NEOGAF's Game of the Gen

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

I love neogaf too but SW should not do one of these. We are way too shallow minded a community to ever make a fair list. Too many obvious biases on top of the fact that we all know MGS4 will win and like zero wii games will make the list and limited PC games.

Aljosa23

Than GUFU should do one!

I'm all for that. Maybe I will do one, contribute something (that means I probably won't get to it :P)

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

[QUOTE="Aljosa23"]

I heart NeoGAF. Great list, we should do one.

Giancar

I love neogaf too but SW should not do one of these. We are way too shallow minded a community to ever make a fair list. Too many obvious biases on top of the fact that we all know MGS4 will win and like zero wii games will make the list and limited PC games.

We all know SMG would make the list and Crysis too but apart from that? I seriously am not as optimistic as you are in the SW community, forgive me.

nah, SMG will be able to get into the top ten and crysis and the witcher could easily get there...Giancar

Guess which faction voted for which game!

Ok, neogaf is full of PS3 people, that proves nothing much

obamanian

Ok, neogaf is full of PS3 people, that proves nothing much

obamanian

Actually it's where all the sheep go.

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

I love neogaf too but SW should not do one of these. We are way too shallow minded a community to ever make a fair list. Too many obvious biases on top of the fact that we all know MGS4 will win and like zero wii games will make the list and limited PC games.

Aljosa23

Than GUFU should do one!

[QUOTE="Giancar"][QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

I love neogaf too but SW should not do one of these. We are way too shallow minded a community to ever make a fair list. Too many obvious biases on top of the fact that we all know MGS4 will win and like zero wii games will make the list and limited PC games.

ActicEdge

We all know SMG would make the list and Crysis too but apart from that? I seriously am not as optimistic as you are in the SW community, forgive me.

but it's not like a ton of wii games or pc made into the neogaf list...

Edit: besides Pc games are mixed with multi games (same for ps and 360 ones)

[QUOTE="Giancar"] nah, SMG will be able to get into the top ten and crysis and the witcher could easily get there...Aljosa23

Guess which faction voted for which game!

50% Halo 3

49% ME

1% Fable 2 with tons of fable's tree leaves pics (guess who? lol )

oh and that top 4 isn't that bad: I love 3 games from the 4 you listed :P

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

[QUOTE="Giancar"] nah, SMG will be able to get into the top ten and crysis and the witcher could easily get there...Giancar

We all know SMG would make the list and Crysis too but apart from that? I seriously am not as optimistic as you are in the SW community, forgive me.

Which is exactly why I doubt the quality that a SW made list would contain with the obvious biases we have here since we are actually divided into factions. You think Wii Music could actually make the list around here?

YAY for Crackdown getting some respect! It made the top 10. I loved that game, it was fun as hell.

lemmings will vote so:

50% Halo 3

49% ME

1% Fable 2 with tons of fable's tree leaves pics (guess who? lol )

oh and that top 4 isn't that bad: I love 3 games from the 4 you listed :P

Giancar

YAY for Crackdown getting some respect! It made the top 10. I loved that game, it was fun as hell.

heretrix

[QUOTE="Giancar"][QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

We all know SMG would make the list and Crysis too but apart from that? I seriously am not as optimistic as you are in the SW community, forgive me.

ActicEdge

Which is exactly why I doubt the quality that a SW made list would contain with the obvious biases we have here since we are actually divided into factions. You think Wii Music could actually make the list around here?

Nice to see MotorStorm PR and Valkyrie Chronicles get some love

[QUOTE="Giancar"]

lemmings will vote so:

50% Halo 3

49% ME

1% Fable 2 with tons of fable's tree leaves pics (guess who? lol )

oh and that top 4 isn't that bad: I love 3 games from the 4 you listed :P

Aljosa23

[QUOTE="heretrix"]

YAY for Crackdown getting some respect! It made the top 10. I loved that game, it was fun as hell.

HarlockJC

:( It's a fantastic coop game. To each it's own.

Which is exactly why I doubt the quality that a SW made list would contain with the obvious biases we have here since we are actually divided into factions. You think Wii Music could actually make the list around here?

ActicEdge

Better question: Should Wii Music make the list anywhere? Seriously though there is bias everywhere regardless of factions.

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

[QUOTE="Giancar"] neither am I tbqh but it's not like a ton of wii games or pc made into the neogaf list...Giancar

Which is exactly why I doubt the quality that a SW made list would contain with the obvious biases we have here since we are actually divided into factions. You think Wii Music could actually make the list around here?

Yeah, that's true. Maybe we should give it a shot around here any way. Maybe it'll restore some of my faith back in SW (I can't believe I had faith in SW to begin with :P)

WHAT? :x MGS4 is better than both IMO I am a huge MGS fan :P but the world would be so boring if all of us thought the same wayGiancar

I had fun playing the game but I wouldn't have put crackdown so high on the list. Other then that, not a bad list... I've seen much much worst.

MGS4 should've been number 1.

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

Which is exactly why I doubt the quality that a SW made list would contain with the obvious biases we have here since we are actually divided into factions. You think Wii Music could actually make the list around here?

-RPGamer-

Better question: Should Wii Music make the list anywhere? Seriously though there is bias everywhere regardless of factions.

The difference being we actually seperate ourselves into factions and make a habit of attacking the other ones. I know there is bias everywhere regardless of factions but having factions in the first place doesn't exactly make this the best place to have an atleast civiliized vote now does it. I have to say, comparing our own bias to someone who's name is PS3_owns_360 and makes it a point to rip into said consoles whenever they can isn't really the same thing. Bias is bias but there is ridiculous unreasonable bias (hence discrimination and such) amd there is the normal bias every person holds. Which one is more prominant here?

Also, as far as Wii Music goes, the point was that there were people open and willing enough to vote for it and there would be no fear of attack sincethey aren't exactly divided up into groups over at Neogaf. Also, you know, they actually played it unlike most of SW who will still bash it like crazy.

[QUOTE="Giancar"] nah, SMG will be able to get into the top ten and crysis and the witcher could easily get there...Aljosa23

Guess which faction voted for which game!

[QUOTE="Aljosa23"]

[QUOTE="Giancar"] nah, SMG will be able to get into the top ten and crysis and the witcher could easily get there...THQ88

Guess which faction voted for which game!

[QUOTE="toast_burner"]

[QUOTE="obamanian"]

Ok, neogaf is full of PS3 people, that proves nothing much

WilliamRLBaker

U havent played the game have u? its a really great game, but kinda short... Besides unchated graphics look wayyy better than gears...

only 7 people voted for halo 3 ?? i dont think many neo gaf forum goers have a 360

I'm glad to see SMG as #1 on the list. I think Portal should be much higher. I'm surprised and gladthat Fire Emblem Radiant Dawn is in that list.

only 7 people voted for halo 3 ?? i dont think many neo gaf forum goers have a 360

scottiescott238

Yup, GAF is smart. SMG is a modern day classic.

lol @ Uncharted.... WTF.

Galaxy is the best overall title this generation imo.

[QUOTE="scottiescott238"]

only 7 people voted for halo 3 ?? i dont think many neo gaf forum goers have a 360

InsaneBasura

SMG at #1. At least one gaming site seems to have the right idea.

SMG at #1. At least one gaming site seems to have the right idea.

789shadow

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

SMG at #1. At least one gaming site seems to have the right idea.

Aljosa23

To be fair, wii players get to put all their eggs in one basket with their only orignal good game where as gamers have many more choices.

htekemerald

This post just nails it.

Sure is smg is good, but the greatest? Even after playing sunshine n the n64 version?

End of the day, its down to OPINIONS.

And wii gamers have MORE of it due to high NUMBERS

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

To be fair, wii players get to put all their eggs in one basket with their only orignal good game where as gamers have many more choices.

g0ddyX

This post just nails it.

Sure is smg is good, but the greatest? Even after playing sunshine n the n64 version?

End of the day, its down to OPINIONS.

And wii gamers have MORE of it due to high NUMBERS

oh.... and critics agree. Just sayin...