IGN: PS3's top 25 games destroys XBOX 360's top 25 games.

[QUOTE="mystervj"][QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

Obviously, it doesn't "put it to shame", but it's clearly superior.

saleen335

MGS4 being at 9 and Fallout 3 being at 2 depresses me. IGN loves FO3 way, way, way too much.

Upparoom

[QUOTE="mystervj"][QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

Obviously, it doesn't "put it to shame", but it's clearly superior.

TheMaryCeleste

Let's say both XBL and PSN were $60 a year--which one would you choose?

XBL obviously, but since PSN isn't $60 a year that argument isn't really valid.

Saying only GS scores count is like saying only American sales count because this site is American. And whatever you write/say won't change the fact that the 360 has more AA/AAA games rated by critics, an online service that puts PSN to shame, and better sales, so don't even bother. :)

TheMaryCeleste

But we're in a Gamespot forum.....:|

anyway just look at these http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Game_of_the_Year

I want whatever the clown was smoking when he made the PS3 list. No Demon's Souls :lol:

True that. I'm also tired of people wearing my shades. I'm looking at you steve.FIipMode

Oh yeah, I went there. :D

[QUOTE="mystervj"][QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

Obviously, it doesn't "put it to shame", but it's clearly superior.

TheMaryCeleste

Let's say both XBL and PSN were $60 a year--which one would you choose?

[QUOTE="Upparoom"]

MGS4 being at 9 and Fallout 3 being at 2 depresses me. IGN loves FO3 way, way, way too much.

hd5870corei7

Yeah that old list was much better. I still don't see what IGN loves so much about Fallout 3, it isn't even the best fallout :|

[QUOTE="mystervj"][QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

Obviously, it doesn't "put it to shame", but it's clearly superior.

TheMaryCeleste

Let's say both XBL and PSN were $60 a year--which one would you choose?

Meh it's just some list IGN made up, I think Gears 2 should of been on there and whats with the lack of Project Gotham Racing. I would not take this list as the definitive top 25 console games for 360 or Ps3.

Its like saying my friends top Ps3 list destroys his top 360 list, it might do as Ps3 has good exclusives, but doesn't mean much as its just an opinion one which carries the same if not more weight than IGNs because I respect his opinion.

GOW3, being so low is crazy, I mean to me it would be a tie or close to a tie between MGS4, GOW3 and Uncharted 2 for 1st. And also theres not even a cod game mentioned on the ps3 list lol. Guess they had to make room for more ps3 exclusives :)

GOW3, being so low is crazy, I mean to me it would be a tie or close to a tie between MGS4, GOW3 and Uncharted 2 for 1st. And also theres not even a cod game mentioned on the ps3 list lol. Guess they had to make room for more ps3 exclusives :)

GreyFoXX4

really? the 360's list destroys the ps3's, not the other way around. :lol:

KarateeeChop

How? The majority of those 360 games are on the PS3:roll: Do you honestly believe that?

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

[QUOTE="mystervj"] Not really, not worth the $60 a year, I'd avoid it like a plague. chaplainDMK

Let's say both XBL and PSN were $60 a year--which one would you choose?

So it's basically better?

GOW3, being so low is crazy, I mean to me it would be a tie or close to a tie between MGS4, GOW3 and Uncharted 2 for 1st. And also theres not even a cod game mentioned on the ps3 list lol. Guess they had to make room for more ps3 exclusives :)

[QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

really? the 360's list destroys the ps3's, not the other way around. :lol:

1Stark1

How? The majority of those 360 games are on the PS3:roll: Do you honestly believe that?

Because PS3 killed his dog, or something. just ignore him.

Where is Demon's Souls on that PS3 list? Tower Knight are disappoint :evil:

Think of it this way. Batman is #9 on the PS3 list, and only #22 on the Xbox 360 list. So, according to IGN, the 360 has better games.

But don't think of it that way, because both list fail to match my opinion. :P

Avian005

Yet COD4 is #17 on PS3 list and #3 on the 360 list;) Try again

wheres warhawk!?

Ribnarak

[QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

really? the 360's list destroys the ps3's, not the other way around. :lol:

1Stark1

How? The majority of those 360 games are on the PS3:roll: Do you honestly believe that?

gta4 is 9th on the 360's list and 8th on the ps3's list.

the 360 obviously has more quality games.

sorry, but pretending otherwise won't change this fact.

[QUOTE="chaplainDMK"][QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

Let's say both XBL and PSN were $60 a year--which one would you choose?

TheMaryCeleste

So it's basically better?

That Tower knight meme just goes way the hell over my head.FIipMode

[QUOTE="1Stark1"]

[QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

really? the 360's list destroys the ps3's, not the other way around. :lol:

XboximusPrime

How? The majority of those 360 games are on the PS3:roll: Do you honestly believe that?

Because PS3 killed his dog, or something. just ignore him.

Will do lol:P

[QUOTE="1Stark1"]

[QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

really? the 360's list destroys the ps3's, not the other way around. :lol:

KarateeeChop

How? The majority of those 360 games are on the PS3:roll: Do you honestly believe that?

gta4 is 9th on the 360's list and 8th on the ps3's list.

the 360 obviously has more quality games.

sorry, but pretending otherwise won't change this fact.

[QUOTE="Avian005"]

Think of it this way. Batman is #9 on the PS3 list, and only #22 on the Xbox 360 list. So, according to IGN, the 360 has better games.

But don't think of it that way, because both list fail to match my opinion. :P

1Stark1

Yet COD4 is #17 on PS3 list and #3 on the 360 list;) Try again

[QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

[QUOTE="1Stark1"]

How? The majority of those 360 games are on the PS3:roll: Do you honestly believe that?

mystervj

gta4 is 9th on the 360's list and 8th on the ps3's list.

the 360 obviously has more quality games.

sorry, but pretending otherwise won't change this fact.

batman is 9th on ps3's list and 22nd on the 360's list.

burnout is 19th on ps3's list, but it didn't even make the 360's list.

checkmate :lol:

8 ps3 exclusives in the to 15, and 4 360 exclusives in the top 15. Sorry but that says it all.

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

LegatoSkyheart

PS3

• Demon Souls = Game of the Year 2009
• Metal Gear Solid 4 = Game of the Year 2008

360 (& PC)

• Gears of War = Game of the Year 2006

yep.

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

[QUOTE="chaplainDMK"] Xbox Live, but the thing is, Playstation Network doesent cost a dime... The gaming experience is the same, Xbox live has some extra bonuses like the intergration into the actual system, but that isn't worth 60$ a year... mystervj

So it's basically better?

Why do you think that PSN is free and XBL is not? Think about it.

[QUOTE="mystervj"][QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

gta4 is 9th on the 360's list and 8th on the ps3's list.

the 360 obviously has more quality games.

sorry, but pretending otherwise won't change this fact.

batman is 9th on ps3's list and 22nd on the 360's list.

burnout is 19th on ps3's list, but it didn't even make the 360's list.

checkmate :lol:

8 ps3 exclusives in the to 15, and 4 360 exclusives in the top 15. Sorry but that says it all.

GreyFoXX4

[QUOTE="FIipMode"]That Tower knight meme just goes way the hell over my head.skinny_man_69

[QUOTE="iMojo786_PSN"]

[QUOTE="Ninja-Max"]What does it matter if they're exclusive so long as they're great games available for xbox 360 owners to enjoy? :)emorainbo

[QUOTE="mystervj"][QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

So it's basically better?

TheMaryCeleste

Why do you think that PSN is free and XBL is not? Think about it.

Because Xbox live pays your taxes, walks your dog, and it prints money for you:o

[QUOTE="mystervj"][QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

gta4 is 9th on the 360's list and 8th on the ps3's list.

the 360 obviously has more quality games.

sorry, but pretending otherwise won't change this fact.

KarateeeChop

batman is 9th on ps3's list and 22nd on the 360's list.

burnout is 19th on ps3's list, but it didn't even make the 360's list.

checkmate :lol:

[QUOTE="LegatoSkyheart"]

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

360 > PS3 in quantity in high-quality games (critics).

360 > PS3 in online service.

360 > PS3 sales (software and hardware).

Try again next year.

iMojo786_PSN

PS3

• Demon Souls = Game of the Year 2009
• Metal Gear Solid 4 = Game of the Year 2008

360 (& PC)

• Gears of War = Game of the Year 2006

yep.

[QUOTE="mystervj"][QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

So it's basically better?

TheMaryCeleste

Why do you think that PSN is free and XBL is not? Think about it.

Because people are stupid enough to pay for online gaming which is free everywhere else. Why should MS make it free when people are so stupid to pay for it?

You know they tried this scam on the PC with GFWL and guess what the pc gamers didn't pay and it became FREE!

[QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

[QUOTE="mystervj"] CoD4 is 3rd on 360's list while 17th on PS3 list? GreyFoXX4

batman is 9th on ps3's list and 22nd on the 360's list.

burnout is 19th on ps3's list, but it didn't even make the 360's list.

checkmate :lol:

wow, what a self-contradicting list.

[QUOTE="mystervj"][QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

So it's basically better?

TheMaryCeleste

Why do you think that PSN is free and XBL is not? Think about it.

[QUOTE="iMojo786_PSN"]

[QUOTE="LegatoSkyheart"]

PS3

• Demon Souls = Game of the Year 2009
• Metal Gear Solid 4 = Game of the Year 2008

360 (& PC)

• Gears of War = Game of the Year 2006

yep.

Avian005

[QUOTE="GreyFoXX4"][QUOTE="KarateeeChop"]

batman is 9th on ps3's list and 22nd on the 360's list.

burnout is 19th on ps3's list, but it didn't even make the 360's list.

checkmate :lol:

KarateeeChop

wow, what a self-contradicting list.

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

[QUOTE="mystervj"] Not really, the bonus features are largely useless, PSN doesn't have ads enabled, so it offers better experience in that regard.loadedboon

Why do you think that PSN is free and XBL is not? Think about it.

Because people are stupid enough to pay for online gaming which is free everywhere else. Why should MS make it free when people are so stupid to pay for it?

You know they tried this scam on the PC with GFWL and guess what the pc gamers didn't pay and it became FREE!

I'm sorry, but they're paying for it due to the fact that it's worth it. Now let's say that Valve started charging for Steam, or Sony started charging for PSN--how many customers would they have? Pretty much zero.

[QUOTE="loadedboon"]

[QUOTE="TheMaryCeleste"]

Why do you think that PSN is free and XBL is not? Think about it.

TheMaryCeleste

Because people are stupid enough to pay for online gaming which is free everywhere else. Why should MS make it free when people are so stupid to pay for it?

You know they tried this scam on the PC with GFWL and guess what the pc gamers didn't pay and it became FREE!

I'm sorry, but they're paying for it due to the fact that it's worth it. Now let's say that Valve started charging for Steam, or Sony started charging for PSN--how many customers would they have? Pretty much zero.

Let's say MS makes Live Gold free.. oh wait that is never gonna happen.

[QUOTE="Avian005"]

[QUOTE="iMojo786_PSN"] so ever since ps3 joined in the console battle 360 got no GOTY's, goes to show which is the better console :)

_Cadbury_