Now we've seen gameplay for both, which looks better: GT5 or F3? POLL

Topic with Forza 3 Gameplay footage:

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=27010843&tag=topics;title

GT 5 Gameplay:

http://www.gametrailers.com/game/gran-turismo-5/11148

I realize it's not the ebst quality vids we have at this point, but based on what's been shown till now, which one do you feel looks better?

I personally think GT5 looks better than Forza.

Thats like asking, what are you a lemming or a cow?

Thats like asking, what are you a lemming or a cow?

ThatsSimtastic

Fanboys are a minority here at SW. They just shout so loud their presence stands out more. Most people here try to be at least a little objective.

Thats like asking, what are you a lemming or a cow?

ThatsSimtastic

Thats like asking, what are you a lemming or a cow?

ThatsSimtastic

Forza3 imo. Environments look better and i think cars look about the same.

[QUOTE="ThatsSimtastic"]

Thats like asking, what are you a lemming or a cow?

NielsNL

Fanboys are a minority here at SW. They just shout so loud their presence stands out more. Most people here try to be at least a little objective.

Fanboys are the majority here at SW. Most of them try to hide it to create a false sense of credibility.

i will have to put it into two categories

vehicles - gt5

environment - forza

is this tread about the visuals or the gameplay? lolkweeni

The visuals. We haven't played it (at least I haven't). It's about the visuals during gameplay. So the non-replay visuals.

[QUOTE="NielsNL"]

[QUOTE="ThatsSimtastic"]

Thats like asking, what are you a lemming or a cow?

Blue-Sky

Fanboys are a minority here at SW. They just shout so loud their presence stands out more. Most people here try to be at least a little objective.

Fanboys are the majority here at SW. Most of them try to hide it to create a false sense of credibility.

It's not that bad I think.

[QUOTE="kweeni"]is this tread about the visuals or the gameplay? lolNielsNL

The visuals. We haven't played it (at least I haven't). It's about the visuals during gameplay. So the non-replay visuals.

oh if its the gameplay visuals then forza

gt looks like doodoo in gameplay

after seeing both after listening to so much hype i think both showings were a little dissapointing lol

after seeing both after listening to so much hype i think both showings were a little dissapointing lol

_zeldredz_

i saw shift, i was impressed. lol the cockpit view looks better in shift than the cockpit views in gt and forza

[QUOTE="_zeldredz_"]

after seeing both after listening to so much hype i think both showings were a little dissapointing lol

anshuk20002

i saw shift, i was impressed. lol the cockpit view looks better in shift than the cockpit views in gt and forza

I must admit that itlooks to be turning outthe best NFS since years.

Edit: Since the underrated Porsche Challenge I'd say...

That forza 3 gameplay is from the E3 build. The game looks much better now.aero250

Do you have a more recent link? I'll put it in the OP if you do.

[QUOTE="kweeni"]is this tread about the visuals or the gameplay? lolNielsNL

The visuals. We haven't played it (at least I haven't). It's about the visuals during gameplay. So the non-replay visuals.

i think visually they are on par...

[QUOTE="aero250"]That forza 3 gameplay is from the E3 build. The game looks much better now.NielsNL

Do you have a more recent link? I'll put it in the OP if you do.

[QUOTE="NielsNL"]

[QUOTE="aero250"]That forza 3 gameplay is from the E3 build. The game looks much better now.aero250

Do you have a more recent link? I'll put it in the OP if you do.

Then let's stick to what we do have.

Forza not only looked better than GT5 it actually looked fun to play as well. I own both systems and Forza 3 will get my money without question.

I've seen both live. GT5 looks better. Not that much better, though.IronBass

You were at GC? It's only a 3 hour drive from where Il ive, but I couldn't make it.

Forza not only looked better than GT5 it actually looked fun to playas well. I own both systems and Forza 3 will get my money without question.

sexy_robot_man

:) come on... so a gameplay vid for Forza3 were a guy was controlling a vehicle against AI cars on a track looked more fun that GT5 were a guy was controlling a vehicle against AI cars on a track made you believe one game looked more fun to play than the other??? SW you gotta love it :)

You were at GC? It's only a 3 hour drive from where Il ive, but I couldn't make it.NielsNL

Im 99% sure this is the E3 build

And this is a build a few weeks old

[QUOTE="sexy_robot_man"]

Forza not only looked better than GT5 it actually looked fun to playas well. I own both systems and Forza 3 will get my money without question.

Malta_1980

:) come on... so a gameplay vid for Forza3 were a guy was controlling a vehicle against AI cars on a track looked more fun that GT5 were a guy was controlling a vehicle against AI cars on a track made you believe one game looked more fun to play than the other??? SW you gotta love it :)

Well said! :D

Im 99% sure this is the E3 build

And this is a build a few weeks old

aero250

Both aren't gameplay footage.

[QUOTE="sexy_robot_man"]

Forza not only looked better than GT5 it actually looked fun to playas well. I own both systems and Forza 3 will get my money without question.

Malta_1980

:) come on... so a gameplay vid for Forza3 were a guy was controlling a vehicle against AI cars on a track looked more fun that GT5 were a guy was controlling a vehicle against AI cars on a track made you believe one game looked more fun to play than the other??? SW you gotta love it :)

[QUOTE="aero250"]

Im 99% sure this is the E3 build

And this is a build a few weeks old

Both aren't gameplay footage.

I mean come on GT is finally adding online on the 5th sequel :roll:sexy_robot_man

[QUOTE="aero250"]

Im 99% sure this is the E3 build

And this is a build a few weeks old

NielsNL

Both aren't gameplay footage.

I think this is the last gameplay vid

[QUOTE="sexy_robot_man"] I mean come on GT is finally adding online on the 5th sequel :roll:IronBass

[QUOTE="Malta_1980"]

[QUOTE="sexy_robot_man"]

Forza not only looked better than GT5 it actually looked fun to playas well. I own both systems and Forza 3 will get my money without question.

sexy_robot_man

:) come on... so a gameplay vid for Forza3 were a guy was controlling a vehicle against AI cars on a track looked more fun that GT5 were a guy was controlling a vehicle against AI cars on a track made you believe one game looked more fun to play than the other??? SW you gotta love it :)

and??

So with online = more fun, right?? in that case you will have more fun on GT5 since 16 players online is more fun than 8, right??

My point was that surely both titles will be great, but saying ' X looks like more fun than Y based on gameplay vids which basically did the same thing which is racing a car against AI ones on a track sounds ridiculous'.. (no offence)

[QUOTE="IronBass"][QUOTE="sexy_robot_man"] I mean come on GT is finally adding online on the 5th sequel :roll:aero250

true, but you know as much as i do that while Xbox had a good online setup, PS2 didnt.... GT5p though showed that GT titles surely give so much more replay value with added online modes and GT5 will be even better considering PD had more time to fix online and PSN is a solid online service..

Forza 1 had online.aero250

[QUOTE="NielsNL"]

[QUOTE="aero250"]

Im 99% sure this is the E3 build

And this is a build a few weeks old

Both aren't gameplay footage.

I think this is the last gameplay vid

[QUOTE="sexy_robot_man"] I mean come on GT is finally adding online on the 5th sequel :roll:IronBass

[QUOTE="aero250"]Forza 1 had online.IronBass

[QUOTE="NielsNL"]

[QUOTE="aero250"]

Im 99% sure this is the E3 build

And this is a build a few weeks old

PAL360

Both aren't gameplay footage.

I think this is the last gameplay vid

That's the one i already linked.

GT4 was going to have online and Sony scrapped the idea for some unknown reason. Gran Turismo 4 was released Jan 10 2005 The PS2 network adapter was released along with the HDD on July 19 2001. Sony dropped the ball period.sexy_robot_man

[QUOTE="IronBass"][QUOTE="sexy_robot_man"] I mean come on GT is finally adding online on the 5th sequel :roll:sexy_robot_man

No one is denying the first XBOX had better online capabilities than the PS2, which was the main issue here. But that was that gen, and this is this.

[QUOTE="IronBass"][QUOTE="aero250"]Forza 1 had online.aero250

You know what i mean.aero250

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="NielsNL"]

Both aren't gameplay footage.

aero250

I think this is the last gameplay vid

that the game has actually improved since E3 :| Why?

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="NielsNL"]

Both aren't gameplay footage.

NielsNL

I think this is the last gameplay vid

That's the one i already linked.

oh...my bad :P

[QUOTE="aero250"]You know what i mean.IronBass