Now that the Hype has worn off, what do you think of these games?

Super Smash Bros Brawl - Awesome although the online is disappointing


Super Mario Galaxy - best game this gen that I've played so far IMO.

Killzone 2 - Haven't played.

Metal Gear Solid 4 - haven't played but I'm not that big a fan of Metal Gear


Gears of War 2 -haven't played. I thought the first one was good but a little overrated


Halo 3 - Great but overrated. I did like it more then 2.


Grand Theft Auto 4 - Great game but I've only played about an hour of it.


Crysis - haven't played because my PC can't handle it. I plan to upgrade it by the end of the year.

TheElfChild

Super Smash Bros Brawl Meh
Super Mario Galaxy Meh
Killzone 2 Have not played, do not wish to play
Metal Gear Solid 4 Have not played, do wish to play
Gears of War 2 Have not played, do no wish to play
Halo 3 Meh
Grand Theft Auto 4 Meh
Crysis Quite amazing, from the demo on low

TheElfChild

killzone 2= still great, easily the best shooter on the ps3 and will probley stay that way this entire year(that includes it being better then MW2) and most of next year.

MGS4= Possibly my favoirte game. Not as good as the frist play through, but still a damn fun game but with terrible online that should have never been put in the game.

Crysis= meh, looks amazing, was fun first play through, not going to play it again. might pick up warhead in hopes of a more fun game.

GTA4= bad game, but still better then SA. GTA: Vice City is the best, GTA3 is the second, GTA 4 is third.

Super Smash Bros Brawl


Super Mario Galaxy

Killzone 2

Metal Gear Solid 4


Gears of War 2


Halo 3


Grand Theft Auto 4


Crysis

TheElfChild

Super Smash Brothers Brawl- Poor control scheme for those of us without GCN controllers, unable to find that "easy to learn, hard to master" balance in gameplay that defined the series. 3/5

Super Mario Galaxy- A great game, but is missing that certain je ne sais quois that made prior Mario titles like 64 so great. 4/5.

Killzone 2- Above average shooter. The campaign is a waste of time, and the multiplayer fails to live up to it's potential due to communication and teamwork issues. 3/5.

Metal Gear Sold 4- Superb at times, but Kojima needs to hire an editor, and the gameplay isn't as strong as earlier entries. 3/5.

Gears of War 2- Similar to Killzone 2 -- it has it's moments, but the campaign is laughably bad and the multiplayer has issues. 3/5.

Halo 3- Shares the series' hallmark inconsistent singleplayer, but makes up for it with some of the best multiplayer out there. 4/5.

Grand Theft Auto 4- Tries to blend the prior titles' "turned-up-to-11" gameplay and humour with a degree of realism and a deep, emotional story; fails miserably. Good thing Liberty City itself is breathtaking. 3/5.

Crysis- Similar to Halo: CE -- a superb shooter when the developer isn't forcing you to corridor crawl and/or fight a mindless and boring enemy. Luckily for Crysis, the rest of the game really is that good. 5/5.

Super Smash Bros Brawl


Super Mario Galaxy

Killzone 2

Metal Gear Solid 4


Gears of War 2


Halo 3


Grand Theft Auto 4


Crysis

TheElfChild

1-awesome 2-still good but dont play it anymore 3-awesome and my most played game right now 4-still great will play it over again once i can pry myself away from killzone 2 5-dont own it but is still fun to play co-op story mode 6-never was a huge fan of halo 7-Sucks top 5 most overrated games this gen imo 8-i wish i had a pc good enough to play the darn thing but obv still graphics king

Before i go on, some thing is bugging the crap out of me... Can people stop saying SSBB is unbalanced? It way more balanced than Melee in every way possible with or without items/smash balls....

SSBB- Besides what i said above, i enjoyed Melee more. It had this more fluid feel to it and it wasnt so, dare i say, casual.... still a good game.

Mario Galaxy- Really good, one of the best game's this year.

Metal Gear Solid 4- Probably the best game ive played all year. It was to epic

Resistance 2- I didn't like this game at all. But then again i hate the FPS genre.

Halo 3- Really dislike this milked series, i gave Halo 3 a good long try and it had its moments but i really dislike the game and series

GeoW 2 A better sequel than Halo but i was still disappointed, still a blast to play with friends.

Super Smash Bros Brawl - Never Played the game


Super Mario Galaxy - Never Played the game

Killzone 2 -Amazing game

Metal Gear Solid 4- Best game this Gen (so far at least)


Gears of War 2 - Amazing game


Halo 3 - Good/Fungame


Grand Theft Auto 4 - Great game


Crysis - Never played the game

TheElfChild

Super Smash Bros Brawl- Almost the same as the last one/Has the absolute worst SP I have ever played all the way through.

Super Mario Galaxy- Fun at times, horribly overrated, controls can be frustrating at times.

Killzone 2- Haven't had much experience, from what I have played it seems pretty good, but also seems like it would get dull too soon for me.

Metal Gear Solid 4- Not deserving of a 10, but all around good game.


Gears of War 2- Bleh, hoped for a lot, got a little.


Halo 3- Was fun while it lasted, online was far too similar to Halo 2 causing it to get old very quickly.


Grand Theft Auto 4- Is this game really even different from the other GTA's? Series really hasn't done much since GTA 3.


Crysis- Haven't played, but looks pretty.

Super Smash Bros Brawl 80


Super Mario Galaxy 100

Killzone 2 have not played

Metal Gear Solid 4 90


Gears of War 2 85


Halo 3 90


Grand Theft Auto 4 90


Crysis 95

TheElfChild

All = AwesomeOreoMilkshake

Super Smash Bros Brawl


Super Mario Galaxy

Killzone 2

Metal Gear Solid 4


Gears of War 2


Halo 3


Grand Theft Auto 4


Crysis

TheElfChild

Brawl - Blows, melee is better

Galaxy - Still cool killzone 2 - still cool

mgs4 - utterly epic, still remember every last scene

gears 2 - dissapointing, 1 was better

halo 3 - i was sick of halo after halo 2

gta4 - booooring

crysis - pretty but boring

Super Smash Bros Brawl- crap

Super Mario Galaxy - crap

Killzone 2 - trash

Metal Gear Solid 4 - lame


Gears of War 2 - godlike


Halo 3 - achievement by man that rivals space travel.


Grand Theft Auto 4 - boring


Crysis - all graphics.

TheElfChild

my opinion is infallible

[QUOTE="TheElfChild"]

Super Smash Bros Brawl- crap

Super Mario Galaxy - crap

Killzone 2 - trash

Metal Gear Solid 4 - lame


Gears of War 2 - godlike


Halo 3 - achievement by man that rivals space travel.


Grand Theft Auto 4 - boring


Crysis - all graphics.

porky_ownsu

my opinion is infallible

lemming xbox fanboy, go grab your ankles for bill gates somewhere else

Super smash bros Brawl- haven't played, don't wish to play.

Super Mario Galaxy- haven't played, don't wish to play.

Killzone 2- the whole game was meh, the MP was the face saving.

Metal Gear Solid 4- Best game this generation so far, nothing came near it.

Gears of War 2- The game was meh.

Grand theft Auto 4- second best game this generation.

Halo 3 - the game was meh, same old same.

Crysis- haven't played the game, wish to play it.

All = AwesomeOreoMilkshake

only one that sucked was gta4, can i please get more than 15 fps on my 360? and will you STOP calling me? kthx. paullywog

Super Smash Bros Brawl


Super Mario Galaxy

Killzone 2

Metal Gear Solid 4


Gears of War 2


Halo 3


Grand Theft Auto 4


Crysis

TheElfChild

1. Awesome, best fighting game so far this gen and easily better than Melee. 2. Great, but SMG2 will be better, and the controls/camera angles are a bit troublesome. 3. Haven't played 4. Best game this gen. 5. Gears of War 1.5, I can't really call it a sequel. 6. Meh, it's just Halo 2 again with no changes at all. 7. Okay, but not a big change from GTA:SA 8. Best graphics for the PC and an awesome FPS. This gen's Half-Life 2.

Super Smash Bros Brawl- Almost the same as the last one/Has the absolute worst SP I have ever played all the way through.Z0MBIES

Please elaborate. I have no idea how you can say SSBB is like SSBM.

All = AwesomeOreoMilkshake

Gears of War 2 - Not as good as the first one. Not completely disappointed. Will give it another play through.

Halo 3 - A pretty good FPS. Not as good as Halo CE. Want to play with keyboard/mouse.

Grand Theft Auto 4 - I just don't get how it's fun. A huge open city with nothing to do in it other than drive from point A to point B.

Crysis - A pretty good FPS. Far from the best. Graphics are great but also bland.

Super Smash Bros Brawl - 85/100


Super Mario Galaxy - 95/100

Killzone 2 - 80/100

Metal Gear Solid 4 - 90/100


Gears of War 2 - 85/100


Halo 3 - 90/100


Grand Theft Auto 4 - 90/100


Crysis - 95/100

havent played halo 3 or gears of war 2, but the rest are all awesome.

Super Smash Bros Brawl - Possibly the best game on the Wii in my opinion.


Super Mario Galaxy - I didn't like this game that much, Good controls and graphics but the story didn't do much for me.

Killzone 2 - Not played it, but from what I have seen it looks incredible

Metal Gear Solid 4 - Same as Killzone 2


Gears of War 2 - Good game, fun online at times, good graphics.


Halo 3 - Good game, but online did get a bit repetitive, and the ranking system was quite annoying.


Grand Theft Auto 4 - My favourite game this gen, looks great and such a laugh online.


Crysis - Not played but screenshots look amazing.

Super Smash Bros Brawl (played a bit- pretty fun)


Super Mario Galaxy (havent played)

Killzone 2(havent played)

Metal Gear Solid 4(havent played)


Gears of War 2 (meh)


Halo 3 (alright)


Grand Theft Auto 4 (awesome)


Crysis (awesome)

TheElfChild

a mon avis

Super Smash Bros Brawl havent yet played. heard good things though


Super Mario Galaxy havent played it yet either

Killzone 2 was slightly underwhelmed when i bought it, still a very solid FPS though

Metal Gear Solid 4 epic game. epic story, gameplay, voice acting, everything. Best single player game ive played in years


Gears of War 2 very fun, different game. got it at midnight, but the oniline was terrrible at first. Still, a fun strategic game


Halo 3 still the king of online shooters. Nothing beats halo online


Grand Theft Auto 4 havent yet played this game, which reminds me that i really should


Crysis from the couple hours ive spent on the game, it was really fun. AMAZING graphics obviously. set the technical standard for games

TheElfChild

Super Smash Bros Brawl- Never played it


Super Mario Galaxy - Meh, overrated

Killzone 2 - Never playe it (will soon though)

Metal Gear Solid 4 - Not my cup of tea, too much cinematics


Gears of War 2 - Never played it


Halo 3 - Playing this rigth now actually. The SP is good but I've had better. I don't like MP so can't judge it. Great production values though but average graphics


Grand Theft Auto 4 - Lots of fun but definately no 10


Crysis - Played it for a couple of minutes. Visuals are stunning (duh) but gameplay seemed semi-generic. Some of the suit's features are kinda cool.

TheElfChild

Killzone 2

-I like it more than I initially did. I got used to the controls and I wish more shooters had that heavy feel.

Metal Gear Solid 4

-I still think the writing was terrible, but I like it a little more. It is an awsome game. Not the greatest ever though. The crappy writing and poor dialogue are still just horrible.

Gears of War 2

-I'm still disappointed with the multiplayer--the whole reason I bought it--but my initial outrage at that games flaws as wained a little.

Halo 3

-I still think this game is nothing special and is more like Halo 2.5. I just can't play it. Its too boring.

Grand Theft Auto 4

-Its a pretty good game for what it is supposed to be, but yeah overrated.

Super Smash Bros Brawl


Super Mario Galaxy

Killzone 2

Metal Gear Solid 4


Gears of War 2


Halo 3


Grand Theft Auto 4


Crysis

TheElfChild

i havent played crysis and those wii games but the list is fantastic....except GTAIV which is worst game of this gen IMO

out of those i played killzone 2 ( ok single player good multiplayer) and crysis (great single player+mod support and ok multiplayer) and i liked them both especially crysis

Super Smash Bros Brawl IDK


Super Mario Galaxy IDK

Killzone 2 7 (+ 0.5 for great gfx)

Metal Gear Solid 4 9


Gears of War 2 8


Halo 3 6.5 (Same lack of fun I had with KZ2 but with not so hot visuals)


Grand Theft Auto 4 7


Crysis 9

TheElfChild

H3, KZ2 and GTA4 all failed to make me care enough to bother completing them so I consider the scores I gave them generous.

These are SP scores btw. I mostly find MP way beyond dull.

Of those You list, all were disappointing except SMG, and GTA4 and Halo3 were ok but just not for me.

Super Smash Bros Brawl - alright i guess. fun butgot old FAST.


Super Mario Galaxy - the first mario gamei thoroughly enjoyed, great fun.

Killzone 2 - the best graphics on consoles so far this gen, epic SP, really fun MP, great shooter. (on par with Halo 3 for me, though still beaten by COD4)

Metal Gear Solid 4 - without a doubt the best game this gen imo.


Gears of War 2 -on its own its a really good game. its only when compared to the first that it disappoints me greatly. especially the online. although horde mode sort of makes up for that.


Halo 3 - awesome shooter. good soundtrack, good SP, amazing MP. graphics could have been better but the MP more than makes up for it. on per with KZ2 imo.


Grand Theft Auto 4 - havent played much of it, but from what i played i was disappointed.


Crysis - not really a PC gamer. all i'll say is that the graphics on this game are unparalleled on any gaming system.

TheElfChild

[QUOTE="TheElfChild"]

Super Smash Bros Brawl


Super Mario Galaxy

Killzone 2

Metal Gear Solid 4


Gears of War 2


Halo 3

Animal-Mother

All the other games even though they were HYPED, I still enjoy playing them, and think they are great.