NEOGAF's Game of the Gen

Voted by NEOGAF's members.

1. Super Mario Galaxy - 147
2. MGS4 - 102
3. Uncharted - 39
4. Bioshock - 22
5. Mass Effect - 21
6. Street Fighter 4 - 18
7. Little Big Planet - 17
8. Call of Duty 4 - 16
9. Crackdown - 14
10. Valkyria Chronicles - 12
11. Left 4 Dead - 10
11. Team Fortress 2 - 10
11. Rock Band 1/2 - 10
14. Oblivion - 8
14. Fallout 3 - 8
16. Resident Evil 5 - 7
16. Halo 3 - 7
16. Dead Space - 7
19. Mirror's Edge - 6
20. Demon's Souls - 5
20. Warhawk - 5
20. Gears of War - 5
20. Dead Rising - 5
20. Wii Sports - 5
25. Portal - 4
25. Killzone 2 - 4
25. Grand Theft Auto 4 - 4
28. Super Smash Bros Brawl - 3
28. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess - 3
28. Megaman 9 - 3
28. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Trials and Tribulations - 3
32. FIFA 09 - 2
32. Flower - 2
32. No More Heroes - 2
32. Orange Box - 2
32. Orange Box - 2
32. Ninja Gaiden 2 - 2
32. Devil May Cry 4 - 2
32. Metroid Prime 3 - 2
32. World of Goo - 2
32. Crysis - 2
32. Monster Hunter Freedom 2 - 2
32. Fable 2 - 2
32. Lost Odyssey - 2
45. Men of War - 1
45. Heavenly Sword - 1
45. Chromehounds - 1
45. Hot Shots Golf - 1
45. Wii Music - 1
45. Far Cry 2 - 1
45. Rainbow 6: Vegas - 1
45. Viva Pinata - 1
45. Space Giraffe - 1
45. Tales of Vesperia - 1
45. Europa Universalis III: Complete - 1
45. Saints Row 2 - 1
45. Banjo Nuts and Bolts - 1
45. The World Ends with You - 1
45. World of Warcraft - 1
45. Etrian Odyssey 2 - 1
45. Disgaea PSP - 1
45. Fire Emblem Radiant Dawn - 1
45. Bangai-O - 1
45. Professor Layton 1 - 1
45. Motorstorm Pacific Rift - 1
45. Timeshift - 1
45. Mario Kart Wii - 1
45. Civilization 4 - 1
45. Test Drive Unlimited - 1
45. Secret PS3 game - 1
45. MLB 08: The Show - 1
45. Skate 2 - 1
45. Imagine Party Babiez Wii - 1
45. Elite Beat Agents - 1
45. GRID - 1
45. Bionic Commando ReArmed - 1
45. Siren Blood Curse - 1
45. Battlefield: Bad Company - 1
45. Prince of Persia - 1
45. Geometry Wars Retro Evolved - 1
45. Audiosurf - 1

SAUCE

decent list in my opinion. lets do one here at GameSpot or have we already?

To be fair, wii players get to put all their eggs in one basket with their only orignal good game where as gamers have many more choices.

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess is NOT from this generation. IS from last generation. The gamecube generation.

Just because wii can play gamecube games and add some new control scheme doesnt make zelda TP a wii game.

The wii and gamecube version are the same, and are last generation. They only released the wii version first to trick buyers.

Or is FF7 from this generation also because I can download it on japanese PSN and play withouth disc swaping and faster loading.

Nintendo fans are so last gen.

MGS 4 should be number 1 and SMG #2

I'm happy to see they have chose the right game for #1

Ok, neogaf is full of PS3 people, that proves nothing much

MGS 4 should be number 1 and SMG #2

ihsanqueen

Ok, neogaf is full of PS3 people, that proves nothing much

obamanian

Ok, neogaf is full of PS3 people, that proves nothing much

obamanian

Let me guess Fale 2 should be #1.

Ok, neogaf is full of PS3 people, that proves nothing much

obamanian

Where the **** is Braid?? Oh I see, this another one of those "downloadable games don't count" occasions, isn't it?

EDIT: nope, now I see Flower and Space Giraffe (what!?) on the list, which makes it even more weird.

I enjoyed Mario Galaxy but I would not put it at the top of the list. It was to linear, I wish the levels were more open like Mario 64.wooooode

I can honestly say I didint enjoy galaxy. I got bord rather quickly.

[QUOTE="obamanian"]

Ok, neogaf is full of PS3 people, that proves nothing much

toast_burner

Pretty good list, SMG and MGS4 definitely deserve to be the top 2.

Super mario galaxy has an amazing story.

Lets save the princess from browser again....

Next gen graphics...... OH yea, dinamic lighting, high rez textures, poligons.

Ground breaking AI and phisics. What AI? Phisics, we are in the space and juperman jumps. That is all we need.

Fully interactive and destroyale enviroments redefining the industry.

Or is just juperman jumping on heads?

Nintendo gamers are so nostalgic. Zelda, mario kart, mario, smash brothers and pokemon are the only franchises that can stuck on time and withouth any improvements but still satisfy its fans. (they even keep buying the same game over and over)

Nintendo sure knows how to milk it.

Super mario galaxy has an amazing story.

Lets save the princess from browser again....

Next gen graphics...... OH yea, dinamic lighting, high rez textures, poligons.

Ground breaking AI and phisics. What AI? Phisics, we are in the space and juperman jumps. That is all we need.

Fully interactive and destroyale enviroments redefining the industry.

Or is just juperman jumping on heads?

Nintendo gamers are so nostalgic. Zelda, mario kart, mario, smash brothers and pokemon are the only franchises that can stuck on time and withouth any improvements but still satisfy its fans. (they even keep buying the same game over and over)

Nintendo sure knows how to milk it.

ropumar

So you haven't played it then?

Don't really agree with the list, thought Super Mario Galaxy deserves top 5. I can see MGS4 is still the most overrated game of the gen.AAllxxjjnn

Uncharted at 3rd? Right :roll:

What the hell is going on with "Secret PS3 Game" being at 45. Other than that I reckon thats not a bad list at all. Bionic Commando Rearmed could have gone up a few spots, thats my personal fav this gen.

What's Uncharted doing so high? It's fun, but it's not that great.

[QUOTE="ropumar"]

Super mario galaxy has an amazing story.

Lets save the princess from browser again....

Next gen graphics...... OH yea, dinamic lighting, high rez textures, poligons.

Ground breaking AI and phisics. What AI? Phisics, we are in the space and juperman jumps. That is all we need.

Fully interactive and destroyale enviroments redefining the industry.

Or is just juperman jumping on heads?

Nintendo gamers are so nostalgic. Zelda, mario kart, mario, smash brothers and pokemon are the only franchises that can stuck on time and withouth any improvements but still satisfy its fans. (they even keep buying the same game over and over)

Nintendo sure knows how to milk it.

Mr_Nordquist

So you haven't played it then?

not only that ! his research skills are almost at level 0 :lol:

Super mario galaxy has an amazing story.

Lets save the princess from browser again....

Next gen graphics...... OH yea, dinamic lighting, high rez textures, poligons.

Ground breaking AI and phisics. What AI? Phisics, we are in the space and juperman jumps. That is all we need.

Fully interactive and destroyale enviroments redefining the industry.

Or is just juperman jumping on heads?

Nintendo gamers are so nostalgic. Zelda, mario kart, mario, smash brothers and pokemon are the only franchises that can stuck on time and withouth any improvements but still satisfy its fans. (they even keep buying the same game over and over)

Nintendo sure knows how to milk it.

ropumar

The reason Galaxy is on top because its the best Wii game this gen while PS3/360 had plenty of great games to choose from...raskullibur

and why they listed these games ?

Super Mario Galaxy

rock band

Dead Rising

Wii Sports

Super Smash Bros Brawl

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess

Megaman 9

Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Trials and Tribulations

FIFA 09

No More Heroes

Metroid Prime 3

World of Goo

Wii Music

Fire Emblem Radiant Dawn

Bangai-O

Professor Layton

Mario Kart Wii

Skate 2

Imagine Party Babiez Wii

Elite Beat Agents

Geometry Wars

OH NOOOOOOO MORE THAN 1 GAME :o:o:o

[QUOTE="wooooode"]I enjoyed Mario Galaxy but I would not put it at the top of the list. It was to linear, I wish the levels were more open like Mario 64.finalfantasy94

I can honestly say I didint enjoy galaxy. I got bord rather quickly.

To be fair, wii players get to put all their eggs in one basket with their only orignal good game where as gamers have many more choices.

htekemerald

[QUOTE="AAllxxjjnn"]Don't really agree with the list, thought Super Mario Galaxy deserves top 5. I can see MGS4 is still the most overrated game of the gen.godofwar2610

Fallout 3 = Oblivion on that list... FAIL.

Well, besides Uncharted getting 3rd (no way in hell its the 3rd best game this gen) I say the list is pretty good. I wouldn't expect SW to actually understand the reasoning and thinking behind the list since all we do here is play scores but its pretty damn good and a representation of many different gamers. Also, SMG FTW.

Super mario galaxy has an amazing story.

Lets save the princess from browser again....

Next gen graphics...... OH yea, dinamic lighting, high rez textures, poligons.

Ground breaking AI and phisics. What AI? Phisics, we are in the space and juperman jumps. That is all we need.

Fully interactive and destroyale enviroments redefining the industry.

Or is just juperman jumping on heads?

Nintendo gamers are so nostalgic. Zelda, mario kart, mario, smash brothers and pokemon are the only franchises that can stuck on time and withouth any improvements but still satisfy its fans. (they even keep buying the same game over and over)

Nintendo sure knows how to milk it.

ropumar

I heart NeoGAF. Great list, we should do one.

I heart NeoGAF. Great list, we should do one.

Aljosa23

I love neogaf too but SW should not do one of these. We are way too shallow minded a community to ever make a fair list. Too many obvious biases on top of the fact that we all know MGS4 will win and like zero wii games will make the list and limited PC games.

I love neogaf too but SW should not do one of these. We are way too shallow minded a community to ever make a fair list. Too many obvious biases on top of the fact that we all know MGS4 will win and like zero wii games will make the list and limited PC games.

ActicEdge

Than GUFU should do one!

[QUOTE="Aljosa23"]

I heart NeoGAF. Great list, we should do one.

ActicEdge

I love neogaf too but SW should not do one of these. We are way too shallow minded a community to ever make a fair list. Too many obvious biases on top of the fact that we all know MGS4 will win and like zero wii games will make the list and limited PC games.