PS3's Gamerankings AAA Exclusives

So Sigma is exclusive to PS3?

SOedipus

no. we're not talking about improved graphics and bonus content. if we were then there would be A LOT more games that would lose their multiplat status and become exclusive.

I disagree completely. Even gamerankings has it listed as multiplat...w/e though.

Puckhog04

have you ever, for example, played the ps2 and gba versions of lego star wars?

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"][QUOTE="Puckhog04"][QUOTE="CaseyWegner"]

[QUOTE="SOedipus"]None, but the 360 and Wii only have two if that makes you feel any better.SOedipus

graw + forza 2 + halo 3 + mass effect = 4

and the ps3 has one.

Isn't GRAW multiplat...

no. the 360 version is not the same as the others. different versions...same name.

So Sigma is exclusive to PS3?

GRAW for the 360 has different locations, different developers, and isnt a FPS like the rest it is a third person shooter.

[QUOTE="Puckhog04"]

I disagree completely. Even gamerankings has it listed as multiplat...w/e though.

CaseyWegner

have you ever, for example, played the ps2 and gba versions of lego star wars?

Don't play handhelds so, No.

I have played both version of GRAW though and, other than the fact that the computer version is in first person, they feel exactly the same.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"][QUOTE="Puckhog04"]

I disagree completely. Even gamerankings has it listed as multiplat...w/e though.

Puckhog04

have you ever, for example, played the ps2 and gba versions of lego star wars?

Don't play handhelds so, No.

I have played both version of GRAW though and, other than the fact that the computer version is in first person, they feel exactly the same.

the ps2 and gba versions share the same name but are indeed different games.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"][QUOTE="Puckhog04"]

I disagree completely. Even gamerankings has it listed as multiplat...w/e though.

Puckhog04

have you ever, for example, played the ps2 and gba versions of lego star wars?

Don't play handhelds so, No.

I have played both version of GRAW though and, other than the fact that the computer version is in first person, they feel exactly the same.

How exactly are the PS2/xbox versions of GRAW even remotely similar to the 360 version?

They arn't even the same story, gameplay, one is first person and one is 3rd person.. so yeah, how are they the same? Although they do have the same name. As the PS2 review says in the good section.. " It's got the same name as the awesome Xbox 360 game."

The PS3's exclusive's scores are better than the 360's.

That's not a lie either,I averaged them all out... and i still have the numbers. Probably be an even bigger difference now considering mass effect went down and uncharted went up from when I calculated the scores. H8s2spooge

you averaged the scores? why would you do that? it's next to meaningless. the 360 has more AAAEs and AAEs than the ps3 does. those are the numbers that mean something.

[QUOTE="Gamersince81"][QUOTE="rhaigun"][QUOTE="Gamersince81"]

[QUOTE="GameOverKayo"]Uncharted is not AAA its 89.9 lolMrSickVisionz

do your math 89.9% =s 90%.

What school you attend? Your math teacher never tought you how to round up lol?

When you goto college your teacher will gladly tell you that s/he doesn't do rounding and that you could get an 89.9999 and you still won't recieve an A. Seems mean but it instills the point that YOUR GRADE IS YOUR GRADE.

I attended two Universities and i never heard that in any math class. More importantly, what does it say on GR at the top of screen regarding Uncharted's overall % ? Does it say 89.9 or 90%? Thank you, have a good day!!

so do we all agree the ps3 has 1 AAAE by the rule of rounding up?Mystery_Writer

You mean by basic Mathematical rules. ;)

It's not as if Uncharted is being given an unfair advantage...it's just math. All games are rounded up on gamerankings if they are .5 and above.

Yes though. PS3 has 1 AAAE. Gamerankings changes daily though so we'll see if it sticks.

[QUOTE="GameOverKayo"]Uncharted is not AAA its 89.9 lolGamersince81

do your math 89.9% =s 90%.

Cows are getting desperate. 89.9 = 89.9 :|

[QUOTE="Gamersince81"]

[QUOTE="GameOverKayo"]Uncharted is not AAA its 89.9 lolIdonomeus

do your math 89.9% =s 90%.

Cows are getting desperate. 89.9 = 89.9 :|

http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/932984.asp

:|

[QUOTE="Idonomeus"][QUOTE="Gamersince81"]

[QUOTE="GameOverKayo"]Uncharted is not AAA its 89.9 lolPuckhog04

do your math 89.9% =s 90%.

Cows are getting desperate. 89.9 = 89.9 :|

http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/932984.asp

:|

Why are we rounding it up when the exact average is available? Whatever, I'm willing to give cows a token AAAE but I don't want to see it done for any other games on other systems that are capable of getting a true AAAE and already have a few. Those systems don't need our pity.

http://www.gamerankings.com/

[QUOTE="Puckhog04"][QUOTE="Idonomeus"][QUOTE="Gamersince81"]

[QUOTE="GameOverKayo"]Uncharted is not AAA its 89.9 lolIdonomeus

do your math 89.9% =s 90%.

Cows are getting desperate. 89.9 = 89.9 :|

http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/932984.asp

:|

Why are we rounding it up when the exact average is available? Whatever, I'm willing to give cows a token AAAE but I don't want to see it done for any other games on other systems that are capable of getting a true AAAE and already have a few. Those systems don't need our pity.

http://www.gamerankings.com/

AAAE's aren't yours to give. "We" didn't round it up, Gamerankings knows math and rounds it up because of this reason. 89.9% = 90% according to mathematics due to the rounding rule. Gamerankings didn't make the math rule up either. ;)

True AAAE? Again, that's not for you to decide. ;)

[QUOTE="GameOverKayo"]Uncharted is not AAA its 89.9 lolGamersince81

do your math 89.9% =s 90%.

I doubt you could find me a mathmetician who will tell you that 89.9 >= 90 though :P

LEMMINGS ANSWER THIS:

NAME ONE REVIEW SITE THAT MEASURES GAMES BY A 100th OF A PERCENTAGE?

None! therefore, you round up.

this is getting sad.

X360 / Wii fans, i know it's not a true AAAE, but could you please let this one slide this time for PS3 fans?

they just want to celebrate one AAAE before the end of the year.

show some holiday spirit :)

Actually, CVG UK has yet to be added, and they gave it a 9. Anyone good at maths who can work it out if it brings it up to 90%?

http://www.computerandvideogames.com/article.php?id=177052

What the hell is all this "Its mathematical rules to round" crap? No its not. You round in math when you need an integer. Real life doesnt work on integers. If a architect designs a bridge with a 33.9 degree angle and the bridge is built with a 34 degree angle - that bridge could fall down. What crazy little planet do you all live in where decimal numbers are auto rounded? Its amazing.Cali3350

i'm not agreeing with ps3 fans or anyting. i know it's just a sad desperate attempt claiming everyone should round up numbers to integers.

But regardless of this (i agree sad) attempt, what do you say if you / people here (X360 / wii fans) give them one AAAE? (just saying it might make them relex a bit and stop bashing other consoles out of desperation :) )

[QUOTE="saolin323"]

There are no AAA title for PS3 there

Uncharted is 89.9%, NOT 90%

If you round it, essentially you can round a 85.1% to 90% too, so you simply can't do it, you have to go by the book in that aspect, it either is or not

CaseyWegner

no review system uses that precise of a system. gamerankings rounds it to 90% so it's 90%. the ps3 has one AAAE at gamerankings. accept it.

Hey, ok, no big deal.

BTW, are you a real mod ? How do they allow PS3 fanboys as mods ? Maybe i should contact the administator immediately

Also gamerankings labels the game as 89.9 in the fron page, they DID NOT round it at all, that is just what your opinion is on what they should have done maybe

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"][QUOTE="saolin323"]

There are no AAA title for PS3 there

Uncharted is 89.9%, NOT 90%

If you round it, essentially you can round a 85.1% to 90% too, so you simply can't do it, you have to go by the book in that aspect, it either is or not

saolin323

no review system uses that precise of a system. gamerankings rounds it to 90% so it's 90%. the ps3 has one AAAE at gamerankings. accept it.

Hey, ok, no big deal.

BTW, are you a real mod ? How do they allow PS3 fanboys as mods ? Maybe i should contact the administator immediately

Also gamerankings labels the game as 89.9 in the fron page, they DID NOT round it at all, that is just what your opinion is on what they should have done maybe

I feel sorry for you casey, you just cant win can you? :(

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"][QUOTE="saolin323"]

There are no AAA title for PS3 there

Uncharted is 89.9%, NOT 90%

If you round it, essentially you can round a 85.1% to 90% too, so you simply can't do it, you have to go by the book in that aspect, it either is or not

saolin323

no review system uses that precise of a system. gamerankings rounds it to 90% so it's 90%. the ps3 has one AAAE at gamerankings. accept it.

Hey, ok, no big deal.

BTW, are you a real mod ? How do they allow PS3 fanboys as mods ? Maybe i should contact the administator immediately

Also gamerankings labels the game as 89.9 in the fron page, they DID NOT round it at all, that is just what your opinion is on what they should have done maybe

GameRankings lists it as 90%. It also lists it as 89.9%. As far as I'm concerned, it's 90%, because I'm not so goddamn pathetic that 0.1% will keep me from acknowledging it as a AAA-worthy game.

[QUOTE="GameOverKayo"]Uncharted is not AAA its 89.9 lolGamersince81

do your math 89.9% =s 90%.

Then Super Mario galaxy is 98% tied 1st place with OoT. (97.5% = 98 )

[QUOTE="saolin323"][QUOTE="CaseyWegner"][QUOTE="saolin323"]

There are no AAA title for PS3 there

Uncharted is 89.9%, NOT 90%

If you round it, essentially you can round a 85.1% to 90% too, so you simply can't do it, you have to go by the book in that aspect, it either is or not

mjarantilla

no review system uses that precise of a system. gamerankings rounds it to 90% so it's 90%. the ps3 has one AAAE at gamerankings. accept it.

Hey, ok, no big deal.

BTW, are you a real mod ? How do they allow PS3 fanboys as mods ? Maybe i should contact the administator immediately

Also gamerankings labels the game as 89.9 in the fron page, they DID NOT round it at all, that is just what your opinion is on what they should have done maybe

GameRankings lists it as 90%. It also lists it as 89.9%. As far as I'm concerned, it's 90%, because I'm not so goddamn pathetic that 0.1% will keep me from acknowledging it as a AAA-worthy game.

For me, front page counts, front page says 89.9%, i am sue if it was a 360 game, would NEVER be allowed to have AAA with such a score

[QUOTE="Gamersince81"]

[QUOTE="GameOverKayo"]Uncharted is not AAA its 89.9 lolwapahala

do your math 89.9% =s 90%.

Then Super Mario galaxy is 98% tied 1st place with OoT. (97.5% = 98 )

For the love of god stop listening to the cows, it has been proven to lower your IQ. 97.6 > 97.5 and 90.0 > 89.9. Oot is rated higher then SMG and the average score of Uncharted is not equal or greater than 90.0 (AAA). Now that's settled I wonder when PS3 will get it's first AAAE?

For me, front page counts, front page says 89.9%, i am sue if it was a 360 game, would NEVER be allowed to have AAA with such a scoresaolin323

[QUOTE="mjarantilla"][QUOTE="saolin323"][QUOTE="CaseyWegner"][QUOTE="saolin323"]

There are no AAA title for PS3 there

Uncharted is 89.9%, NOT 90%

If you round it, essentially you can round a 85.1% to 90% too, so you simply can't do it, you have to go by the book in that aspect, it either is or not

saolin323

no review system uses that precise of a system. gamerankings rounds it to 90% so it's 90%. the ps3 has one AAAE at gamerankings. accept it.

Hey, ok, no big deal.

BTW, are you a real mod ? How do they allow PS3 fanboys as mods ? Maybe i should contact the administator immediately

Also gamerankings labels the game as 89.9 in the fron page, they DID NOT round it at all, that is just what your opinion is on what they should have done maybe

GameRankings lists it as 90%. It also lists it as 89.9%. As far as I'm concerned, it's 90%, because I'm not so goddamn pathetic that 0.1% will keep me from acknowledging it as a AAA-worthy game.

For me, front page counts, front page says 89.9%, i am sue if it was a 360 game, would NEVER be allowed to have AAA with such a score

[QUOTE="saolin323"][QUOTE="mjarantilla"]For me, front page counts, front page says 89.9%, i am sue if it was a 360 game, would NEVER be allowed to have AAA with such a scoreshivaskunk9mm

Forza 2 isn't AAA. Use the rankings section to see the top rated games on each platform. This link shows the top 20 games on 360 and Forza 2 is clearly lower then 90.0

http://www.gamerankings.com/itemrankings/simpleratings.asp

[QUOTE="freakyzeeky1986"]

[QUOTE="GameOverKayo"]Uncharted is not AAA its 89.9 lolakif22

omigosh... Its like 0.1 away from AAA :roll:

Seriously, can't you guys just enjoy the games and not pay attention to GR scores?

sorry, 0.1 difference is 0.1 difference

89.9 =/= 90

Its funny you gave PDZ a 88 in your reviews now your here again playing it by the book saying Uncharted isn't AAA

[QUOTE="akif22"][QUOTE="freakyzeeky1986"]

[QUOTE="GameOverKayo"]Uncharted is not AAA its 89.9 lolBlinblingthing

omigosh... Its like 0.1 away from AAA :roll:

Seriously, can't you guys just enjoy the games and not pay attention to GR scores?

sorry, 0.1 difference is 0.1 difference

89.9 =/= 90

Its funny you gave PDZ a 88 in your reviews now your here again playing it by the book saying Uncharted isn't AAA

89.9 is less then 90.0. Its really that simple. Any title on any other platform is held to that same standard.

[QUOTE="shivaskunk9mm"][QUOTE="saolin323"][QUOTE="mjarantilla"]For me, front page counts, front page says 89.9%, i am sue if it was a 360 game, would NEVER be allowed to have AAA with such a scoreJimmyT2

Forza 2 isn't AAA. Use the rankings section to see the top rated games on each platform. This link shows the top 20 games on 360 and Forza 2 is clearly lower then 90.0

http://www.gamerankings.com/itemrankings/simpleratings.asp

Go here. Then, in the Filter Control Box, go to the drop-down menu next to Platform and select PS3. You will then be confronted with a list of PS3 games, starting with the highest-rated. Uncharted has 89.9%. That is not AAA. CoD4 and Oblivion are AAA, however, yet they are multiplat.

If we must round out up, then games like Super Smash Bros. Melee from last generation which received an 8.9 on GameSpot and an 89.9% on GameRankings might as well be AAA as well, correct? Or does the rule only go for PS3 games which were close, but not quite there? Everybody keeps spouting that Super Smash Bros. is not an AAA franchise after all.

Ok, i say, from pure pitty, let's give that AAA to Drake to the poor PS3 fanboys, they just need it so much

Who in their right mind goes by GameRankings? MetaCritic is the world-wide authority in entertainment reviews.
According to MetaCritic, the PS3 has 3 AAAs, none of which are Sony exclusives, the 360 has 11 AAAs, 5 of which are Microsoft exclusives, and the Wii has 4 AAAs, 3 of which are Nintendo exclusives (minus RE4).
The 360 and Wii are completely detsroying the PS3. It's an unfair fight, if you ask me. At this rate, the PS3 might not even last into '08. A $200 price drop in its first year, now that is desperate! Even with that price drop, it's still being outsold by the Wii and 360 in nearly every region of the world.Ninjaogta

New sku =/= price drop/increase

if that was so then 360 saw an $80 increase with elite

My school always tells me to round to 3 signficant figures so... 89.9 it is.

Kidding, Uncharted is AAAE, accept it already.

[QUOTE="CaseyWegner"][QUOTE="saolin323"]

There are no AAA title for PS3 there

Uncharted is 89.9%, NOT 90%

If you round it, essentially you can round a 85.1% to 90% too, so you simply can't do it, you have to go by the book in that aspect, it either is or not

saolin323

no review system uses that precise of a system. gamerankings rounds it to 90% so it's 90%. the ps3 has one AAAE at gamerankings. accept it.

Hey, ok, no big deal.

BTW, are you a real mod ? How do they allow PS3 fanboys as mods ? Maybe i should contact the administator immediately

Also gamerankings labels the game as 89.9 in the fron page, they DID NOT round it at all, that is just what your opinion is on what they should have done maybe

tell me what number is at the top here. my opinion had nothing to do with it.

http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/932984.asp

I feel bad for people who choose their games based on score.

They are missing out on sooo much.

Call of Duty 4

Oblivion

Uncharted (if you round)

those are the only AAA games of any kind for the PS3. Of course, only one is close to AAAE.

How does it matter?

In a couple of weeks, the game will most probably drop to AA, just like rachet dropped to AA after being ranked AAA for 2 weeks. ut right now, Uncharted should be counted as an AAAE, its just common sense.

How does it matter?

In a couple of weeks, the game will most probably drop to AA, just like rachet dropped to AA after being ranked AAA for 2 weeks. ut right now, Uncharted should be counted as an AAAE, its just common sense.

whocares4peace

uncharted has actually been on the rise. it's worked it's way up from around 87%.

[QUOTE="saolin323"][QUOTE="CaseyWegner"][QUOTE="saolin323"]

There are no AAA title for PS3 there

Uncharted is 89.9%, NOT 90%

If you round it, essentially you can round a 85.1% to 90% too, so you simply can't do it, you have to go by the book in that aspect, it either is or not

CaseyWegner

no review system uses that precise of a system. gamerankings rounds it to 90% so it's 90%. the ps3 has one AAAE at gamerankings. accept it.

Hey, ok, no big deal.

BTW, are you a real mod ? How do they allow PS3 fanboys as mods ? Maybe i should contact the administator immediately

Also gamerankings labels the game as 89.9 in the fron page, they DID NOT round it at all, that is just what your opinion is on what they should have done maybe

tell me what number is at the top here. my opinion had nothing to do with it.

http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/932984.asp

I took the liberty of adding and dividing:

3508.5 / 39 = 89.961

I also see on that very same page: "Average Ratio: 89.9% - (89.3%)"

Maybe someone should query Gamerankings on what all 3 of these numbers mean and how they ought to be interpreted. is the "90%" simply Gamerankings rounded opinion? Do we now believe rounded numbers are acceptable, given that we've NEVER accepted a rounded number before? Or is it a simple matter of interpretation?

And do cows presume more reviews won't come in and clear this matter up entirely? It'll either go up and be an unquestsionable 90%, or it'll drop...but there will be more reviews counted before it's all said and done, I think.