Metacritic 2010 analysis - PS3 comes out top console.

BTW, where are the hermits :) Didn't they have a gazillion exclusives in 2010 ... :)

KiZZo1

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"]

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

you mean the graph that I just mathematically proved that the difference ammounts to ONE game IF you round the numbers up in favour of the Ps3?

ohthemanatee

But there is still a difference in good games and the ps3 comes out on top

a difference that doesn't even ammount to half a game

you are claiming ownage over that? over 1 multiplat?

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"]MCs graph says different though

TintedEyes

the graph doesn't state the exact numbers :|

it is on par with what I said

in what?

you mean the graph that I just mathematically proved that the difference ammounts to ONE game IF you round the numbers up in favour of the Ps3?

ohthemanatee

If you put the cursor over the graph you get values. PS3 has 102 good games. 360 has 101 good games.

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"]

But there is still a difference in good games and the ps3 comes out on top

TintedEyes

a difference that doesn't even ammount to half a game

you are claiming ownage over that? over 1 multiplat?

the news that 360 wins? that seems out of character for you

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

you mean the graph that I just mathematically proved that the difference ammounts to ONE game IF you round the numbers up in favour of the Ps3?

glez13

If you put the cursor over the graph you get values. PS3 has 102 good games. 360 has 101 good games.

so i'm right then, there is a difference of exactly one multiplat

the problem is that it's offset by a difference of several exclusives in favour of the 360

It's not only the cows who said/say that Exclusives > Library. Lemmings were asserting the opposite. So the irony does not apply to one side only ...

KiZZo1

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"][QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

a difference that doesn't even ammount to half a game

you are claiming ownage over that? over 1 multiplat?

ohthemanatee

the news that 360 wins? that seems out of character for you

[QUOTE="KiZZo1"]

It's not only the cows who said/say that Exclusives > Library. Lemmings were asserting the opposite. So the irony does not apply to one side only ...

TintedEyes

I wouldn't know, I wasn't here the last year

BTW, where are the hermits :) Didn't they have a gazillion exclusives in 2010 ... :)

KiZZo1

and they got beaten by the wii :P

this thread should be a everyone vs everyone thing.

So, in what way was data/results twisted and manipulated this time? It's a trend for these certain threads by a certain user.

So, in what way was data/results twisted and manipulated this time? It's a trend for these certain threads by a certain user.

Verge_6

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"] Not claiming ownage, just posting the newsTintedEyes

the news that 360 wins? that seems out of character for you

no, it doesn't, it has one more good game

I don't know where you got the "gameS" idea from

[QUOTE="glez13"]

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

you mean the graph that I just mathematically proved that the difference ammounts to ONE game IF you round the numbers up in favour of the Ps3?

ohthemanatee

If you put the cursor over the graph you get values. PS3 has 102 good games. 360 has 101 good games.

so i'm right then, there is a difference of exactly one multiplat

the problem is that it's offset by a difference of several exclusives in favour of the 360

Apparently the PS3 has two multiplats that the 360 doesn't have and the 360 has one more exclusive so obviously you still have one extra game for PS3 in a direct comparison.

So, in what way was data/results twisted and manipulated this time? It's a trend for these certain threads by a certain user.

Verge_6

[QUOTE="heretrix"]

This thread is a backfire reaching epic proportions. :lol:

TintedEyes

But it gets better, you refuse to admit that you owned yourself. but whatever. It's entertaining. :)

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"][QUOTE="heretrix"]

This thread is a backfire reaching epic proportions. :lol:

heretrix

But it gets better, you refuse to admit that you owned yourself. but whatever. It's entertaining. :)

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

[QUOTE="glez13"]

If you put the cursor over the graph you get values. PS3 has 102 good games. 360 has 101 good games.

glez13

so i'm right then, there is a difference of exactly one multiplat

the problem is that it's offset by a difference of several exclusives in favour of the 360

Apparently the PS3 has two multiplats that the 360 doesn't have and the 360 has one more exclusive so obviously you still have one extra game for PS3 in a direct comparison.

except that never mattered when dicussing the 360, it is the console with most games due to it's many 360/PC multiplats, but these are imediatly excluded on system wars

[QUOTE="heretrix"]

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"] what? how?TintedEyes

But it gets better, you refuse to admit that you owned yourself. but whatever. It's entertaining. :)

by what ammount?

BTW, where are the hermits :) Didn't they have a gazillion exclusives in 2010 ... :)

KiZZo1

Bow down before the true exclusives king:

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"][QUOTE="Verge_6"]

So, in what way was data/results twisted and manipulated this time? It's a trend for these certain threads by a certain user.

KiZZo1

No , 2 more multiplats for PS3, one more exclusive for 360 ...

exactly, it's just a shame that multiplats never mattered before on system wars, so why we are even having this conversation is a bit strange

[QUOTE="glez13"]

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

so i'm right then, there is a difference of exactly one multiplat

the problem is that it's offset by a difference of several exclusives in favour of the 360

ohthemanatee

Apparently the PS3 has two multiplats that the 360 doesn't have and the 360 has one more exclusive so obviously you still have one extra game for PS3 in a direct comparison.

except that never mattered when dicussing the 360, it is the console with most games due to it's many 360/PC multiplats, but these are imediatly excluded on system wars

So? That is a MC graph and those most be included there and simply PS3 had one more. I don't see what is so hard to understand here. Also that is just quantity. What does the quality analysis say? Does the PS3 also win there or what?

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

[QUOTE="glez13"]

Apparently the PS3 has two multiplats that the 360 doesn't have and the 360 has one more exclusive so obviously you still have one extra game for PS3 in a direct comparison.

glez13

except that never mattered when dicussing the 360, it is the console with most games due to it's many 360/PC multiplats, but these are imediatly excluded on system wars

So? That is a MC graph and those most be included there and simply PS3 had one more. I don't see what is so hard to understand here. Also that is just quantity. What does the quality analysis say? Does the PS3 also win there or what?

yes, but this is system wars, if he wants to post an MC graph by MC rules i'm sure he can just use the MC forums or the general chat

P.S. the problem for "quality" is that it's meanigless, there is a difference of 5% in MC's numbers in quality but in reality it only ammounts to two games (multiplats I might add) versus one exclusive

so... yeah, not that hard to follow

[QUOTE="KiZZo1"]

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]the PS3 beat the 360 by 1 multiplat the 360 beats the PS3 by several exclusives result: The PS3 wins lolTintedEyes

No , 2 more multiplats for PS3, one more exclusive for 360 ...

multiplats don't count on system wars, sorry :)

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"][QUOTE="KiZZo1"]

No , 2 more multiplats for PS3, one more exclusive for 360 ...

ohthemanatee

multiplats don't count on system wars, sorry :)

With Kinect, 360's chart will start looking like the Wii every year more and more.kuraimen

yes, but this is system wars, if he wants to post an MC graph by MC rules i'm sure he can just use the MC forums or the general chat

P.S. the problem for "quality" is that it's meanigless, there is a difference of 5% in MC's numbers in quality but in reality it only ammounts to two games (multiplats I might add) versus one exclusive That is not quality. That is quantity of quality games. To really see quality we need and average metascore of only good games. For all we know the PS3 has more games but all could be 75 or near it, while the Wii that has the less could have most games scoring like 85 or around it, just to say something.

so... yeah, not that hard to follow

ohthemanatee

Nah, the anarchy vote let's any one use any source as long as it makes sense.

Yeah. I don't see how to find a way to see quality properly with those stats. The average one seems to be of the whole library, so the mixed and bad games drag the good ones with them. An average of only the good titles would be helpful, but there seems to be none.

Nah, the anarchy vote let's any one use any source as long as it makes sense.glez13

That chart says the ps3 had slightly less exclusives released than the 360, but the ps3 had slightly more games? WTF is going here?

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"] which amounts to one more good game for the ps3, it's right on there,chart, don't know why there is so much denialTintedEyes

multiplats don't count on system wars, sorry :)

Caseywegner, many many many times

and if you want to go by MC's rules then post this on the MC forums

truth of the matter is, going by MC, the 360 wins because it had more exclusives

That chart says the ps3 had slightly less exclusives released than the 360, but the ps3 had slightly more games? WTF is going here?

Pug-Nasty

PS3 has one less exclusive but two more multiplats according to that. I'm also dubious of these PS3 multiplats, but I'm also dubious of those 360 exclusives. These numbers go against my preconceptions.

Quite the entertaining thread. I sometimes think the TC enjoys looking and MC and SW numbers more than actually playing games.

[QUOTE="glez13"]

[QUOTE="Pug-Nasty"]

That chart says the ps3 had slightly less exclusives released than the 360, but the ps3 had slightly more games? WTF is going here?

KiZZo1

PS3 has one less exclusive but two more multiplats according to that. I'm also dubious of these PS3 multiplats, but I'm also dubious of those 360 exclusives. These numbers go against my preconceptions.

Yeah, I'm surprised that PS3 has more multiplats than 360, but keep in mind that those are the good ones - meaning score above 75% (I think) ... Maybe 360 still has more if we count all games ...

Oh, they're not counting every game released? Makes more sense then. You don't usually see PS3/PC multiplats that aren't also on the 360, so I wasn't seeing how those numebrs add up.

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"][QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

multiplats don't count on system wars, sorry :)

ohthemanatee

Caseywegner, many many many times

and if you want to go by MC's rules then post this on the MC forums

truth of the matter is, going by MC, the 360 wins because it had more exclusives

[QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"] Who said that? And this isn't even SW this is MCTintedEyes

Caseywegner, many many many times

and if you want to go by MC's rules then post this on the MC forums

truth of the matter is, going by MC, the 360 wins because it had more exclusives

A) I don't care if you don't see a rule, have any questions? PM casey, he's the lord of the mods on system wars for a reason

B) 360 wins in gametrailers, IGN, G4 and most importantly: Gamespot, if you want to take Metracritic's word as god, then go to Metacritic's forums

C) Metacritic is not fact

D) You can keep calling a cat a dog, but in the end your thread was an epic backfire

That purple thing says the ps3 loses to the 360 and the blue thing says ps3 won lol, 360 has better exclusives like that graph stated thread backfire :lol:.johny300

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"][QUOTE="ohthemanatee"]

Caseywegner, many many many times

and if you want to go by MC's rules then post this on the MC forums

truth of the matter is, going by MC, the 360 wins because it had more exclusives

ohthemanatee

A) I don't care if you don't see a rule, have any questions? PM casey, he's the lord of the mods on system wars for a reason

B) 360 wins in gametrailers, IGN, G4 and most importantly: Gamespot, if you want to take Metracritic's word as god, then go to Metacritic's forums

C) Metacritic is not fact

D) You can keep calling a cat a dog, but in the end your thread was an epic backfire

[QUOTE="johny300"]That purple thing says the ps3 loses to the 360 and the blue thing says ps3 won lol, 360 has better exclusives like that graph stated thread backfire :lol:.TintedEyes

A) you mean 1 more good game

B) Exclusives are what matter on system wars remember? ;)

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"]

[QUOTE="waltefmoney"]

Sorry, it beat the PSP.

Half-Way

But as you can see meta is including everything in that chart

but its still surprising how wrong SW was.

Everyone was talking about how bad the xbox360 did when it comes to exclusives, yet it actually beat the ps3 o,o

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"][QUOTE="johny300"]That purple thing says the ps3 loses to the 360 and the blue thing says ps3 won lol, 360 has better exclusives like that graph stated thread backfire :lol:.ohthemanatee

A) you mean 1 more good game

B) Exclusives are what matter on system wars remember? ;)