In your opinion realistically will any game get a 10 on game spot this year?

[QUOTE="Genesis-X"][QUOTE="arbitor365"]

i want to say uncharted 3, but even if it gets the across the board 10/10s and GOTYs that uncharted 2 got, they still probably wont give it a 10/10. and if Tom Mc-bias reviews it, than it definitely wont score higher than an 8.5.

arbitor365

i would like Tom if he had a shred of objectivity and integrity in his reviews. his review for infamous 2 is so smarmy and full of spiteful nitpicking that it is clear he was biased against it from the beginning. it is one of the most misinforming, hate-filled, biased reviews in this site's history.

I have yet to come accross a single person who has played the game who shares his opinion. there is not a sane person who has played both infamous games who thinks that the second game is worse than the first.

He really does make the site look bad because once people read his review and play the game for themselves they will think

"gamespot gave "infamous" a 9/10 and "infamous 2" a 7.5/10? they clearly dont know what they are talking about."

Arkham City might if they really improve everything from Arkham Asylum.

aznfunnyjunker

I can see Skyward Sword getting it... maybe BF3 but that seems iffy.

Games with a realistic chance imo: Skyward Sword, Forza 4, and Journey

Games that I can't see possibly getting a 10 (although everyone else can): Skyrim. Since I'm confident it will be a buggy mess at points.

[QUOTE="Genesis-X"][QUOTE="arbitor365"]

i want to say uncharted 3, but even if it gets the across the board 10/10s and GOTYs that uncharted 2 got, they still probably wont give it a 10/10. and if Tom Mc-bias reviews it, than it definitely wont score higher than an 8.5.

arbitor365

i would like Tom if he had a shred of objectivity and integrity in his reviews. his review for infamous 2 is so smarmy and full of spiteful nitpicking that it is clear he was biased against it from the beginning. it is one of the most misinforming, hate-filled, biased reviews in this site's history.

I have yet to come accross a single person who has played the game who shares his opinion. there is not a sane person who has played both infamous games who thinks that the second game is worse than the first.

He really does make the site look bad because once people read his review and play the game for themselves they will think

"gamespot gave "infamous" a 9/10 and "infamous 2" a 7.5/10? they clearly dont know what they are talking about."

From what I've played, I'm not as impressed with inFamous 2 as I am was with inFamous' 2009 debut.

[QUOTE="arbitor365"]

[QUOTE="Genesis-X"]You'd probably like Tom more if he gave Infamous 2 what he felt it didn't deserve, right?moose_knuckler

i would like Tom if he had a shred of objectivity and integrity in his reviews. his review for infamous 2 is so smarmy and full of spiteful nitpicking that it is clear he was biased against it from the beginning. it is one of the most misinforming, hate-filled, biased reviews in this site's history.

I have yet to come accross a single person who has played the game who shares his opinion. there is not a sane person who has played both infamous games who thinks that the second game is worse than the first.

He really does make the site look bad because once people read his review and play the game for themselves they will think

"gamespot gave "infamous" a 9/10 and "infamous 2" a 7.5/10? they clearly dont know what they are talking about."

From what I've played, I'm not as impressed with inFamous 2 as I am was with inFamous' 2009 debut.

Didn't play Infamous generally before I cracked open Infamous 2. Played it, hated it. And considering some value it over the previous game, the series as a whole can't be that spectacular.

I would say Skyrim and Zelda have the best chances but even then they are very, very slim.

I think Skyrim has a legit chance of getting a 10.

I think that it wouldn't even matter; last year, a game with a 9.5 won GOTY over a game with a 10.

I think that it wouldn't even matter; last year, a game with a 9.5 won GOTY over a game with a 10.

turtlethetaffer

Skyward Sword probably has the best chance I would say.

NaveedLife

MW3 baby!

why? because gamespot love a yearly release of an FPS especially when it dosent change a thing! gamespot is the coolest gaming site eva! MW3 mark my words will be a 10/10 game!

finalstar2007

[QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

Skyward Sword probably has the best chance I would say.

lightleggy

why not? Shaping up to be pretty damn awesome, with a large number of gameplay hours and a second playthrough.

[QUOTE="moose_knuckler"]

[QUOTE="arbitor365"]

i would like Tom if he had a shred of objectivity and integrity in his reviews. his review for infamous 2 is so smarmy and full of spiteful nitpicking that it is clear he was biased against it from the beginning. it is one of the most misinforming, hate-filled, biased reviews in this site's history.

I have yet to come accross a single person who has played the game who shares his opinion. there is not a sane person who has played both infamous games who thinks that the second game is worse than the first.

He really does make the site look bad because once people read his review and play the game for themselves they will think

"gamespot gave "infamous" a 9/10 and "infamous 2" a 7.5/10? they clearly dont know what they are talking about."

Bretter2200

From what I've played, I'm not as impressed with inFamous 2 as I am was with inFamous' 2009 debut.

Didn't play Infamous generally before I cracked open Infamous 2. Played it, hated it. And considering some value it over the previous game, the series as a whole can't be that spectacular.

I certainly don't find either to be in leagues of my personal 9+ sandbox games, like GTAIV and RDR, but it has a certain charm to it that makes me keep coming back. The first has more than enough flaws for some to not bother playing it, but I couldn't get enough of it for it's great pacing and addictive gameplay.

[QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

I think that it wouldn't even matter; last year, a game with a 9.5 won GOTY over a game with a 10.

Bigboi500

I know, it makes no sense. Especially considering RDR wasn't even that great.

[QUOTE="lightleggy"][QUOTE="NaveedLife"]

Skyward Sword probably has the best chance I would say.

turtlethetaffer

why not? Shaping up to be pretty damn awesome, with a large number of gameplay hours and a second playthrough.

[QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

[QUOTE="lightleggy"] lol nolightleggy

why not? Shaping up to be pretty damn awesome, with a large number of gameplay hours and a second playthrough.

Um, maybe by the fan base... but we are talking about this website here.

I went with know, but the only games I could possibly expect to get a 10 from GS would be UC3, BF3, and Diablo III.

[QUOTE="lightleggy"][QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

why not? Shaping up to be pretty damn awesome, with a large number of gameplay hours and a second playthrough.

turtlethetaffer

Um, maybe by the fan base... but we are talking about this website here.

[QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

[QUOTE="lightleggy"] because every zelda has turned out to be a "guarented 10" since OoT was released. and when it gets released, people hate it. so you could pretty much say they all floplightleggy

Um, maybe by the fan base... but we are talking about this website here.

Um... I had no idea the franchise needed saving... pretty much every game in the series is great. (with a few exceptions. Zelda II is meh, as well as Phantom Hourglass, and Majora's Mask is phenominal.)

and come on, nintendo fanboys...SS wont be getting a 10...its the zelda cycle...zelda game gets announced, hype hits the roof, game is released and it turns out to be disliked by fans and then fans start saying "oh I remember the *insert previous zelda tittle* how great it was, much better than this *insert current zelda tittle* which is just utter crap, how could they screw up so badly?" then a new zelda gets announced, and the cycle repeats.lightleggy

[QUOTE="lightleggy"][QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

Um, maybe by the fan base... but we are talking about this website here.

turtlethetaffer

Um... I had no idea the franchise needed saving... pretty much every game in the series is great. (with a few exceptions. Zelda II is meh, as well as Phantom Hourglass, and Majora's Mask is phenominal.)

[QUOTE="turtlethetaffer"]

[QUOTE="lightleggy"] im talking about the website indeed, the users create the hype, every zelda game gets hyped as 10 (except for the handheld ones) and none of them achieves that score, so past OoT every zelda has flopped. you cant deny that it has been happening with every zelda game since OoT, its always "OH THIS ZELDA GAME WILL DEFINITLY SAVE THE FRANCHISE! YEAH ITS DEFINITLY A 10!"lightleggy

Um... I had no idea the franchise needed saving... pretty much every game in the series is great. (with a few exceptions. Zelda II is meh, as well as Phantom Hourglass, and Majora's Mask is phenominal.)

Maybe you need to check the plot? There are several different aspects of it from ALttP, the greatest of which is Midna. The game wasn't really recycled crap.

I calling it, Forza Motorsport 4. Quote me if it gets below a 10 so i could accept my ownage;)

it's so late in the gen it's almost impossible for there expectations to be met

Skyward might do it tho

I calling it, Forza Motorsport 4. Quote me if it gets below a 10 so i could accept my ownage;)

Dark_man123

Forza 4 does look great as well, but I doubt it'll get a 10. I'm personally suspecting 9.5, with the Bad being "No tutorial for Auto Vista Mode"

I'm gonna laugh when it does though.

Much like Beast mode.

well uc3 will be better than gears 3, and gears 3 got a 9.5, so you do the math SpeedsterCards

well uc3 will be better than gears 3, and gears 3 got a 9.5, so you do the math SpeedsterCards

first 9.6 in years confirmed? :o

[QUOTE="SpeedsterCards"]well uc3 will be better than gears 3, and gears 3 got a 9.5, so you do the math eboyishere

9.6? :o

[QUOTE="eboyishere"]

[QUOTE="SpeedsterCards"]well uc3 will be better than gears 3, and gears 3 got a 9.5, so you do the math SpeedsterCards

9.6? :o

How do you know it will be 10 material?

[QUOTE="SpeedsterCards"]well uc3 will be better than gears 3, and gears 3 got a 9.5, so you do the math Mr_Positive

[QUOTE="Mr_Positive"][QUOTE="SpeedsterCards"]well uc3 will be better than gears 3, and gears 3 got a 9.5, so you do the math SpeedsterCards

[QUOTE="SpeedsterCards"][QUOTE="eboyishere"]

9.6? :o

turtlethetaffer

How do you know it will be 10 material?

[QUOTE="SpeedsterCards"][QUOTE="Mr_Positive"]it doesn't take a genius to know that uc3 will have a better story, graphics, and delivery than gears 3. Mr_Positive

I don't see anything promising enough to get a 10.

[QUOTE="Mr_Positive"][QUOTE="SpeedsterCards"]SpeedsterCards

[QUOTE="Mr_Positive"][QUOTE="SpeedsterCards"]no i haven't, but i can make a good guess based on the developers past games and current videos showing gameplaySpeedsterCards