Poll: Would you be OK with detachable next gen controllers?

I'm not closed off to the possibility, but sacrificing ergonomics to attempt to push infantile/gimmicky gameplay concepts will be considered a fatal misstep, so much so I would withhold from a purchase until down the road.

That would suck but so far, I think ergonomics can get quite a boost if the controllers are at least 2 parts since you are able to have more several positions comfortably available to the user. General shape and button positioning need to be improved for the new design, definitely.

No. Too much like the garbage controllers Nintendo has been putting out. No thank you.

Totally. Detachable is an option. Those who don't like it don't need to do it. An extra option is never a bad thing

Yes please.

I already have detached controllers on my next-gen system. They are called mouse and keyboard. :)

Depends, as long as the system is like the switch and allows multiple controllers, it's all gravy.

Depends on the console

It seem like an unnecessary idea for PlayStation or Xbox, but I makes sense Nintendo since they've been doing that sorta thing. I never thought any controller I've used needed that kind of option, I've had any comfort issues. Maybe if they re-release the OG ps1 with remastered they should think about a cool controller update as well

I'm okay with current gen detachable controllers, the Switch Joycon are outstanding. Sony has reason to emulate the idea, and be able to use the two-piece setup for "Move type" VR stuff but that makes it more expensive, even though some will never use the feature and M$ has no reason to at all so I doubt this will become commonplace.

Thank you but no, thank you.

Noice. xD

Yup!

I see.

Looking at the DS4 (gyro, lights) and the PSVR Headset, it can seen a natural evolution of the PS brand though.

Perhaps a new detachable controller style could give us something more ergonomic and have more buttons to improve gameplay.

Definitely more comfy. Imagine just separating your hands and lying them on each of your side during a couch session. That's already a far more neutral position. You could even play in bed and actively shift positions way easier without letting go of the controllers.

Oh wow. Time for 9th Gen power glove!? J/K.. or maybe.. hmm.. nahh.. hmm.. I do wonder if gloves can become a thing for future stuff. Gestures and able to use far more inputs. I guess that's for way too far down the line huh?

i have no desire in gimmicks,just give me a regular controller with a lengthy battery life

DS3 was perfect in that department

We survived Detachable Penis, so I'm sure we can get through that.

I remember those. Otherwise known as the Bobbitt. lol Wasn't the most popular thing on the block. :P

Sure. With an option for a "Pro" controller as well, then I would have no problems.

Seeing how it works so well on the Switch, my answer is definitely.

Do you mean like the Switch?

I think the joycons are useful for their intention but in terms of the button size, ergonomics and button positions, it leaves me wanting. All the same, they serve their purpose and there are alternatives any way. As long as there is a purpose for them, why not? :)

Yay Sony to copy Nintendo again like with the motion controllers. I say Hell no! Lame gimmicks

Like the Nintendo Switch? Nintendo needs to call their consoles what they are, The Nintendo Gimmick. Nintendo Gimmick 2, 3, 4. It's obviously what their consoles are.

Depends on the functionality and the system. I'm more inclined towards the traditional controller but something like what the Switch is doing seems fine to me. I not really all that interested in VR though so that kind of functionality isn't too compelling for me.

I tried playing Mario Kart on the Switch with the joycons as one whole controller and did not like it. I'm hoping the rumor of a Switch-esq PlayStation are false. Sony doesn't need to waste money in the handheld space anymore.

Wait. What? xD

I guess that still has to be done specially for handicaps that might be used to having a unibody controller. This isn't sarcasm btw. I hope better controls for physical handicaps and hastening of body recovery/augmentation/prosthetics at mass market price.

How I wish I had enough spare cash for any a 3DS or a Switch.

Something more ergonomic. The Switch default handheld controllers are compromised for size and from my imagination of a PS/Xbox controllers, it probably won't be for 1 controller splitting into two for 2 players but more for ergonomics and probably better/more inputs.

I doubt those rumors and this won't really be for handhelds or at least any traditional handheld controller.

@j2zon2591:

Hell no.

Have you even used the Switch controller? Or are you just going off what you think to be true?

Yes, and it's goofy. No thank you.

"Goofy," how?

@clone01: omfg lol. U have to be trolling. That thing is the stupidest controller Nintendo has ever made.

Not remotely. It works quite well, actually. omfg, lol.

@clone01: omfg lololol

I like Nintendo too, but the switch and it's goofy controller are a complete disaster.

How? Please explain.

No... don't force crap on me I don't want. If I want controls for VR then I will buy them separately.

Yep!

I love this!! He doesn't agree with the majority opinion and that's ok.

Remember, you only speak for you

I'm not sure if I understand the idea of this detachable controller.

Hell No, keep that Nintendo crap within the Nintendo bubble.

Who says the majority of gamers likes detachable controllers?

Unlikely.

My problem with his statements are that they are a sweeping generalization based entirely on a slanted opinion. Detachable or not, the Joycon works. Its analog sticks, shoulder, and face buttons are responsive and functional. To call it garbage is erroneous.

I am a fan of detachable/modular controllers. I think the form factor of the Wii controller was theoretically perfect.

It could be used modularly:

1. Wii/nunchuk for motion controls

2. B.O.S.S. for normal games that need normal controllers like NSMBU or Punch out

3. Arcade Stick-it could attach as an arcade stick for stuff like Tatsunoko vs Capcom

4. Light gun attatchment for light gun games

This is the perfect idea imo. now the execution during the Wii gen wasn't something to write home about but that is how a controller can best be utilized moving forward.

"Functional"

When did I say they did?

The majority of posts on this forum are favorable to Switch. That was the majority I was speaking of. He obviously doesn't like the joycon

Those that own the Switch maybe, but not the majority of people here believe that.

Still not what I am saying. I am going by posts, not beliefs. I don't know how everyone here feel or believe. I do know I have read more favorable posts about Switch then unfavorable since it released.

Well, forget VR for a second (though I'm a big fan)... anything that increases accessibility and ease of use for people with disabilities... count me the f*** in.

Yeah from people who own the Switch. Nintendo fans will hype just about anything Nintendo releases so that ain't saying much.

There's nothing more comfortable than the wiimote + nunchuck (Or separated joy con) way of holding a controller. So relaxed. Feels great. Those saying no are living in the stone age of gaming.

I don't keep a tally of what everyone owns here.