie , Sheep and lemming will act : Haha , cows still have no exclusive AAAs !1!!!!

Gamespot is probably going to give metroid an over-exaggerated scoreLinKuei_warrior

Or maybe they will give it the score they think is right, and you'll just not agree with it... and go on and on about how you don't agree...

Gamespot is probably going to give metroid an over-exaggerated scoreLinKuei_warrior

gamespot doesnt seem to like the wii. i unfortunately think halo will score betterV-a-i-z-a-r-d

What terrible damage control over the Wii's horrid games.

[QUOTE="V-a-i-z-a-r-d"]gamespot doesnt seem to like the wii. i unfortunately think halo will score bettertaikthebate

What terrible damage control over the Wii's horrid games.

1. Which will score higher on Gamespot?
2. What would you like the other side to put in their signature if they are wrong?

I think that Metroid Prime 3 will score higher, and if Halo 3 scores lower I want Lemmings to admit ownage by putting in their signatures "I hyped Halo 3, but it turned out to be casual trash." :P

Now it's your turn. Remember to include both things in your reply.:)

Lilac_Benjie

I'll take that bet.

If MP3 outscores Halo 3 I will leave GS and quit posting. If Halo 3 outscores MP3 I want you to leave GS and quit posting. Like, forever, no coming back under some new name or whatever.

I don't even own a 360, I just want you to leave and quit posting.

[QUOTE="taikthebate"]

[QUOTE="V-a-i-z-a-r-d"]gamespot doesnt seem to like the wii. i unfortunately think halo will score betterV-a-i-z-a-r-d

What terrible damage control over the Wii's horrid games.

It probably is, but that doesn't make the Wii's games any better.

Halo 3 im betting:D

But MP3 wont be a runover