If Uncharted 2 was on the 360 it would sell 5 million

I own both the PS3 and 360. I think Uncharted 2 should be GOTY or right up there. How is this game selling so poorly on the PS3? IF this great game was on the 360 it would have sold about 3 x's more. Why is this so? Lets not get into a bash fest, just want reasons why this is the case.

I own both the PS3 and 360. I think Uncharted 2 should be GOTY or right up there. How is this game selling so poorly on the PS3? IF this great game was on the 360 it would have sold about 3 x's more. Why is this so? Lets not get into a bash fest, just want reasons why this is the case.

PrimusGears

Larger userbase....obviously

Too bad it's not and it never will

/thread.

[QUOTE="PrimusGears"]

I own both the PS3 and 360. I think Uncharted 2 should be GOTY or right up there. How is this game selling so poorly on the PS3? IF this great game was on the 360 it would have sold about 3 x's more. Why is this so? Lets not get into a bash fest, just want reasons why this is the case.

Yankees718

Larger userbase....obviously

the userbase isn't doubled...but games like MW2 and AC2 sell twice as much on the 360.

I agree, it would have cross game chat too, and I have lots of friends to talk to while we play different games.:D

[QUOTE="PrimusGears"]

I own both the PS3 and 360. I think Uncharted 2 should be GOTY or right up there. How is this game selling so poorly on the PS3? IF this great game was on the 360 it would have sold about 3 x's more. Why is this so? Lets not get into a bash fest, just want reasons why this is the case.

Yankees718

Larger userbase....obviously

I dont think its that much larger. I mean look at Mw2, THE 360 is selling 4 million to 2 million. THey dont have double the userbase

If I passed on it on my ps3 what makes ya think I wouldnt on my 360.....HuH :P

I think the game's release was just eclipsed by other titles. MW2 was like a couple weeks away. I could definitely see UC2 pick steadily within the upcoming months. I haven't even bought it yet because I've been too busy with Dragon Age and Demon Souls.

I think the game's release was just eclipsed by other titles. MW2 was like a couple weeks away. I could definitely see UC2 pick steadily within the upcoming months. I haven't even bought it yet because I've been too busy with Dragon Age and Demon Souls.

Blue-Sky

its a great game, should be selling alot more.

[QUOTE="mitu123"]

I agree, it would have cross game chat too, and I have lots of friends to talk to while we play different games.:D

BURSTIIIFIRE

All cows care about is their precious Blueray player and they try to act like hardcore gamers.

its that much larger. I mean look at Mw2, THE 360 is selling 4 million to 2 million. THey dont have double the userbase

PrimusGears

/facepalm

lemmings still fail to realize that NPD is ameican numbers and that there is double the userbase of american 360s vs american ps3s.

I own both the PS3 and 360. I think Uncharted 2 should be GOTY or right up there. How is this game selling so poorly on the PS3? IF this great game was on the 360 it would have sold about 3 x's more. Why is this so? Lets not get into a bash fest, just want reasons why this is the case.

PrimusGears

lol Uncharted selling poorly? really?.. no its not.. its now 1 and half million.. probably reach 2 million by end of the year and you say poorly? :roll:

[QUOTE="PrimusGears"]

I own both the PS3 and 360. I think Uncharted 2 should be GOTY or right up there. How is this game selling so poorly on the PS3? IF this great game was on the 360 it would have sold about 3 x's more. Why is this so? Lets not get into a bash fest, just want reasons why this is the case.

finalstar2007

lol Uncharted selling poorly? really?.. no its not.. its now 1 and half million.. probably reach 2 million by end of the year and you say poorly? :roll:

yeah if uncharted2 is selling poorly, and so is forza3.

Or it could've sold worse like Ninja Gaiden II or Banjo: Nuts &Bolts. That's why "What If Scenarios" are useless.

[QUOTE="PrimusGears"]

I own both the PS3 and 360. I think Uncharted 2 should be GOTY or right up there. How is this game selling so poorly on the PS3? IF this great game was on the 360 it would have sold about 3 x's more. Why is this so? Lets not get into a bash fest, just want reasons why this is the case.

Yankees718

Larger userbase....obviously

If it were on the 360, I still wouldn't have bought it.Skittles_McGee

If it were on the 360, I still wouldn't have bought it.Skittles_McGee

I own both the PS3 and 360. I think Uncharted 2 should be GOTY or right up there. How is this game selling so poorly on the PS3? IF this great game was on the 360 it would have sold about 3 x's more. Why is this so? Lets not get into a bash fest, just want reasons why this is the case.

PrimusGears

Wouldn't have bought it whether it was on the 360 or the ps3.

Honestly I don't know. Could of sold more or less if it was on the 360. Who knows.

Probably, but unfortunately it's not going to happen.

So much damage control here it's not even funny. Yup GOTY contender not worth playing if you happen to own the console it's on.:roll:

It'd look like crap though :P

Seriously though, it probably wouldnt sell that great. It lacks teh chainsaws and space marines.

Still 5 million is incredible.

I own both the PS3 and 360. I think Uncharted 2 should be GOTY or right up there. How is this game selling so poorly on the PS3? IF this great game was on the 360 it would have sold about 3 x's more. Why is this so? Lets not get into a bash fest, just want reasons why this is the case.

PrimusGears

Yes, but this is moot as Uncharted 2 cannot be done on 360.

I agree, it would have cross game chat too, and I have lots of friends to talk to while we play different games.:D

mitu123

I hate cross game chat. I dont use my X360 as substitute telephone. If I'm not playing with you, I don't want to talk to you :P

Edit: I should say, my lil bro's x360, not mine :P

lack of hardcore gamers. lets face the facts if you went through the "wait" your not a tru gamer(console).People that are buying the ps3 now don't really buy good games. They dont know what to buy. They would be happy with lair. Uncharted is the best game this year. It should have done just as well as mw2 on the ps3qbell

PS3 has a low userbase. So 5 Million is impossible to have PS3 that sales. BloodSeeker1337

likely and its because of one sole fact....

Microsoft made a game machine...sony doesn't know what they made why is why the ad says it does every thing...but whats everything? when it should do one thing very very well and thats video games.

the majority of people that purchased the 360 was for a game machine...the majority of people that purchased a ps3 was to get a cheap bluray player....which is shown by the fact games sell higher on the 360 all most all the time, why people have logged more hours on 360 games then quite a few ps3 games combined.

[QUOTE="BloodSeeker1337"]PS3 has a low userbase. So 5 Million is impossible to have PS3 that sales. lhughey

likely and its because of one sole fact....

Microsoft made a game machine...sony doesn't know what they made why is why the ad says it does every thing...but whats everything? when it should do one thing very very well and thats video games.

the majority of people that purchased the 360 was for a game machine...the majority of people that purchased a ps3 was to get a cheap bluray player....which is shown by the fact games sell higher on the 360 all most all the time, why people have logged more hours on 360 games then quite a few ps3 games combined.

WilliamRLBaker

So you are saying that the majority of the PS3 userbase bought a PS3 for the Blu-ray player because the 360 userbase are buying more games?

I think you are drawing conclusions a little too early.