NeoGAF gets WiiMusic early - heeeere we goooo.....................

I don't think it should. It's not a game so why rate it as a game?JLF1

So Wii Fit shouldn't have been rated either?

It doesn't matter what you think. It's playable as a game on a console, thus, it's going to be reviewed.

This just seems like a poor attempt at not wanting the game to be reviewed after seeing people with positive attitudes after playing.

If Wii Music DOES get a good score, the new fanboy argument will be that the "toy" never should have been reviewed to begin with.

[QUOTE="JLF1"]I don't think it should. It's not a game so why rate it as a game?AlexSays

So Wii Fit shouldn't have been rated either?

It doesn't matter what you think. It's playable as a game on a console, thus, it's going to be reviewed.

This just seems like a poor attempt at not wanting the game to be reviewed after seeing people with positive attitudes after playing.

If Wii Music DOES get a good score, the new fanboy argument will be that the "toy" never should have been reviewed to begin with.

1. Did you miss the part with "I" as in my opinion? I am well aware that my opinion doesn't mean anything and neither does yours.

2. Did you miss the part were I said that I don't care what it scores?

3. I expect the exact same reaction from the sheep if it scores bad.

[QUOTE="AlexSays"]

[QUOTE="JLF1"]I don't think it should. It's not a game so why rate it as a game?JLF1

So Wii Fit shouldn't have been rated either?

It doesn't matter what you think. It's playable as a game on a console, thus, it's going to be reviewed.

This just seems like a poor attempt at not wanting the game to be reviewed after seeing people with positive attitudes after playing.

If Wii Music DOES get a good score, the new fanboy argument will be that the "toy" never should have been reviewed to begin with.

1. Did you miss the part with "I" as in my opinion? I am well aware that my opinion doesn't mean anything and neither does yours.

2. Did you miss the part were I said that I don't care what it scores?

3. I expect the exact same reaction from the sheep if it scores bad.Not true. People need to be high if they were hyping this game or sarcastic

Not true. People need to be high if they were hyping this game or sarcastic

spectravoid

Alright, I see your point. Let me rephrase it.

I expect the exact same reaction from the very few people that hyped it if it scores bad.

1.) Did you miss the part with "I" as in my opinion? I am well aware that my opinion doesn't mean anything and neither does yours.

2. Did you miss the part were I said that I don't care what it scores?

3. I expect the exact same reaction from the sheep if it scores bad.

JLF1

1.) Obviously it is your opinion. I'm asking you to back up your opinion. You haven't done so.

2.) I don't care what it scores either. But we don't care for entirely different reasons.

3.) Here's the flaw in your argument. Sheep aren't saying the game will be good. All the other fanboys are saying the game will be bad. There's no "ownage" to be had when most Wii fanboys don't even care about the game.

You're right though, as in every fanboy will be screaming, "Wii hyped this!!!11 LOLZZZ!!11" if the game scores bad.

When that's not the case.

1. Obviously it is your opinion. I'm asking you to back up your opinion. You haven't done so.

2.) I don't care what it scores either. But we don't care for entirely different reasons.

3.) Here's the flaw in your argument. Sheep aren't saying the game will be good. All the other fanboys are saying the game will be bad. There's no "ownage" to be had when most Wii fanboys don't even care about the game.

You're right though, as in every fanboy will be screaming, "Wii hyped this!!!11 LOLZZZ!!11" if the game scores bad.

When that's not the case.

AlexSays

Wow i might actually buy the game, not just because the NeoGAF review but because it looks like it actualy might be fun at parties.

Does anyone how much it will cost? 50 dollars seems a bit too steep for this kind of game.

Wow i might actually buy the game, not just because the NeoGAF review but because it looks like it actualy might be fun at parties.

Does anyone how much it will cost? 50 dollars seems a bit too steep for this kind of game.

AzureEm

unless nintendo pays you to own it i dont think its worth it

Wow i might actually buy the game, not just because the NeoGAF review but because it looks like it actualy might be fun at parties.

Does anyone how much it will cost? 50 dollars seems a bit too steep for this kind of game.

AzureEm

Based on the Australian price, it will be $50 in the US.

[QUOTE="AzureEm"]

Wow i might actually buy the game, not just because the NeoGAF review but because it looks like it actualy might be fun at parties.

Does anyone how much it will cost? 50 dollars seems a bit too steep for this kind of game.

VendettaRed07

unless nintendo pays you to own it i dont think its worth it

You never know until you try =)

[QUOTE="AzureEm"]

Wow i might actually buy the game, not just because the NeoGAF review but because it looks like it actualy might be fun at parties.

Does anyone how much it will cost? 50 dollars seems a bit too steep for this kind of game.

Nintendo_Man

Based on the Australian price, it will be $50 in the US.

Aww darn =( Well rent for me at the start then.

Somehow I call fake.SpruceCaboose

LOL Its not

1- There are videos of him (with his name) spreading through the internets

2- He said how he got the game

3- Faking something like that (even impressions) will get you BANNED in GAF

4- Sp0rsk is an ex-GAF moderator and a very well known and "respected" poster there

5- GAF is not Gamespot/SW

So I'm NOT crazy for defending Wii Music... :oAlexSays

[QUOTE="SpruceCaboose"]Somehow I call fake.Fawlcon_Pawnch

LOL Its not

1- There are videos of him (with his name) spreading through the internets

2- He said how he got the game

3- Faking something like that (even impressions) will get you BANNED in GAF

4- Sp0rsk is an ex-GAF moderator and a very well known and "respected" poster there

5- GAF is not Gamespot/SW

don't care. definite pass for me.Dreams-Visions

At least keep an open mind...It looks like crap to me also but you never know until you try

If it gets good reviews I will at least give it a rent. If it gets bad reviews then I would understand the pass

Who though DDR would be such a good game until you played it. Or that a game is a kid's plastic guitar would be a good game

[QUOTE="Fawlcon_Pawnch"]

[QUOTE="SpruceCaboose"]Somehow I call fake.nintendo-4life

LOL Its not

1- There are videos of him (with his name) spreading through the internets

2- He said how he got the game

3- Faking something like that (even impressions) will get you BANNED in GAF

4- Sp0rsk is an ex-GAF moderator and a very well known and "respected" poster there

5- GAF is not Gamespot/SW

Its hard to get in and when your part of GAF know of the troll stuff goes there. You get kicked off in a heart beat. I know some who have been waiting over a month to get on the board.

[QUOTE="Dreams-Visions"]don't care. definite pass for me.HarlockJC

At least keep an open mind...It looks like crap to me also but you never know until you try

If it gets good reviews I will at least give it a rent. If it gets bad reviews then I would understand the pass

Who though DDR would be such a good game until you played it. Or that a game is a kid's plastic guitar would be a good game

[QUOTE="nintendo-4life"][QUOTE="Fawlcon_Pawnch"]

[QUOTE="SpruceCaboose"]Somehow I call fake.HarlockJC

LOL Its not

1- There are videos of him (with his name) spreading through the internets

2- He said how he got the game

3- Faking something like that (even impressions) will get you BANNED in GAF

4- Sp0rsk is an ex-GAF moderator and a very well known and "respected" poster there

5- GAF is not Gamespot/SW

Its hard to get in and when your part of GAF know of the troll stuff goes there. You get kicked off in a heart beat. I know some who have been waiting over a month to get on the board.

So it's like Facepunch Studios where it's nazistically stupid?

[QUOTE="nintendo-4life"][QUOTE="Fawlcon_Pawnch"]

[QUOTE="SpruceCaboose"]Somehow I call fake.HarlockJC

LOL Its not

1- There are videos of him (with his name) spreading through the internets

2- He said how he got the game

3- Faking something like that (even impressions) will get you BANNED in GAF

4- Sp0rsk is an ex-GAF moderator and a very well known and "respected" poster there

5- GAF is not Gamespot/SW

Its hard to get in and when your part of GAF know of the troll stuff goes there. You get kicked off in a heart beat. I know some who have been waiting over a month to get on the board.

i have been interested in GAF for a while, though i can't say it's as good as SW honestly :P

1- Competent Moderation keeps trolls out

2- No trolls means theres a more serious place to talk

3- More serious place attracts more serious and credible people

4- Credibility grows industry takes notice

5- Industry giants, developers, programers start posting there (David Jaffe,etc...)

6- Industry insiders from all over the world are members and bring info first-hand

7- BIG userbase makes industry respect it, their opinions actually have weight (Too Human scandal)

8- Strict selection also limits the amount of useless posters and idiots that register there

------

A quick example was the recent Marvel VS Capcom 2 on XBL/PSN announcement, it was them who discovered this first.

This happens all the time

So it's like Facepunch Studios where it's nazistically stupid?

insanejedi

I have no idea what your talking about. It's where most of the pros post. Do you remember that whole event with the guy that did Too Human posted a thread about the game saying how good it was.

That was a GAF

That is something you will never see here.

[QUOTE="nintendo-4life"]

1- Competent Moderation keeps trolls out

2- No trolls means theres a more serious place to talk

3- More serious place attracts more serious and credible people

4- Credibility grows industry takes notice

5- Industry giants, developers, programers start posting there (David Jaffe,etc...)

6- Industry insiders from all over the world are members and bring info first-hand

7- BIG userbase makes industry respect it, and their opinions actually have some weight

8- Strict selection also limits the amount of useless posters and idiots that register there

------

A quick example was the recent Marvel VS Capcom 2 on XBL/PSN announcement, it was them who discovered this first.

This happens all the time

Fawlcon_Pawnch

it took me 3 weeks to actually get accepted, then i just threw the account away (as in didn't use it at all).

i have been interested in GAF for a while, though i can't say it's as good as SW honestly :P

nintendo-4life

I would not want to start all over again.

I rather stay on a board where at least I am a little well know.

:shock: .... time to get that account working eh? ^_^nintendo-4life

Or...

You can give it to me :lol:

Its a nightmare to get in

[QUOTE="insanejedi"]

So it's like Facepunch Studios where it's nazistically stupid?

HarlockJC

I have no idea what your talking about. It's where most of the pros post. Do you remember that whole event with the guy that did Too Human posted a thread about the game saying how good it was.

That was a GAF

That is something you will never see here.

Dennis Dyack only posted in there because it was essentially free PR for the game. It was the biggest independent gaming fourm and is what probebly contributed the fact that the game actually sold. Bottem line: He posted there because it was the biggest, if System Wars was bigger than NeoGAF in terms of number of people using the fourms and people posting, he would have most likely posted it here.

There are leauges for posting? Where do I sit then? Amature? Minor Leauges? Is GAF the NHL of fourms? Wat?

There are leauges for posting? Where do I sit then? Amature? Minor Leauges? Is GAF the NHL of fourms? Wat?

insanejedi

What....I guess I am too tried to understand what your trying to say there

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"][QUOTE="insanejedi"]

So it's like Facepunch Studios where it's nazistically stupid?

insanejedi

I have no idea what your talking about. It's where most of the pros post. Do you remember that whole event with the guy that did Too Human posted a thread about the game saying how good it was.

That was a GAF

That is something you will never see here.

Dennis Dyack only posted in there because it was essentially free PR for the game. It was the biggest independent gaming fourm and is what probebly contributed the fact that the game actually sold. Bottem line: He posted there because it was the biggest, if System Wars was bigger than NeoGAF in terms of number of people using the fourms and people posting, he would have most likely posted it here.

There are leauges for posting? Where do I sit then? Amature? Minor Leauges? Is GAF the NHL of fourms? Wat?

It has nothing to do with the number of members, its all about credibility.

Developers and industry hot shots in SW? :lol::lol:

[QUOTE="insanejedi"]

There are leauges for posting? Where do I sit then? Amature? Minor Leauges? Is GAF the NHL of fourms? Wat?

HarlockJC

What....I guess I am too tried to understand what your trying to say there

If there Pro's what does that make us? How can you be a pro in posting?

[QUOTE="insanejedi"][QUOTE="HarlockJC"][QUOTE="insanejedi"]

So it's like Facepunch Studios where it's nazistically stupid?

Fawlcon_Pawnch

I have no idea what your talking about. It's where most of the pros post. Do you remember that whole event with the guy that did Too Human posted a thread about the game saying how good it was.

That was a GAF

That is something you will never see here.

Dennis Dyack only posted in there because it was essentially free PR for the game. It was the biggest independent gaming fourm and is what probebly contributed the fact that the game actually sold. Bottem line: He posted there because it was the biggest, if System Wars was bigger than NeoGAF in terms of number of people using the fourms and people posting, he would have most likely posted it here.

There are leauges for posting? Where do I sit then? Amature? Minor Leauges? Is GAF the NHL of fourms? Wat?

It has nothing to do with the number of members, its all about credibility.

Developers and industry hot shots in SW? :lol::lol:

If you actually rembered anything, Developers actually posted in Gamespot, in particular a Prey developer posted to complain about the score it recived.There are actually many other examples to that.

[QUOTE="Fawlcon_Pawnch"][QUOTE="insanejedi"][QUOTE="HarlockJC"][QUOTE="insanejedi"]

So it's like Facepunch Studios where it's nazistically stupid?

insanejedi

I have no idea what your talking about. It's where most of the pros post. Do you remember that whole event with the guy that did Too Human posted a thread about the game saying how good it was.

That was a GAF

That is something you will never see here.

Dennis Dyack only posted in there because it was essentially free PR for the game. It was the biggest independent gaming fourm and is what probebly contributed the fact that the game actually sold. Bottem line: He posted there because it was the biggest, if System Wars was bigger than NeoGAF in terms of number of people using the fourms and people posting, he would have most likely posted it here.

There are leauges for posting? Where do I sit then? Amature? Minor Leauges? Is GAF the NHL of fourms? Wat?

It has nothing to do with the number of members, its all about credibility.

Developers and industry hot shots in SW? :lol::lol:

If you actually rembered anything, Developers actually posted in Gamespot, in particular a Prey developer posted to complain about the score it recived.There are actually many other examples to that.

[QUOTE="HarlockJC"][QUOTE="insanejedi"]

There are leauges for posting? Where do I sit then? Amature? Minor Leauges? Is GAF the NHL of fourms? Wat?

insanejedi

What....I guess I am too tried to understand what your trying to say there

If there Pro's what does that make us? How can you be a pro in posting?

I quess that makes us whatbes

Its like this one of the reasons why we would never get someone like him to post on this board at least under his real name. Is because of the posters. I do wish they would add a few more rules like you can't start a thread until you level 5 and maybe you can not even post until your a higher level.

I have a couple friends working for a major company on a game which no one on here knows about yet. It is great to be able to ask them questions and learn more about gaming has a whole. Well I don't know if I will ever post on GAF it's something we are missing out on here compared to there.

I am starting to have a hard time tying if this was hard to understand my bad....good night all

If there Pro's what does that make us?

insanejedi

We are the casuals :lol: :lol:

[QUOTE="nintendo-4life"]

it took me 3 weeks to actually get accepted, then i just threw the account away (as in didn't use it at all).

i have been interested in GAF for a while, though i can't say it's as good as SW honestly :P

HarlockJC

I would not want to start all over again.

I rather stay on a board where at least I am a little well know.

i've had an account in IGN as well... but i just didn't like the community or the board itself... GAF has really good topics and community though

While I could not care any less in the game, it helps to restore my faith in gaming humanity when somebody admits they were at fault.

We need more of this type of behavior.