[QUOTE="RyanShazam"][QUOTE="Im_single"] No, not at all, say in 1998, games like Starcraft, HL, MGS, OOT Baldur's Gate, RE2 all released, while all of them amazing games, only one can win GOTY, the others can't. Demon's Souls won GOTY on GS, while HL didn't, does that make Demon's Souls better than HL? Not a chance.Im_single
So Demon's Souls can't be classified as one of the best games ever because you think Half Life is a better game? The way i look at it is we have have opinions then we have professional reviewers opinions... Since we don't have factual evidence as to which games are considered better than others, critics reviews are the closest thing to facts we have to back up claims. Besides who said HL isn't one of the best games ever? Im just saying if a game wins GOTY it has its own spot in the Best Game Ever Category.
BTW I think Demon's Souls is a way better game than the Half Life series
I can't always agree with critics, while their opinions are nice, it's just hard to take them seriously sometimes, not to mention GOTY doesn't qualify a game as anything but the best game released that year, which was my point, I don't see any logic in saying that if a game wins GOTY it qualifies it as one of the best ever, that's me putting it nicely.Well i guess we don't agree with each other... typical argument lol
Log in to comment