New Suoer Mario Bros Wii to be GOTY? Total Impartial Poll

[QUOTE="simslifer"]

that spot is already reserved for uncharted 2...

aia89

How can you possibly say that if you haven't beat U2?

In fact, I read in your other thread that Uncharted was boring, so what are you doing playing Tomb Raider, a lower scoring series?

I smell something funny, using your posting history.

[QUOTE="aia89"][QUOTE="simslifer"]

that spot is already reserved for uncharted 2...

simslifer

sorry 9.5 >> 7.0

[QUOTE="aia89"][QUOTE="simslifer"]

that spot is already reserved for uncharted 2...

SolidTy

How can you possibly say that if you haven't beat U2?

In fact, I read in your other thread that Uncharted was boring, so what are you doing playing Tomb Raider, a lower scoring series?

I smell something funny, using your posting history.

im gonna call a 7.5 or less megaflop that will cause several sheep suicides and massive damage control.

Silenthps

While i'm sure it will be my personal one I doubt it because although ur not losing much for online since it was never there you can bet GS will really cruel on this point, I however do think it will get AAA because they sound like they really like it in the previews.

[QUOTE="Braviere"]In recent years, specifically last gen, when has a Mario game ever win GOTY? Think about that while you continue hoping.ActicEdge

Uh 2 years ago. Super MArio Galaxy. This is a really bad post. I actually am kind of embarrassed you missed that.

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

[QUOTE="Braviere"]In recent years, specifically last gen, when has a Mario game ever win GOTY? Think about that while you continue hoping.Braviere

Uh 2 years ago. Super MArio Galaxy. This is a really bad post. I actually am kind of embarrassed you missed that.

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

[QUOTE="Braviere"]In recent years, specifically last gen, when has a Mario game ever win GOTY? Think about that while you continue hoping.Braviere

Uh 2 years ago. Super MArio Galaxy. This is a really bad post. I actually am kind of embarrassed you missed that.

[QUOTE="simslifer"]

that spot is already reserved for uncharted 2...

aia89

[QUOTE="Braviere"][QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

Uh 2 years ago. Super MArio Galaxy. This is a really bad post. I actually am kind of embarrassed you missed that.

OreoMilkshake

because he cannot accept the fact that Mario won many times, while UC....never!

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

[QUOTE="Braviere"]In recent years, specifically last gen, when has a Mario game ever win GOTY? Think about that while you continue hoping.Braviere

Uh 2 years ago. Super MArio Galaxy. This is a really bad post. I actually am kind of embarrassed you missed that.

So I'm suspose to look to the past to find a mario GOTY when the most recent one out right now was GOTY? And "in recent years" followed by "last gen" is a contradiction. A really bad one. I'm suspose to think about why SMS didn't win GOTY when the most Recent one did indeed win that award?Please enlighten me.

[QUOTE="aia89"][QUOTE="simslifer"]

that spot is already reserved for uncharted 2...

blazinpuertoroc

[QUOTE="Braviere"][QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

Uh 2 years ago. Super MArio Galaxy. This is a really bad post. I actually am kind of embarrassed you missed that.

ActicEdge

So I'm suspose to look to the past to find a mario GOTY when the most recent one out right now was GOTY? And "in recent years" followed by "last gen" is a contradiction. A really bad one. I'm suspose to think about why SMS didn't win GOTY when the most Recent one did indeed win that award?Please enlighten me.

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

[QUOTE="Braviere"] I'm embarrassed that you missed when I specifically said "Last Gen".Last time I checked Super Mario Galaxy is a Wii game, which is current gen and not the last one.I could have worded it better,however, it is not my fault that you misread my post.So your reply was bad, not my post. Nice Try ThoughBraviere

So I'm suspose to look to the past to find a mario GOTY when the most recent one out right now was GOTY? And "in recent years" followed by "last gen" is a contradiction. A really bad one. I'm suspose to think about why SMS didn't win GOTY when the most Recent one did indeed win that award?Please enlighten me.

What are you even getting at? Besides making a post that has no logical context you are trying to defend it like you have some profound point. Let's stop dancing around the issue. What is your point?

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

[QUOTE="Braviere"] I'm embarrassed that you missed when I specifically said "Last Gen".Last time I checked Super Mario Galaxy is a Wii game, which is current gen and not the last one.I could have worded it better,however, it is not my fault that you misread my post.So your reply was bad, not my post. Nice Try ThoughBraviere

So I'm suspose to look to the past to find a mario GOTY when the most recent one out right now was GOTY? And "in recent years" followed by "last gen" is a contradiction. A really bad one. I'm suspose to think about why SMS didn't win GOTY when the most Recent one did indeed win that award?Please enlighten me.

Um what exactly does this have to do with anything?

Super Mario Galaxy was GOTY 2007 thats all he needs to look back to.

[QUOTE="Braviere"][QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

So I'm suspose to look to the past to find a mario GOTY when the most recent one out right now was GOTY? And "in recent years" followed by "last gen" is a contradiction. A really bad one. I'm suspose to think about why SMS didn't win GOTY when the most Recent one did indeed win that award?Please enlighten me.

bobcheeseball

Um what exactly does this have to do with anything?

Super Mario Galaxy was GOTY 2007 thats all he needs to look back to.

[QUOTE="bobcheeseball"]

[QUOTE="Braviere"] If you didn't realize by now, Wii games are irrelavent to my post.Last Gen was 3-4 years ago, the Wii came out late 06, I wouldn't have said years if I didn't plan on going further than 2 years. I would've just said 2 years ago.The contradiction is also irrelavent because I said "specifically", which you have disregarded.As for your last question, I didn't say "The last console Mario game", so you don't have to think about SMS at all.As long as it is a Mario game from Last Gen.Once again, Nice Try ThoughBraviere

Um what exactly does this have to do with anything?

Super Mario Galaxy was GOTY 2007 thats all he needs to look back to.

What were you trying to accomplish with your first post?

[QUOTE="Braviere"][QUOTE="bobcheeseball"]

Um what exactly does this have to do with anything?

Super Mario Galaxy was GOTY 2007 thats all he needs to look back to.

ActicEdge

What were you trying to accomplish with your first post?

Is unlikely, but mario galaxy 2 can be 2010 GOTY

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

[QUOTE="Braviere"] Time for my questions because I'm finding it hard to understand why you two can't tell the difference from Last Gen and Current Gen. What does SMG have to do with my original post? Braviere

What were you trying to accomplish with your first post?

Actually, if the audience cannot understand the point being put forward to them it is the writers fault. This isn't a novel with deep literary meaning, criticism and iamgery, this is a gaming forum. Say what you mean clearly.

Is unlikely, but mario galaxy 2 can be 2010 GOTY

JuarN18

I have to say it doesn't look like it brings enough new things to the table for that.

sheepspot am confirmed?

sheepspot am comfirmed?

SilverChimera

That's what I said.

[QUOTE="Braviere"][QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

What were you trying to accomplish with your first post?

ActicEdge

Actually, if the audience cannot understand the point being put forward to them it is the writers fault. This isn't a novel with deep literary meaning, criticism and iamgery, this is a gaming forum. Say what you mean clearly.

[QUOTE="JuarN18"]

Is unlikely, but mario galaxy 2 can be 2010 GOTY

789shadow

I have to say it doesn't look like it brings enough new things to the table for that.

ya, but uncharted 2 dosent have this problem, right?

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

[QUOTE="JuarN18"]

Is unlikely, but mario galaxy 2 can be 2010 GOTY

DeadEndPanda

I have to say it doesn't look like it brings enough new things to the table for that.

ya, but uncharted 2 dosent have this problem, right?

Does it look like I care about Uncharted 2?

Mario Bros. Wii reeks of 8.0, another good game for Wii, but not exceptional or outstanding, like the games PS3 has been getting all year.

[QUOTE="DeadEndPanda"]

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

I have to say it doesn't look like it brings enough new things to the table for that.

789shadow

ya, but uncharted 2 dosent have this problem, right?

Does it look like I care about Uncharted 2?

dunno, its hard to judge people just from an avatar picture :P

but since you asked. il say no

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

[QUOTE="JuarN18"]

Is unlikely, but mario galaxy 2 can be 2010 GOTY

DeadEndPanda

I have to say it doesn't look like it brings enough new things to the table for that.

ya, but uncharted 2 dosent have this problem, right?

Uncharted 2 doesn't bring anything new compared to Uncharted?

Did you just say that and try to make believe it was a serious statement?

[QUOTE="DeadEndPanda"]

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

I have to say it doesn't look like it brings enough new things to the table for that.

GiantMuffin

ya, but uncharted 2 dosent have this problem, right?

Uncharted 2 doesn't bring anything new compared to Uncharted?

Did you just say that and try to make believe it was a serious statement?

read the post, it says "not enough new things" not "no new things" ;)

[QUOTE="GiantMuffin"]

[QUOTE="DeadEndPanda"]

ya, but uncharted 2 dosent have this problem, right?

DeadEndPanda

Uncharted 2 doesn't bring anything new compared to Uncharted?

Did you just say that and try to make believe it was a serious statement?

read the post, it says "not enough new things" not "no new things" ;)

Oh ok, let me know when Mario Galaxy 2 adds 10 player multiplayer and 3 player online co-op, with a trophy/achievement system.

[QUOTE="DeadEndPanda"]

[QUOTE="GiantMuffin"]

Uncharted 2 doesn't bring anything new compared to Uncharted?

Did you just say that and try to make believe it was a serious statement?

GiantMuffin

read the post, it says "not enough new things" not "no new things" ;)

Oh ok, let me know when Mario Galaxy 2 adds 10 player multiplayer and 3 player online co-op, with a trophy/achievement system.

oki il tell ya when/if they add multiplayer, anything eals?

SMG2 added on gameplay elements, and some pritty interesting ideas.

and that just based on 1 video

Uncharted to be GOTY for its graphics? there are other elements to take into account, actually. you ppl are obsesssed with graphics

It wont even be the best 2D game released this year

Jaysonguy

What will that be, Henry Hatswoth in the puzzling adventure?

52 positive votes!!!!!!

[QUOTE="Ratchet_Fan8"]fine,then Splosion man if it counts hereIronBass

The other poster said "Fine,whats a better 2D game IYO?" I said splosion man >.>Ratchet_Fan8

Something is seriously wrong with this poll!:P Anyway I can't say for certain if it winning it or not, but it will be very surprising in my opinion if New Super Mario Bros Wii win game of the year honor considering there were alot of great games this year.

My 8 ball says NO. Man would it be fun on here if my 8 ball was wrong. HarlockJC

I doubt it. If a pltformer wins next year, it's going to be a 3d one.

I doubt it, I can see if getting AAA easily, but GOTY is a stretch.