If Gamespot could change one review score...

...not that they ever would, weeks, months, or years after the fact or even that they would ever admit a hindsight mistake to a review score, which game do you think they would change...

I believe (and obviously this isnt meant to be a rip on gamespot thread at all, just some light hearted thought) they wish they could go back and drop GTA4 buy at least a point.

GTA4- 9.0 or even an 8.5

Mass Effect XBOX360- is a 9.0 or higher. (for me its a 10) at the time of its release the game was amazing and still is to this day.

AND YES!!!! i am well aware of the fact that games are reviewed by their currant standards at the time of release, im speaking more about games that just never felt like they fit the score they recieved.

GTA IV, definetely not a 10.

I think quite a lot of people will mention that one.

well for gta 4 it should have been a 7 max

final fantasy XIII a 6 max

god of war 3 7.5

Mgs4: 8.0

funny thing those are my four favourite franchise yet I find they were defininetely not that great this gen

mgs4 around an 8.5 or 9.0. how it got a 10 is beyond me.

Infamous 2...

inFamous 2, obviously. Ridiculously low score for that quality of a game.

Probably Infamous 2. It was way better than infamous 1, how it scored lower is beyond me.

I will always say inFamous 2 was a TERRIBLE score but if I had a choice

Diddy Kong Racing- to a 8-8.5 unreal it got a 6...

But overall I would chose FF9 and instead of a 8.5 give it a 9.5... If ff8 can get a 10 this game can get a better score

Guys damn, what is up with everybody hating on GTA4? What's wrong with it.

MGS4 down to a 8.0/10racing1750

Call of Duty: Black Ops should be a 10.

street cleaning simulator to an 11.

[QUOTE="racing1750"]MGS4 down to a 8.0/10Mozelleple112

tbh as a huge MGS fan its far from a 10 and im being brutal with the truth.

Call of Duty: Black Ops should be a 10.

MetroidPrimePwn

From 1 to 100? Definitely.

Guys damn, what is up with everybody hating on GTA4? What's wrong with it.

xWoW_Rougex

I'd change Company of Heroes to 10 :)

[QUOTE="racing1750"]MGS4 down to a 8.0/10Mozelleple112

Only three games come to mind.

Tools of Destruction, Infamous 2, and the Halo RTS game.

Great thread!

Fallout new vegas should become at least 8.5.

Left for dead 2 should be 7.

Bioshock should be 10.

Portal rocks just thought I would say that.

I agree that gta 4 is not a 10 but it did something that no other game has in making a real, believable nyc and for that it should have a 9. Add in a good story, fun gameplay and decent missions/ graphics and you have a 9.5-10.

Nothing really.

And GTA4 deserves a 10.

I would let gamespot actually review DW7 and it would get a 10. :3

[QUOTE="Mozelleple112"][QUOTE="racing1750"]MGS4 down to a 8.0/10racing1750

Infamous 2 - 7.5 to 8.5

R&C TOD - 7.5 to 9.0

I agree pretty much everybody in here with GTA4.

I would give GTA4 a 9 and RDR the 10.

I don't care how good THPS3 is (PS2 version), it doesn't deserve to share a pedestal with the likes of OOT and MGS4

Must be one of the few who actually loved GTA 4. :(

Anyway, Modern Warfare 2 should be a 3/10. I was going to say 1/10, but then I realized how much fun it was to use the grenade launched while camping.

Skies of Arcadia should be a 9.5

None. It's just a score, somewhat meaningless.

Dungeon Master 2 should be 9.5 at least.

Infamous 2 to an 8.5 or 9. I can't speak for GTA IV though, since I haven't played it.

Killzone 3 - at least a 9

"Assassin's" creed brotherhood - a 5 at best

Mass Effect 2 - 8

Red Dead Redemption - 8

Portal 2 - 10

Demon's Souls 9.5

legend of dragoon

Well to be honest everyone is gonna disagree with GS scores because people have different opinions.