@treelog187 said:
@rictshard:
Every numbered MGS title has been AAA status.
- MGS - 94
- MGS2 - 96
- MGS3 - 91 and rose to a 94 with Subsistence.
- MGS4 - 94
Every numbered MGS title has swept up multiple goty awards with the most recent getting both a perfect score and goty on this very site.
If you're basing your argument on Ground Zeroes, you might want to read those reviews instead of looking at just the scores. Reviewers thought the game was excellent, but nobody likes paying for a demo no matter how great it may be. The amount of content was the issue, something MGSV will have no shortage of.
It's foolish to make predictions about goty 2015 right now, but it's even more foolish to count MGSV out of the running when it's one of the most ambitious upcoming titles coming from a killer pedigree.
History is not on your side. The fact that this game plays better than every MGS and even Splinter Cell before it doesn't help you either.
Now dumber.
Not even sure how I didn't get this response in my inbox.
I based my GOTY predictions based on what games have been shown and what games have been hyped or received accolades so far. Regardless of weather you want to admit it or not, MGSV wasn't even one of the top five biggest games at E3 this past year.
As far as MGS GOTY history, lets take a look at that, and I'm not going to count Readers Choice Awards
MGS: Didn't win a single GOTY award, the majority of GOTY awards for 1998 went to Ocarina of Time
Sons of Liberty: Won one GOTY award from Game Informer. As opposed to Halo CE which won 5 GOTY awards, GTA3 which won 7 and Final Fantasy X that won 1
Snake Eater: Did not receive one GOTY award, as oppose to Halo 2 winning 4, Half Life 2 winning 10, GTA San Andreas winning 3, World of Warcraft winning 1 and Doom 3 winning 1
Guns of the Patriots: 3 GOTY Awards, one of them from Gamespot, 2 others from Gamezine, a site that I can't even access, and PAL Gaming Network which is defunct, but to be fair so are some other sites that reviewed Ocarina of Time so I'll give it a pass
3 GOTY awards as oppose to GTA4 which won 10, LBP that won 3, Fallout 3 that won 6, and Fable 2 that won 3.
So much for sweeping multiple GOTY awards as you stated. 2 MGS games didn't receive any, the other one's only receive one from a major publisher and were overshadowed by several other games. History isn't on my side? Apparently it's not on your side either.
Also, enough with the demo excuse. GZ had less content, it was also $30 as oppose to $60. Halo ODST had a 3-4 hour campaign and a multiplayer component that everyone already owned, $60 and 83 on Metacritic. That excuse doesn't fly.
Log in to comment