Looks like the 360 won this FALL

[QUOTE="BPoole96"]

So now we are going by who wins seasons and months? Are we eventually going to get down to minutes and hours? "OMG! PS3 has been winning for the past 6 hours!"

MizFitAwesome

Last time I chrcked cows were trying to weigh the whole year based on September sales...

I know. That wasn't necessary aimed only at Lems. Both are guilty of it

Why is everyone making such a big ordeal about this expansion. Its not a game. I would rate the KZ2 map pack as a 10, does that make it another AAAE??

So lemmings are claiming victory by arbitrarily picking the part of the year they did slightly better in?

[QUOTE="BPoole96"]

So now we are going by who wins seasons and months? Are we eventually going to get down to minutes and hours? "OMG! PS3 has been winning for the past 6 hours!"

MizFitAwesome

Last time I chrcked cows were trying to weigh the whole year based on September sales...

No they aren't.

every one seams to be forgetting the great yr wii is having ,

from start to finish

we had

dead rising ctyd

house of the dead overkill

dead space extraction

metroid prime trillogy

wii sports resort

wii fit plus-for those intrested me im not in particular intristed in it

new super mario bros-coming

resident evil 1

re 0 -dec 1st 09

nfs nitro so ya um

what a nice day i think wii has won this entire year overall the ps3 did a maraculous job against the 360 360 didnt have much , forza 3 is pretty much like forza2 no changes besides the dash view which pgr already had

mariokart64fan

Why is that lineup better than the higher rated PS3 and 360 lineups?

So lemmings are claiming victory by arbitrarily picking the part of the year they did slightly better in?

hakanakumono

Oh yeah the 360 won alright, it had the most returned systems due to hardware failure this past month and every month prior.

Congratulations you have a complete failure on your hands.

Man, i can't believe these 360 fanboys, boasting about various game sales when the console there played on doesn't last long enough to get through these games.

so we are going to disregard the rest of the year because the ps3 had 2 AAA games (infamous and killzone 2)?

yea lets try to paint a bigger picture here

Oh yeah the 360 won alright, it had the most returned systems due to hardware failure this past month and every month prior.

Congratulations you have a complete failure on your hands.

Man, i can't believe these 360 fanboys, boasting about various game sales when the console there played on doesn't last long enough to get through these games.

Oh yeah the 360 won alright, it had the most returned systems due to hardware failure this past month and every month prior.

Congratulations you have a complete failure on your hands.

Man, i can't believe these 360 fanboys, boasting about various game sales when the console there played on doesn't last long enough to get through these games.

Oh yeah the 360 won alright, it had the most returned systems due to hardware failure this past month and every month prior.

Congratulations you have a complete failure on your hands.

Man, i can't believe these 360 fanboys, boasting about various game sales when the console there played on doesn't last long enough to get through these games.

[QUOTE="SpiritOfFire117"][QUOTE="Knight-of-NINE"]

Oh yeah the 360 won alright, it had the most returned systems due to hardware failure this past month and every month prior.

Congratulations you have a complete failure on your hands.

Man, i can't believe these 360 fanboys, boasting about various game sales when the console there played on doesn't last long enough to get through these games.

Knight-of-NINE

[QUOTE="Knight-of-NINE"][QUOTE="SpiritOfFire117"] I hadn't had another RROD in a year so yes it's lasted me atleast.mitu123

Hmm. That's actually kind of true, afterall, 3 AAAE > 2 AAAE and 1 AAE.Stevo_the_gamer

So lemmings are claiming victory by arbitrarily picking the part of the year they did slightly better in?

hakanakumono

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]

[QUOTE="SolidTy"]

Yeah, but you are saying this DLC is going to count, when in reality, when it's released on Disc is when it will count.Who's to say what a AAA score means for DLC? Just comparing it to full retail games is silly, like when Braid was compared to Super Mario Galaxy.

SolidTy

Comparing to full retail games is silly? Gamespot sure doesn't think so.

• "This superb downloadable episode for GTAIV would be easy to recommend even if it were a full retail product selling for three times its actual price."

• "More new content than many full-priced games. "

Like I didn't see Bioshockownz throwing those around earlier.

Yeah, I read the review.

Someone better tell Rockstar, they obviously have a $60 game here, and they are screwing this whole thing up.

Heck, it was probably reviewed on full retail standards, I'm sure.

I guess we figured out the deal though, due to Gamespot's Reviewer. Thank goodness.

Maybe if this is handled right, when Episodes is released, and if that get's reviewed, we can just keep getting scores over and over. It's going to be wonderful.

[QUOTE="mitu123"]

[QUOTE="Knight-of-NINE"] I don't know how these 360 boys do it.h575309

They should. I know *one* person who hasn't had theirs red ring yet, but it's less than a year old.

Geez, I mean really, the 360 went for what 1 1/2 years with only 1 AAAe, and now yall can't be happy with the 2 you got this month and now trying to add expansions as ownage. I mean really, Geez I loved Mgs4 but I beat that over a year ago right with gta4, and bogt by no means stands up to a full released game, heck is it released already, I don't recall seeing no one lining up to buy it like they did for gta4 when it was released lol. This place is really getting to be a little pathetic really.

P.S. I don't recall us cows being this pathitic back on 06 and 07, we just wanted people to realise that we had games and good games to play back then.

Ratings don't tell the whole story, a 9.5 is not always a 9.5, at least in not terms of what you get out of a game.

Nobody in their right mind, for example,will argue that Forza 3 is just as good as Uncharted 2, even though both got the same score at GS.

So you can tally up all the AAAE you want, but it doesn't mean squat when it comes time to play the game.

Ratings don't tell the whole story, a 9.5 is not always a 9.5, at least in not terms of what you get out of a game.

Nobody in their right mind, for example,will argue that Forza 3 is just as good as Uncharted 2, even though both got the same score at GS.

So you can tally up all the AAAE you want, but it doesn't mean squat when it comes time to play the game.

p2250

[QUOTE="p2250"]

Ratings don't tell the whole story, a 9.5 is not always a 9.5, at least in not terms of what you get out of a game.

Nobody in their right mind, for example,will argue that Forza 3 is just as good as Uncharted 2, even though both got the same score at GS.

So you can tally up all the AAAE you want, but it doesn't mean squat when it comes time to play the game.

Hahadouken

Ya, replies from the fringe racing car sim crowd

ZOOM ZOOM

suddenly when its in your lemming favor it's ok, lets count comment crash on ps3 while were at it too. How about killzone 2 map packs or fallout 3 expansions,... dlc doesn't count... stop graspig for straws. and your no hermit, a hermit or you would be siding strictly with pc not 360... 360 == lemming.Midnightshade29

That is DLC, and the Fallout 3 content are add-ons, both of which don't hold a candle to "expansions" like Shivering Isles, Twilight of the Arnor, and BoGT. Where am I showing that I'm not siding by PC? What the hell? lol

Ballad of Gay Tony doesn't count because it's DLC. Can you buy it on a disk? It's in Episodes of Liberty City, but that hasn't been reviewed.aaronmullan

It counts because it's an expansion.

I hadn't had another RROD in a year so yes it's lasted me atleast.SpiritOfFire117

My launch Xbox 360 still works perfectly. w00t! But knock on wood there, mate!

I never understood this. If DLC can be counted, why can't XBL/PSN games count? They are released via the same way... by download...zero_snake99

Demons Souls, Uncharted 2, and Ratchet Clank, all released only this month say Hi.It_Is_Wut_It_Is

Interesting startegy MS is adopting, starving its consumer base for 10 months in order to make whatever dlc scrap they release seem like prime stake, it even works on reviewers - we all played halo3 in 2007

we all played gta 4 in 2008

the only game wiht even a hint of fortitude is forza 3.daaamn what a game

[QUOTE="It_Is_Wut_It_Is"]Demons Souls, Uncharted 2, and Ratchet Clank, all released only this month say Hi.clone01

Ratings don't tell the whole story, a 9.5 is not always a 9.5, at least in not terms of what you get out of a game.

Nobody in their right mind, for example,will argue that Forza 3 is just as good as Uncharted 2, even though both got the same score at GS.

So you can tally up all the AAAE you want, but it doesn't mean squat when it comes time to play the game.

The 360 made a good comeback.Racer850

Nice try lems, but DLC doesn't count. if ratchet was priced at the same price it would have been AAA too. Try again.

How did it win this fall, Uncharted 2? Ratchet? Demon Souls? Stop grasping at straws.FIipMode

According to the TC:

9.5 + 9.5 + 9.0>9.5 + 9.0 + 8.5