Madden on the Wii is better then the PS3 or 360 versions

[QUOTE="too_much_eslim"][QUOTE="Firelore29"]

[QUOTE="too_much_eslim"][QUOTE="too_much_eslim"]whats this call your shot mode? How is it any different from hot routes.Firelore29

http://wii.ign.com/articles/897/897601p1.html

Ok seriously man I can understand that you are going to buy the 360 or PS3 version and your trying to defend your purchase but honestly... look at that. "Nothing special or innovative"? ....wow...

[QUOTE="Firelore29"]

Ok seriously man I can understand that you are going to buy the 360 or PS3 version and your trying to defend your purchase but honestly... look at that. "Nothing special or innovative"? ....wow...

too_much_eslim

Ok I'm done posting to you because you simply can't accept the fact that your wrong. I've played every Madden in years and I know all about hot routes. This is nothing like hot routes. Read the IGN review Bozon even said that he played an entire game changing virtually every play as he went.

Ok seriously man I can understand that you are going to buy the 360 or PS3 version and your trying to defend your purchase but honestly... look at that. "Nothing special or innovative"? ....wow...

Firelore29

Much like how you are defending your purchase to us by proclaiming the Wii version better without having even played it, based entirely on the opinion of a biased journalist at IGN?

[QUOTE="Firelore29"]

Ok seriously man I can understand that you are going to buy the 360 or PS3 version and your trying to defend your purchase but honestly... look at that. "Nothing special or innovative"? ....wow...

CronoSquall

Much like how you are defending your purchase to us by proclaiming the Wii version better without having even played it, based entirely on the opinion of a biased journalist at IGN?

Touche. I just said that to get posts. ;) As it stands hardly anyone realizes that this new Wii version offers something completely different as this thread proves.

[QUOTE="too_much_eslim"][QUOTE="Firelore29"]

Ok seriously man I can understand that you are going to buy the 360 or PS3 version and your trying to defend your purchase but honestly... look at that. "Nothing special or innovative"? ....wow...

Firelore29

Ok I'm done posting to you because you simply can't accept the fact that your wrong. I've played every Madden in years and I know all about hot routes. This is nothing like hot routes. Read the IGN review Bozon even said that he played an entire game changing virtually every play as he went.

Offering something "different" doesn't automatically make it worthwhile or noteworthy. Different does not equate to better, and neither does "innovative". (innovation is more commonplace than most people here make it out to be)CronoSquall

I would agree that different does not always equte to better and neither does innovative. However when reports come back saying that new and innovative does add a lot to the gameplay experience then yes it makes it better.

[QUOTE="CronoSquall"]Offering something "different" doesn't automatically make it worthwhile or noteworthy. Different does not equate to better, and neither does "innovative". (innovation is more commonplace than most people here make it out to be)Firelore29

I would agree that different does not always equte to better and neither does innovative. However when reports come back saying that new and innovative does add a lot to the gameplay experience then yes it makes it better.

[QUOTE="Zhengi"]

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]What? Wii's Madden 08 wasn't any better - what makes you think 09 would be any different? :roll:Stevo_the_gamer

Well, Madden 07 Wii was the best version that year, so I don't see how your argument is valid at all.

so its official...PC gamers are no longer allowed to claim the PC version is superior when it comes out months later.

Nintendo Power gave Madden 09' a 9. Before people scream "BIAS!", they gave 07' an 8.5 and 08' an 8.

Looks like this will be the best on yet.

[QUOTE="AlphaGamer469"] Has anyone seen the coverart for the Wii version vs the 360/PS3 versions? On the PS3/360 Favre is doing an action pose like throwing a pass. On the Wii cover, he looks puzzled, almost like he has to use the bathroom. Sorry, but the Wii will be by far the more casualized version. Most of the enhancements will be on the 360/PS3 versions. I'm willing to bet the PS3/360 versions will have an imediate roster update...bobbetybob

Never judge a game by it's cover?

Nintendo Power gave Madden 09' a 9. Before people scream "BIAS!", they gave 07' an 8.5 and 08' an 8.

Looks like this will be the best on yet.

Nickman71

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"][QUOTE="Zhengi"]

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]What? Wii's Madden 08 wasn't any better - what makes you think 09 would be any different? :roll:clone01

Well, Madden 07 Wii was the best version that year, so I don't see how your argument is valid at all.

so its official...PC gamers are no longer allowed to claim the PC version is superior when it comes out months later.

wow how in the **** did PC get in the argument.

so its official ... console fanboys bash the pc for no reason

its porbabaly the same on every consoleNSR34GTR

[QUOTE="clone01"][QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"][QUOTE="Zhengi"]

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]What? Wii's Madden 08 wasn't any better - what makes you think 09 would be any different? :roll:jaisimar_chelse

Well, Madden 07 Wii was the best version that year, so I don't see how your argument is valid at all.

so its official...PC gamers are no longer allowed to claim the PC version is superior when it comes out months later.

wow how in the **** did PC get in the argument.

so its official ... console fanboys bash the pc for no reason

i'm just messing around...i was just arguing with the above post that suggested that because something comes out a little later, its not good.

Yes, and don't games that come out latter on another system (ex. Halo on PC) usually get a lower score?

So Wii Madden 07 must have been really good.

Nickman71

And Mass Effect came out later and received a higher score (Though one could argue the Xbox 360 review was botched in the first place).

so its official...PC gamers are no longer allowed to claim the PC version is superior when it comes out months later.

clone01

Does the PC have anything to do with this, laddy? No. What a pathetic flamebait.

Funny, the entire defense of the Wii as a system revolves around its sales success. Good to know people are finally beginning to realize commercial success doesn't equal quality.

subrosian

No, The Wii version was the 3rd best selling version, the First and Second place were taken by the 360 and DS respectively.

There is no feature that the Wii is capable of adding that other systems are not - however the 360 & PS3 version can have sound (discrete surround)

subrosian

How does surround sound affect gameplay in a sports game? Please elaborate, you DO know the Wii is capable of displaying sound right? lol.

graphics (720p+)

subrosian

I'll give you the graphics argument.

, online (real infrastructure vs. friends codes), multiplayer (greater system power and online capabilities),

subrosian

Third party and, in some cases, first party developers can have their own online system and looking back on previous versions, EA hosts their own games(MOH: H2, Madden 07/08, etc) and they turn out to be the exact same thing on all other versions, without friend codes that is. And What does "system power" have to do with multiplayer? We all know the TG-16 had up to 5 players on a single system which means, by your logic, that it's more powerful than a 360 and a Ps3 because it has more "system power" for multiplayer.

add-on content (hard drives vs memory cards, and again online infrastructure) and features (system power) that the Wii version is incapable of.

subrosian

Again, Nintendo isn't forcing developers to take out downloadable content in the Wii version of their games, all they have to do it code the game to save on SD cards, like Guitar Hero World Tour and Rock Band 2 will, and yes I'm talking about the Wii version. And "memory cards", as you call them can go up to 32 GB each nowadays, SD's write much faster than HD's and are non-volatile, which means there aren't moving parts that can wear down or easily break on against shock. So hard drives < "memory cards".

I ask AGAIN, what kind of features the 360 adn PS3 version will have that cannot be done on the Wii because of "system power".

Does the PC have anything to do with this, laddy? No. What a pathetic flamebait.

Stevo_the_gamer

not flamebait at all, just making a point. is bioshock worse because it came out on PS3 later? no.

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]

Does the PC have anything to do with this, laddy? No. What a pathetic flamebait.

clone01

not flamebait at all, just making a point. is bioshock worse because it came out on PS3 later? no.

[QUOTE="clone01"]

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]

Does the PC have anything to do with this, laddy? No. What a pathetic flamebait.

Stevo_the_gamer

not flamebait at all, just making a point. is bioshock worse because it came out on PS3 later? no.

in your original quote you implied it. a previous poster had mentioned that Madden '07 was the best version. you responded by shutting the comment down, stating that it had come out after the other console iterations. its certainly easy to infer that response as an assault on the Wii version.

in your original quote you implied it. a previous poster had mentioned that Madden '07 was the best version. you responded by shutting the comment down, stating that it had come out after the other console iterations. its certainly easy to infer that response as an assault on the Wii version.

clone01

[QUOTE="clone01"]

in your original quote you implied it. a previous poster had mentioned that Madden '07 was the best version. you responded by shutting the comment down, stating that it had come out after the other console iterations. its certainly easy to infer that response as an assault on the Wii version.

Stevo_the_gamer

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"][QUOTE="Zhengi"]

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"]What? Wii's Madden 08 wasn't any better - what makes you think 09 would be any different? :roll:clone01

Well, Madden 07 Wii was the best version that year, so I don't see how your argument is valid at all.

so the italicized "after" doesn't denote a demeaning response? um...okay. perhaps in the future, you might want to write something along the lines of "The Wii version scored better because it was released after the previous iterations, etc."

so the italicized "after" doesn't denote a demeaning response? um...okay. perhaps in the future, you might want to write something along the lines of "The Wii version scored better because it was released after the previous iterations, etc."

clone01

[QUOTE="clone01"]

so the italicized "after" doesn't denote a demeaning response? um...okay. perhaps in the future, you might want to write something along the lines of "The Wii version scored better because it was released after the previous iterations, etc."

Stevo_the_gamer

keep telling yourself that...your posting history more than shows your hatred for all things Wii. you're not fooling anyone.