PC gaming the best? Not

Always hear claims that PC has more AAA exclusivesthanany ofthe consoles. I think this might not be true. So to test I will take argubly(sp?) the best three years of last gen consoles (2003, 2004, 2005) and compare gameranking scores of 90 and up from PC, XBOX, PS2 and GC for each year. Then I will whittle down to exclusives. - Two edits

XBOX

2003 :8 games GTA:DP,KOTOR,PGR2.PoP:Sands of Time,SCII,NCAA2004,Panzer Dragoon Orta,ESIII:Morrowing GOYE

2004: 5 games: Halo2,Burnout 3:Takedown,SC:PT,NG,NFL 2K5

2005:7 games NG:Black, SC:CT, Forza,GTA:SA,Psychonauts,Burnout Revenge,Winning Eleven 8

20 total games - 19 because NG and Black are the same game (but SSX3 just missed but 90+ on other consoles) 3 exclusive, 2 could be considered as it was 3 years before they got on another system 3-5

GC:

2003: 7 games: Loz:WW, SCII, SSX3,Viewtiful Joe,PoP:SoT,Madden 2004,NCAA2004

2004: 1 Game: MP2:Echoes

2005: 1 Game: RE4

Total 9 games 2 Exclusive + 1 times that didn't get 90+ on other system 2-3

PS2:

2003: 8 Games: R&C:Going Commando, Tony Hawk Underground, VF4:Evolution, SCII, PoP:SoT,Madden2004,SSX3,NCCA2004

2004: 7 Games: GTA:SA,Burnout 3: Winning Eleven 7, R&C UYA,MGS3: SE, PES4,Madden2005

2005: 6 Games: RE4,GoW,Guitar Hero,SotC,Winning Eleven 8, Burnout Revenge

21 total 6 Exclusive

PC:

2003: 4 Games GTA:VC,KOTOR,CoD,Splinter Cell

2004: 6 Games: HL2, UT 2004, WoW, Rome:TW,Chronicles of RiddicK, The Sims2

2005: 4 Games: Civ IV,GTA;SA,SC:CT,Battlefield 2

14 total 6 exclusives

PS2 21 total, Xbox 19 total, PC 14 total, GC 9 total - fail to see PC dominance here - am I missing something? Next edit Exclusives

PS2 6 exclusives, PC 6 Exclusives, Xbox 3(to 5) exclusives, GC 2(to3) exlusives - still not seeing the dominance here Pc ties PS2 and Xbo is imo i behind. Where is the dominance.

Then if we actaully see how many games were out for each system and what percentage.... - well that's a different argument

Always hear claims that PC has more AAA exclusivesthanany ofthe consoles. I think this might not be true. So to test I will take argubly(sp?) the best three years of last gen consoles (2003, 2004, 2005) and compare gameranking scores of 90 and up from PC, XBOX, PS2 and GC for each year. Then I will whittle down to exclusives. - Two edits

thew13

You're looking to get your feeling hurt son.

Thats nice, we go by gamespot. Last generation the PC led with 69 AAA titles, .... insurmountable AA titles, and lord knows how many A titles. The closest follow was the PS2 with 60 AAA titles. So far this gen, the PC has accumulated 8 AAA titles and 48(?) AA titles. Nearly three times the 360.Vandalvideo

You've obviously never had a decent gaming PC otherwise you wouldn't have made this ridiculous thread.

PC Standards > Any Console Standards and it still gets more AAA and AA games.

How many hack and slash dungeon crawler and rts and fps infest the pc a year, this is why i hate pc gaming.benjaminbuckner

And what type of games do you like?

Problems with PC gaming: too small screen, lack of split-screen multiplayer, and no controllers. Upside great graphics.casey7672

[QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"]How many hack and slash dungeon crawler and rts and fps infest the pc a year, this is why i hate pc gaming.Philmon

And what type of games do you like?

JRpgs, action adventure, games like shadow of the collousous, platformers, fighting games.

[QUOTE="casey7672"]Problems with PC gaming: too small screen, lack of split-screen multiplayer, and no controllers. Upside great graphics.Vandalvideo

Who hooks their PC's up to their HDTV's? And what PC uses a PS3 six axis controller?

Problems with PC gaming: lack of split-screen multiplayer. Upside great graphics and unsurpassed multiplayer.casey7672

Fixed.

Who hooks their PC's up to their HDTV's? And what PC uses a PS3 six axis controller?

casey7672

*raises hand*

Insecure Lemming anti-PC thread number 2134.

Here it goes again

Since Xbox 360 Release :

Total AAA (# exclusive)

* PC: 9 (5)
* Xbox 360: 7 (3)
* Wii: 3 (1)
* PS3: 3 (0)

Total AA (# exclusive)

* PC: 62 (44)
* Xbox 360: 52 (6)
* PS3: 20 (1)
* Wii: 19 (1)

A little outdated (not even over a month, but it includes Bioshock)

.... rofl 6 AA exclusives compared to 44. Epic phail.

Problems with PC gaming: too small screen, lack of split-screen multiplayer, and no controllers. Upside great graphics.casey7672

Stupidest Post I've ever seen, Someone has already said they hook upto HD tv's and the moniters can range between 15" and 30"

Who hooks their PC's up to their HDTV's? And what PC uses a PS3 six axis controller?casey7672

pc agming is the best bicause: pc have the biggest number of exclusives pc have the best games and mouse and keyboard is much more better than contollersFIghterFX

what was the last AAA exclusive.

[QUOTE="FIghterFX"]pc agming is the best bicause: pc have the biggest number of exclusives pc have the best games and mouse and keyboard is much more better than contollersbenjaminbuckner

what was the last AAA exclusive.

See link in my sig. TC = fail.

Stupid you say. I don't know of any PC monitors that go to 65" 1080p. I was just trying to make pros and cons so kiss my butt!casey7672

[QUOTE="FIghterFX"]pc agming is the best bicause: pc have the biggest number of exclusives pc have the best games and mouse and keyboard is much more better than contollersbenjaminbuckner

what was the last AAA exclusive.

what is aaa? 0_o

[QUOTE="gamerchris810"]

[QUOTE="casey7672"]Problems with PC gaming: too small screen, lack of split-screen multiplayer, and no controllers. Upside great graphics.casey7672

Stupidest Post I've ever seen, Someone has already said they hook upto HD tv's and the moniters can range between 15" and 30"

Stupid you say. I don't know of any PC monitors that go to 65" 1080p. I was just trying to make pros and cons so kiss my butt!

But your only con is lack of split screen multiplayer. Because you can use a controller on a PC and you can hook up your pc to any tv. Even the 100 inch projectors.

[QUOTE="gamerchris810"]

[QUOTE="casey7672"]Problems with PC gaming: too small screen, lack of split-screen multiplayer, and no controllers. Upside great graphics.casey7672

Stupidest Post I've ever seen, Someone has already said they hook upto HD tv's and the moniters can range between 15" and 30"

Stupid you say. I don't know of any PC monitors that go to 65" 1080p. I was just trying to make pros and cons so kiss my butt!

Ok so hook up PC to Tv End of. PC owns. And answer to your second comment, how childish.

[QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"]

[QUOTE="FIghterFX"]pc agming is the best bicause: pc have the biggest number of exclusives pc have the best games and mouse and keyboard is much more better than contollersVandalvideo

what was the last AAA exclusive.

How many hack and slash dungeon crawler and rts and fps infest the pc a year, this is why i hate pc gaming.benjaminbuckner

[QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"]How many hack and slash dungeon crawler and rts and fps infest the pc a year, this is why i hate pc gaming.legol1

I have no idea what you just said. :|

[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"][QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"]

[QUOTE="FIghterFX"]pc agming is the best bicause: pc have the biggest number of exclusives pc have the best games and mouse and keyboard is much more better than contollersgingerdivid

what was the last AAA exclusive.

Not exclusive, its on the xbox360

[QUOTE="Philmon"]

[QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"]How many hack and slash dungeon crawler and rts and fps infest the pc a year, this is why i hate pc gaming.benjaminbuckner

And what type of games do you like?

JRpgs, action adventure, games like shadow of the collousous, platformers, fighting games.

PC's do get Action Adventure games, hell even RE4 and DMC3 made it to the PC. As for platformers guess which system had the last AAA platform game? Here is a cule.

[QUOTE="gingerdivid"][QUOTE="Vandalvideo"][QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"]

[QUOTE="FIghterFX"]pc agming is the best bicause: pc have the biggest number of exclusives pc have the best games and mouse and keyboard is much more better than contollersMeu2k7

what was the last AAA exclusive.

Not exclusive, its on the xbox360

The last AAAE for the PC was Galactic Civilizations II: Dread Lords. See the full list for each platform here.

[QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"][QUOTE="Philmon"]

[QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"]How many hack and slash dungeon crawler and rts and fps infest the pc a year, this is why i hate pc gaming.Philmon

And what type of games do you like?

JRpgs, action adventure, games like shadow of the collousous, platformers, fighting games.

PC's do get Action Adventure games, hell even RE4 and DMC3 made it to the PC. As for platformers guess which system had the last AAA platform game? Here is a cule.

xbox live arcade my friend.

[QUOTE="legol1"][QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"]How many hack and slash dungeon crawler and rts and fps infest the pc a year, this is why i hate pc gaming.NerdMan

I have no idea what you just said. :|

[QUOTE="legol1"][QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"]How many hack and slash dungeon crawler and rts and fps infest the pc a year, this is why i hate pc gaming.NerdMan

I have no idea what you just said. :|

Thats nice, we go by gamespot. Last generation the PC led with 69 AAA titles, .... insurmountable AA titles, and lord knows how many A titles. The closest follow was the PS2 with 60 AAA titles. So far this gen, the PC has accumulated 8 AAA titles and 48(?) AA titles. Nearly three times the 360.Vandalvideo

Just going by Gameranking cause it is easier to sort - Also when new consoles come out, there is usually a catchup time period, PC never has an adjustment period - that is why I use 2003-2005 - IF PC is os superior it should kill consoles even during console peak years

[QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"][QUOTE="Philmon"]

[QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"]How many hack and slash dungeon crawler and rts and fps infest the pc a year, this is why i hate pc gaming.Philmon

And what type of games do you like?

JRpgs, action adventure, games like shadow of the collousous, platformers, fighting games.

PC's do get Action Adventure games, hell even RE4 and DMC3 made it to the PC. As for platformers guess which system had the last AAA platform game? Here is a cule.

That game is actually on Xbox Live arcade.

Just going by Gameranking cause it is easier to sort - Also when new consoles come out, there is usually a catchup time period, PC never has an adjustment period - that is why I use 2003-2005 - IF PC is os superior it should kill consoles even during console peak yearsthew13

[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"]Thats nice, we go by gamespot. Last generation the PC led with 69 AAA titles, .... insurmountable AA titles, and lord knows how many A titles. The closest follow was the PS2 with 60 AAA titles. So far this gen, the PC has accumulated 8 AAA titles and 48(?) AA titles. Nearly three times the 360.thew13

Just going by Gameranking cause it is easier to sort - Also when new consoles come out, there is usually a catchup time period, PC never has an adjustment period - that is why I use 2003-2005 - IF PC is os superior it should kill consoles even during console peak years

The question is , after this holiday, what does the 360 have? The Pc has already suprassed the PS3's 2008 lineup let alone the 360's 2008 of nearly nothiness.

Always hear claims that PC has more AAA exclusivesthanany ofthe consoles. I think this might not be true. So to test I will take argubly(sp?) the best three years of last gen consoles (2003, 2004, 2005) and compare gameranking scores of 90 and up from PC, XBOX, PS2 and GC for each year. Then I will whittle down to exclusives. - Two edits

thew13

You can not use a site like gamerankings, simply because the accumilated scores are not from the same sources. If you are going to make a list at least use a single site that reviews games on all the platforms for a much more accurate comparison.

[QUOTE="thew13"]

[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"]Thats nice, we go by gamespot. Last generation the PC led with 69 AAA titles, .... insurmountable AA titles, and lord knows how many A titles. The closest follow was the PS2 with 60 AAA titles. So far this gen, the PC has accumulated 8 AAA titles and 48(?) AA titles. Nearly three times the 360.Meu2k7

Just going by Gameranking cause it is easier to sort - Also when new consoles come out, there is usually a catchup time period, PC never has an adjustment period - that is why I use 2003-2005 - IF PC is os superior it should kill consoles even during console peak years

The question is , after this holiday, what does the 360 have? The Pc has already suprassed the PS3's 2008 lineup let alone the 360's 2008 of nearly nothiness.

what does pc have all it games go to 360 and the other way around.

[QUOTE="Meu2k7"][QUOTE="thew13"]

[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"]Thats nice, we go by gamespot. Last generation the PC led with 69 AAA titles, .... insurmountable AA titles, and lord knows how many A titles. The closest follow was the PS2 with 60 AAA titles. So far this gen, the PC has accumulated 8 AAA titles and 48(?) AA titles. Nearly three times the 360.benjaminbuckner

Just going by Gameranking cause it is easier to sort - Also when new consoles come out, there is usually a catchup time period, PC never has an adjustment period - that is why I use 2003-2005 - IF PC is os superior it should kill consoles even during console peak years

The question is , after this holiday, what does the 360 have? The Pc has already suprassed the PS3's 2008 lineup let alone the 360's 2008 of nearly nothiness.

what does pc have all it games go to 360 and the other way around.

really...?

Since Xbox 360 Release :

Total AAA (# exclusive)

* PC: 9 (5)
* Xbox 360: 7 (3)
* Wii: 3 (1)
* PS3: 3 (0)

Total AA (# exclusive)

* PC: 62 (44)
* Xbox 360: 52 (6)
* PS3: 20 (1)
* Wii: 19 (1)

tells a different story ... silly lemming , look at the exclusives difference :P

[QUOTE="thew13"]

[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"]Thats nice, we go by gamespot. Last generation the PC led with 69 AAA titles, .... insurmountable AA titles, and lord knows how many A titles. The closest follow was the PS2 with 60 AAA titles. So far this gen, the PC has accumulated 8 AAA titles and 48(?) AA titles. Nearly three times the 360.Meu2k7

Just going by Gameranking cause it is easier to sort - Also when new consoles come out, there is usually a catchup time period, PC never has an adjustment period - that is why I use 2003-2005 - IF PC is os superior it should kill consoles even during console peak years

The question is , after this holiday, what does the 360 have? The Pc has already suprassed the PS3's 2008 lineup let alone the 360's 2008 of nearly nothiness.

Not saying there aren't years the PC is superior, just that it is not that vast a difference and when consoles get into year 3+ they will even things out if not gai. look at my original post now

[QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"][QUOTE="Philmon"]

[QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"]How many hack and slash dungeon crawler and rts and fps infest the pc a year, this is why i hate pc gaming.Philmon

And what type of games do you like?

JRpgs, action adventure, games like shadow of the collousous, platformers, fighting games.

PC's do get Action Adventure games, hell even RE4 and DMC3 made it to the PC. As for platformers guess which system had the last AAA platform game? Here is a cule.

[QUOTE="Philmon"][QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"][QUOTE="Philmon"]

[QUOTE="benjaminbuckner"]How many hack and slash dungeon crawler and rts and fps infest the pc a year, this is why i hate pc gaming.rexoverbey

And what type of games do you like?

JRpgs, action adventure, games like shadow of the collousous, platformers, fighting games.

PC's do get Action Adventure games, hell even RE4 and DMC3 made it to the PC. As for platformers guess which system had the last AAA platform game? Here is a cule.

forza 2 motorsport my friend.