Naked Snake vs Solid SNake , who would win?

Top is Solid snake of course, and bottom is Nake snake. who do you think would win in a CQC fight? and both are at the same age. i know solid ends up killing big boss. but big boss was so old, it was not even a match for solid. so i am asking if both where the same age, who do you think would win.

i'm not sure about this, but in the NES metal gears this showdown occurs and solid snake wins.

and i'm pretty sure naked snake is big boss; i'm not sure though, don't know MGS3's story.

i'm not sure about this, but in the NES metal gears this showdown occurs and solid snake wins.

and i'm pretty sure naked snake is big boss; i'm not sure though, don't know MGS3's story.

krunkfu2

i'm not sure about this, but in the NES metal gears this showdown occurs and solid snake wins.

and i'm pretty sure naked snake is big boss; i'm not sure though, don't know MGS3's story.

krunkfu2

Let me confirm it by saying Big Boss is Naked Snake.

[QUOTE="krunkfu2"]

i'm not sure about this, but in the NES metal gears this showdown occurs and solid snake wins.

and i'm pretty sure naked snake is big boss; i'm not sure though, don't know MGS3's story.

hashimgillani1

Let me confirm it by saying Big Boss is Naked Snake.

and yes you do fight him in metal gear on the nes

though you dont kill him until metal gear 2. metal gear 2 (and maybe 1?) came with metal gear solid 3 subsistence

regardless, im sure you could just find both games online like i did. they were actually really good for two really old games

and to the tc, im going with solid snake. i mean....he does beat naked snake....

Difficult one.

You've got a perfect solider who is genetically supirior to all, and then you've got a clone of him, that only posseses his dominant genes - essentially you are only making that clone out of those genes, which makes it difficult to answer.

You then fall into the debate of Solid vs. Liquid, which is essentially Nurture vs. Nature. Is Solid Snake the best soldier ever simply because he was conditioned to be that? How does one go about saying that Naked Snake is the perfect soldier? Shouldn't Solidus be the perfect one? Considering he's a combinition of the best dominant and recessive genes of Big Boss.

Personally I think Naked Snake is the perfect soldier, however Solid Snake isthe perfect mercenery.

[QUOTE="krunkfu2"]

i'm not sure about this, but in the NES metal gears this showdown occurs and solid snake wins.

and i'm pretty sure naked snake is big boss; i'm not sure though, don't know MGS3's story.

robotech31

than yea, solid snake wins. he's cooler anyway.

Neither. Naked Raiden. Hes hot...

jk

Um this fight allready happened.

Solid Snake wins. THats why Big Boss is dead.

Does anyone actually know there were games about solid snake before metal gear solid.jg4xchamp

i did. ive beaten them both too :D

thats also where you first meet grey fox

Um this fight allready happened.

Solid Snake wins. THats why Big Boss is dead.

Does anyone actually know there were games about solid snake before metal gear solid.jg4xchamp

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"]Um this fight allready happened.

Solid Snake wins. THats why Big Boss is dead.

Does anyone actually know there were games about solid snake before metal gear solid.robotech31

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"]Um this fight allready happened.

Solid Snake wins. THats why Big Boss is dead.

Does anyone actually know there were games about solid snake before metal gear solid.REforever101

i did. ive beaten them both too :D

thats also where you first meet grey fox

well naked snake is naked, ans solid snake is solid. from this data, we can imply that naked snake is not solid because if he were to be solid, he would be called solid naked snake. so basically, naked snake is a puddle of cat vomit seeing as he is liquid and cant move, or think, or do anything, so solid snake wins.

Difficult one.

You've got a perfect solider who is genetically supirior to all, and then you've got a clone of him, that only posseses his dominant genes - essentially you are only making that clone out of those genes, which makes it difficult to answer.

You then fall into the debate of Solid vs. Liquid, which is essentially Nurture vs. Nature. Is Solid Snake the best soldier ever simply because he was conditioned to be that? How does one go about saying that Naked Snake is the perfect soldier? Shouldn't Solidus be the perfect one? Considering he's a combinition of the best dominant and recessive genes of Big Boss.

Personally I think Naked Snake is the perfect soldier, however Solid Snake isthe perfect mercenery.

elbow2k

well naked snake is naked, ans solid snake is solid. from this data, we can imply that naked snake is not solid because if he were to be solid, he would be called solid naked snake. so basically, naked snake is a puddle of cat vomit seeing as he is liquid and cant move, or think, or do anything, so solid snake wins.

Dopemonk736

[QUOTE="Dopemonk736"]

well naked snake is naked, ans solid snake is solid. from this data, we can imply that naked snake is not solid because if he were to be solid, he would be called solid naked snake. so basically, naked snake is a puddle of cat vomit seeing as he is liquid and cant move, or think, or do anything, so solid snake wins.

WeAreToast

Naked Snake gives me a solid snake. :D

I mean um....

i say liquid he just wont die lol CommanderTy

Naked Snake is much better then Solid Snake

The original will always be better that the copy.

Naked Snake.

Big Boss, best freakin' character in the MG series.

Naked Snake, obviously. If it weren't for him, there wouldn't even be a Solid Snake.

I was reading through all these posts thinking these people have played MGS4! Then I saw the dates on the posts......

If you played and beat MGS4, you would know which is better. Naked Snake is much better. Naked Snake is Liquid and Solid Snake put together. Naked has the best of both worlds. Nonstop-Madness

Naked Snake gives me a solid snake. :D

I mean um....

goblaa

:lol: now that was funny

solid has already killed him twice (once not by his own hand) so i'd say Solid

Solid is just cooler, and also doesn't anyone else hope the MGS movie gets going and makes a decent film? it could be done. esspecially with Christian Bale or Hugh Jackman as Solid Snake.

When I see "Naked" Snake I can't help but think of:

It's like I'm wearing nothing at all!Nothing at all!NOTHING AT ALL!

Difficult one.

You've got a perfect solider who is genetically supirior to all, and then you've got a clone of him, that only posseses his dominant genes - essentially you are only making that clone out of those genes, which makes it difficult to answer.

You then fall into the debate of Solid vs. Liquid, which is essentially Nurture vs. Nature. Is Solid Snake the best soldier ever simply because he was conditioned to be that? How does one go about saying that Naked Snake is the perfect soldier? Shouldn't Solidus be the perfect one? Considering he's a combinition of the best dominant and recessive genes of Big Boss.

Personally I think Naked Snake is the perfect soldier, however Solid Snake isthe perfect mercenery.

elbow2k

Actually, it was Solid Snake that possessed the recessive genes, Liquid possessed the dominant. Liquid was told that he was the inferior one, but was misinformed (listen to Ocelot's conversation with Solidus at the end of MGS1's credits).

solid has already killed him twice (once not by his own hand) so i'd say Solid

Solid is just cooler, and also doesn't anyone else hope the MGS movie gets going and makes a decent film? it could be done. esspecially with Christian Bale or Hugh Jackman as Solid Snake.

darth-pyschosis