Of all RTS, TBS, RPG, and Adventure games...

Of all the games in these four genres, which is your favorite, which do you think is the most overrated, and which do you think is the most underrated?

I'd say:

RTS:

Favorite: Command and Conquer 3

Underrated: Anything EA, Age of Empires III, Universe At War

Overrated: StarCraft or Age of Empires II

TBS:

Favorite: Civilzation III or Disciples II

Underrated: Any AW game other than Days of Ruin, Civilization III

Overrated: Advance Wars: Days of Ruin

RPG:

Favorite: Diablo II

Underrated: The Legend of Dragoon

Overrated: Pokemon FireRed and LeafGreen

Adventure:

Favorite: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

Underrated: The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap

Overrated: The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask

RTS:

Favorite: Warcraft III: Frozen Throne

Underrated: ... none I feel that most RTS are rated similar to my opinion.

Overrated: THE WHOLE DAMN GENERIC UNBALANCED COMMAND & CONQUER SERIES!

TBS:

Favorite: Civilzation IV

Underrated: Heroes of Might & Magic

Overrated: Fire Emblem's

RPG:

Favorite: Baldurs Gate II , Diablo II

Underrated: The Witcher, Mass Effect.

Overrated: All pokemons above Red/Blue/Yellow , Most FF games ( not all ) Neverwinter Night series.

I didnt do adventure ... adventure is point click stories ... Zelda is more action Adventure.

Of all the games in these four genres, which is your favorite, which do you think is the most overrated, and which do you think is the most underrated?

I'd say:

RTS:

Favorite: Command and Conquer 3

Underrated: Anything EA, Age of Empires III, Universe At War

Overrated: StarCraft or Age of Empires II

TBS:

Favorite: Civilzation III or Disciples II

Underrated: Any AW game other than Days of Ruin, Civilization III

Overrated: Advance Wars: Days of Ruin

RPG:

Favorite: Diablo II

Underrated: The Legend of Dragoon

Overrated: Pokemon FireRed and LeafGreen

Adventure:

Favorite: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

Underrated: The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap

Overrated: The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask

sc_ajk29

you are so freaking right about legend of dragoon, one of the most special rpgs imo

I'd say:

RTS:

Overrated: THE WHOLE DAMN GENERIC UNBALANCED COMMAND & CONQUER SERIES!

Meu2k7

Leave. Now.

If you think C&C is generic and unbalanced, you ain't seen nothin' yet, my friend.

*cough*generic = AOE2, unbalanced = StarCraft*cough*

Oh and BTW, I saw you gave C&C3 an 8.5. :lol:

[QUOTE="Meu2k7"]I'd say:

RTS:

Overrated: THE WHOLE DAMN GENERIC UNBALANCED COMMAND & CONQUER SERIES!

sc_ajk29

Leave. Now.

Denied. :P Ok, Il give credit to Red Alert 1 ... after than ... jokes.

Uh let see:

RTS:

Favorite: Starcraft

Underrated: World in Conflict

Overrated: Age of Empire III

TBS:

Favorite: Jeanne D'Arc(I loving it so much:D)

Overrated: ?

Underrated: Jeanne D'Arc

RPG:

Favorite: Kingdom Hearts, Pokemon Gold, and Guild Wars

Overrated: FFXII

Underrated: FFIII DS

Adventure:

Favorite: A Link to the Past

Overrated: Twilight Princess

Underrated: The Minish Cap

RTS:

Favorite: Starcraft, Warcraft 3, Dawn of War, Company of Heroes

Underrated: World in Conflict, it got high. But not high enough for me :D

Overrated: Command and Conquer. It's good, but not THAT good.

TBS:

Favorite: Civilzation IV

Underrated: Galactc Civilization 2

Overrated: Fire Emblem's

RPG:

Favorite: Diablo 2, Fallout 1/2

Underrated: The Witcher

Overrated: Neverwinter Night's series.

EDIT: HOW COULD I FORGET FALLOUT!?

Favorite: WarCraft III

Underrated: Dawn of War

Overrated: Age of Empires III

TBS:

Favorite: Heroes of Might and Magic 3

Underrated: Heroes of Might and Magic 2

Overrated: Uhhh...I haven't played an overrated TBS.

RPG:

Favorite: Fallout

Underrated: Fallout 2

Overrated: Oblivion

Adventure:

Favorite: Grim Fandango

Underrated: Riven

Overrated: Indigo Prophecy

I will do 5 genres, since the TC seems to have mixed up adventure with action-adventure :)

RTS:

Favorite: Close Combat 3

Underrated: Squad Assault

Overrated: Total Anihilation

TBS:

Favorite:Galatic Civilizations 2

Underrated: Lords of Magic

Overrated: Advance Wars

RPG:

Favorite: Fallout

Underrated: Vampire: Bloodlines

Overrated: Oblivion

Adventure:

Favorite: Riven: the sequel to Myst

Underrated: Dark Eye

Overrated: Fahrenheit


Action-Adventure:

Favorite: Outcast

Underrated: Omikron

Overrated: Zelda: OoT

RTS

the best - starcrat, C&C, ROME, CIVILIZATION.

underrated-sins of a solar empire.

overrated - age of mythology

[QUOTE="Meu2k7"]I'd say:

RTS:

Overrated: THE WHOLE DAMN GENERIC UNBALANCED COMMAND & CONQUER SERIES!

sc_ajk29

Leave. Now.

If you think C&C is generic and unbalanced, you ain't seen nothin' yet, my friend.

*cough*generic = AOE2, unbalanced = StarCraft*cough*

Oh and BTW, I saw you gave C&C3 an 8.5. :lol:

Starcraft unbalanced? You sir, leave now.

RTS
Favourite: Warlords Battlecry 2
Underrated: Battle Realms
Overrated: Warcraft 3

RPG
Favourite: Planescape Torment
Underrated: The Witcher
Overrated: Oblivion

Adventure
Favourite: Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge
Underrated: Dreamfall: The Longest Journey
Overrated: Broken Sword (all of them)

RTS:

Favourite : Starcraft

Underated : Battle Realms, Age of Mythology

Overated : Command and Conquer 3, Age of empires

TBS

Favourite : HoMM 3

Underrated : HoMM 4

Overated : Civilization Series

RPG :

Favourite : Planescape Torment

Underated : Vampire - Bloodlines

Overated : Oblivion, FFX, FFXII, Suikoden 3

Adventure :

Favourite : Grim Fadango

Underrated : Riven

Overated : Dreamfall

RTS:

Favorite: Warcraft 3: the frozen throne

Underrated: Same as above game.

Overrated: any AoE game

TBS:

Favorite: AW: days of ruin

Underrated: N/A

Overrated: N/A

RPG:

Favorite: Morrowind

Underrated: FFIV

Overrated: FFX

Adventure:

Favorite: DMC4 >.>'

Underrated: Dead Rising

Overrated: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

RTS:

Favorite: Warcraft 3

Underrated: Homeworld

Overrated: Company of Heroes

TBS:

Favorite: Heroes of Might and Magic 3

Underrated: X-COM: UFO Defense/Enemy Unknown

Overrated: None that I can think of

RPG:

Favorite: Fallout 2

Underrated: Ultima series

Overrated: Jade Empire

Adventure:

Favorite: A Link to the Past

Underrated: Monkey Island

Overrated: No More Heroes

-------------------

Planeforger, you made a major mistake. You admitted that Oblivion is a RPG :P

RTS:

Favorite: Company of Heroes

Underrated: Homeworld, Universe at War: Earth Assault

Overrated: Warcraft 3, Starcraft

TBS:

Favorite: Galactic Civilizations 2

Underrated: I dont know. I don't play a whole lot of them.

Overrated: I dont know. I don't play a whole lot of them.

RPG:

Favorite: Mass Effect

Underrated: Vampire the Masquerade - (Both Redemption & Bloodlines)

Overrated: Oblivion

RTS:

Favorite: Anything with Total War onit....

Underrated: Total War+Hearts of Iron (Paradox etc)

Overrated: Warcraft 3, Starcraft *enter dumbed down pathetic Dune2 clo(w)ne*

TBS:

Favorite: Galactic Civilizations 2, CIVIII

Underrated: HOOMV.

Overrated: CIV4.

RPG:

Favorite: ESIII, Diablo2

Underrated: Maybe Witcher

Overrated: Oblivion

RTS

favorite: DoW, starcraft

underrated: DoW

overrated: AoE 3, CnC 3

TBS

favorite: silent storm

underrated: silent storm

overrated: ummm cant think of anything

RPG

favorite: fallout

underrated: ummm cant think of anything

overrated: FF

RTS

Favorite: Starcraft, Dawn of War, Red Alert 2

Underrated: Dawn of War

Overrated: CnC 3

RPG: Dunno(don't play much RPGs)

TBS:

Favorite: Total War series

Underrated: Europa Universilis 3

Overrated: Dunno

RTS:

Favourite: C&C 2: Red Alert

Underated: WIC

Overated: Warcraft 3

RPG:

Favourite: FFVII and KOTOR 1

Underated: Fallout

Overated: FFX

Adventure:

Favourite: Grim Fandango

Overated: Syberia(series)

Underated: Farenheight

TPS:

Favourite: Gears Of War

Overated: Tomb raider series

Underated: RE 4(should've been AAAA:P)

RTS:

Favorite: Command and Conquer 3

Underrated: Anything EA, Age of Empires III, Universe At War

Overrated: StarCraft or Age of Empires II

sc_ajk29

Leave. Now.

If you think C&C is generic and unbalanced, you ain't seen nothin' yet, my friend.

*cough*generic = AOE2, unbalanced = StarCraft*cough*

Oh and BTW, I saw you gave C&C3 an 8.5. :lol:

sc_ajk29

How can you actually tell other people to leave when you're own list is poor. C&C3? Age of Empires 3?? Universe at war?????

RTS:

Favorite: Total Annihilation

Most underrated: Total Annihilation

Most overrated: Starcraft (yes, I said it)

TBS:

Favorite: Fire Emblem

Underrated: idk

Overrated: idk

RPG:

Favorite: KotOR

Most underrated: Tales of Symphonia

Most overrated: any FF after 7

Adventure:

Favorite: Metroid Prime

I'll only do RTS - It's the only genre I play other than FPS games.

Favourite: Company of Heroes / Dawn of War / Homeworld

Underrated: Dawn of War / Homeworld

Overrated: Age of Empires 3 / Starcraft / Warcraft 3