Well maybe we should ask who walked out of E3 with the most momentum (Mind and Marketshare)? Marketshare meaning a tangible boost in unit sales immediately after E3? That's the true tell.
This topic is locked from further discussion.
[QUOTE="heretrix"]
If it's all about the games then Nintendo won.
finalstar2007
Then why didnt they say Nintendo on that video??.. each has his/her own intrest/tastes. for me Sony won then Nintendo comes second
I don't give a crap about that video. What I give a crap about is awesome announcements. Nintendo announced game after game after game then closed the show with hot chicks bringing 3DS's out for the crowd to see.That's how you friggin do it. Sony's press conference was filled with commercials and friggin montages.As much as I enjoyed the Kevin Butler appearance and I'm certainly more interested in Sony's offerings than Ninty's, Nintendo simply had the better show.Most of the stuff Sony showed was announced already.
[QUOTE="coasterguy65"]
[QUOTE="TehNubTuber"] What can I say...
TehNubTuber
What does a Panda on a kids toy have to do with haters?
Dude how can you not get it :P
So bashing the Wii and the 360 like you do isn't hating? Man I'm done wasting my time on this.
Although I agree that Nintendo won best E3 conference, I think that GT is correct in saying that the PS3 had the best software lineup (excluding 3DS since it isnt out)
[QUOTE="93soccer"]All about games. Nintendo wiped the floor with Sony and MS at E3 2010FIipMode
Wait slow down, while I agree Nintendo won they didnt really wipe the floor with Sony, they had a great lineup of games too.
pretty simple....for everyone who says Nintendo won E3 because of the games....lets list them....
lets list all the games that were shown from Sony and Nintendo...... as far as home console, IT IS NOT EVEN CLOSE.....but still lets add everything together...all the games that were shown....
I'll just talk about Sony.... I think they did a great job of showing upcoming games, demoing games, and had some nice suprises as well with Portal and Twisted Metal.
If it is about games, 3DS won. Which means Nintendo won E3.
AmayaPapaya
Well to be more precise, they were simply tech demoes, similar to the infamous Final Fantasy 7 tech demo shown at E3 2005 at Sony's conference. However I will agree on how Nintendo did win E3 overall but the line-up of games coming out "this" year on the Wii, I personally prefer what the my PS3 has to offer. If Zelda Skyward Sword or Pikmin were announced for this fall, the Wii would've soo won for me. So far, Kirby Epic Yarn, Sonic Colors & Donkey Kong Country Returns are the main 3 games that really interest me on the Wii.
That being said, I still think Nintendo's E3 was probably the best they have had in a long time. We haven't really had an actually good E3 from Nintendo since 2005 (since 2006 was mostly about new tech and I was rather skeptical with the whole Wii mantra).
[QUOTE="TehNubTuber"]
[QUOTE="coasterguy65"]
What does a Panda on a kids toy have to do with haters?
coasterguy65
Dude how can you not get it :P
So bashing the Wii and the 360 like you do isn't hating? Man I'm done wasting my time on this.
Just watch the vid 8)[QUOTE="TehNubTuber"][QUOTE="Microsoft1234"]i think you have sony confused with nintendoHalf-Way
watch it again without the (fanboy)glasses 8)
Same result, PS3 won :DSheeps are in Denial now, GT knows what they are doing and they are absolutely right.
You guys actually think Wii has a shot at best software line up? LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL
mysterj
GT? didnt they put MW2 as their GOTY 09`? :P
and they also said "nintendo wii was just behind with its lineup"
so sony had software, while nintendo had both software and hardware
If PS3 won E3 it must have done it on exclusives since basically all its multiplats are on the 360. And what exclusives stole the show and made everyone go wow or mega impressed? TBh, Sony showed sequels to popular games, they didn't do much worth winning E3 imo. Not to MS won, if Sony was decent, MS was terrible. The winner of E3 to me was nintendo, but even then, its mainly because 3DS looks Godly.
[QUOTE="mysterj"]
Sheeps are in Denial now, GT knows what they are doing and they are absolutely right.
You guys actually think Wii has a shot at best software line up? LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL
Half-Way
GT? didnt they put MW2 as their GOTY 09`? :P
and they also said "nintendo wii was just behind with its lineup"
so sony had software, while nintendo had both software and hardware
Meh to GT's GOTY 2009. PS3 still had better software line up, which has nothing to do with 3DS. I sense damage control.To those who havent botherd to watch the video its not nintendo .v microsoft vs sony
Its PC vs PS3 vs DS vs 360 vs wii
If PS3 won E3 it must have done it on exclusives since basically all its multiplats are on the 360. And what exclusives stole the show and made everyone go wow or mega impressed? TBh, Sony showed sequels to popular games, they didn't do much worth winning E3 imo. Not to MS won, if Sony was decent, MS was terrible. The winner of E3 to me was nintendo, but even then, its mainly because 3DS looks Godly.
ActicEdge
And thats all wii ever does so why does it matter
Im beginning to thing ppl didnt even watch the video :roll:Yeah...no.
Sony was 2nd...by far. Nintendo was the clear "winner" of this year's E3.
The_Game21x
[QUOTE="The_Game21x"]Im beginning to thing ppl didnt even watch the video :roll: If all you're basing this on is quantity, then perhaps Sony did win E3 but even then, it's arguable that Nintendo would still take home the gold.Yeah...no.
Sony was 2nd...by far. Nintendo was the clear "winner" of this year's E3.
Foliage-King
Yeah...no.
Sony was 2nd...by far. Nintendo was the clear "winner" of this year's E3.
Im beginning to thing ppl didnt even watch the video :roll: If all you're basing this on is quantity, then perhaps Sony did win E3 but even then, it's arguable that Nintendo would still take home the gold. Nintendo had cool stuff, may be 3Ds was the coolest, but announcing a console and high promises doesn't justify any awards ... if so do you think Sony should have any credit if it unvelid the PSP Go in this E3 ...... NOO. the overall quality and surprises was on Sony confrence, and it seems GT liked sorcery which looked cool and use the move brilliantly, While Kinect not so much, not gaming wise.[QUOTE="The_Game21x"][QUOTE="Foliage-King"] Im beginning to thing ppl didnt even watch the video :roll:2mrwIf all you're basing this on is quantity, then perhaps Sony did win E3 but even then, it's arguable that Nintendo would still take home the gold. Nintendo had cool stuff, may be 3Ds was the coolest, but announcing a console and high promises doesn't justify any awards ... if so do you think Sony should have any credit if it unvelid the PSP Go in this E3 ...... NOO. the overall quality and surprises was on Sony confrence, and it seems GT liked sorcery which looked cool and use the move brilliantly, While Kinect not so much, not gaming wise. Meh, maybe to you but the majority of the gaming community is pretty much in agreement that Nintendo had the strongest showing this year.
[QUOTE="2mrw"][QUOTE="The_Game21x"] If all you're basing this on is quantity, then perhaps Sony did win E3 but even then, it's arguable that Nintendo would still take home the gold.The_Game21xNintendo had cool stuff, may be 3Ds was the coolest, but announcing a console and high promises doesn't justify any awards ... if so do you think Sony should have any credit if it unvelid the PSP Go in this E3 ...... NOO. the overall quality and surprises was on Sony confrence, and it seems GT liked sorcery which looked cool and use the move brilliantly, While Kinect not so much, not gaming wise. Meh, maybe to you but the majority of the gaming community is pretty much in agreement that Nintendo had the strongest showing this year. by the majority of the gaming community, you mean WHO exactly?? Coz i have here one of the leading gaming sites saying Sony had the best E3 .
[QUOTE="Foliage-King"][QUOTE="The_Game21x"]Im beginning to thing ppl didnt even watch the video :roll: If all you're basing this on is quantity, then perhaps Sony did win E3 but even then, it's arguable that Nintendo would still take home the gold. No its not because quality is subjective. Ps3 had much more games then wiiYeah...no.
Sony was 2nd...by far. Nintendo was the clear "winner" of this year's E3.
The_Game21x
[QUOTE="Foliage-King"][QUOTE="The_Game21x"] If all you're basing this on is quantity, then perhaps Sony did win E3 but even then, it's arguable that Nintendo would still take home the gold.mysterjNo its not because quality is subjective. Ps3 had much more games then wii Not to mention that more of the Sony game shown will get AAA. With diverse genre too.
What crystal ball store do you use?
Stop spreading lies, what legitimate questions have a dodged? :roll: no need to get mad mestitia[QUOTE="TehNubTuber"]
[QUOTE="Arbiterisl33t69"]TC is ghost-posting, only instead of wandering off to different threads, he wanders off, ignores legitimate questions that would prove Sony did not win E3, and replies to someone else, OR randomly makes a post replying to no-one saying how Sony is the best thing in the world yadda yaddaohthemanatee
You know i was wandering what his old account was, this makes perfect sense, Thanks.
On Topic: Gratz to the PS3 on GT i suppose. Nintendo however won E3.
Not to mention that more of the Sony game shown will get AAA. With diverse genre too.[QUOTE="mysterj"][QUOTE="Foliage-King"] No its not because quality is subjective. Ps3 had much more games then wii789shadow
What crystal ball store do you use?
Nintendo will release 1 game between now and next E3 with AAA track record, Metroid, that's it Sony will release 3 games between now and next E3, GT5/LBP2/KZ3.[QUOTE="789shadow"]
[QUOTE="mysterj"] Not to mention that more of the Sony game shown will get AAA. With diverse genre too.mysterj
What crystal ball store do you use?
Nintendo will release 1 game between now and next E3 with AAA track record, Metroid, that's it Sony will release 3 games between now and next E3, GT5/LBP2/KZ3.Gran Turismo does not have an AAA track record, and just going by previous games is absurd.
All the fair points have been said, but I'll repeat the main one: E3 to me is about games and hardware. Nintendo provided the best games and best hardware. Thus, Nintendo won. It is a lot about personal opinion, but most people with an objective bone in their body can look at it that way. :P
Sorry TC... the only reason people think Sony won is because Nintywas so far ahead, no one could see them.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment