So, BF3 vs MW3

BF3 will be the better game but MW3 will get better sales.

Am I doing it right?

BF3 will be the better game but MW3 will get better sales.

Am I doing it right?

nameless12345

Taking into account the horrible beta, I am positive MW3 will be the better game. At least on consoles.

[QUOTE="nameless12345"]

BF3 will be the better game but MW3 will get better sales.

Am I doing it right?

SHATT3R3D-GLASS

Taking into account the horrible beta, I am positive MW3 will be the better game. At least on consoles.

I agree with this

MW3 will have the better SP. The online will be broken in both, so MW3 > BF3.

[QUOTE="nameless12345"]

BF3 will be the better game but MW3 will get better sales.

Am I doing it right?

SHATT3R3D-GLASS

Taking into account the horrible beta, I am positive MW3 will be the better game. At least on consoles.

Its a beta. Doesnt need to be amazing to make the final product what it is. I had more fun with the beta than the last 3 CODS combined.

MW3 will have the better SP. The online will be broken in both, so MW3 > BF3.

Pug-Nasty

[QUOTE="Pug-Nasty"]

MW3 will have the better SP. The online will be broken in both, so MW3 > BF3.

MonsieurX

At least MW3 is the concluding part of an interesting trilogy set during WW3.

BF3? Nothing.

[QUOTE="Pug-Nasty"]

MW3 will have the better SP. The online will be broken in both, so MW3 > BF3.

MonsieurX

putting assumption aside about SP because we don't know which one will be better.
BUT we do know that:

Graphics

Sound quality

Destruction

Physics

Player count

Variety

New Engine overall.

Is better in one game than the other.

SO by comparin these^, BF3 easily.

Dear lord...

putting assumption aside about SP because we don't know which one will be better.
BUT we do know that:

Graphics

Sound quality

Destruction

Physics

Player count

Variety

New Engine overall.

Is better in one game than the other.

SO by comparin these^, BF3 easily.

Ribnarak

We do know MW3 will be better in SP... because DICE have never been good at making them.

We also know that MW3 will be much better in MP, because they revolutionized that aspect of a FPS with the CoD franchise, and they don't call it the 'King of the genre' for nothing.

We know, lastly, that BF3 will be better in technology (sound and graphics).

This is what we know thus far. Also that CoD will have a superior online service (CoD Elite).

[QUOTE="Ribnarak"]

putting assumption aside about SP because we don't know which one will be better.
BUT we do know that:

Graphics

Sound quality

Destruction

Physics

Player count

Variety

New Engine overall.

Is better in one game than the other.

SO by comparin these^, BF3 easily.

SHATT3R3D-GLASS

We do know MW3 will be better in SP... because DICE have never been good at making them.

We also know that MW3 will be much better in MP, because they revolutionized that aspect of a FPS with the CoD franchise, and they don't call it the 'King of the genre' for nothing.

We know, lastly, that BF3 will be better in technology (sound and graphics).

This is what we know thus far. Also that CoD will have a superior online service (CoD Elite).

[QUOTE="Ribnarak"]

putting assumption aside about SP because we don't know which one will be better.
BUT we do know that:

Graphics

Sound quality

Destruction

Physics

Player count

Variety

New Engine overall.

Is better in one game than the other.

SO by comparin these^, BF3 easily.

SHATT3R3D-GLASS

We do know MW3 will be better in SP... because DICE have never been good at making them.

We also know that MW3 will be much better in MP, because they revolutionized that aspect of a FPS with the CoD franchise, and they don't call it the 'King of the genre' for nothing.

We know, lastly, that BF3 will be better in technology (sound and graphics).

This is what we know thus far. Also that CoD will have a superior online service (CoD Elite).

I think it's safe to say that BF3 is vastly superior in almost every possible objective way.

[QUOTE="Ribnarak"]

putting assumption aside about SP because we don't know which one will be better.
BUT we do know that:

Graphics

Sound quality

Destruction

Physics

Player count

Variety

New Engine overall.

Is better in one game than the other.

SO by comparin these^, BF3 easily.

SHATT3R3D-GLASS

We do know MW3 will be better in SP... because DICE have never been good at making them.

We also know that MW3 will be much better in MP, because they revolutionized that aspect of a FPS with the CoD franchise, and they don't call it the 'King of the genre' for nothing.

We know, lastly, that BF3 will be better in technology (sound and graphics).

This is what we know thus far. Also that CoD will have a superior online service (CoD Elite).

I think it's safe to say that BF3 is vastly superior in almost every possible objective way.

el3m2tigre

If it's going to look and play like the beta, then no.

I think it's safe to say that BF3 is vastly superior in almost every possible objective way.

el3m2tigre

this is exactly my point that im trying to convey as well. Some people don't understand this.

[QUOTE="el3m2tigre"]

I think it's safe to say that BF3 is vastly superior in almost every possible objective way.

Haiyama

If it's going to look and play like the beta, then no.

[QUOTE="el3m2tigre"]

I think it's safe to say that BF3 is vastly superior in almost every possible objective way.

Haiyama

If it's going to look and play like the beta, then no.

DICE apparently fixed everything wrong that the beta had.

After 2 hours of BF3 beta I have to say with all the negative mojo surrounding it, I'm still hyped for it.

MW3 will sell better but like the TC said BF3 will be the better over all game.

I think it's safe to say that BF3 is vastly superior in almost every possible objective way.

el3m2tigre

I think MW3 will be the both the better selling game and the better game aswell. BF games are just boring to me, you just run around looking for people to kill (you rarely do) and when you finally do you get shot and have to wait like 10 minutes to respawn. BF is the waiting game and the single player mode is mediocre while most COD single player modes are fun. Also COD has more modes which means more fun....And you don't have tu run around for an hour alone before you FINALLY find someone to shoot at lol

I think MW3 will be the both the better selling game and the better game aswell. BF games are just boring to me, you just run around looking for people to kill (you rarely do) and when you finally do you get shot and have to wait like 10 minutes to respawn. BF is the waiting game and the single player mode is mediocre while most COD single player modes are fun. Also COD has more modes which means more fun....And you don't have tu run around for an hour alone before you FINALLY find someone to shoot at lol

ShadowMoses900

Take it back.ActionRemix

[QUOTE="ActionRemix"]Take it back.Lto_thaG

Lol, that s*** is huge.

This again.

Yeah, MW3 will suck and BF3 will rock.

[QUOTE="SHATT3R3D-GLASS"]

[QUOTE="Ribnarak"]

putting assumption aside about SP because we don't know which one will be better.
BUT we do know that:

Graphics

Sound quality

Destruction

Physics

Player count

Variety

New Engine overall.

Is better in one game than the other.

SO by comparin these^, BF3 easily.

Ribnarak

We do know MW3 will be better in SP... because DICE have never been good at making them.

We also know that MW3 will be much better in MP, because they revolutionized that aspect of a FPS with the CoD franchise, and they don't call it the 'King of the genre' for nothing.

We know, lastly, that BF3 will be better in technology (sound and graphics).

This is what we know thus far. Also that CoD will have a superior online service (CoD Elite).

Variety and player count don't make BF3 the "superior" game...

The reason I listed MW3 as superior in the MP department, is because CoD is a phenomenon only because of the MP. If it were sold without the MP, it would sell nothing.

BF3 is not a phenomenon, it's just another shooter next to the likes of Resistance 3.

Variety and player count don't make BF3 the "superior" game...

The reason I listed MW3 as superior in the MP department, is because CoD is a phenomenon only because of the MP. If it were sold without the MP, it would sell nothing.

BF3 is not a phenomenon, it's just another shooter next to the likes of Resistance 3.

SHATT3R3D-GLASS

Are you saying MW3 a.ka. Modern Rehash, isn't just a normal shooter?

[QUOTE="ShadowMoses900"]

I think MW3 will be the both the better selling game and the better game aswell. BF games are just boring to me, you just run around looking for people to kill (you rarely do) and when you finally do you get shot and have to wait like 10 minutes to respawn. BF is the waiting game and the single player mode is mediocre while most COD single player modes are fun. Also COD has more modes which means more fun....And you don't have tu run around for an hour alone before you FINALLY find someone to shoot at lol

ActionRemix

lol that sniper-shotgun combo is crazy, that would be pointless in real life since shotguns spread. But still pretty funny...

[QUOTE="SHATT3R3D-GLASS"]

Variety and player count don't make BF3 the "superior" game...

The reason I listed MW3 as superior in the MP department, is because CoD is a phenomenon only because of the MP. If it were sold without the MP, it would sell nothing.

BF3 is not a phenomenon, it's just another shooter next to the likes of Resistance 3.

el3m2tigre

Are you saying MW3 a.ka. Modern Rehash, isn't just a normal shooter?

No, it is

the biggest entertainment release of the year

the concluding instalment in a legendary series millions of gamers are waiting for

the first game to introduce Elite

No, it is the biggest entertainment release of the year the concluding instalment in a legendary series millions of gamers are waiting for the first game to introduce EliteSHATT3R3D-GLASS

Both will be good. I don't give a crap about any of them at this time. Skyrim and Skyward Sword FTW.charizard1605

Same here, except it's Skyrim and Uncharted 3 FTW, yes you knew it was coming :P

lol that sniper-shotgun combo is crazy, that would be pointless in real life since shotguns spread. But still pretty funny...ShadowMoses900

[QUOTE="el3m2tigre"]

[QUOTE="SHATT3R3D-GLASS"]

Variety and player count don't make BF3 the "superior" game...

The reason I listed MW3 as superior in the MP department, is because CoD is a phenomenon only because of the MP. If it were sold without the MP, it would sell nothing.

BF3 is not a phenomenon, it's just another shooter next to the likes of Resistance 3.

SHATT3R3D-GLASS

Are you saying MW3 a.ka. Modern Rehash, isn't just a normal shooter?

No, it is

the biggest entertainment release of the year

the concluding instalment in a legendary series millions of gamers are waiting for

the first game to introduce Elite

Just so you'll know, the COD franchise set the standards of generic FPS's.

[QUOTE="ShadowMoses900"]lol that sniper-shotgun combo is crazy, that would be pointless in real life since shotguns spread. But still pretty funny...ActionRemix

Well I only shoot wiht buckshot in my shot gun. I prefer handguns though, especially my CZ Compact, it's comfortable to shoot and can fire mulitple types of handgun ammo and it's easy to carry with CC License.

BF3 will be the better game but MW3 will get better sales.

Am I doing it right?

nameless12345

yes. that is the main consensus

[QUOTE="ActionRemix"][QUOTE="ShadowMoses900"]lol that sniper-shotgun combo is crazy, that would be pointless in real life since shotguns spread. But still pretty funny...ShadowMoses900

Well I only shoot wiht buckshot in my shot gun. I prefer handguns though, especially my CZ Compact, it's comfortable to shoot and can fire mulitple types of handgun ammo and it's easy to carry with CC License.

Shotguns we have here are for hunting and they spread like crazy. But military shotguns will rip you apart at quite a distance. The slugs will absolutely F*** you up as they are practically just big balls of metal. Shotguns are very strong in real life but need to be toned down in games a bit

BF3 will be the better game but MW3 will get better sales.

Am I doing it right?

nameless12345

[QUOTE="nameless12345"]

BF3 will be the better game but MW3 will get better sales.

Am I doing it right?

Merex760

hahaha best analogy ever :P

Also another good one is "Toyota sells more than ferari, Does that make them a better car?"

MW3 will have the better SP. The online will be broken in both, so MW3 > BF3.

Pug-Nasty

and we're basing this off a BETA? Ok...well I guess that's all I need to hear.

[QUOTE="Merex760"][QUOTE="nameless12345"]

BF3 will be the better game but MW3 will get better sales.

Am I doing it right?

seanmcloughlin

hahaha best analogy ever :P

Also another good one is "Toyota sells more than ferari, Does that make them a better car?"

While my last good COD experience was COD4, I can say I'll prefer the gameplay of MW3 to BF3. The beta of BF3 left a bad taste in my mouth and I honestly lost any interest I had at that point.

I think MW3 will be the both the better selling game and the better game aswell. BF games are just boring to me, you just run around looking for people to kill (you rarely do) and when you finally do you get shot and have to wait like 10 minutes to respawn. BF is the waiting game and the single player mode is mediocre while most COD single player modes are fun. Also COD has more modes which means more fun....And you don't have tu run around for an hour alone before you FINALLY find someone to shoot at lol

ShadowMoses900

and you pretty much failed to realise that BF is an objective based game. You don't "run around" just to find people to kill. You go after and fight for the objective's. Also CoD has more modes for no reason. People are going to end up playing Domination, Deathmatch, TDM, and S&D 90% of the time anyway.

Please stop using the beta as a reason to think the game will be shat.IGN played the newest build with no problems, no glitches. The game runs & works great.

With that being said MW3 does not have a beta & i gurantee you it will be the most borken game since mw2. MW3 itself is one giant glitch this holiday season.

WhenBF3 comes out problem free it will make everyone look bad for judging the game on a unfinished build

I also i dont understand why anyone would purchase mw3 even if you are the biggest cod fan. The MP will be the same as 4, waw, mw2, bo so why would you shell out $60 for an experience you already have. I will stick with the cod games i already have. Not shelling out more money for a giant map pack when thereare completely superior titles coming out this season