Well this the way i see it. either psp or nds wasn't really interresting, but if i needed to choise between them. i would consider the following
games n1
graphics n2
innovation ( i want something new ) n3
battery life n4
screens n5
device look(s) and useage n6
while i look at the nds:
n1) It has alot of games for basicly everything, so thats a big plus for me ( i growed up with mario, goldeneye, zelda so i basicly know there willl be games for me ) besides that it has alot of side games from 3th party developers like call of duty etc ) so for everything there is enought.
n2) grahpics, well while it is a massive upgrade from the GBA, its just not that great to watch. they said at the launche its there first 3D gaming handheld, but at the end it was more a maxed 2d gaming handheld, there where 3D games but they just looked way to outdated, even on the little screen ( 3th party developers) While mario 64 was a good buying point, and 3d mario kart. there never came a beloved 3d zelda.
the 2D + lesser graphics is just a big - for me
n3) innovation, big big plus. i hated the gba throught its sun screen, you needed to be in the sun in order to actually see stuff, the 2 screens where cool to look at, while i found the first version of it to kiddy looking. the DS lite was just a really great product.
not to forget the touchscreen, wifi etc. Just a great solution. The dsi and dsi xl i really didn't bother to even give it a try. it isn't a new generation it adds for me compleet nothing then bigger screens, but the compleet lack on processing power / gpu power, makes the jiggies even more bigger which already ennoyed me ALOT.
n4) Main reason i play a handheld, because i dont got the room or dont wanna spend space to place a console next to my pc. my room is little. and i prefer handheld gaming, simple because you can drop it everywhere and pick it up everywehere. Its just a better solution for me. i had basicly every handheld already besides the gameboy color, which i really didn't found a big enought upgrade besides color, which where awfull at those times mostly.
With handheld gaming for me = wireless ( dont mean wifi with this, but without a cable) gaming for a long time. i just wanna chill out somewhere without having to plug in cables etc. The DS had about a 15 hour + gaming time which was perfectly. specially if you play a game on a long session. so basicly this was a big plus for me
n5) screen(s), main problems where, damaging ( protector plates for the screen ) the screen, and no backlight, while the backlight got solved at the DS version, the protection for the screens where just super. Cant say any different. you can close the DS and the screens wont be harmed. this saves me alot of trouble with getting dirty / reflecting screen protectors which i always had etc. big plus for this one too
so basicly, the DS only had a rought time for me, that the graphics just didn't worked out that well. Still the first party games did go very well with it atleast.
n6) loved the device, simple because it could protect itself as a shell.
And now the PSP:
n1) i basicly love final fantasy, the kingdom heartz games for my ps2, besides that gta was ofcourse really doable, but after gta3 on the pc, i had seen about everything. The other games where either just lacking interrest on me, because i just didn't liked to play any sports games to start with, and the fps games i mostly just could play on my system. While there where great titles, it just lacked a overal potention of a 3D zelda ( which never came anyway ), but overal mario. A handheld without mario was just a big issue for me. But other games where interresting, only the DS just won the overal game feeling
so we can keep it save on this place 50/50, but when i needed to make a choise atm, i still would go with the nds, nothing beats a simple mario game tho, and there are enought other games. specialy when ff and kingdom hearts did came towards the DS also.
n2) what can i say? psp is the choise here. cant blame it. If i would only made a dicision on this deparment i would directly jump towards the PSP.
n3) innovation, i wont lie to you. i just dont see it. overal the nds got a better innovation score here, i just dont see the innovation behind the psp, besides graphics. other then that there is non.
n4) battery life is horrible, its just way to short. if i'm correct itslike 2-3 hours max? its way to short for me. i dont wanna run around with a accupack/cable etc.
n5) screens, while the screen wa superior towards the DS version. i just hated the way that psp just couldn't protect it screen itself.
n6) the game device looked really good, but was overal too big for
psp had basicly more downsizes for me if you compare it towards a DS. while i really just found both a bit on the lacking on either graphical deparment or innovating deparments.
I lost kinda interrest in handhelds until a few months ago, throught lack on improvements. either the psp didn't got the improvements on later models which i wanted innovation. even teh psp go was just a compleet failure, the DSi and XL just didn't gave me the improvements what i wanted, they just increased the problem overal by making the screens bigger.
Now that the 3DS is announced, i cant wait. basicly next gen graphics + full 3D games which have 3D effects. i finally hope that nintendo is moving towards compleet 3D gaming, the support of 3th party developers is way better, and the graphical lacking power system is just perfect. The 3D zelda oot is just what i wanted etc. With a good battery lifetime of about 13+ hours. which is just great.
While the PSP2 probably will be launched soonish next to the 3DS, i do know that PSP2 graphics will be way superior like they did with there PSP version against the DS. Still its basicly the same deal with the DS vs PSP again a few years ago ( still yet to date ).
the 3DS has finally some good 3D looking titels + effect + touchscreen + 2 screens which can make your life easyer. keeping the DS shell is just perfect for me as protection for the device, my last weakness of the DS = look. the look is fine now, like the lite etc. 3D effect movies and photo's is just brilljan to just place it like that.
If the psp only comes out with improved graphics (tegra2) which eats again power, the shell isn't changed. i simple will keep the 3DS, and just do not even bother to go for a psp2 at all.
To get to some really concreet points.
The DS sold way way way better then the PSP, if you wanna compare this towards eachother you can say i cant play sales, well actually you can. if there are more sales, more developers are attracted towards the handheld system = more people that buy it = more profit for company's and gamers themself.
Sales is what its all about, are the sales bad, and the company is big enought like metroid prime last title. they can still throw out a entire new game + alot of promotion around it to make it successfull. if the company is a just starting one / older one without much hit titles, it will fall or drop its interrest really fast.
The DS basicly sold more consoles which means, more people are playing games, which means bigger sales on game deparments etc.
While the DS on statistics is more interresting for basicly everybody. the PSP didn't do a really bad job.
i just hope they gona announce a psp2 soon, just to keep pressure on the 3DS price. But we will see.
Log in to comment