IGN: PS3's top 25 games destroys XBOX 360's top 25 games.

PS3's latest top 25 games list makes the 360's look abysmal. Only 5 of the 360's top 25 games were exclusives, and 3 of which are a Halo title. Not to mention the top XBOX 360 games (ME2) is a multi-plat that's also coming to the PS3. PS3's top 25 list consisted of 15 PS3 only exclusives. What are your guys feelings on the lists? Here they are:

PS3:

25 ModnationRacers

24 MLB 10: The Show

23 A Crack in Time

22 Super Stardust HD

21 Flower

20 Resistance:Fall of Man

19 Burnout Paradise

18 Borderlands

17 COD4

16 Valkyria Chronicles

15 Super StreetFighter4

14 Uncharted

13 Heavy Rain

12 Dead Space

11 Shatter

10 God of War 3

9 MGs4

8 GTA4

7 Batman AA

6 Killzone 2

5 Infamous

4 LittleBigPlanet

3 Red Dead Redemption

2 Fallout 3

1 Uncharted 2

XBOX 360

25. super street fighter 4

24.left for dead 2

23.splintercell conviction

22.batman arkham asylum

21. call of duty modern warfare 2

20- Gears of War

19-Fifa 10

18-Dead Space

17-Halo Wars

16-Assassins Creed 2

15.forza 3

14.alan wake

13. halo ODST

12.rock band 2

11.borderlands

10. oblivion

9. GTAIV

8. Bioshock

7. Mass Effect

6. The Orange Box

5. Halo 3

4. RDR

3. COD4

2. Fallout 3

1. ME2

[QUOTE="Ninja-Max"]What does it matter if they're exclusive so long as they're great games available for xbox 360 owners to enjoy? :)iMojo786_PSN

What does it matter if they're exclusive so long as they're great games available for xbox 360 owners to enjoy? :)Ninja-Max

i dont see it

this is destroying 360's list? lol i actually see a few psn games on ps3 even tho xbl spanks psn in quality and quantity

[QUOTE="Ninja-Max"]What does it matter if they're exclusive so long as they're great games available for xbox 360 owners to enjoy? :)iMojo786_PSN

Wasn't the 360 list done a while ago?Stevo_the_gamer

really? the 360's list destroys the ps3's, not the other way around. :lol:

None of those picks surprised me, except for F3 being so high.FIipMode

How about you stop arguing about "exclusives" and just enjoy the games, no matter what they are? These devs spend their lives making great games, and here you people bicker about exclusivity and other meaningless stuff. You fanboys should do yourselves a favor. Take a 6 month break from gaming, and durng that time, i don't know, try to get laid or something. Then go play a multiplat on any system and tell me how much you enjoyed it.

PS3 fanboys give console gaming a bad name, which sadly, this website is mostly comprised of.

wheres warhawk!?

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

TheMaryCeleste

really? the 360's list destroys the ps3's, not the other way around. :lol:

KarateeeChop

Think of it this way. Batman is #9 on the PS3 list, and only #22 on the Xbox 360 list. So, according to IGN, the 360 has better games.

But don't think of it that way, because both list fail to match my opinion. :P

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

chaplainDMK

PS3 has more highly rated games?

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

chaplainDMK

Numbers don't lie, that PS3 list is easily superior to that of the 360s ... both have ton of great games to satisfy both parties though, so I guess it doesn't matter all that much.

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

TheMaryCeleste

PS3

• Demon Souls = Game of the Year 2009
• Metal Gear Solid 4 = Game of the Year 2008

360 (& PC)

• Gears of War = Game of the Year 2006

yep.

[QUOTE="chaplainDMK"][QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

mystervj

It's the facts, dude. Don't act like you don't know it.

I don't understand how playstation fanboys today consider graphics to be the best part about the ps3 when back in the ps2 days, not only did they graet games, but those games had mediocre graphics. Still didnt stop them from being awesome (Resident Evil 4, Shadow of the Colossus, etc).

The thing is, the 360 hardware might not be the best, but it does have the best of everything, decent graphics, and games that appeal more to the "older gamer." I'm sorry, but I cannot fathom playing Modnation Racers, of Little big Planet, or even Heavy Rain because these games are sort of an acquired taste. But that doesnt make these games bad in anyway, since they're great for fans and people who actually PLAY them

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

LegatoSkyheart

PS3

• Demon Souls = Game of the Year 2009
• Metal Gear Solid 4 = Game of the Year 2008

360

• Gears of War = Game of the Year 2006

yep.

Meh. LOL @ Fallout 3 being number 2 though! :lol:93soccer

[QUOTE="mystervj"][QUOTE="chaplainDMK"] 360 has a exclusive AAAA? TheMaryCeleste

It's the facts, dude. Don't act like you don't know it.

[QUOTE="LegatoSkyheart"]

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

Avian005

PS3

• Demon Souls = Game of the Year 2009
• Metal Gear Solid 4 = Game of the Year 2008

360 & PC

• Gears of War = Game of the Year 2006

yep.

Oh I'm sorry.

I meant to say 360 AND PC.

is that the actual order for both lists? if so why is there such a difference in the positioning of multiplats :? (i must be missing something right?)

PS3

18 Borderlands

7 Batman AA

XBOX 360

22.batman arkham asylum

11.borderlands

[QUOTE="FIipMode"]None of those picks surprised me, except for F3 being so high.Stevo_the_gamer

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

LegatoSkyheart

PS3

• Demon Souls = Game of the Year 2009
• Metal Gear Solid 4 = Game of the Year 2008

360

• Gears of War = Game of the Year 2006

yep.

Saying only GS scores count is like saying only American sales count because this site is American. And whatever you write/say won't change the fact that the 360 has more AA/AAA games rated by critics, an online service that puts PSN to shame, and better sales, so don't even bother. :)

Wow. you can play 80% of the 360's best games on a ps3. however you can only play 40% of the ps3 best games on the 360. imagine that. looks like the best experience can be found on the ....

[QUOTE="LegatoSkyheart"]

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

TheMaryCeleste

PS3

• Demon Souls = Game of the Year 2009
• Metal Gear Solid 4 = Game of the Year 2008

360

• Gears of War = Game of the Year 2006

yep.

Saying only GS scores count is like saying only American sales count because this site is American. And whatever you write/say won't change the fact that the 360 has more AA/AAA games rated by critics, an online service that puts PSN to shame, and better sales, so don't even bother. :)

The 360 list seems a little odd, since they forgot to mention even Gears of War 1 or 2. Seems kinda odd since both were great AAA titles...Surely they can compare to Halo ODST?

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

[QUOTE="LegatoSkyheart"]

PS3

• Demon Souls = Game of the Year 2009
• Metal Gear Solid 4 = Game of the Year 2008

360

• Gears of War = Game of the Year 2006

yep.

chaplainDMK

Saying only GS scores count is like saying only American sales count because this site is American. And whatever you write/say won't change the fact that the 360 has more AA/AAA games rated by critics, an online service that puts PSN to shame, and better sales, so don't even bother. :)

Obviously, it doesn't "put it to shame", but it's clearly superior.

Lack of demon souls reallyy hurts the list

[QUOTE="LegatoSkyheart"]

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

TheMaryCeleste

PS3

• Demon Souls = Game of the Year 2009
• Metal Gear Solid 4 = Game of the Year 2008

360

• Gears of War = Game of the Year 2006

yep.

Saying only GS scores count is like saying only American sales count because this site is American. And whatever you write/say won't change the fact that the 360 has more AA/AAA games rated by critics, an online service that puts PSN to shame, and better sales, so don't even bother. :)

this is the perfect post.

[QUOTE="chaplainDMK"][QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

Saying only GS scores count is like saying only American sales count because this site is American. And whatever you write/say won't change the fact that the 360 has more AA/AAA games rated by critics, an online service that puts PSN to shame, and better sales, so don't even bother. :)

TheMaryCeleste

Obviously, it doesn't "put it to shame", but it's clearly superior.

[QUOTE="chaplainDMK"][QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

Saying only GS scores count is like saying only American sales count because this site is American. And whatever you write/say won't change the fact that the 360 has more AA/AAA games rated by critics, an online service that puts PSN to shame, and better sales, so don't even bother. :)

TheMaryCeleste

Obviously, it doesn't "put it to shame", but it's clearly superior.

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

[QUOTE="chaplainDMK"] An online service that puts PSN to shame? In what? Dedicated servers? Oh right, more PSN games have dedicated servers then XBL games... Oh and you pay 60$ a year for it... Yes, for the 1 month i tried it out, I got absolutley no reason to say that XBL demolishes PSN. They are the same thing when playing games. mystervj

Obviously, it doesn't "put it to shame", but it's clearly superior.

360s list did have alot of multiplatform games on it.

The lists sahred quite a few games though. Overal I think theyre was more actual exclusvies in the PS3 list then the 360 one had.

MGS4 being at 9 and Fallout 3 being at 2 depresses me. IGN loves FO3 way, way, way too much.

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

[QUOTE="chaplainDMK"] An online service that puts PSN to shame? In what? Dedicated servers? Oh right, more PSN games have dedicated servers then XBL games... Oh and you pay 60$ a year for it... Yes, for the 1 month i tried it out, I got absolutley no reason to say that XBL demolishes PSN. They are the same thing when playing games. mystervj

Obviously, it doesn't "put it to shame", but it's clearly superior.

Let's say both XBL and PSN were $60 a year--which one would you choose?

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

[QUOTE="chaplainDMK"] An online service that puts PSN to shame? In what? Dedicated servers? Oh right, more PSN games have dedicated servers then XBL games... Oh and you pay 60$ a year for it... Yes, for the 1 month i tried it out, I got absolutley no reason to say that XBL demolishes PSN. They are the same thing when playing games. chaplainDMK

Obviously, it doesn't "put it to shame", but it's clearly superior.

i agree but intergration is better and has nothing to do with gold so why pay the $60. just to access the online portion of the game? thats just foolish. thumbs down to xblg and psn+ thumbs up to psn but not xbls because i still can't play online.