Should GS even bother reviewing Wii/PS3 titles anymore?

Why are we the ones blind?

XD88FDB

He's the all-seeing eye! :shock:

[QUOTE="user_nat"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="user_nat"]Or just maybe, the 360 has better games.Michael85

Nobody said the 360 games were overrated, slick.

Oh, I see. So just Wii and PS3 games are under rated.. hmm

PS3:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 30 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 29 (1 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 30 (2 AAA)

Result: Gamespot over rates.

Wii:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 28 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 7 (3 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 13 (3 AAA)*

I don't think they have VC games listed.

Result: Donno, hard to tell with gamespots VC titles.

360:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 80 (10 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 71 (9 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 80 (12 AAA)

*Hard to count to be sure.

Result: Game spot around the norm.

Apparently you've put enough time into your response to convince me that I've gotten under your skin. Good.

Maybe now you'll stop defending them and start thinking on your own.

Gamespot's Reviews are law here in SW.

But IRL they mean Jack ****...

Just buy whatever console or consoles you want an play whatever games you want

And think whatever the hell you want.

Peace.

Apparently you've put enough time into your response to convince me that I've gotten under your skin. Good.

Maybe now you'll stop defending them and start thinking on your own.

Michael85

Not you in particular, everyone who thinks gamespot is biased, which it isn't.

Whats there to think about on my own? I clearly showed you gamespot does not under rated PS3/Wii titles.

Although, the Wii is debatable, thanks to Warioware.

I have to agree. If it's a shooter on the 360, it gets an automatic AAA.Zhengi

Should I go get a list of shooters that arn't AAA?

I have to agree. If it's a shooter on the 360, it gets an automatic AAA.Zhengi

Lost Planet...

[QUOTE="darklord888"][QUOTE="Michael85"]You're always going to be a fanboy with that attitude. So long as you think GS is right.Michael85

Proof? What, you want me to post more scores to counter GS's scores?

Yeah, 'cause that makes sense.

It's all My opinion vs your opinion when it comes to reviews...

Absolutely pointless to argue about them...

In fact What the **** am I even doing here... :?

[QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="user_nat"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="user_nat"]Or just maybe, the 360 has better games.XD88FDB

Nobody said the 360 games were overrated, slick.

Oh, I see. So just Wii and PS3 games are under rated.. hmm

PS3:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 30 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 29 (1 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 30 (2 AAA)

Result: Gamespot over rates.

Wii:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 28 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 7 (3 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 13 (3 AAA)*

I don't think they have VC games listed.

Result: Donno, hard to tell with gamespots VC titles.

360:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 80 (10 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 71 (9 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 80 (12 AAA)

*Hard to count to be sure.

Result: Game spot around the norm.

Apparently you've put enough time into your response to convince me that I've gotten under your skin. Good.

Maybe now you'll stop defending them and start thinking on your own.

Gamespot's Reviews are law here in SW.

Why?

I guess I shouldn't ask, you already know the answer: because you've been told to follow them.

Or just maybe, the 360 has better games.user_nat

That's the correct answer. Don't know why it's so hard for cows to understand this. Lair sucked, Halo 3 doesn't. There was nothing biased.

[QUOTE="Michael85"]

Apparently you've put enough time into your response to convince me that I've gotten under your skin. Good.

Maybe now you'll stop defending them and start thinking on your own.

user_nat

Not you in particular, everyone who thinks gamespot is biased, which it isn't.

Whats there to think about on my own? I clearly showed you gamespot does not under rated PS3/Wii titles.

Although, the Wii is debatable, thanks to Warioware.

I have to agree. If it's a shooter on the 360, it gets an automatic AAA.Zhengi

Should I go get a list of shooters that arn't AAA?

Sure.

While you're at it, go get a list of shooters not on the 360 that are AAA.

lol why is anyone even fighting with this guy. i find it hilarious how serious he takes all this:lol:

i wonder what hell come up with next.

lol why is anyone even fighting with this guy. i find it hilarious how serious he takes all this:lol:

i wonder what hell come up with next.

white45e

I'm sure serious right now. Don't even mess with me I'm so serious.

[QUOTE="XD88FDB"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="user_nat"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="user_nat"]Or just maybe, the 360 has better games.Michael85

Nobody said the 360 games were overrated, slick.

Oh, I see. So just Wii and PS3 games are under rated.. hmm

PS3:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 30 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 29 (1 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 30 (2 AAA)

Result: Gamespot over rates.

Wii:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 28 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 7 (3 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 13 (3 AAA)*

I don't think they have VC games listed.

Result: Donno, hard to tell with gamespots VC titles.

360:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 80 (10 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 71 (9 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 80 (12 AAA)

*Hard to count to be sure.

Result: Game spot around the norm.

Apparently you've put enough time into your response to convince me that I've gotten under your skin. Good.

Maybe now you'll stop defending them and start thinking on your own.

Gamespot's Reviews are law here in SW.

Why?

I guess I shouldn't ask, you already know the answer: because you've been told to follow them.

Not really,

I don't want to waste 60$ on a Bad game...

But I usally Rent games.. and decide for myself

so that makes Gamespot even more chock full of BS...

If you don't like it here, then why even bother?

Your not gonna change anything....

The reviews are here to stay...

[QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="XD88FDB"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="user_nat"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="user_nat"]Or just maybe, the 360 has better games.XD88FDB

Nobody said the 360 games were overrated, slick.

Oh, I see. So just Wii and PS3 games are under rated.. hmm

PS3:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 30 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 29 (1 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 30 (2 AAA)

Result: Gamespot over rates.

Wii:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 28 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 7 (3 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 13 (3 AAA)*

I don't think they have VC games listed.

Result: Donno, hard to tell with gamespots VC titles.

360:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 80 (10 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 71 (9 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 80 (12 AAA)

*Hard to count to be sure.

Result: Game spot around the norm.

Apparently you've put enough time into your response to convince me that I've gotten under your skin. Good.

Maybe now you'll stop defending them and start thinking on your own.

Gamespot's Reviews are law here in SW.

Why?

I guess I shouldn't ask, you already know the answer: because you've been told to follow them.

Not really,

I don't want to waste 60$ on a Bad game...

But I usally Rent games.. and decide for myself

so that makes Gamespot even more chock full of BS...

If you don't like it here, then why even bother?

Your not gonna change anything....

The reviews are here to stay...

So if you rent games then decide for yourself, what are YOU doing here?

Wasting your time? No, you need GS. You need them so you can rub their review scores in other people's faces.

Don't act like you don't. That's what system wars is. So say you're not a part of it is to say you don't participate, which is clearly untrue.

In fact, the biggest hypocrit here is myself. But I'm not so elite that I can't admit it.

lol why is anyone even fighting with this guy. i find it hilarious how serious he takes all this:lol:

i wonder what hell come up with next.

white45e

I'm bored.

Sure.

While you're at it, go get a list of shooters not on the 360 that are AAA.

Michael85

You want me to go through all the platforms ever and find all the AAA shooters? Just ask hermits how many there are on the PC. (I'm not that bored)

Anyhow:

Gamespot has shooters in 3 lists, First Person, Tatical and Other.

First Person: 4 AAA, 2 exclusive. Not AAA: 9.

Tatical: 2 AAA, 1 exclusive, Not AAA: 2.

Other*: 1 AAA, 0 exclusive, Not AAA: 15.

Totals: 7 AAA, Not AAA: 26

So I guess that means shooters on the 360 arn't automatic AAA, and seeing as there was only 3 exclusive AAA, there is just as much AAA on other platforms (PC).

*Few XBLA titles here.

[QUOTE="XD88FDB"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="XD88FDB"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="user_nat"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="user_nat"]Or just maybe, the 360 has better games.Michael85

Nobody said the 360 games were overrated, slick.

Oh, I see. So just Wii and PS3 games are under rated.. hmm

PS3:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 30 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 29 (1 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 30 (2 AAA)

Result: Gamespot over rates.

Wii:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 28 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 7 (3 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 13 (3 AAA)*

I don't think they have VC games listed.

Result: Donno, hard to tell with gamespots VC titles.

360:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 80 (10 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 71 (9 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 80 (12 AAA)

*Hard to count to be sure.

Result: Game spot around the norm.

Apparently you've put enough time into your response to convince me that I've gotten under your skin. Good.

Maybe now you'll stop defending them and start thinking on your own.

Gamespot's Reviews are law here in SW.

Why?

I guess I shouldn't ask, you already know the answer: because you've been told to follow them.

Not really,

I don't want to waste 60$ on a Bad game...

But I usally Rent games.. and decide for myself

so that makes Gamespot even more chock full of BS...

If you don't like it here, then why even bother?

Your not gonna change anything....

The reviews are here to stay...

So if you rent games then decide for yourself, what are YOU doing here?

Wasting your time? No, you need GS. You need them so you can rub their review scores in other people's faces.

Don't act like you don't. That's what system wars is. So say you're not a part of it is to say you don't participate, which is clearly untrue.

In fact, the biggest hypocrit here is myself. But I'm not so elite that I can't admit it.

Ha you just summed up everything in a nice package.. Kudos to you man.. Kudos. 8)

Hey at the end of the day I just like to play some games that aren't bad.

and Make fun of people who try to defend there wack ass games...

What the **** am I doing here?

I dunno but I like to Argue with people.

It's nice.

[QUOTE="white45e"]

lol why is anyone even fighting with this guy. i find it hilarious how serious he takes all this:lol:

i wonder what hell come up with next.

user_nat

I'm bored.

Sure.

While you're at it, go get a list of shooters not on the 360 that are AAA.

Michael85

You want me to go through all the platforms ever and find all the AAA shooters? Just ask hermits how many there are on the PC. (I'm not that bored)

Anyhow:

Gamespot has shooters in 3 lists, First Person, Tatical and Other.

First Person: 4 AAA, 2 exclusive. Not AAA: 9.

Tatical: 2 AAA, 0 exclusive, Not AAA: 2.

Other*: 1 AAA, 0 exclusive, Not AAA: 15.

Totals: 7 AAA, Not AAA: 26

So I guess that means shooters on the 360 arn't automatic AAA, and seeing as there was only 2 exclusive AAA, there is just as much AAA on other platforms (PC).

*Few XBLA titles here.

What's the point of padding the spaces with XBLA titles?

Did you have any specific games in mind? (That have been underrated)

What's the point of padding the spaces with XBLA titles?

Michael85

You don't like admiting to being wrong do you?

XBLA titles are games also.

Ha you just summed up everything in a nice package.. Kudos to you man.. Kudos. 8)

Hey at the end of the day I just like to play some games that aren't bad.

and Make fun of people who try to defend there wack ass games...

What the **** am I doing here?

I dunno but I like to Argue with people.

It's nice.

XD88FDB

Nah, it's not nice. I'm not even arguing, if you haven't noticed. I'm asking a few general questions, getting a rise or two out of people to see how they react, being accused of taking the forum to seriously, whatever. People are trying so hard to prove me wrong that it's very, VERY clear to me how seriously they take GS's scores.

GS is to the 360 what IGN is to the Wii. It's just unfortunate that PS3 fans don't have a site to run to that underrates all titles that aren't on their system.

lol why is anyone even fighting with this guy. i find it hilarious how serious he takes all this:lol:

i wonder what hell come up with next.

white45e

He acts like there is some conspiracy lol and he will lead the REVOLUTION.

He isn't Michael anymore. I will call him " V "

[QUOTE="XD88FDB"]

Ha you just summed up everything in a nice package.. Kudos to you man.. Kudos. 8)

Hey at the end of the day I just like to play some games that aren't bad.

and Make fun of people who try to defend there wack ass games...

What the **** am I doing here?

I dunno but I like to Argue with people.

It's nice.

Michael85

Nah, it's not nice. I'm not even arguing, if you haven't noticed. I'm asking a few general questions, getting a rise or two out of people to see how they react, being accused of taking the forum to seriously, whatever. People are trying so hard to prove me wrong that it's very, VERY clear to me how seriously they take GS's scores.

Yet you make a thread about gamespot scores?????? who's taking this seriously ???

When ever someone answers your question you call them a blind fanboy.. then you rant like a " fanboy " saying you wish you had a site to go to to see your favorite games get better scores than they deserve.

[QUOTE="XD88FDB"]

Ha you just summed up everything in a nice package.. Kudos to you man.. Kudos. 8)

Hey at the end of the day I just like to play some games that aren't bad.

and Make fun of people who try to defend there wack ass games...

What the **** am I doing here?

I dunno but I like to Argue with people.

It's nice.

Michael85

Nah, it's not nice. I'm not even arguing, if you haven't noticed. I'm asking a few general questions, getting a rise or two out of people to see how they react, being accused of taking the forum to seriously, whatever. People are trying so hard to prove me wrong that it's very, VERY clear to me how seriously they take GS's scores.

GS is to the 360 what IGN is to the Wii. It's just unfortunate that PS3 fans don't have a site to run to that underrates all titles that aren't on their system.

Well gamespot is still going to review PS3 and Wii games...

Because they are a Multi-platform Review Site.

so in the end.. nothing is accomplished, Good Job

V.

[QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="XD88FDB"]

Ha you just summed up everything in a nice package.. Kudos to you man.. Kudos. 8)

Hey at the end of the day I just like to play some games that aren't bad.

and Make fun of people who try to defend there wack ass games...

What the **** am I doing here?

I dunno but I like to Argue with people.

It's nice.

Reneg4de

Nah, it's not nice. I'm not even arguing, if you haven't noticed. I'm asking a few general questions, getting a rise or two out of people to see how they react, being accused of taking the forum to seriously, whatever. People are trying so hard to prove me wrong that it's very, VERY clear to me how seriously they take GS's scores.

Yet you make a thread about gamespot scores?????? who's taking this seriously ???

When ever someone answers your question you call them a blind fanboy.. then you rant like a " fanboy " saying you wish you had a site to go to to see your favorite games get better scores than they deserve.

Cue

Pen and Teller.

It's Bull****.

[QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="XD88FDB"]

Ha you just summed up everything in a nice package.. Kudos to you man.. Kudos. 8)

Hey at the end of the day I just like to play some games that aren't bad.

and Make fun of people who try to defend there wack ass games...

What the **** am I doing here?

I dunno but I like to Argue with people.

It's nice.

Reneg4de

Nah, it's not nice. I'm not even arguing, if you haven't noticed. I'm asking a few general questions, getting a rise or two out of people to see how they react, being accused of taking the forum to seriously, whatever. People are trying so hard to prove me wrong that it's very, VERY clear to me how seriously they take GS's scores.

Yet you make a thread about gamespot scores?????? who's taking this seriously ???

When ever someone answers your question you call them a blind fanboy.. then you rant like a " fanboy " saying you wish you had a site to go to to see your favorite games get better scores than they deserve.

Still running to GS's rescue?

I'm taking it so seriously that I've forgone ending my sentences with multiple puncuation marks in effort to make my questions any more urgent.

[QUOTE="Reneg4de"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="XD88FDB"]

Ha you just summed up everything in a nice package.. Kudos to you man.. Kudos. 8)

Hey at the end of the day I just like to play some games that aren't bad.

and Make fun of people who try to defend there wack ass games...

What the **** am I doing here?

I dunno but I like to Argue with people.

It's nice.

XD88FDB

Nah, it's not nice. I'm not even arguing, if you haven't noticed. I'm asking a few general questions, getting a rise or two out of people to see how they react, being accused of taking the forum to seriously, whatever. People are trying so hard to prove me wrong that it's very, VERY clear to me how seriously they take GS's scores.

Yet you make a thread about gamespot scores?????? who's taking this seriously ???

When ever someone answers your question you call them a blind fanboy.. then you rant like a " fanboy " saying you wish you had a site to go to to see your favorite games get better scores than they deserve.

Cue

Pen and Teller.

It's Bull****.

I give it 5 hours before GS bans me, and about 10 years before the general populace catches on to the intentions of the thread, had their attention spans lasted long enough to do so.

[QUOTE="Reneg4de"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="XD88FDB"]

Ha you just summed up everything in a nice package.. Kudos to you man.. Kudos. 8)

Hey at the end of the day I just like to play some games that aren't bad.

and Make fun of people who try to defend there wack ass games...

What the **** am I doing here?

I dunno but I like to Argue with people.

It's nice.

Michael85

Nah, it's not nice. I'm not even arguing, if you haven't noticed. I'm asking a few general questions, getting a rise or two out of people to see how they react, being accused of taking the forum to seriously, whatever. People are trying so hard to prove me wrong that it's very, VERY clear to me how seriously they take GS's scores.

Yet you make a thread about gamespot scores?????? who's taking this seriously ???

When ever someone answers your question you call them a blind fanboy.. then you rant like a " fanboy " saying you wish you had a site to go to to see your favorite games get better scores than they deserve.

Still running to GS's rescue?

I'm taking it so seriously that I've forgone ending my sentences with multiple puncuation marks in effort to make my questions any more urgent.

Yes Gamespot is Wrong.... Dead Wrong and every PS3/Wii title should get AAA reguardless. :roll:

But no... Lets be a fricking Grammer Nazi :roll:

[QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="XD88FDB"]

Ha you just summed up everything in a nice package.. Kudos to you man.. Kudos. 8)

Hey at the end of the day I just like to play some games that aren't bad.

and Make fun of people who try to defend there wack ass games...

What the **** am I doing here?

I dunno but I like to Argue with people.

It's nice.

Reneg4de

Nah, it's not nice. I'm not even arguing, if you haven't noticed. I'm asking a few general questions, getting a rise or two out of people to see how they react, being accused of taking the forum to seriously, whatever. People are trying so hard to prove me wrong that it's very, VERY clear to me how seriously they take GS's scores.

Yet you make a thread about gamespot scores?????? who's taking this seriously ???

When ever someone answers your question you call them a blind fanboy.. then you rant like a " fanboy " saying you wish you had a site to go to to see your favorite games get better scores than they deserve.

Well, he said it himself. He's the biggest hypocrit here.

[QUOTE="Michael85"]

What's the point of padding the spaces with XBLA titles?

user_nat

You don't like admiting to being wrong do you?

XBLA titles are games also.

I don't pay full price for XBLA games. Do you?

[QUOTE="Reneg4de"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="XD88FDB"]

Ha you just summed up everything in a nice package.. Kudos to you man.. Kudos. 8)

Hey at the end of the day I just like to play some games that aren't bad.

and Make fun of people who try to defend there wack ass games...

What the **** am I doing here?

I dunno but I like to Argue with people.

It's nice.

ToScA-

Nah, it's not nice. I'm not even arguing, if you haven't noticed. I'm asking a few general questions, getting a rise or two out of people to see how they react, being accused of taking the forum to seriously, whatever. People are trying so hard to prove me wrong that it's very, VERY clear to me how seriously they take GS's scores.

Yet you make a thread about gamespot scores?????? who's taking this seriously ???

When ever someone answers your question you call them a blind fanboy.. then you rant like a " fanboy " saying you wish you had a site to go to to see your favorite games get better scores than they deserve.

Well, he said it himself. He's the biggest hypocrit here.

The hilarious part is the sheer amount of people who refuse to read any part of the thread coming in here, hootin' and hollerin', ready for a fight.

Yet they have no idea of the situation.

[QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. thriteenthmonke

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

WarioWare?

[QUOTE="thriteenthmonke"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. Michael85

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

WarioWare?

I said games, not flaming bags of crap.

lol...pretty harsh on that, but true!

[QUOTE="ToScA-"][QUOTE="Reneg4de"][QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="XD88FDB"]

Ha you just summed up everything in a nice package.. Kudos to you man.. Kudos. 8)

Hey at the end of the day I just like to play some games that aren't bad.

and Make fun of people who try to defend there wack ass games...

What the **** am I doing here?

I dunno but I like to Argue with people.

It's nice.

Michael85

Nah, it's not nice. I'm not even arguing, if you haven't noticed. I'm asking a few general questions, getting a rise or two out of people to see how they react, being accused of taking the forum to seriously, whatever. People are trying so hard to prove me wrong that it's very, VERY clear to me how seriously they take GS's scores.

Yet you make a thread about gamespot scores?????? who's taking this seriously ???

When ever someone answers your question you call them a blind fanboy.. then you rant like a " fanboy " saying you wish you had a site to go to to see your favorite games get better scores than they deserve.

Well, he said it himself. He's the biggest hypocrit here.

The hilarious part is the sheer amount of people who refuse to read any part of the thread coming in here, hootin' and hollerin', ready for a fight.

Yet they have no idea of the situation.

Considering they seem to be content shelling out AAA scores to all things shooter on the 360, it's pretty obvious at this point that the only games they enjoy include a shotgun.

Lost Planet got AA.

shotguns are cool...:|

[QUOTE="Michael85"][QUOTE="thriteenthmonke"][QUOTE="Michael85"]

[QUOTE="monkeysrfat"]I don't get the feeling this thread is going to end well. The only thing bias about gamespot is their love for halo. Art_424

Open your eyes, man. They're underrating every game not on 360. Every. Last. One.

WarioWare?

I said games, not flaming bags of crap.

lol...pretty harsh on that, but true!

Don't you

EVER EVER EVER!!! Talk about Wii's Flaming Bags of Crap LIKE THAT!!! :evil::lol:

I don't see a Shotgun in this Newly Reviewed Xbox 360 game but it did get AAA. :lol:

http://au.gamespot.com/xbox360/puzzle/puzzlequestchallenge/review.html?sid=6180836

I don't know how people can shrug off gamespot's bias.

I don't know how people can shrug off gamespot's bias.

trizzle_a

I don't know how you can say they are biased..

Like the post I did earlier in this thread showed, based off metratic and game rankings, gamespot over rated the PS3 and is about right for the other 2..

[QUOTE="trizzle_a"]

I don't know how people can shrug off gamespot's bias.

user_nat

I don't know how you can say they are biased..

Like the post I did earlier in this thread showed, based off metratic and game rankings, gamespot over rated the PS3 and is about right for the other 2..

This whole thread basically boils down to.

Im mad the 360 has so many great titles while the (insert console of choice here) doesn't

You guys need to stop just comparing scores. It goes way deeper than that.

Mp3 gets knocked for being too similar to MP2. Halo3 gets praised for being too similar to Halo2.

Bioshock and MP3 gets knocked for being to easy despite having 3 difficulty levels which they totally ignore pointing out in their review. Halo3 they mention their multiple difficulty levels.

meh ill mention more later

Oh, I see. So just Wii and PS3 games are under rated.. hmm

PS3:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 30 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 29 (1 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 30 (2 AAA)

Result: Gamespot over rates.

Wii:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 28 (3 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 7 (3 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 13 (3 AAA)*

I don't think they have VC games listed.

Result: Donno, hard to tell with gamespots VC titles.

360:

Games rated higher than AA at gamespot: 80 (10 AAA)*

Games rated higher than AA at Metacritic: 71 (9 AAA)

Games rated higher than AA at Gamerankings: 80 (12 AAA)

*Hard to count to be sure.

Result: Game spot around the norm.

user_nat

You had to include VC games for Gamespot, but not for Metacritic or Gamerankings. xD