Should GS even bother reviewing Wii/PS3 titles anymore?

I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. monkeysrfat

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. Michael85

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

WarioWare?

[QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. thriteenthmonke

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

WarioWare?

I said games, not flaming bags of crap.

So they should go back and give Lair a shotgun and everything will be good.Phantom_Menace

Throw in a chainsaw and it's a contender for GOTY.

[QUOTE="Phantom_Menace"]So they should go back and give Lair a shotgun and everything will be good.Michael85

Throw in a chainsaw and it's a contender for GOTY.

...hmm...that's dangerous thinking there.

Or just maybe, the 360 has better games.user_nat

Nobody said the 360 games were overrated, slick.

ohhh teh BiasBlueBarad

We have a winner. Too bad your sarcasm is getting in the way of your common sense.

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. Michael85

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

[QUOTE="BlueBarad"]ohhh teh BiasMichael85

We have a winner. Too bad your sarcasm is getting in the way of your common sense.

They funny thing is that the same people that claim the bias argument are the first to praise a positive review...

I mean cmon, look at the gamerankings ratings. Can all of those people really be wrong?

Considering they seem to be content shelling out AAA scores to all things shooter on the 360, it's pretty obvious at this point that the only games they enjoy include a shotgun.Michael85

Well maybe if PS3 and Wii games start getting Shotguns in them...:)

maybe just maybe they'll be started to rate them AAA

[QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. DrinkDuff

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

Wow.

I mean, really...Wow.

Well, hey, who needs intuition when you've got blind faith?

[QUOTE="Michael85"]Considering they seem to be content shelling out AAA scores to all things shooter on the 360, it's pretty obvious at this point that the only games they enjoy include a shotgun.XD88FDB

Well maybe if PS3 and Wii games start getting Shotguns in them...:)

maybe just maybe they'll be started to rate them AAA

Drake's Fortune = guranteed AAA if the shotgun blows enemies into little pieces instead of just killing them.

[QUOTE="DrinkDuff"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. Michael85

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

Wow.

I mean, really...Wow.

Well, hey, who needs intuition when you've got blind faith?

I don't know about being baias, but they generally rate things very wierd. Alot of games are underrated and other are rated to high heavens, its just strange to me.

World in Conflict, are you serious? You should leave the website if you don't agree :( go somewhere else. Bye, kthx.

[QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="BlueBarad"]ohhh teh BiasBlueBarad

We have a winner. Too bad your sarcasm is getting in the way of your common sense.

They funny thing is that the same people that claim the bias argument are the first to praise a positive review...

I mean cmon, look at the gamerankings ratings. Can all of those people really be wrong?

They weren't wrong when they flopped WarioWare.

[QUOTE="XD88FDB"]

[QUOTE="Michael85"]Considering they seem to be content shelling out AAA scores to all things shooter on the 360, it's pretty obvious at this point that the only games they enjoy include a shotgun.Michael85

Well maybe if PS3 and Wii games start getting Shotguns in them...:)

maybe just maybe they'll be started to rate them AAA

Drake's Fortune = guranteed AAA if the shotgun blows enemies into little pieces instead of just killing them.

Correctamundo... !!!:D

[QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="DrinkDuff"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. darklord888

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

Wow.

I mean, really...Wow.

Well, hey, who needs intuition when you've got blind faith?

That's kind of the point, there, slick.

Considering they seem to be content shelling out AAA scores to all things shooter on the 360, it's pretty obvious at this point that the only games they enjoy include a shotgun.Michael85

you need to be stupid or under 10 years old to not see how much bias GS is. 3 years ago, I used to trust thier reviews. now I never trust them with any non-FPS review. and lately they have been under-rating alot of PS3/Wii games, just because you dont controll a leg-less, shotgun carrying player.khalid

Maybe they should make one super faction called "mindless drones". "sheep", "lemmings", and "cows" just don't seem to cut it anymore.Michael85

System Wars.

they are making good reviews for every game.

their is no bias.

[QUOTE="darklord888"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="DrinkDuff"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. Michael85

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

Wow.

I mean, really...Wow.

Well, hey, who needs intuition when you've got blind faith?

That's kind of the point, there, slick.

[QUOTE="khalid"]you need to be stupid or under 10 years old to not see how much bias GS is. 3 years ago, I used to trust thier reviews. now I never trust them with any non-FPS review. and lately they have been under-rating alot of PS3/Wii games, just because you dont controll a leg-less, shotgun carrying player.darklord888

What part about "underrating games NOT on 360" do you not understand? Or are you content arguing this imaginative leap you've made where, in some alternate reality, I've managed to state "360 games are overrated".

[QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="darklord888"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="DrinkDuff"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. darklord888

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

Wow.

I mean, really...Wow.

Well, hey, who needs intuition when you've got blind faith?

That's kind of the point, there, slick.

What I think deserves *insert score here* is irrelevent. What you think of GS's credibility should be your main concern.

If you think they're spot on, or even in the ballpark, you should probably rethink your position. Although if you're a 360 fan, I don't expect you'd be dissappointed with Gamespot's attitude as of late.

[QUOTE="darklord888"][QUOTE="khalid"]you need to be stupid or under 10 years old to not see how much bias GS is. 3 years ago, I used to trust thier reviews. now I never trust them with any non-FPS review. and lately they have been under-rating alot of PS3/Wii games, just because you dont controll a leg-less, shotgun carrying player.Michael85

What part about "underrating games NOT on 360" do you not understand? Or are you content arguing this imaginative leap you've made where, in some alternate reality, I've managed to state "360 games are overrated".

Maybe the games just aren't that good....

and deserved to be rated as such....

There's plenty of Crap games on 360 as well...

[QUOTE="Michael85"]Maybe they should make one super faction called "mindless drones". "sheep", "lemmings", and "cows" just don't seem to cut it anymore.XD88FDB

System Wars.

That implies that there's a "war". There's no war; GS has these people kissing their ass at every turn. Mindless drones...haha.

[QUOTE="DrinkDuff"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. Michael85

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

Wow.

I mean, really...Wow.

Well, hey, who needs intuition when you've got blind faith?

I just got finsihed playing Heavenly Sword, and I think it is slightly underrated here. Obviously MP3 and Zelda Tp were as well. Alot of other games fall into the very close to the GS score range imo. RFom was dead on if you ask me and I own the game. If any recent title was underscored it was Bioshock. dru26

Actually IMO HS was Spot on...

It was Great... no more no less.

[QUOTE="darklord888"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="darklord888"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="DrinkDuff"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. Michael85

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

Wow.

I mean, really...Wow.

Well, hey, who needs intuition when you've got blind faith?

That's kind of the point, there, slick.

What I think deserves *insert score here* is irrelevent. What you think of GS's credibility should be your main concern.

If you think they're spot on, or even in the ballpark, you should probably rethink your position. Although if you're a 360 fan, I don't expect you'd be dissappointed with Gamespot's attitude as of late.

[QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="DrinkDuff"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. DrinkDuff

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

Wow.

I mean, really...Wow.

Well, hey, who needs intuition when you've got blind faith?

Still blind?

Give it a few years. You won't see clearly until you've been given a reason to, and if you're a 360 fan, you won't see any reasons to for the rest of the gen.

[QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="darklord888"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="darklord888"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="DrinkDuff"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. darklord888

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

Wow.

I mean, really...Wow.

Well, hey, who needs intuition when you've got blind faith?

That's kind of the point, there, slick.

What I think deserves *insert score here* is irrelevent. What you think of GS's credibility should be your main concern.

If you think they're spot on, or even in the ballpark, you should probably rethink your position. Although if you're a 360 fan, I don't expect you'd be dissappointed with Gamespot's attitude as of late.

[QUOTE="user_nat"]Or just maybe, the 360 has better games.Michael85

Nobody said the 360 games were overrated, slick.

Oh, I see. So just Wii and PS3 games are under rated.. hmm

PS3:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 30 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 29 (1 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 30 (2 AAA)

Result: Gamespot over rates.

Wii:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 28 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 7 (3 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 13 (3 AAA)*

I don't think they have VC games listed.

Result: Donno, hard to tell with gamespots VC titles.

360:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 80 (10 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 71 (9 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 80 (12 AAA)

*Hard to count to be sure.

Result: Game spot around the norm.

[QUOTE="DrinkDuff"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="DrinkDuff"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. Michael85

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

Wow.

I mean, really...Wow.

Well, hey, who needs intuition when you've got blind faith?

Still blind?

Give it a few years. You won't see clearly until you've been given a reason to, and if you're a 360 fan, you won't see any reasons to for the rest of the gen.

Why are we the ones blind?

Wii and PS3 are still young...

PS3 and Wii will have many many many AAA's before the sun sets on this Console Cycle.

You're always going to be a fanboy with that attitude. So long as you think GS is right.Michael85

[QUOTE="Michael85"]You're always going to be a fanboy with that attitude. So long as you think GS is right.darklord888

But Truth be Told...

Sorry Cows

Sorry Sheep

Xbox 360 is getting better games then the PS3 and Wii. At the MOMENT...

[QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="user_nat"]Or just maybe, the 360 has better games.user_nat

Nobody said the 360 games were overrated, slick.

Oh, I see. So just Wii and PS3 games are under rated.. hmm

PS3:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 30 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 29 (1 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 30 (2 AAA)

Result: Gamespot over rates.

Wii:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 28 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 7 (3 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 13 (3 AAA)*

I don't think they have VC games listed.

Result: Donno, hard to tell with gamespots VC titles.

360:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 80 (10 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 71 (9 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 80 (12 AAA)

*Hard to count to be sure.

Result: Game spot around the norm.

Apparently you've put enough time into your response to convince me that I've gotten under your skin. Good.

Maybe now you'll stop defending them and start thinking on your own.

[QUOTE="Michael85"]You're always going to be a fanboy with that attitude. So long as you think GS is right.darklord888

Proof? What, you want me to post more scores to counter GS's scores?

Yeah, 'cause that makes sense.