Out of these three 9.5/10 games, which is the most deserving of the score?

9.5: Superb

"We absolutely recommend any game in this range, especially to fans of that particular genre. However, games that score in the 9 range are also typically well suited to new players. Games that earn 9s are naturally uncommon, and earn GameSpot's Editors' Choice Award for their outstanding quality."

Out of:

Which is the most deserving of the 9.5 score, in your opinion?

The score is extremely difficult to get on Gamespot and many feel that certain games deserved that score but just missed out. Out of the 3 recent 9.5/10s, which do you feel is the most deserving of the excellent score? ie. Which is the best of the best?

What do you guys think?

Can't believe I'm doing this...but SMG. The game is insanely fun. I do believe Crysis deserved it's score as well, but SMG the most.

EDIT: Just want to say that I haven't been this impressed with a Mario game in a looooong time.

Super Mario Galaxychocolate1325

Super Mario Galaxychocolate1325

Pretty much.

Mario Galaxy IMO for rejuvenating the platforming genre.

2nd most deserving would probably have to be Crisis for breaking the graphics barrier.

Super Mario Galaxychocolate1325

agreed

Tough. Halo 3 I believe should be a 9.0. It's a fantastic game, but does nothing new with the series, except Forge mode.

Crysis is a technical marvel, but as a game you should buy, you might have you overhaul your PC. I guess that should bring it down to a 9.0, due to the money you have to spend on it.

But really, that's not a good reason. But it's something, so I guess that leaves Mario Galaxy.

Crysis and SMG deserved it (I think Halo 3 deserved a 9.0 or possibly an 8.5 based on previous GS reviews). I guess I would say SMG deserved it more. So far, there hasn't been a single review that has called SMG anything less than fantastic. No game has battled with Ocarina of Time for the top spot this long.

SMG.

Sunshine all but killed my love for the franchise, and Galaxy brought my love back in full force. Wonderful game no matter how good the others are.

SMG.

SMG for sure, halo 3 is 2nd, crysis.. not so muchdipper145

[QUOTE="dipper145"]SMG for sure, halo 3 is 2nd, crysis.. not so muchMikerules868

People always forget about that game, poor Massive :(

Crysis.

Halo 3 to me seemed like Halo 2 with a fresh coat of paint, and that's what Halo 2 was to Halo 1 only it added online.

Super Mario Galaxy deserved a 10.

1. Super Mario Galaxy

2. Crysis

3. Halo 3

Super Mario Galaxychocolate1325

Boy I have to Admit.

Seeing SMG I have to say that game puts wii in a whole new light for me (Just about sold on buying one)

ANd I've probably never said anything good about the Wii

Crysis

Then halo 3

then smg

SMG deserved a 10.

Crysis.bignice12

Super Mario Galaxychocolate1325

That wouldn't be fair for me to say, as I haven't played Crysis. However, between Halo 3 and Galaxy, I have to go for the latter. The designers made some fantastic levels, and sorry for potential spoilers, but the Toy Time Galaxy (which housed an incredibly frustrating Purple Coin task) was likely my favorite.

That wouldn't be fair for me to say, as I haven't played Crysis. However, between Halo 3 and Galaxy, I have to go for the latter. The designers made some fantastic levels, and sorry for potential spoilers, but the Toy Time Galaxy (which housed an incredibly frustrating Purple Coin task) was likely my favorite.

WeAreToast

Heavy Metal Mecha Bowser was the coolest thing ever.

[QUOTE="WeAreToast"]

That wouldn't be fair for me to say, as I haven't played Crysis. However, between Halo 3 and Galaxy, I have to go for the latter. The designers made some fantastic levels, and sorry for potential spoilers, but the Toy Time Galaxy (which housed an incredibly frustrating Purple Coin task) was likely my favorite.

sexy_chimp

Heavy Metal Mecha Bowser was the coolest thing ever.

Any Toy Time level except for Luigi's Purple Coins = Awesome.

Luigi's Purple Coins = @#$%!!!!!