If Gamespot could change one review score...

[QUOTE="jasonharris48"]

Metal Gear Solid 4 7/10 (just doesn't live up to previous games)

GTA4 8-8.5 at best

Mass Effect 1 9/10 (it's a far better RPG than part two although that isn't saying much)

Shadow of the Colossus 9.0

Persona 3 Fes 9.0

FInal Fantasy XIII 6.0

Mozelleple112

mgs4 is a total let-down. it's no surprise the majority agrees that it deserves no more than a 7. :?

mgs4 is a total let-down. it's no surprise the majority agrees that it deserves no more than a 7. :?

MozartXVI

mgs4 is a total let-down. it's no surprise the majority agrees that it deserves no more than a 7. :?

[QUOTE="MozartXVI"]

mgs4 is a total let-down. it's no surprise the majority agrees that it deserves no more than a 7. :?

Lexter45

GTA IV a 6. Give it some praise for technical achievment and slam it for broken gameplay.

RDR a 7. Acknowledge that it played better than GTA IV and slam it for becoming completely boring by the time it was halfway through. I don't even know how I made it through an entire playthrough of that game.

Also, every online focused game that is laggy should have its score cut by half right off the bat.

[QUOTE="Lexter45"][QUOTE="MozartXVI"]

mgs4 is a total let-down. it's no surprise the majority agrees that it deserves no more than a 7. :?

jasonharris48

The user posted a screenshot to demonstrate why the game doesn't deserve its score.

Resistance 2 ... How the **** did that score AAA??? o_O

Resistance 2 ... How the **** did that score AAA??? o_O

W1NGMAN-

Probably 'cause it's one of the best shooters this gen?

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

Resistance 2 ... How the **** did that score AAA??? o_O

Pug-Nasty

Probably 'cause it's one of the best shooters this gen?

[QUOTE="Pug-Nasty"]

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

Resistance 2 ... How the **** did that score AAA??? o_O

W1NGMAN-

Probably 'cause it's one of the best shooters this gen?

That's fine, but you should give some sort of reasons as to why it didn't deserve its score. I'll give you reasons why it did.

-Extremely inventive, satisfying arsenal of weapons.

-Boss fights that are actually fun and challenging.

-Huge game on every level. Massive level design, ridiculous amounts of enemeies on screen, huge bosses.

-A lengthy SP campaign, a great co-op component that had its own identity. A massive MP component that ran better than 99.9 % of games in its genre on all platforms.

Even its graphics were pretty good for its scale. The enemies were diverse. The action was constant.

Honestly, the only thing I can see not liking is the setting if it's just not your thing, but the people who come out and say the game was horrible make me laugh. They say the game was generic or mediocre. These are not cirticisms, they are things people say when they can't think of a real criticism.

[QUOTE="Pug-Nasty"]

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

Resistance 2 ... How the **** did that score AAA??? o_O

W1NGMAN-

Probably 'cause it's one of the best shooters this gen?

change Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 score to an 8 or something around that. It's always stood out as a bad choice for a perfect 10 in my opinion.

[QUOTE="jasonharris48"]

[QUOTE="Lexter45"] Please, you know for a fact the game looks better than that. Unfortunately since you haven't played it as you don't own a PS3 you have to rely on bad Screenshots.Pug-Nasty

The user posted a screenshot to demonstrate why the game doesn't deserve its score.

nope, i didn't mention anything about its graphics; i just posted a screenshot to go along with that mediocre game. but now that you mention it, mgs4 DOES look terrible... :(

[QUOTE="Pug-Nasty"]

[QUOTE="jasonharris48"] Huh? The user didn't even comment on the graphics?

MozartXVI

The user posted a screenshot to demonstrate why the game doesn't deserve its score.

nope, i didn't mention anything about its graphics; i just posted a screenshot to go along with that mediocre game. but now that you mention it, mgs4 DOES look terrible... :(

So many I'd like to alter slightly (Twilight Princess to 9.0, Mass Effect to 9.5 etc) but I'd most like NIER to score much, much higher.

I generally agree with GameSpot's scores, but I think Resistance 2 should be lower (no more than a 7.5) and inFamous 2 should be at least an 8.0

Killzone 3 - at least a 9

"Assassin's" creed brotherhood - a 5 at best

Mass Effect 2 - 8

Red Dead Redemption - 8

Portal 2 - 10

Demon's Souls 9.5

Cow4ever

Hi there charlesdarwin55 :oops:

Starcraft 2/Super Mario Galaxy/Every Ace Attorney game - 10

RDR/GTA4/ME2/DA2/Crysis 2/Every CoD - 5.0 or less

The Witcher 2/Metro 2033/Deus Ex HR - 9.5

Darksiders/Twilight Princess/Silent Hill: Shattered Memories - 9.0

Warhammer 40K Space Marine/Portal 2/Duke Nukem Forever/Red Steel 2 - 8.0

Sniper Ghost Warrior/Nier/The Conduit 1+2 - 7.0

No one else chose just one, so neither will I! /rebel

System Shock 2 to like a 9.7 or something from back in the day. :P

Lol, why would I care? if I think a game is excellent but GS thinks otherwise why the **** would I care?

Enjoy your games regardless of what others think..

Starcraft 2/Super Mario Galaxy/Every Ace Attorney game - 10

RDR/GTA4/ME2/DA2/Crysis 2/Every CoD - 5.0 or less

The Witcher 2/Metro 2033/Deus Ex HR - 9.5

Darksiders/Twilight Princess/Silent Hill: Shattered Memories - 9.0

Warhammer 40K Space Marine/Portal 2/Duke Nukem Forever/Red Steel 2 - 8.0

Sniper Ghost Warrior/Nier/The Conduit 1+2 - 7.0

No one else chose just one, so neither will I! /rebel

ChubbyGuy40

Lost Odyssey. What were they f'in thinking? They hated it because it stuck with the traditional JRPG combat system. Haters gonna hate! LO is a 9.5/10 in my book.

Oh, and GTA IV.. a 10/10? No game this gen.. deserves a 10. No game ever actually...not even Ocarina of Time! Well, maybe OoT. :P

[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"]

Starcraft 2/Super Mario Galaxy/Every Ace Attorney game - 10

RDR/GTA4/ME2/DA2/Crysis 2/Every CoD - 5.0 or less

The Witcher 2/Metro 2033/Deus Ex HR - 9.5

Darksiders/Twilight Princess/Silent Hill: Shattered Memories - 9.0

Warhammer 40K Space Marine/Portal 2/Duke Nukem Forever/Red Steel 2 - 8.0

Sniper Ghost Warrior/Nier/The Conduit 1+2 - 7.0

No one else chose just one, so neither will I! /rebel

BlackoutGunshot

I'd change Company of Heroes to 10 :)

anshul89

Starcraft 2/Super Mario Galaxy/Every Ace Attorney game - 10

RDR/GTA4/ME2/DA2/Crysis 2/Every CoD - 5.0 or less

The Witcher 2/Metro 2033/Deus Ex HR - 9.5

Darksiders/Twilight Princess/Silent Hill: Shattered Memories - 9.0

Warhammer 40K Space Marine/Portal 2/Duke Nukem Forever/Red Steel 2 - 8.0

Sniper Ghost Warrior/Nier/The Conduit 1+2 - 7.0

No one else chose just one, so neither will I! /rebel

ChubbyGuy40

mgs4 is a total let-down. it's no surprise the majority agrees that it deserves no more than a 7. :?

MozartXVI

Lost Odyssey. What were they f'in thinking? They hated it because it stuck with the traditional JRPG combat system. Haters gonna hate! LO is a 9.5/10 in my book.

Oh, and GTA IV.. a 10/10? No game this gen.. deserves a 10. No game ever actually...not even Ocarina of Time! Well, maybe OoT. :P

Elann2008

Infamous 2 review, they are the only site to rate it low and it makes them look foolish.

[QUOTE="kuraimen"]

Lexter45

Thief 1 & 2 are the ultimate stealth kings ... Thief 3 not so much :cry:

System Shock 2 to like a 9.7 or something from back in the day. :P

longtonguecat

QFT!!!

and the original Deus Ex shoukd have been as well.

Assassin's Creed 1 = 9.0

Mario Kart 64 = 6.4

Two Worlds = 7.0

Assassin's Creed should be 2 points lower. Mario Kart 64 2 points higher. Two Worlds 3 points lower.

AvIdGaMeR444

Giving Zelda: TP AAA (9.0 or higher) instead of 8.8 .. that would have literally changed the course of history :P

MGS4 did NOT deserve a perfect score neither did GTA4 for that matter but I'm just trying to be fair here.