How do sheep explain all the first party Gamecube titled that failed to get AAA?

[QUOTE="mojito1988"]

So if a game does not get a 9+ its not worth buying? Oh boy thats a new one on me

 

Bread_or_Decide

I don't have money to waste on anything but the best games.

Starved for attention, I see.karicha9

Thank you for noticing!

[QUOTE="wavedash101"]

Same could be said for lots of Sony party parties too...yet not being AA didnt stop MK: DD or SSBM from selling tons of systems...or garnering tons of acclaim...some of the best games of all time didnt get AAA here, just look at Gamespot's greatest games of all time list >_>

Bread_or_Decide

So you brought up Sony.....okay not sure why you did.

Then you brought up sales...not sure why you did that either.

Sheep say..NINTENDO # 1 FIRST PARTY...well what happened with these games on the Cube?

[QUOTE="Bread_or_Decide"][QUOTE="mojito1988"]

So if a game does not get a 9+ its not worth buying? Oh boy thats a new one on me

 

Hoffgod

I don't have money to waste on anything but the best games.

Both those games were awesome and should have got AAA

His point is that Nintendo's 1st gen didn't do as well last year as they have done in the past, thats it. 

[QUOTE="Bread_or_Decide"][QUOTE="wavedash101"]

Same could be said for lots of Sony party parties too...yet not being AA didnt stop MK: DD or SSBM from selling tons of systems...or garnering tons of acclaim...some of the best games of all time didnt get AAA here, just look at Gamespot's greatest games of all time list >_>

 

Microsoft1234

So you brought up Sony.....okay not sure why you did.

Then you brought up sales...not sure why you did that either.

Sheep say..NINTENDO # 1 FIRST PARTY...well what happened with these games on the Cube?

brawl isn't even out yet you newb. 

[QUOTE="wavedash101"]

Same could be said for lots of Sony party parties too...yet not being AA didnt stop MK: DD or SSBM from selling tons of systems...or garnering tons of acclaim...some of the best games of all time didnt get AAA here, just look at Gamespot's greatest games of all time list >_>

 

Bread_or_Decide

So you brought up Sony.....okay not sure why you did.

Then you brought up sales...not sure why you did that either.

Sheep say..NINTENDO # 1 FIRST PARTY...well what happened with these games on the Cube?

They won 2 GOTY awards on Gamespot that's what happened. 

So the "best" developer isn't really the best at all it seems.

 

Bread_or_Decide

Name another dev that had two GOTY's last gen. 

Come on down folks.

Show me what ya got.

Nintendo first party is supposed to be the best ever. What happened?

Metroid and Zelda achieved AAA what happened to the rest?

 

Bread_or_Decide

[QUOTE="Bread_or_Decide"]

So the "best" developer isn't really the best at all it seems.

 

mojito1988

Best? I would never say that Nintendo is the best. I would say that nintendo is the best developer that also happens to make the top hardware in the industry and posts the highest profits every quarter in gaming. (humm maybe that does make them the best now that you mention it lol)

So by your logic a game that scored AA can't improve for the next sequal??? Explain the scores of Morrowind and Oblivion!!!

BTW this thread shows how shallow you are when it comes to games and there scores!!! What if Halo 3, Mass Effect, and/or Forza didn't score AAA???

So by your logic a game that scored AA can't improve for the next sequal??? Explain the scores of Morrowind and Oblivion!!!

BTW this thread shows how shallow you are when it comes to games and there scores!!! What if Halo 3, Mass Effect, and/or Forza didn't score AAA???

FireEmblem_Man

[QUOTE="phatkav"][QUOTE="Bread_or_Decide"]

[QUOTE="phatkav"]Wait a munite, AA games are now horrible games that no one should mention? Bread_or_Decide

If Nintendo is the best developer there is then shouldn't all of their most important franchises be AAA? I mean if you are buying a console simply for their games is that not too much to ask?

Super Smash Bros. Melee - 8.9

Paper Mario: The Thousand year Door - 9.1

Super Mario Sunshine - 8

ANimal Crossing - 8.1

Metroid Prime - 9.7

Metroid Prime 2 - 9.1

I see good titles in here.  

Yeah Metroid and Zelda walked away pretty good. Paper Mario stood strong. And lets throw a dog a bone...Smash Bros. managed to outscore its N64 counterpart.

The rest crumbled. You can't ignore that.

So the "best" developer isn't really the best at all it seems.

Bread_or_Decide

Games are really only graded on a single player experience and they tack a few extra points on for multiplayer. That's why party games score low. Realistically they have the higher, if not infinite, replay value but require more players. Kalel559

Mario Kart Double Dash, Super Mario Sunshine, Starfox Adventure, F-Zero,Super Smash Bros.

These are some very key first party franchises and none of them managed to get a 9 at gamespot.

How are we supposed to get excited for these games on the Wii if they couldn't cut in the Cube?

Discuss.

 

Bread_or_Decide

Did you actually play these games and are arguing their quality?... or are you just looking at the score based on a single web-site (useless) opinion of some games youve never played before?

I would only argue with someone who has made up their own mind... and is not some dim media slave. 

Forget the GS reviews, look at the average score for all sites:

SSBM: 9.0

SM Sunshine: 9.2

MK DS: 8.7

F-Zero GX: 8.9

There you go, GS underated them all by quite a bit except for SSBM.

metal gear solid

usually regarded as the best ps1 game

scored an 8.5 on gamespot

/thread

Mario Kart Double Dash, Super Mario Sunshine, Starfox Adventure, F-Zero,Super Smash Bros.

These are some very key first party franchises and none of them managed to get a 9 at gamespot.

How are we supposed to get excited for these games on the Wii if they couldn't cut in the Cube?

Discuss.

 

Bread_or_Decide

SSBM and F-Zero ARE AAA titles IMO.

I'm sick of this thinking that AA or even A games are bad. Get a freaking (preferbly unbiased) opinion you idiotic faboys! 

1) GS underrated Super Mario Sunshine, Super Smash Bros Melee, Mario Kart: DD.

2) So A and AA games are not great and fun?

[QUOTE="Can-o-Mark"]Yeah people, listen to the man. These games suck, because they didnt get a 9.

There are only 3 rankings on gamespot:

AAAA: 10/Perfect
AAA - 9.0-9.9/Awesome
Less than AAA - CrapAnxz

I disagree with that. Some of the best games I played were AA. 

[QUOTE="Bread_or_Decide"]

So the "best" developer isn't really the best at all it seems.

luigigreen

Mario Kart Double Dash, Super Mario Sunshine, Starfox Adventure, F-Zero,Super Smash Bros.

These are some very key first party franchises and none of them managed to get a 9 at gamespot.

How are we supposed to get excited for these games on the Wii if they couldn't cut in the Cube?

Discuss.

 

Bread_or_Decide

Nintendo 1st party games are ALWAYS AAA to Sheep, NO MATTER WHAT. Even Mario Party, Custom Robo, and Wario Ware. AAA. No exceptions. That's how their hearts work. 

No Magazine, Site, article, will sway them. 

Gamespot underrated SSBM imo.Wahoo2k

[QUOTE="Bread_or_Decide"]

Mario Kart Double Dash, Super Mario Sunshine, Starfox Adventure, F-Zero,Super Smash Bros.

These are some very key first party franchises and none of them managed to get a 9 at gamespot.

How are we supposed to get excited for these games on the Wii if they couldn't cut in the Cube?

Discuss.

SolidTy

Nintendo 1st party games are ALWAYS AAA to Sheep, NO MATTER WHAT. Even Mario Party, Custom Robo, and Wario Ware. AAA. No exceptions. That's how their hearts work.

No Magazine, Site, article, will sway them.

Mario Kart Double Dash, Super Mario Sunshine, Starfox Adventure, F-Zero,Super Smash Bros.

These are some very key first party franchises and none of them managed to get a 9 at gamespot.

How are we supposed to get excited for these games on the Wii if they couldn't cut in the Cube?

Discuss.

Bread_or_Decide

[QUOTE="SolidTy"][QUOTE="Bread_or_Decide"]

Mario Kart Double Dash, Super Mario Sunshine, Starfox Adventure, F-Zero,Super Smash Bros.

These are some very key first party franchises and none of them managed to get a 9 at gamespot.

How are we supposed to get excited for these games on the Wii if they couldn't cut in the Cube?

Discuss.

 

Riviera_Phantom

Nintendo 1st party games are ALWAYS AAA to Sheep, NO MATTER WHAT. Even Mario Party, Custom Robo, and Wario Ware. AAA. No exceptions. That's how their hearts work.

No Magazine, Site, article, will sway them.

Well, you're one of the rare SHEEP with Taste.

*Looks at Sig*

Actually, this is the case, since you have Kratos from Sony's God of War in your Sig, and an Xbox Live sig as well.
You have learned what I learned, Nintendo can't keep you happy by themselves, you crave more...like me.

[QUOTE="Bread_or_Decide"]

Mario Kart Double Dash, Super Mario Sunshine, Starfox Adventure, F-Zero,Super Smash Bros.

These are some very key first party franchises and none of them managed to get a 9 at gamespot.

How are we supposed to get excited for these games on the Wii if they couldn't cut in the Cube?

Discuss.

 

SolidTy

Nintendo 1st party games are ALWAYS AAA to Sheep, NO MATTER WHAT. Even Mario Party, Custom Robo, and Wario Ware. AAA. No exceptions. That's how their hearts work. 

No Magazine, Site, article, will sway them. 

That also goes by Sony fans with Sony's first party titles and Microsoft fans with their first party titles!!!!

But overall you have to admit, Nintendo do tend to make great games although they may not be always AAA but they're always fun to play