If Gears of War 3 beat Uncharted 2 in the graphics department

[QUOTE="kong_sevixnine"]

Gears of War 2 came out late 2008.Killzone 2 came out early 2009 and topped it, that was less than a year. Months and months later came Uncharted 2 which looked better thanboth games

XD

I believe gears 2 was in production for 3 years, and killzone 2 was in production for 6 or more.

[QUOTE="pc-ps360"]

god of war 3 and heavy rain already beat uncharted 2 graphics.

Hell no.

[QUOTE="roflcopter317"]

[QUOTE="pc-ps360"]

god of war 3 and heavy rain already beat uncharted 2 graphics.

gaming25

Hell no.

Uncharted 2 is the best looking ps3 game. God of war 3 looks ok, and since when does animations alone make the graphics better?

The game is coming out 2 years later. There's no reason for it NOT to look better.

DarkLink77

One and a quater I am pretty sure.

[QUOTE="gaming25"][QUOTE="roflcopter317"]

Hell no.

Uncharted 2 is the best looking ps3 game. God of war 3 looks ok, and since when does animations alone make the graphics better?

I personally don't think Uncharted 2 looks that great, if anything it's equal to or a little bit below gears 2 graphics in my opinion.

In the remote chance if it does, it still has KZ2, God of war 3 to beat. Then We move on to a higher tier which consists of Killzone 3, Uncharted 3 and Santa Monica's next game. Also don't ever count out The last guardian.

[QUOTE="gaming25"][QUOTE="roflcopter317"]

Hell no.

roflcopter317

Uncharted 2 is the best looking ps3 game. God of war 3 looks ok, and since when does animations alone make the graphics better?

uncharted 2 looks amazing but compared to god of war 3 im sorry, but uncharted 2 is a jaggie mess

Yeh and it took 3 years for the ps3 to match the 360...G-O-M-J

[QUOTE="GGam3r"][QUOTE="roflcopter317"]

Do you realise Gears 2, and most of the other 360 exclusives came out years before uncharted 2, back when the game devs didn't have the tech?

ArtisTool

In the remote chance if it does, it still has KZ2, God of war 3 to beat. Then We move on to a higher tier which consists of Killzone 3, Uncharted 3 and Santa Monica's next game. Also don't ever count out The last guardian.

gpuking

You got to be kiddin me?

gears 2 looks better so of course gears 3 will.

[QUOTE="ermacness"]

[QUOTE="G-O-M-J"]Yeh and it took 3 years for the ps3 to match the 360...hd5870corei7

I had a real good laugh though, one of the best comedy posts today.

In the remote chance if it does, it still has KZ2, God of war 3 to beat. Then We move on to a higher tier which consists of Killzone 3, Uncharted 3 and Santa Monica's next game. Also don't ever count out The last guardian.

gpuking

[QUOTE="gpuking"]

In the remote chance if it does, it still has KZ2, God of war 3 to beat. Then We move on to a higher tier which consists of Killzone 3, Uncharted 3 and Santa Monica's next game. Also don't ever count out The last guardian.

mellodude12

Graphics between the consoles are a tiny difference... Seriously if graphics were a number then the PS3 would have 100 "graphics" and the xbox probably 103 "Graphics"... Basic analogy but it's not all about raw power... PS3 architecture is much better suited to fluid dynamics compared to the xbox, meaning water effects not just splashes and ripples but full on weight and physics of water are much easier to achieve without much effect... But obviously lighting and shading is better on xbox, just depends on the style used by the developer which determines how a game looks, it aint all resolution and detail.JohnF111

Me personally... i would give the Ps3 like a 115 and a 360 around a 90(in graphics) Crysis 2 is the best graphics a 360 is capable of and the 360 can't even run it properly and there are loads of glitches and bugs. Uncharted 2, God of war 3, Killzone 3 perform much smoother and graphically looks just as good if not better then Crysis 2. The 360 does do lighting better, but the Ps3 does everything else much better including textures. I haven't seen a 360 game yet with as impressive textures as Killzone 3 or Socom 4mellodude12

Really?

First off, i haven't seen a console game yet on either current gen platform that is 100% consistant graphically.

Next, I'm pretty dam sure that the Xenos GPU in the 360 does Textures and fill rate a lot better than the RSX.

A lot better.

The fact that Crysis2 is even comparable to the PS3's best.. being just a multi-plat engine, says multitudes about the 360 true capabilities in the hands of a talented developer.

Finally, the fact that you mentioned Socom 4 as a graphical beast means you have zero creditability!

Lmao!

[QUOTE="mellodude12"][QUOTE="gpuking"]

In the remote chance if it does, it still has KZ2, God of war 3 to beat. Then We move on to a higher tier which consists of Killzone 3, Uncharted 3 and Santa Monica's next game. Also don't ever count out The last guardian.

soulitane

[QUOTE="soulitane"][QUOTE="mellodude12"]Absolutely this. Infamous 2 is looking amazing too! p.s From what I've seen of Uncharted 3 sp it blows away anything I've seen upcoming for the 360.mellodude12

[QUOTE="mellodude12"]Me personally... i would give the Ps3 like a 115 and a 360 around a 90(in graphics) Crysis 2 is the best graphics a 360 is capable of and the 360 can't even run it properly and there are loads of glitches and bugs. Uncharted 2, God of war 3, Killzone 3 perform much smoother and graphically looks just as good if not better then Crysis 2. The 360 does do lighting better, but the Ps3 does everything else much better including textures. I haven't seen a 360 game yet with as impressive textures as Killzone 3 or Socom 4AnxietyAttack

Really?

First off, i haven't seen a console game yet on either current gen platform that is 100% consistant graphically.

Next, I'm pretty dam sure that the Xenos GPU in the 360 does Textures and fill rate a lot better than the RSX.

A lot better.

The fact that Crysis2 is even comparable to the PS3's best.. being just a multi-plat engine, says multitudes about the 360 true capabilities in the hands of a talented developer.

Finally, the fact that you mentioned Socom 4 as a graphical beast means you have zero creditability!

Lmao!

[QUOTE="GGam3r"][QUOTE="roflcopter317"]

Do you realise Gears 2, and most of the other 360 exclusives came out years before uncharted 2, back when the game devs didn't have the tech?

ArtisTool

I don't care what graphics awards it won at the time, MGS4 is not very impressive to me. Fuzzy image quality, lots of jaggies, and low res textures make it look pretty mediocre. There are many games on both consoles that look better than MGS4.

As for whether Gears 3 will look better than Uncharted 2, well I think it is possible based on what I have seen so far. But I do think that Uncharted 2 will probably still have more artistry and polish. Uncharted 3 will also likely surpass both of them.

Macutchi, Lol @ your sig. It's epic.

Damage control already

[QUOTE="gpuking"]

In the remote chance if it does, it still has KZ2, God of war 3 to beat. Then We move on to a higher tier which consists of Killzone 3, Uncharted 3 and Santa Monica's next game. Also don't ever count out The last guardian.

Bus-A-Bus

You got to be kiddin me?

Crysis 2 so more like a year and 3 mos?

If it beats it, good for it. Uncharted 2 still looks fantastic.

Comparing high end graphics now is like comparing two million dollar Ferraris of the same model and saying one is better because it has a tiny bit more shine in the paint because it isn't as dirty.

Wasdie

If it beats it, good for it. Uncharted 2 still looks fantastic.

Comparing high end graphics now is like comparing two million dollar Ferraris of the same model and saying one is better because it has a tiny bit more shine in the paint because it isn't as dirty.

Wasdie

Equal graphics does NOT prove a system can handle a game, some things that actually effect gameplay are taxing on the cpu even if it can match pretty looking it doesn't mean it has everything going on as the other one does, I mean psn games are in 1080p but I don't think wipeout HD is more taxing then Infamous

Consoles have already hit their peak in performance quite a long while back.

It's more about how creative a developer can work with these limits.

You have to know what are the most important assets to make highly detailed and which ones should be low detailed or cut from the game.

You substitute effects that are demanding for effects that are not as good but are less demanding.

You use more scripted events as it does not require as much hardware power.

When using those scripted scenes it may free up some extra performance that can be used to improve visuals while within those scripted scenes.

Basically it's not a battle of technical graphics but a battle of art style and how creative developers are.

I am sure the best looking PS3 games could be done on the xbox 360 just as well and visa versa.

Then it would be kind of sad that it took the 360 2 years (comes out 2011) to reach a game that came out in 2009. Plus doesn't Naughty Dog work on 2 year cycles? So Uncharted 3 would come out soon after that. But also at the same time it may prove that the 360 can handle Uncharted 2 graphics. Naughty Dog already said there is much more optimizing they can do so that Uncharted looks even better. The leap from Uncharted 1 to 2 is huge, and maybe the leap from Uncharted 2 to 3 will also be huge. What are your thoughts?GGam3r

my thoughts:

LMAO :lol: u MAD huh??:P

Crazy Thought dont you think they will be on par with each other? anyone else notice this is a thread from last year?

[QUOTE="AnxietyAttack"]

[QUOTE="mellodude12"]Me personally... i would give the Ps3 like a 115 and a 360 around a 90(in graphics) Crysis 2 is the best graphics a 360 is capable of and the 360 can't even run it properly and there are loads of glitches and bugs. Uncharted 2, God of war 3, Killzone 3 perform much smoother and graphically looks just as good if not better then Crysis 2. The 360 does do lighting better, but the Ps3 does everything else much better including textures. I haven't seen a 360 game yet with as impressive textures as Killzone 3 or Socom 4mellodude12

Really?

First off, i haven't seen a console game yet on either current gen platform that is 100% consistant graphically.

Next, I'm pretty dam sure that the Xenos GPU in the 360 does Textures and fill rate a lot better than the RSX.

A lot better.

The fact that Crysis2 is even comparable to the PS3's best.. being just a multi-plat engine, says multitudes about the 360 true capabilities in the hands of a talented developer.

Finally, the fact that you mentioned Socom 4 as a graphical beast means you have zero creditability!

Lmao!

And fyi Halo Reach textures smash Socom 4 textures into the ground easily imho.

Socom 4 looks worse than MAG!

Nuff said.

Consoles have already hit their peak in performance quite a long while back.

It's more about how creative a developer can work with these limits.

You have to know what are the most important assets to make highly detailed and which ones should be low detailed or cut from the game.

You substitute effects that are demanding for effects that are not as good but are less demanding.

You use more scripted events as it does not require as much hardware power.

When using those scripted scenes it may free up some extra performance that can be used to improve visuals while within those scripted scenes.

Basically it's not a battle of technical graphics but a battle of art style and how creative developers are.

I am sure the best looking PS3 games could be done on the xbox 360 just as well and visa versa.

BanMido76

Did someone in this topic honestly say that Killzone 3 has better quality textures compared to Gears 3?

Oh man. lol

I love all the arguing about graphics, It's all opinion now so deal with it. C2 looks better then any console game , no one can prove me wrong. And gears beta looks better then any console multiplayer.

i just want to play both games since both games are awesome :) (well Geow3 is not out yet but am sure it will be an amazing title)

also i guess Geow3 will be compared to UC3 considering they are both coming out later this year

imo Gears 3 already tops Uncharted 2

imo Gears 3 already tops Uncharted 2

strangeisland

And thats the Beta mutilplayer vs single player and as cows like to says now they have alot of time to polish imagine how good it will look.:)

lol damage control. cows said it was impossible for 360 to produce uncharted 2like visuals and now they're saying it took too long tobeat UC2 :|

Harisemo

There either saying that or quoting each other about how 360 somehow still doesn't compete when 360 already has a game that easily competes with anything on their console :lol: